Zaka Swartz retweeted
Paul McCartney has spent fifty years telling the world to stop eating meat, and on this subject he is not a serious person.
He wrote Yesterday, so he is allowed almost anything. The trouble starts when he gets on to dinner.
He gave up meat in the 1970s after looking out of his farmhouse window at the lambs while eating one. He had, a few years before, released a single called Mary Had a Little Lamb.
He still keeps sheep on the farm in Scotland. None of them is ever eaten. They are shorn, they grow old, and they are buried. It is the only flock in Argyll run as a retirement home, and it is offered as a model for feeding eight billion people.
In 2009 he launched Meat Free Monday, to save the planet one day a week. He promoted it between world tours, which are conducted by private jet.
In 2008 Lexus gave him a hybrid limousine for his green credentials. It came from Japan. It was flown, 7,000 miles, because the boat would have taken too long. The carbon saved by the hybrid engine was spent about a hundred times over before he had sat in it.
He says that if slaughterhouses had glass walls everyone would be vegetarian. The frozen sausages sold under his late wife's name are made of rehydrated soya and rapeseed oil in a factory owned by an American conglomerate, and nobody has ever asked for a look round.
Last year he wrote to Brussels to defend the right of a vegetable to be called a burger.
So the position is that a sheep on a Scottish hill is a moral emergency, the jet is logistics, and the planet will be rescued on Mondays.
He has never, in fifty years, met a hill farmer he could not write a song about and then put out of business.
Zaka Swartz retweeted
Hospitals find cancer by injecting you with sugar and photographing where it goes.
It is called a PET scan. The injection is glucose with a radioactive tag on it.
You lie still for an hour while it spreads. Then the scanner maps where the sugar ended up, and the tumours light up like towns seen from a plane.
They light up because a tumour takes in glucose at many times the rate of the tissue around it.
Otto Warburg showed why in the 1920s. Cancer cells ferment sugar instead of burning it properly, even with plenty of oxygen around. Fermenting is wasteful, about a twentieth of the energy per molecule, so the cell needs an enormous supply.
Before the scan you are told to fast, and to avoid sugar and carbohydrate the day before.
Sugar in your blood would compete with the tracer and blur the picture. The radiographers need the tumour hungry.
Then the result comes back, treatment starts, and on the ward the trolley comes round with biscuits, juice, jelly and ice cream. To keep your weight up.
The scanning department knows what a tumour eats. The catering department has not been told.
Zaka Swartz retweeted
Every vitamin target you have ever been handed was measured on people eating bread, sugar and seed oil.
They don't apply to carnivore.
The fewer carbs you eat, the less vitamin C you need.
The fewer carbs you burn, the less thiamine you need.
The less sugar you eat, the less magnesium you need.
The less seed oil you eat, the less vitamin E you need.
The less omega 6 you eat, the less omega 3 you need.
The fewer phytates you eat, the less zinc and iron you need.
The fewer oxalates you eat, the less calcium you need.
The less soy and raw kale you eat, the less iodine you need.
The fewer vegetables you eat, the less sodium you need.
The less plant protein you lean on, the less protein you need.
Half the nutrition label is a repair bill for the other half.
Take the thief out of the house and you need fewer locks. They look at a plate with no plants on it and say deficient. The word they are reaching for is efficient.
Zaka Swartz retweeted
University debate: "Red meat is a prop for fragile men."
Vegan: "Steak, bacon, the barbecue. It's a costume. Men eat red meat to feel like cavemen, and the adverts sell it back to them with fire and tongs. Take away the insecurity and nobody needs it."
Anthropologist: "Who needs more iron, a man or a woman?"
Vegan: "The same."
Anthropologist: "She needs about double. More again when she's pregnant."
Vegan: "She can get it from spinach."
Anthropologist: "She keeps a few percent of what's in spinach. From red meat, several times that. Who loses blood every month?"
Vegan: "Obviously."
Anthropologist: "Who builds a second skeleton and a second brain out of her own body, then feeds it for a year?"
