Alex Turvy (@alexturvy) profile picture
New Orleans, LA
Joined December 2007
Photo by Alex Turvy (@alexturvy)Photo by Alex Turvy (@alexturvy)Photo by Alex Turvy (@alexturvy)Photo by Alex Turvy (@alexturvy)
For TikTok researchers, this feels like a stressful moment—potential bans, disrupted projects, uncertain futures. But it’s also a moment of opportunity. Disruption opens new angles and questions. Here are 5 thing that I'm thinking through in this strange moment🧵
1
1
73
5/6: Maybe the most valuable research won’t be about TikTok itself but about how digital cultures adapt to structural disruption. Real-time evolution of platform practices is happening now.
1
50
6/6: A TikTok ban represents more than policy change—it's a critical moment for understanding how platforms, practices, and communities adapt to structural disruption. These are urgent research questions. What angles are we missing? What other rifts might emerge?
43
SCENARIO 4 THREAD - THE BAN TAKES EFFECT: 1/4: Enforcing a ban on TikTok would mark the first time Congress has prohibited a specific platform (as far as I know, not a legal expert), raising questions about future thresholds for national security risks.
1
41
3/4: A U.S. ban on TikTok could accelerate the "splinternet," leading to the fragmentation of global platforms into national versions, promoting digital sovereignty through forced localization.
1
14
4/4: The ban might prompt global platforms to establish national subsidiaries, creating a future where platforms operate under localized governance to comply with varying national regulations.
12
SCENARIO 3 THREAD – SUPREME COURT INTERVENTION: 1/6: TikTok plans to appeal to the Supreme Court and seek a "stay" to halt enforcement during the appeal process. If granted, this stay would allow TikTok to continue operating in the U.S. until a final decision is made.
1
21
5/6: Even a conservative Supreme Court might be wary of upholding a law that bans a specific platform, considering the implications for government control over speech platforms.
1
9
6/6: The Court could establish new criteria for evaluating platform bans, balancing national security, free speech, and digital commerce, setting a precedent for future cases.
8
SCENARIO 2 THREAD - THE TRUMP WORKAROUND: 1/6: For me -- feels like a classic case of the 'I'd like to see ol Donny Trump wriggle out of THIS jam' dynamic.
1
78
5/6 Alternative solutions: Trump might direct the Attorney General to deprioritize enforcement or negotiate new data control measures, such as extending a "Project Texas"-style arrangement (although this hasn't satisfied regulators thus far), instead of pursuing full divestment.
1
12
6/6: Geopolitical signaling: Trump's approach to TikTok could indicate a broader shift in U.S.-China tech relations, using the platform as a bargaining chip in larger trade and tariff negotiations.
7