Cooper Davis (@Cooperdavis) header
Cooper Davis (@Cooperdavis) profile picture

ExecDirector @_innercompass | well paired w/ @lauradelano | depsychiatrizationist l verstehenmaxxing

New England
Joined August 2009
Photo by Cooper Davis (@Cooperdavis)Photo by Cooper Davis (@Cooperdavis)Photo by Cooper Davis (@Cooperdavis)Photo by Cooper Davis (@Cooperdavis)Photo by Cooper Davis (@Cooperdavis)Photo by Cooper Davis (@Cooperdavis)Photo by Cooper Davis (@Cooperdavis)Photo by Cooper Davis (@Cooperdavis)Photo by Cooper Davis (@Cooperdavis)Photo by Cooper Davis (@Cooperdavis)
My ADHD/stimulant story, as told to Ethan Brooks for @TheAtlantic, for a podcast feature called Scripts—about the pills we take for our brains, and the stories we tell ourselves about them YouTube: youtu.be/B1GnowLnpdc?si=sva0… podcasts.apple.com/us/podcas…
2
10
3
62
31,178
this kind of circular reasoning is why anyone with a schizophrenia dx gets damned to hell anyone with it who accomplishes anything or recovers is determined to have been misdiagnosed always preserving the illusion that it's a black hole nothing of value can ever crawl out of
In December 1952 a young New Zealand writer was days away from a lobotomy, with her mother's signature already on the consent form. The operation was cancelled only because the hospital superintendent happened to read in his newspaper that her first book had won the country's top literary prize. She had never had the illness they were treating. Janet Frame was a shy, red-haired teacher's college student from a poor railway family in Otago. In 1945, at 21, she had a breakdown, and within weeks she was committed to Seacliff Mental Hospital outside Dunedin and diagnosed with schizophrenia. She looked the condition up in a textbook and found it described as a slow, incurable deterioration of the mind. She spent most of the next eight years being proved right by the people treating her. Over those years she was given more than 200 rounds of electroconvulsive therapy, unmodified, with no anaesthetic and no muscle relaxant. She said later that it shredded her memory. In between she wrote. A friend gathered her stories and got them published in 1951, as The Lagoon, while she was still a patient. By late 1952 the doctors had decided the next step was a prefrontal leucotomy, cutting the connections at the front of her brain to make her calmer. Her mother, told it was for the best, signed. Janet counted down the days. Then the superintendent, Dr Geoffrey Blake-Palmer, came onto the ward holding a newspaper. The Lagoon had won the Hubert Church Memorial Award. He told her he had decided she should stay as she was. The operation was cancelled. In 1957, at the Maudsley Hospital in London, a team of psychiatrists examined her properly and told her she had never had schizophrenia. They said she should never have been put in a mental hospital at all, and that most of what was wrong with her by then had been caused by her time on the wards. She went on to become New Zealand's greatest novelist. Her autobiography became An Angel at My Table, Jane Campion's film. She received the Order of New Zealand, the country's highest honour, and was talked about for the Nobel Prize. She died in 2004, at 79, with her mind intact. The women in the beds around her at Seacliff had no book in the newspaper.
7
7
30
1,526
I worked for two years in Hawaii with Aitken Roshi as his personal attendant. He was the teacher of Linehan's teacher Pat Hawk. Her "dharma grandfather" as we call it. I'm not bringing this up to name drop (Roshi loathed name dropping) but because it gave me an inside view of his deep conflicts around combining Zen/Buddhist practice and psychology. He was so gentle, but the one time I saw him furious was over his heir, John Tarrant's book. He shouted at the dinner table, "Buddhism is NOT psychology!" I never saw him extending that judgement to Linehan, whose work he viewed favorably, but I think it's the root of why DBT can be corrosive. There's something very damaging about making certain kinds of contemplative practice compulsory. I think any treatment program that forces anyone to practice "mindfulness" is problematic, particularly if the clinician has not done any actual formal practice. To quote Roshi a second time, "you can't get clear water from a rusty pipe". Carceral care is the cancer here, in whatever form it takes.