Vegan: "Women."
Anthropologist: "And who's more likely to be the vegetarian in the house?"
Vegan: "...Women."
Anthropologist: "About two to one. So the half of the species with the biggest bill has been talked out of the food that pays it."
Vegan: "Women outlive men. They're managing."
Anthropologist: "Nearly half the teenage girls in Britain are short of iron. Tired, cold, pale, and told it's their age."
Vegan: "So steak is feminism now."
Anthropologist: "It's arithmetic. He needs the least and gets the adverts. She needs the most and gets a salad and a leaflet on fatigue."
Vegan: "Then why is every meat advert a man with tongs?"
Anthropologist: "The advert is for the man who wants to feel like a hunter. The steak was for the woman who has just made a person."
Zaka Swartz retweeted
Bill Gates wants the rich world to give up beef for a version grown in a tank, and he is not a serious person.
In 2021 he published a book called How to Avoid a Climate Disaster and announced that wealthy countries should move to 100% synthetic beef. You would get used to the taste, he said. He had money in the companies that make it.
He owns four private jets. He calls them his guilty pleasure, the way other men mean a second biscuit. One study put his flying alone at 1,600 tonnes of carbon in a year, about what 300 ordinary Britons manage with their cars, boilers and holidays included. He took one of the jets to the Paris climate conference, and put that in the book.
Around the time the book came out, he was part of a bid for the world's biggest private jet servicing company. He had identified aviation as a problem and bought the petrol station.
He is also the largest private owner of farmland in America, some 270,000 acres, a good share of it growing potatoes for chips.
And his favourite food, by his own account, on his own blog, is the cheeseburger. He wishes it were not. So he has invested in a company that makes fat out of carbon dioxide and hydrogen, so that the grease in his burger need never have met a cow.
The plan, then, is that you eat the paste, he eats the cheeseburger until the paste is ready, and the cow is replaced by a gas cylinder he has shares in.
Most people who cannot stop eating burgers buy a smaller plate. He is rebuilding the food supply of the Western world around his own willpower.
Zaka Swartz retweeted
Vitamin C and glucose use the same door into your cells, which is why a sailor on biscuit got scurvy and an Inuit on seal never did.
Most animals make their own vitamin C. They build it out of glucose.
Humans lost that gene about 60 million years ago. The two molecules are still so alike that vitamin C enters your cells through the glucose transporter.
So they compete. The more sugar in your blood, the longer the queue at the door, and the less vitamin C gets in.
A navy fed on ship's biscuit, porridge, sugar and rum needed lemons to stay alive.
In the Arctic, the explorers who ate fresh seal and bear the way the locals did stayed well. The ones who stuck to flour and tinned stores lost their teeth.
In 1928 two of those explorers, Stefansson and Andersen, checked into Bellevue Hospital in New York and ate nothing but meat for a year under medical watch.
No scurvy. No deficiency of anything. The doctors published it and were visibly disappointed.
Fresh meat carries a little vitamin C. A body with no sugar crowding the door needs only a little.
The daily requirement printed on the orange juice carton was worked out on people eating bread.
Zaka Swartz retweeted
Cancer used to be something a doctor could go looking for and fail to find, and the doctors who looked wrote it down.
A mission doctor spent 11 years among the Labrador Inuit and found no cancer.
A hospital doctor spent 36 years among the Alaskan natives living the old way and found no cancer.
A British army surgeon spent 7 years among 11,000 Hunza and found no cancer.
A district surgeon spent 6 years among 14,000 people in the Orange Free State and found no cancer.
A physician spent 25 years examining 60,000 people in Brazil and Ecuador and found no cancer.
Albert Schweitzer spent his first years in Gabon examining thousands of patients and found no cancer.
Six doctors on four continents, and not one of them was short of patients.
Every one of them wrote the second half too. The trading post arrived, with flour, sugar and tinned fat, and within a generation there was cancer on the ward. Schweitzer watched it walk into his own hospital and put it down to his patients living like Europeans.
