pwc (@biographyofred) header
pwc (@biographyofred) profile picture

retweeter

Joined April 2009
Photo by pwc (@biographyofred)Photo by pwc (@biographyofred)Photo by pwc (@biographyofred)Photo by pwc (@biographyofred)Photo by pwc (@biographyofred)Photo by pwc (@biographyofred)Photo by pwc (@biographyofred)Photo by pwc (@biographyofred)Photo by pwc (@biographyofred)Photo by pwc (@biographyofred)
“Monotheism as a political problem had originated in the Hellenistic transformation of the Jewish faith in God. Insofar as the God of the Jews was amalgamated with the monarchical principle of the Greek philosophers, the concept of the divine Monarchy at first acquired the function of a political-theological propaganda formula for Jews. This political-theological propaganda formula was taken over by the Church in its expansion into the Roman Empire. It then met up with a concept of pagan political theology, according to which the divine Monarch indeed reigned, but the national gods had to rule. In order to counteract this pagan theology, tailored to fit the Roman Empire, it was asserted from the Christian side that the national gods could not rule at all, because national pluralism had been suspended by the Roman Empire. In this sense the Pax Augusta was then interpreted as the fulfillment of the Old Testament eschatological prophecies. Nevertheless, the doctrine of the divine Monarchy was bound to founder on the trinitarian dogma, and the interpretation of the Pax Augusta on Christian eschatology. In this way, not only was monotheism as a political problem resolved and the Christian faith liberated from bondage to the Roman Empire, but a fundamental break was made with every “political theology” that misuses the Christian proclamation for the justification of a political situation. Only on the basis of Judaism and paganism can such a thing as a “political theology” exist. The Christian proclamation of the triune God stands beyond Judaism and paganism, even though the mystery of the Trinity exists only in the Godhead itself, and not in Creation. So too, the peace that the Christian seeks is won by no emperor, but is solely a gift of him who “is higher than all understanding.”” — Erik Peterson, Monotheism as a Political Problem
7
16
3
112
6,128
Most people know that St. Thomas Aquinas rejected St. Anselm’s ontological argument for the existence of God. Far fewer know that his great contemporary, St. Bonaventure, not only defended the argument but developed a sophisticated philosophical account of it that addresses all six of Aquinas’s objections. By drawing upon Aristotelian logic, the metaphysics of divine simplicity, and his understanding of God as being itself (ipsum esse), Bonaventure explains why God’s existence is a self-evident and indubitable truth. Interestingly, Bonaventure’s earlier treatment actually precedes that of Aquinas. He was not writing a direct rebuttal of Aquinas, yet his reasoning provides an answer to each of the objections Aquinas would make famous. This is one of the most important and neglected developments in the history of the ontological argument. Here is a graphic from my forthcoming book summarizing Bonaventure’s answers to all six objections, along with their primary textual sources.
14
32
3
288
9,622
Fighting cancer is… uh…not as fun as you might expect, but…working on a book with your kid is pretty great. Over the past few months, my daughter Alex and I wrote a book in hospital hallways — Redeem The Time. It’s not a cancer memoir (woof that’s boring) — but some of our reflections on time, habits, workaholism, and family. We’re all on the clock, and although death is absolutely wicked, the strange “gift of dying” is that it shatters our self-delusions about control. hachettebookgroup.com/titles…
284
926
63
12,526
696,205
pwc retweeted
new red-letter edition of Elementary Applied Topology! full pdf on my website -- physical book for $15 from amazon... www2.math.upenn.edu/~ghrist/… short story: * new chapter on background material (chapter 0) * new chapter on persistence (chapter 6) * so many errors... fixed! * some new artwork... this book, begun in 2009 when the field was emerging, means a great deal to me. it was always an art project more than a textbook; indeed, the minimalist images were and are the only exercises in the text. if you can figure out what the image means, you have figured out the math behind it. i hope that keeping the pdf available on my site encourages a new generation of students to learn topology. though it might take some time, as the page count went up by a third. also, the bibliography has grown quite a bit, given the developments in the field...
11
49
4
317
12,165
*Turned in a cute li'l book on eternal generation! *Reviewed McCall & Vickers' new systematics! *Finally got some proper bookshelves! *Read some great book reviews of midcentury novels! *Saw a mosaic! All this and more at Theology Weakly no. 5.
3
2
18
1,321
nature's a killer I won't sing to it I hold my breath and listen to the dead singing under the grass Ikkyū
3
14
458
In so far as Heidegger attempts to relate, and indeed to reduce, all “faculties” of knowledge to the “transcendental imagination,” only a single plane of reference, the plane of temporal Dasein, remains for him. The distinction between “phenomena” and “noumena” vanishes and is levelled; for all being now belongs to the dimension of time and thus of finitude. […] Kant never represents this kind of “monism” of the imagination; he rather persists in a decisive and radical dualism, a dualism of the sensible and intelligible worlds. For his problem is not the problem of “being” and “time,” but the problem of “being” and “ought,” of “experience” and “idea.” (Cassirer, 1967, p. 16)
2
8
1
83
3,164
Sic itur ad astra — “Thus one goes to the stars.”
3
40
1
245
6,766
Scales on scales, Wesley in Polish, Psalm 68’s divine warrior in Ephesians, Cotton Mather in bulk, and William Lane Craig’s non-Nicene trinitarian theology. Seven days without theology makes one weak. fredfredfred.com/2026/11/the…
1
10
952
Anya Taylor-Joy says she understands why Frank Herbert wrote a sequel to his first 'Dune' novel since readers hadn't understood the message of the first novel: "[Like the books], this has kind of happened with the movies too. Paul is a very charismatic character and you have to have the third movie to be like, hold up, this is not the moral of the story."
7
49
3
553
17,089
The opening of Merleau-Ponty’s Phenomenology of Perception. I felt it was time to spend an autumn afternoon with Merleau-Ponty. 

