TLDL: it's even worse than you think youtube.com/watch?v=ILEMV0xK…
38
Second, philosophers and psychologists (first two on the left) seemed to disagree more than, for example, physicists (third from left), or neuroscientists (right), which had lower consensus.
1
51
Two visible patters seems to emerge. First, North Americans (right) are more supportive of the theory, whereas the consensus is much lower amongst European researchers (left).
1
38
Those mostly or fully agreeing notably expressed fewer feelings (left), but invoked reasons and evidence (green and yellow, right) against key tenets of IIT, including the Phi measure and its causal relation with phenomenal consc.
1
37
Many of those who disagree feel that the letter was motivated by an agenda (left). They believe or reason that the demarcation between science and pseudoscience is questionable (centre), and cite evidence that IIT makes testable empirical predictions (right).
1
47
60 (10%) eventually responded. Right from the start, most seem to partially agree. But the numbers of 'not at all' and 'little' grew in proportion over time.
1
49
Is the Integrated Information Theory (IIT) pseudoscience? A recent open letter signed by 124 prominent experts argued that IIT is unfalsifiable and unscientific (osf.io/preprints/psyarxiv/zs…). We asked 570 authors of recent papers on consc. Do they agree, and why? (thread, 1/7).
Do you agree with innovations announced for the @ref2028? A random sample of academics from all disciplines mostly does, albeit with many caveats. Concerns include that it might increase #inequality between and within universities. Responses still coming in!
61

