The grandchildren of those Inuit now have some of the highest cancer rates measured anywhere.
Medicine files it under bad luck and old age. It arrived by boat.
Zaka Swartz retweeted
Sigmund Freud's first big idea was that cocaine cures drug addiction, and he tried it out on his best friend.
He was 28, poor, unknown and desperate to make a name. In 1884 he published Über Coca, which he called a song of praise to the drug. Cocaine lifted the mood, he wrote, banished fatigue, and left no craving behind.
His friend Ernst von Fleischl-Marxow was the most gifted physiologist in Vienna. He had lost a thumb to an infection caught at the dissecting table, and the nerve pain had put him on morphine. Freud started him on cocaine to get him off it.
Within a year Fleischl was taking a gram a day. He saw white snakes. He picked at his skin to get at the insects crawling under it. Freud sat up with him through nights he described as the worst of his life.
Fleischl died in 1891, aged 45, addicted to both.
Freud went on taking cocaine for another decade. He posted it to his fiancée and pressed it on his sisters. When a colleague accused him of loosing a third scourge on mankind, after alcohol and morphine, he blamed the patients. Then he left the paper defending himself off the list of his own works.
Medicine has form here. Morphine was the cure for the opium habit. Cocaine was the cure for morphine. Bayer launched heroin in 1898 as the cure for morphine as well, and methadone arrived in due course to cure the heroin.
Each cure has filled the next generation's clinics.
Freud went on to become the most trusted authority of his century on what was wrong with other people's minds.
Zaka Swartz retweeted
Dietician: The new target is 30 different plants a week. It's for your gut.
Patient: Does coffee count?
Dietician: Yes. It's a seed.
Patient: Dark chocolate?
Dietician: Over 70% cocoa, yes.
Patient: Pepper?
Dietician: A quarter of a point. Spices are a quarter each.
Patient: So a curry and a mocha is about four plants.
Dietician: It adds up quickly. That's what makes it achievable.
Patient: Does beef count?
Dietician: No.
Patient: Lamb?
Dietician: No. They're not plants.
Patient: What did the lamb eat?
Dietician: Grass.
Patient: One grass?
Dietician: ...
Patient: My uncle's top meadow has forty kinds of plant in it. He's counted. Grasses, clovers, herbs, things with Latin names. She's on forty plants a day. I get a point for a peppercorn and nothing for her.
Dietician: The points are for plants you eat yourself.
Patient: So they only count if I digest them worse than she does.
Zaka Swartz retweeted
Carnivore is an extreme diet, and thank goodness the moderate one is still available.
Moderate is cereal at 7, a meal deal at 1 and pasta at 7, with something from a packet in between.
Moderate is 8 million people in Britain on a statin.
Moderate is a weekly injection to switch off an appetite the food switched on.
Moderate is having most of your stomach removed on the NHS.
Moderate is 180 diabetic amputations a week in England.
Moderate is a six-year-old under general anaesthetic to have his teeth out.
Moderate is five prescriptions by retirement, two of them for the side effects of the other three.
Extreme is a lamb chop and some butter.
Only one of these has a television report warning you about it.
Zaka Swartz retweeted
Britain had its own carnivore island until 1930, and breakfast there was porridge with a puffin boiled in it for flavour.
St Kilda is a scrap of rock 40 miles out in the Atlantic beyond the Outer Hebrides. No trees. Almost nothing will grow. For something like 2,000 years, people lived on it anyway, on the only crop the place produces, which is seabirds.
The first visitor to write it all down was Martin Martin in 1697. He found 180 islanders in rude health and tried to work out how many gannets they had eaten the previous year. His figure was 22,600. He then counted eggs, and gave up somewhere in the tens of thousands.
Fulmars were salted by the barrel for winter and were said to taste like pork. Puffins were roasted in summer. Gannets were dried in little stone huts all over the hillside, 1,200 of which are still standing. The fat was rendered for lamp oil and the rent was paid in feathers.
