A client told me he gets about ten cold emails a day pitching the exact thing I do. So yeah, it's saturated.
But I've read a lot of those emails and the bar is actually lower than you think. Most of them open with an AI line about your last LinkedIn post. Being relevant and clear already puts you ahead of nearly all of it
Doing food deliveries taught me more about speed to lead than any sales book...
The faster I got an order there, the more likely they were to tip, and the more deliveries I could fit in a day.
With leads a slow reply can cost you the whole deal, and chasing cold leads is time-consuming.
2027 is less than 8 weeks away. If outbound is part of your plan for next year, this is what I'd get sorted before Christmas:
- Domains and inboxes bought and warming
- A list of companies that can actually afford you
- An offer worth replying to
- Someone replying to positive leads within 5 minutes
- Follow ups that keep going until they book or say no
Most of this takes a few weeks to set up properly, so I wouldn't leave it until January.
When an agency owner tells me they tried cold email before and it didn't work, I actually don't mind hearing it at all, it gives me something to work off.
It's usually one of these:
- Wrong list. The companies were too small to afford them or didn't have a need, so the calls weren't qualified
- Emails started landing in spam after the first couple of months
- A generic offer nobody felt was worth replying to
- Replying hours late and giving up after a couple of follow-ups
If you close 2 out of 10 qualified meetings and each client is worth 18k over six months, every qualified meeting is worth about 3.6k to you.
That's the number I'd compare against whatever you're paying for lead gen right now.
Of course, this all depends on how qualified those meetings actually are. Lead gen agencies that just charge per meeting will probably throw in random calls that waste your time, and still charge you for them.
That's why setting the qualification standard upfront is so important.
Someone actually told me... "we want an agency not only to run cold email for us and close the deals too, for the same price as running cold email, just with a little commission extra on closed deals"
You want to outsoruce your entire sales funnel for less than 5k/mo?
A generic playbook or an AI visibility audit might actually add a lot of value. But people have heard about them so many times in cold email that they just don't see it as worth replying to.
The offers that get replies are personalised to the company you're emailing. Something that shows a little of what you'd actually do for them, like 3 ads built for their brand.
It's also pretty common for clients to blame poor results on the agency not putting enough effort in.
A simple Loom breaking down their campaign each week works really well. It'll:
- Show your client the work you've actually been putting in
- Show exactly what's working and what's not
- Cover the improvements you're making the following week
- Suggest engagement ideas so your client can maximise their close rate
Literally a 5 min Loom a week is enough for that.
Replying to @ZaidAD_
when clients can't see which leads are being contacted or what messages they're getting, they have to take the agency's word for it.
i've seen how frustrating that gets, especially when the results aren't where they expected them to be.
If your cold email lists more than one service, I'm probably not replying.
I've had so many that give me a restaurant menu to pick from. SEO, paid ads, web dev, branding, storytelling, all in one message. I'm not going to work out which of your services I need, that's your job.
I ask most prospects on my sales calls the same thing. You get hundreds of these emails, so how come you answered this one?
"I always got these emails and I always ignored"
"It's Friday and I had some time"
"You just got to be there. Got to be in the inbox at the right time"
A lot of it is just timing, which is all the more reason to get on a reply within five minutes. If you don't, they're off their inbox and you've missed them.
20.4K emails, 5.18% reply rate, 42 interested leads and 12 calls booked for an agency we run cold email for. 5 are in the proposal stage and 1 has already closed - all in roughly a month.
What we did:
- Split their market into 5 segments, each with its own campaign, list and copy
- Every segment got the case study closest to it
- Ran 50,000+ companies through an ICP check with Haiku 5.5, so only qualified leads got contacted
The offer was simple: "Can I put together 3 ads and copy for X product? No cost." And every email named a product they actually sell, pulled from their own website, so it never read like a template.
When someone replies interested, we handle it within 5 minutes. They get one ad as a preview and see the other 2 on the call. Anyone who goes quiet gets follow ups that bring something new, like a case study breakdown from a business like theirs.
One segment did a lot better than the rest, so that's where we're doubling down now.


