Pinned Tweet
Replying to @qayyimtaqleed
I understand that Ibn Arabi and Akbarian thought can be difficult to understand, but that is not what Ibn Arabi meant. Let me tell you what he, and the Akbarians, understand all of this to mean.
1/ 1. First, the poem
١ فيَحمدني وأحمدهُ // ويعبدني وأعبدهُ
٢ ففي حالٍ أُقِرُّ بهِ // وفي الأعيانِ أجحدهُ
٣ فيعرفني وأنكرهُ // وأعرفهُ فأشهدهُ
٤ فأنّى بالغِنى وأنا // أساعدهُ فأُسعدهُ
٥ لذاكَ الحقُّ أوجدني // فأعلمهُ فأوجدهُ
٦ بذا جاءَ الحديثُ لنا // وحقَّقَ فيَّ مقصدهُ
1 For He praises me and I praise Him,
and He worships me and I worship Him.
2 For in a state I acknowledge Him,
and in the entities I deny Him.
3 For He knows me and I deny Him,
and I know Him so I witness Him.
4 So how [is there] self-sufficiency and I
help Him and make Him happy?
5 For this reason, the Real brought me into existence,
for I know Him and bring Him into existence.
6 Thus did the report (hadith) come to us,
and realised its intended meaning in me.
«ويعبدني وأعبدهُ»
"and He worships me and I worship Him."
First, a foundational principle in Islamic jurisprudence, fiqh, is that when a Muslim's statement admits multiple interpretations, ninety nine of which would entail kufr while one admits a sound interpretation, you are obliged to interpret according to the one sound meaning.
Before examining the individual readings of this phrase, one methodological point is essential. The masters of the Akbarian school frequently held multiple, concurrent layers of interpretation. They did not necessarily regard these readings as mutually exclusive; rather, they functioned as successive levels of a single reality. Thus, assigning a particular interpretation to one commentator does not mean that he rejected, or was limited to, the other readings.
Once this foundational premise is grasped, it is also necessary to hold in view the passage Ibn Arabi establishes immediately before the verses:
«فإِن ثبت أنك الموجود فالحكم لك بلا شك. وإِن كان الحاكم الحق، فليس له إِلا إِفاضة الوجود عليك والحكم لك عليك. فلا تحمد إِلا نفسك ولا تذم إِلا نفسك، وما يبقى للحق إِلا حمد إِفاضة الوجود لأن ذلك له لا لك. فأنت غذاؤه بالأحكام، وهو غذاؤك بالوجود. فتعين عليه ما تعين عليك. فالأمر منه إِليك ومنك إِليه.»
“If you are established as the one who exists, then the judgement is undoubtedly yours. And if the Real is the one who exercises judgement, He has nothing except to bestow Wujud upon you, while the judgement belongs to you, upon you. So praise none but yourself, and blame none but yourself; what remains for the Real is only the praise of bestowing Wujud, because that belongs to Him, not to you. You are His sustenance through the determinations, and He is your sustenance through Wujud. So what is incumbent upon Him is what is incumbent upon you; the matter is from Him to you and from you to Him.”
In light of this, the Akbarian school approaches the phrase “He worships me” through five cascading layers: first, Divine obedience; second, mushakala, or rhetorical correspondence; third, the dual linguistic reading of the unvocalised Arabic; fourth, the reciprocity of Lordship; and finally, a dialogue in which the pronouns shift according to the speaker.
1. Divine Obedience, The Hadith (Weak, but commonly cited in heart-softening, rqaqa'iq, tradtions)
Al-Jundi and Al-Qashani cite the Prophet's exchange with Abu Talib:
«ما أطوع لك ربك يا محمد!»
“How obedient your Lord is to you, O Muhammad!”
The Prophet replies:
«وأنت يا عم، إن أطعته أطاعك»
“And you, my uncle, if you obey Him, He will obey you.”
Since obedience, ta'a, is one of the meanings associated with worship, 'ibada, Allah's obedience to the servant can therefore be described as His “worship” of him.