The men got the birds by going over 1,000 foot cliffs on a rope, barefoot, and were so good at it that Victorian tourists paid to watch. Their shoes, when they bothered, were made from the neck of a gannet, worn with the beak pointing forward.
Every morning the men met in the street to decide the day's work. Visitors called it the St Kilda Parliament. It had no rules, no leader and no record of ever finishing early.
Then the steamers started calling, with flour, sugar, tea and the common cold. The young left for the mainland. The last 36 islanders asked to be taken off in August 1930.
For two millennia there was a place in the British Isles with no bread, no fields and no greengrocer, and it only became uninhabitable once the groceries arrived.
Zaka Swartz retweeted
The clogged pipe theory of heart disease has one small problem. Half your pipes never clog.
Why does the same blood, carrying the same cholesterol, pass through every vessel you own and only ever block the arteries?
Why has nobody in history needed a stent in a vein?
Why does a leg vein, spotless for 60 years, start growing plaque within a few years of a surgeon stitching it onto the heart as a bypass?
Why do the arteries in your lungs, which run at about a sixth of the pressure, stay clear on the same blood?
Why do those same lung arteries start to clog as soon as the pressure in them rises?
Why does plaque gather at the bends and forks, where the flow batters the wall, and skip the straight runs?
Why, in a study of 136,000 people admitted with heart disease, did nearly half arrive with LDL already under the target?
A drain that blocks because of what is flowing through it blocks everywhere.
An injury happens where the wall takes the beating.
Which of those does this look like?
Zaka Swartz retweeted
John F. Kennedy could not do one sit-up on the day he became the most powerful man on earth, and the corset his doctors kept him in is why the bullet that killed him found its mark.
He had been in pain since Harvard. In 1954 surgeons bolted a metal plate to his spine. The wound went septic and a priest was called to give him the last rites. A second operation took the plate back out. After that came the anaesthetic needles, sometimes several a day, a rocking chair, crutches kept out of the photographs, and a stiff canvas corset he laced on every morning like a second shirt.
That was the settled treatment for a bad back. Cut it, numb it, strap it up and keep it still.
In October 1961 an Austrian called Hans Kraus was shown into the White House. Kraus was a rock climber who had mended his own fractures by moving them, and he examined the President the way he would a recruit. Kennedy could not sit up from the floor. Asked to touch his toes, he could not reach his knees. The most photographed torso in America had been rested for 20 years and there was very little of it left.
Kraus told him the back was weak, and that weak things are loaded until they are strong. He gave him exercises and then weights, in the little gym beside the White House pool, and said he would walk out if the needles carried on.
It worked almost at once. Within a year Kennedy was picking up his children, which he had not been able to do, and playing golf again. Kraus's notes, handed to the Kennedy Library by his widow in 2006, record a lifelong complaint that was very nearly gone by the autumn of 1963.
The corset was the one thing Kraus could not get off him. He told the President he no longer needed it. Kennedy kept lacing it on.
He was wearing it in the open car in Dallas on 22 November. The first bullet went through the base of his neck. A man with nothing round his middle folds forward at that point, down below the line of the seat. Kennedy stayed bolt upright, held there by canvas and laces, with his head exactly where it had been.
His back was the strongest it had been in 20 years, and he died sitting up straight in the last piece of the old treatment.
Zaka Swartz retweeted
Prince Harry runs a campaign telling you to travel more sustainably, and he is not a serious person.
In the summer of 2019 he told British Vogue that he and his wife would have two children at most, for the sake of the planet. Days later he gave a speech about the climate at a Google retreat in Sicily, barefoot. The guests had arrived on private jets and superyachts, and the three days cost a reported $20 million.
He then took four private jet flights in eleven days.
When the newspapers pointed this out, he launched an initiative. It is called Travalyst, and it exists to encourage the rest of us to holiday responsibly. At the launch he explained that he spends 99% of his life flying commercial.