An open mea culpa to Marsha Linehan Guest post by Sorbie Richner “I have been railing against an unflattering composite rendering of you and your work for 15 years now.” psychiatrymargins.com/p/an-o…
1
2
2
858
Cooper Davis retweeted
I wish therapists understood that us coaches and spiritual people in the unlicensed gray area get all of their refugees. If someone gets hurt or failed by a therapist or mainstream psychiatry, they come to us, and now they've got their original problems plus trauma on top. That means there's a steady stream of complex, difficult cases flowing into a fringe that is generally under skilled, poorly organized and unsupported. We often only succeed in helping these people, when we do, because we are highly motivated to help. Therapists can rail and inveigh and lobby against life coaches and astrologers and etc. all you want, that's fine, we can take it. But I think you'll find that you'll be much more effective by working with us. I pay for supervision and coaching from a licensed psychologist, which has helped me be an enormously more effective spiritual director and meditation teacher. And because of the ridiculous state by state licensing standards therapists hold to, I am constantly coming up blank on referrals. I have 70k followers on Twitter. My inbox is deluged with people wanting help. I have maybe 5 or 6 good therapists in my Rolodex and almost all of them are in CO or CA. Like it or not, we are part of the same ecosystem, and we are not actually competing for the same niche. Unregulated dyadic work exists, at least in part, to clean up after the failures and mistakes of mainstream therapists. Therapists could do enormous good - for themselves and for suffering people - by building bridges with life coaches. Offer us your skills and expertise and let us be your connection to the outlaw counseling world. There are far too many people who need help out here and nowhere near enough people with the ability to actually do so. Quit shitting on us on Twitter and come give us a hand with this mess.
24
12
3
235
10,231
Cooper Davis retweeted
Replying to @luxarbo
I randomly ended up in a 300 level deleuzian analysis class led by a visiting professor, himself taking a break from teaching less “challenging”, more “concretized” subjects over at MIT, in part because Hampshire College was already running low on money in 2004 and if you were late to register, you got what you got (and according to Hampshire academic theology, subject matter was more or less immaterial; “mode of inquiry” determines what is learned, and that mode selection is always under one’s own control) Anyway, I suffered through the entire trimester unable to assess if I was learning anything at all. I definitely tried. And the professor (I think his name was Timmy Aziz) said on the very first day that we were there to “co-educate”, as he himself was not entirely sure what the Frenchman was trying to say. It was not my first go-round w/Deleuze, as I had previously ended up in an intro class (again without any particular interest in the subject but for reasons of pure procedure/fate). During that previous encounter i enjoyed the benefit of being able to reference the far more legible Bergson and Nietzsche’s outside works, and it was those guys who ultimately allowed me to sound plausibly caught up on the occasions I ventured to speak up in the first year seminar hall. This class had only 9 of us in it, and the only way to hide having not done the readings was to exude such deeply furrowed consternation and intellectual exertion as to evoke genuine worry in my “co-learners”that they might cause harm to my thought process to even ask me what I was thinking about. I hoped that my strained bearing and expression came across as quizzical to the extreme, as if the text had challenged me so much as to leave me in some kind of physical turmoil. In hindsight, i think they thought I was badly and chronically constipated, or troubled by romantic failures. I got through several months of this without having to produce a single written deliverable, and eventually became less burdened by any responsibility to follow along. If you aren’t familiar with Deleuze: impenetrable is an understatement. To this day, I am convinced his entire oeuvre is a long running practical joke being played by people who know that critical theory is arglebargle, on those who don’t. At the end of the class, it became apparent that I actually needed to make a major statement on how this experience had changed my entire relationship to my own thinking, vandalized my mind palace, or alternately, a highly qualified treatise on how and why I actively chose to prevent it from doing so. At Hampshire, there are no letter grades; instead you get a multi page qualitative evaluation from the professor, and because I had elected to spend the course in a mostly grimacing silence, I was in trouble. I really needed a good evaluation of if I wanted to finish my nontraditional college education in the traditional number of years. The night before my presentation was due, I despaired. I had nothing, and there was no one in the world who could even give me something I could use as my own. There was no way out, and I considered going full on dishonest with “my uncle’s died suddenly, I’ll sort this out when I get back”…but my cowardice was not as strong as my impulsivity. (END oF PART 1/2)