I am not sure whether I am still a Muslim.
I don't really wanna talk about it either.
I am just tired.
Ziad El Labban retweeted
Replying to @ZiadElLabban
I thought the game was alright, but what made it truly memorable was its historical detail. I have no trouble recommending it for that alone, as much of a hot take as that may be.
Ziad El Labban retweeted
Replying to @ZiadElLabban
They should make an Assassin’s Creed set in medieval or Mughal Northwestern Pakistan/India
Yawn.
I am aware of this hadith.
A) The overwhelming majority of scholars do not accept this hadith.
As the scholar Ibn Qutayba said, "The hadith scholars do not establish the hadith of al-Zutt."
One of the reasons is because the man named 'Amr in the chain is not known to have heard from Ibn Mas'ud.
B) "Ride" ("rakiba") in the Arabic language can mean both mount sexually or crowding around someone so closely that they almost climb over him. And Ahmad al-Sirhindi said that.
HUH!!!! NO IT WAS NOT.
Watch this. One of the best videos on YouTube and isn't Arab or Iranian supremacist.
youtu.be/NglaUZ2au8g?si=i1Yd…
Ziad El Labban retweeted
Imam Muhammad ibn Ali al-Sanussi رحمة الله also says:
“…The saved group excepted [in the hadith] is named explicitly in some of its routes. In one: ‘Into seventy-three: seventy-two in the Fire and one in Paradise, and it is al-jama’a.’
Ziad El Labban retweeted
ASWJ is not united in this definition. Sayyid Ahmad ibn Idris رحمة الله notably said:
“Know that the Jama’a (i.e. the community) referred to in the saying ‘God’s hand is with the Jama’a’ means those who follow the Book of God and the Sunna of the Messenger of God,
Replying to @YasirQadhi
I didn't see the whole lecture so I am assuming you mentioned that this verse pertains to the non-believers. Within Islam tho, the majority opinion will almost always be sound because otherwise entails that the texts were unclear. + hadith of Sunna being reflected in the jama'a.
🪷 Meanwhile:
'A'isha al-Ba'uniyya authored more works than any other woman in history before the 20th century.
She was initiated into two Sufi orders and became a shaykha (spiritual master) of one.
She was also a master of three of the four Sunni schools of Islamic jurisprudence, and held an ijaza (scholarly authorisation) to issue fatwas (formal legal opinions).
Ziad El Labban retweeted
The claim that “ethicists always” regarded women as wholly inferior is false, and one line from Rumi, a poet known for writing in allegory, is not a survey of the Islamic ethical tradition.
Ziad El Labban retweeted
He also named women among his own teachers, such as Fatima bint al-Muthanna of Seville and Shams Umm al-Fuqara of Marchena.
Ziad El Labban retweeted
Ibn Arabi, the most influential thinker of the later classical tradition, wrote that “every station, rank and attribute a man can attain can belong to whichever women God wills, just as it belongs to whichever men God wills.”
Ziad El Labban retweeted
A mundane but unique thing is that almost every major world religion uses some form of prayer beads. This goes across the entire world from East to West.
Ziad El Labban retweeted
🧵(1/16) Spinoza argues that prophets & Scripture speak in culturally shaped terms not in philosophical or scientific truths. Revelation is meant only to teach moral guidance while matters of metaphysics, nature and philosophy are outside its scope and should be decided by reason
Ziad El Labban retweeted
Prince Khurram comes home to his father Jahangir at Ajmer in 1616. Twelve years later he'd be Emperor Shah Jahan. The Nawab of Awadh sent the whole book to George III in 1799.
Royal Library, Windsor Castle
#IndianArt #ArtHistory #Art
Ziad El Labban retweeted
Sh. Baha ud-Din al-Baytar On Adhering To The Opinions And Views Of Forgone Schools.
“For we do not judge the invalidity of the speech of a saint of God Most High, or of a scholar among the scholars of the Sunna, except when the scholars of the Sharia,






