In 2021 he played in a polo match in Aspen and went home on a friend's twenty-seat Gulfstream. The following year he was photographed arriving at the airport in an electric car, to board a private jet, to play polo.
The entire philosophy fits in that photograph. The electric car is for the camera and the jet is for the journey.
He lives in California in a house with nine bedrooms and sixteen bathrooms, which works out at eight bathrooms per permitted child.
Nobody minds a prince living like a prince. His family did it for a thousand years without once asking a plumber in Stoke to feel guilty about a fortnight in Tenerife.
The two-child limit, incidentally, is the only one of his environmental pledges he has kept, and it is the one nobody asked for.
Zaka Swartz retweeted
Anne Diamond, one of the best-known faces on British breakfast television, lost her four-month-old son Sebastian to cot death in July 1991. When she went looking for the reason, the trail led back to the best-selling baby book ever written.
Benjamin Spock was the most trusted doctor in the world. Baby and Child Care came out in 1946, and for half a century it was said to sell second only to the Bible. Parents on both sides of the Atlantic kept it by the cot and did what it said. In the first edition he told them to put babies down on their backs. In the editions of the 1950s he changed his mind.
His reasoning sounded like common sense. A baby on its back might be sick in the night and choke on it, and might grow a flat patch on the back of its head. Better, he wrote, to get a baby used to sleeping on its stomach from the start. Hospitals adopted it. Midwives taught it. Grandmothers who had put their own babies down on their backs were corrected by daughters who had read the book.
Nobody had tested it. By 1970 the studies already showed babies sleeping on their fronts dying suddenly about three times as often as babies on their backs. The advice did not change. Cot death got its own line on the death certificate that same year, and through the seventies and eighties it climbed until it was the biggest killer of babies between one month and one year old. In 1989, 1,545 babies died of it in Britain.
The evidence finally broke through at the end of the eighties, from a Bristol doctor, Peter Fleming, and from researchers in New Zealand. Anne Diamond put everything she had behind it: her fame, her programme and her grief. In December 1991 the government launched the Back to Sleep campaign. Cot deaths in Britain fell almost overnight. Today there are around 200 a year.
In 2005 researchers in London went back through fifty years of baby books and studies. They concluded that the front-sleeping advice had run against the evidence since 1970, and that it had probably cost more than 10,000 babies their lives in Britain, and at least 50,000 across Europe, America and Australasia.
Spock never meant any harm. He was the expert, and nobody in a position to check his advice thought they needed to.
The parents who followed it did everything right. They read the book, trusted the doctor, and laid their babies down exactly as they were told.
Zaka Swartz retweeted
Teacher: "Now, class, this is where the cows live. Scientists say land like this could be growing food for people instead."
Farmer: "Could it? Who wants a go? Here's a spade. Dig me a hole for a carrot."
Pupil: "It's stopped."
Farmer: "How far down?"
Pupil: "About that much."
Farmer: "Four inches. What did you hit?"
Pupil: "A rock."
Farmer: "Try over there."
Pupil: "Rock."
Teacher: "With modern farming methods, I'm sure something could be done."
Farmer: "It rains 200 days a year, it's a thousand feet up, and your coach came up the lane in first gear. I'd lose a tractor before I got a turnip."
Teacher: "But it's green. Something is obviously growing."
Farmer: "Grass. It's the one crop that'll have the place. Can any of you eat grass?"
Pupil: "No."
Farmer: "Can she?"
Pupil: "She's eating it now."
Farmer: "And what do we get out of her?"
Pupil: "Milk. And burgers."
Teacher: "That's a slight simplification."
Pupil: "Miss, is the cow the only one who can farm here?"
Farmer: "Put that one down for a scholarship."
Zaka Swartz retweeted
Your porridge oats were sprayed with weedkiller a week or two before harvest, on purpose, to kill the crop.
It is called desiccation. A crop that dies all at once dries evenly in the field, and the combine can go in on schedule.
In wet countries it is routine. Britain, Canada, the northern United States. Oats, wheat, barley.