“WHAT is phenomenology? It may seem strange that this question has still to be asked half a century after the first works of Husserl. The fact remains that it has by no means been answered. Phenomenology is the study of essences; and according to it, all problems amount to finding definitions of essences: the essence of perception, or the essence of consciousness, for example. But phenomenology is also a philosophy which puts essences back into existence, and does not expect to arrive at an understanding of man and the world from any starting point other than that of their 'facticity'. It is a transcendental philosophy which places in abeyance the assertions arising out of the natural attitude, the better to understand them; but it is also a philosophy for which the world is always 'already there' before reflection begins as an inalienable presence; and all its efforts are concentrated upon re-achieving a direct and primitive contact with the world, and endowing that contact with a philosophical status. It is the search for a philosophy which shall be a 'rigorous science', but it also offers an account of space, time and the world as we 'live' them. “
2
18
117
2,302
Paul: I affirm and insist (Eph 4:17). Bayne: "He doth not content himself to speak it, but doth by testification enforce his dehortation, that it might more forcibly enter into them." You know he's serious when he enforces a dehortation by testification. All those syllables.
2
2
20
1,491
Have you seen Jim? Jim was last seen at 4:30a today near 120th Avenue NE and NE 8th Street. He is 85 years old, has dementia, and is likely traveling to Seattle. Please call 911 if you see Jim.
4
6
1
11
2,629
Can't remember which day it is the Lord has made; if anybody knows let me hear from you. I need to calendar when I'm going to rejoice and be glad.
7
6
53
3,037
Replying to @biographyofred
Yes, and then 4:17 is don't walk like gentiles (technically infinitive! but w/imperatival force) and then 4:25 tells them to speak truth to each other, which is Zech 8:16 addressed to exiles returned to Jerusalem. But now applied to gentiles b/c of their unity.
2
1
3
150
K-Pop Demon Hunters is now out on 4K + Blu-Ray, and one of our two videos for it has been published on YouTube! This is a breakdown of the film’s airplane sequence, from first draft to final mix, as explained by the filmmakers themselves. Enjoy! youtube.com/watch?v=VHiwQkN3…
2
48
1
289
25,129
"God the Son" is a threshold concept for Christian doctrine. If you don't get it, you'll keep sliding back & forth between eternal subordination and modalism. Once you get it (and we did write a nice creed about it), a whole field of theology snaps into place & solidifies.
15
21
4
184
9,901
“Kant divides the imagination into the empirical (or reproductive) imagination and the productive imagination. In the reproductive imagination receptivity is, so to speak, dominant. Here, the having of an image is predominantly a matter of letting itself be given an image. It is a matter of the imagination letting itself be carried along by the syntheses (i.e., connections) as association offers them. In the productive imagination, on the other hand, spontaneity is what guides matters. And the synthesis speciosa, as it functions in the schematism, belongs to the productive imagination. Sensibilization as enacted by the imagination must be kept strictly separate from sensible intuition itself. In phenomenological terms, the distinction emerges still more sharply when we contrast the phenomenal character of the corresponding objects of the imagination and of sensible, empirical intuition respectively. The indeterminate object of an empirical intuition is what Kant calls “appearance.” Intuition is empirical insofar as it relates to its object by way of sensation (B 34).”—Heidegger
3
47
1
229
13,429
Earlier this year you couldn't read Cyril of Alexandria's important Thesaurus (let's call it the Treasury mkay?) unless you could read Greek. Now you can read it two different ways, if you're willing to risk ai-translation exposure. Here's a brief critical review.
1
6
1
28
2,975