Ben Karlin (@benkarlin1) header
Ben Karlin (@benkarlin1) profile picture

Co-author of The Teaching and Learning Playbook | Education Faculty @Ambition_Inst | Former DSL / T&L lead / English teacher

Joined October 2020
Photo by Ben Karlin (@benkarlin1)Photo by Ben Karlin (@benkarlin1)Photo by Ben Karlin (@benkarlin1)Photo by Ben Karlin (@benkarlin1)Photo by Ben Karlin (@benkarlin1)Photo by Ben Karlin (@benkarlin1)Photo by Ben Karlin (@benkarlin1)Photo by Ben Karlin (@benkarlin1)Photo by Ben Karlin (@benkarlin1)Photo by Ben Karlin (@benkarlin1)
The behaviour debate(s) on here feel *particularly* charged/toxic at the moment so thought it’d be a good time to collect my various attempts to bring nuance to the discussion (/pretentious milquetoast ramblings, delete as appropriate) in one place. A 🧵 of 🧵s.
1
3
1
4,006
Credit where it’s due, “removing the scarcity of teachers” is quite the euphemism.
"We have spent centuries organising education around the scarcity of teachers and tutors. AI is removing that scarcity. Classrooms, timetables, age-based cohorts, lectures and fixed courses are, in part, ways of distributing limited human expertise among large numbers of learners." @DonaldClark donaldclarkplanb.blogspot.co…
2
12
1,262
The comments:
I remember seeing this poem back when I first joined this site over a decade ago. It still causes lots of debate. Should you give a pupil who has forgotten to bring a pencil to school, a detention? I think the answer is: YES! Before assuming this is unkind... read on... 1/
204
I’m actually less skeptical than some others about the *possibility* of trad-aligned, AI-powered education. But it’s very obvious that Alpha, a for-profit company founded by a tech billionaire and engaged in transparent self-dealing, is not a good vehicle for achieving this.
Alpha School’s downfall is gonna hit like crack
2
1
1
18
1,330
Alpha School’s downfall is gonna hit like crack
6
1
1
34
3,282
We’re teaching kids to read with books about how great it is to be a NIMBY, we are so cooked as a country.
2
203
You’re telling me there’s been a new Emily St John Mandel novel out for over a week and I’m just finding out now, this is unacceptable
1
230
My take on Alpha School is that it is obviously and incontestably a bunch of bullshit, but it’s also bullshit of *vanishing* importance to anyone, even those working in education, outside a tiny, hyper-online bubble, and it can be safely ignored.
3
2
1
23
2,396
Apropos PISA, I’ll just sigh and tap the sign
Why is educational traditionalism coded as politically right wing? And should it be? I’m (broadly) an educational traditionalist and (intensely) a political progressive, and I have some thoughts. A thread.
1
1
1,821
Oh ffs. The same high performance awaits us all, it seems.
Big announcement. So excited to be launching this…
201
Free speech advocates use their free speech to say something that isn’t awful challenge (impossible)
Of course sympathetic to such personal despair. But it also bodes badly for teaching pupils how to be resilient and helping them learn how to cope with criticism/adversity.
217
ICYMI, Huw was on @BBCBreakfast this morning talking about his cancer journey, brain tumour research and hope for the future. Watch from about 2h30 in: bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/m0… And please, please consider a donation if you can: gofundme.com/f/huws-your-dad…
My wonderful friend Huw is living with incurable brain cancer. Huw has spent his life helping others as a GP and now needs help to access potentially life-extending treatment & provide for his young children. Please read Huw’s story and donate if you can: gofundme.com/f/huws-your-dad…
305
Ben Karlin retweeted
I have just completed a series of four professional development videos on the subject of teaching effective whole-class reading lessons. These videos contain high-quality footage of me teaching each part of the reading lesson structures from Primary Reading Simplified. >>
4
170
14
346
61,723
My wonderful friend Huw is living with incurable brain cancer. Huw has spent his life helping others as a GP and now needs help to access potentially life-extending treatment & provide for his young children. Please read Huw’s story and donate if you can: gofundme.com/f/huws-your-dad…
1
2
675
I broadly agree with the educational philosophy underpinning Michaela, am deeply skeptical of the educational philosophy underpinning Alpha, and believe the people running both are morally suspect, because I am capable of holding multiple thoughts in my head at the same time.
The absolute state of this. Reminded of people's reaction to Michaela when it started: the whole "anyone doing something I disagree with in education must be morally suspect."
1
18
3,158
God grant me the confidence of a 24-year old edtech graduate employee condemning a profession she’s never worked in or studied to irrelevance based on zero evidence 🙏
With AI, teaching will become unnecessary. But the role of teacher will become ever more irreplaceable. In the past, teachers stood at the front of the classroom and they taught. They explained things and then answered questions. Sometimes they were extra special, and they cracked jokes. Today, AI is indisputably a better teacher than human beings. It recognizes how you're thinking about a problem and addresses your particular gap immediately. It uses the Socratic Method and Scaffolded Hints without fail and never resorts to over-explaining. It speaks to you in your language, with your learning style, at your pace. And yes, it can even crack jokes. The days of frontal teaching are over. But what is not over is the need for teachers. With AI teaching the technical information, the human teacher is free to tend to the human being. This is best illustrated by example. I've worked with many kids who struggle with math. I'll give my company a quick shoutout -- we raised our students' test scores 2 standard deviations well above the mean, and in an absurdly quick amount of time. Our AI did nearly all of the math, but our tutors did something else: They broke through the emotional walls that prevent learning from happening in the first place. Our tutors noticed when math was making kids beat up on themselves. Our tutors noticed when math was no longer really about math. And that's what they spent their time on: Confidence. When @Josiah was working with his student testing in the 29th percentile, the kid would often burst into tears. Each time, Josiah would gently remind his student that he is capable, math is hard, and that if he takes it step-by-step, he can figure it out and do anything he sets his mind to. They practiced this over and over over, and one season later, the kid placed in the 65th percentile. Together, our AI Rocky optimized the curriculum and Josiah, our human tutor, healed the relationship with failure.
6
11
1
142
14,584
One thousand times this. After Stokes resigning in the middle of the T20WC too.
World Cup winner Alex Hartley criticises the ECB's decision to announce the sacking of Brendon McCullum as England men's Test coach during the historic first women's Test at Lord's.
377
I have worked in schools where children can ignore instructions from adults without consequences. They are miserable, dangerous places.
Noah’s school excelled themselves this week - 40 minute detention for taking 2 FREE bottles of water during sports day in 34 degree heat 😂😂😂
14
37
2,060
88,379
Ben Karlin retweeted
One benefit of external exams that is not often mentioned is that the teacher becomes the student's ally against the exam board, rather than being seen as judge and jury as they typically are in systems that rely on teacher judgment.
7
15
2
97
7,243
The funniest thing about these guys is they desperately want to be seen as cutting edge but literally all their actual claims about education are the same lazy, evidence-free bollocks that’s been floating around for decades.
People have this purist notion that kids should just be self-motivated to do well. For about 5% of them, that's true. But what about every other kid? Motivation is 90% of learning. Our guides figure out what motivates each kid and use it to get them to put in the work. Over time that builds a confidence anchor: the one win where a kid did something hard and hit their goal. Confidence in yourself might be the most valuable thing a kid can build. It changes your entire academic path. And yes, sometimes it starts with an Amazon cart.
2
1
11
2,250
Congo have the opportunity to do the funniest and most disrespectful thing ever here by beating us and then not declaring a national holiday
210