So the glyphosate goes onto the grain itself, days before it is cut, with no growing season left to wash it off.
American government scientists tested the urine of 2,310 people. Glyphosate was in 81% of them. In the children, 87%.
The safety case rests on how it kills. Glyphosate blocks a chemical pathway that plants need to live, and human cells do not have that pathway.
Bacteria do.
Your gut holds trillions of them, and in 2010 the manufacturer was granted a patent on glyphosate as an antibiotic.
So the safety case covers every cell in your body that is you, and none of the ones that are not.
The oats have a heart-health logo on the box.
A bullock on a hill gets sprayed with rain.
Zaka Swartz retweeted
The father of botany went to the Arctic in 1732 to catalogue plants, and came back having written that the healthiest people he had ever seen barely ate any.
Carl Linnaeus was 25, the man who would go on to name every plant in Europe and the species Homo sapiens. Uppsala paid him to spend a summer in Lapland collecting specimens. He collected them. He also could not stop writing about the Sami, the reindeer herders, because they kept outwalking him.
His journal reads like a man losing an argument with his own profession. "I have never seen people have such a good life," he wrote. In summer they ate milk, whey and cheese twice a day and then sat about with nothing to do. In winter, cheese by day and meat in the evening. One reindeer fed four people for a week. He examined their knees and feet to see whether they were built differently, and reported that they were not.
Then he did what a scientist does and listed the reasons the Lapps were so healthy. Number 7 on the list:
"Meat eating: carnivorous animals live longer."
Milk, he added, was what made them supple.
He went home, became the most famous botanist who ever lived, classified 7,700 plants, and spent 40 years as a professor of medicine prescribing them.
The Sami went on eating reindeer.
So the founding document of plant science contains a footnote, in the founder's own hand, noting that the best results he ever saw came from leaving them alone.
Zaka Swartz retweeted
The children's menu is the worst food in the building, and it is served to the only customers who are still growing.
The adults' menu has steak, lamb, fish and eggs.
The children's has nuggets, chips, pasta in red sauce, a small pizza, a carton of juice and ice cream.
A child is building a skeleton, a brain and every organ they will ever own out of what is on that plate.
So the protein and the fat are reserved for the people who have finished growing, and the beige starch goes to the ones laying down bone.
No other mammal does this. The lioness gives the cubs first go at the kill.
The excuse is that children will not eat anything else. Most of them were never offered anything else. Hand a five-year-old a lamb chop and it will be gone in two minutes, bone included.
The menu exists because it costs pennies to make, and it is sold to parents as a kindness.
Zaka Swartz retweeted
The cat exists because grain cannot look after itself.
About ten thousand years ago people in the Middle East began storing wheat and barley, and discovered what every farmer since has known. A heap of grain is the best thing that ever happened to a mouse. The first villages were overrun.
Nobody went out and tamed a cat. A small desert wildcat noticed the mice, moved in and started work. People let it stay, and that was the entire arrangement.
It has barely changed since. The genes of a house cat are almost those of the wildcat. The dog was remade by living with us. The cat is the same animal with a better address.
Every grain civilisation that followed kept it. Egypt, which lived or died by what was in the granary, made the cat sacred, and a man could be killed by a mob for harming one. They had worked out that their bread depended on a meat-eater.
So the first thing farming needed, before the plough or the wheel, was a hunter to guard the crop.
For a hundred centuries the cat sat on top of the largest store of carbohydrate in the world and never touched it. She cannot even taste sugar. She lived on the mice.
Then, in our lifetime, somebody ground the grain into a brown biscuit and poured it into her bowl. Dry cat food is about a third carbohydrate. More than half the cats in the West are now overweight, and diabetes among them has climbed decade on decade. When vets take the biscuit away and feed them meat, a good many recover.
She guarded the grain for ten thousand years and had the sense never to eat it. It took the pet food industry to get it into her.





