9
7
4
102
44,921
I am doing art again. Idk if it will be as interesting as it used to be, bc my brain has depreciated on many levels, but I’ve realized it’s sort of necessary for me to have nonverbal outlets to function properly
Replying to @TheAtlantic
Here’s an example of one of the mandalas I painted at that time, as mentioned in the episode (and in the episode title)
2
14
542
Cooper Davis retweeted
The Chemical Imbalance Myth: What Jack Goulder Gets Wrong I've read the recent Substack article by Jack Goulder entitled Merchants of Psychiatric Doubt and the subsequent exchanges with Dr Horowitz. First of all, I think it was poor judgment of Goulder to misquote Horowitz and Moncrieff, particularly when that quotation was central to his accusation that they had misrepresented their research. More fundamentally, though I think his dismissal of Horowitz's argument as "semantic somersaults" overlooks an important historical distinction. Contrary to the impression given in the article, the chemical imbalance theory was not simply a marketing narrative seized upon by drug companies. It was actively promoted and legitimised by influential figures within institutional medicine, particularly psychiatry. Until relatively recently, the NHS reproduced versions of this explanation on its websites, and as recently as 2025, Rebecca Brendel, a former president of the American Psychiatric Association, was publicly linking low serotonin with depression in the Washington Post. Psychiatry itself helped establish the credibility of this narrative, and the profession's role in promoting it deserves serious historical scrutiny. This matters because the chemical imbalance theory was not merely an abstract scientific hypothesis. It fundamentally shaped how depression was understood by the public, how SSRIs were presented to patients, and potentially how people made decisions about treatment. Millions of people were given the impression, by psychiatrists, GPs and medical journalism, that SSRIs corrected an underlying chemical deficiency. That is a very different proposition from telling patients that these drugs alter brain chemistry in ways we do not fully understand, that their average benefits over placebo are relatively modest, and that they carry risks. The chemical imbalance narrative also had important implications for long term prescribing. If patients believed they had an underlying serotonin deficiency, it was entirely reasonable for them to conclude that they might need medication indefinitely, just as someone with diabetes might require insulin. Whether and to what extent that belief contributed to long term prescribing deserves investigation, but it is hardly a trivial question. In other words, the theory that depression results from low serotonin played an important role in legitimising the widespread use of SSRIs, including their long term use. We now know that this explanation was not supported by the evidence. It is therefore entirely reasonable to say that research challenging the serotonin hypothesis also calls into question one of the principal historical rationales offered for prescribing these drugs. It is true that this is not the same as claiming that SSRIs have been demonstrated to be ineffective. Whether a drug produces a clinically meaningful benefit is a separate empirical question from whether it corrects the biological abnormality it was purportedly prescribed to treat. The is a substantive difference not a semantic one. It also raises important questions about informed consent. Patients are entitled to accurate explanations of why a treatment is being recommended, not simply evidence that it may produce some benefit. What I find particularly striking about the article is that Goulder devotes considerable attention to the philosophical commitments of psychiatry's critics, while giving comparatively little scrutiny to the professional and institutional commitments that helped sustain the chemical imbalance narrative for decades. If his concern is how prior beliefs and institutional interests shape the interpretation and communication of scientific evidence, surely that scrutiny should apply equally to mainstream psychiatry. One can reasonably argue that the serotonin hypothesis has no direct bearing on the evidence from antidepressant efficacy trials. But it does not follow that discrediting the hypothesis has no bearing on the historical justification for prescribing these medications, or on the decisions patients made after being told they suffered from a chemical imbalance. To characterise that distinction as "semantic" is, I think, to fundamentally miss the point of why setting the record straight about the chemical imbalance story matters so much.
5
22
3
59
4,888
Cooper Davis retweeted
Very grateful sir. The TLDR, in my mind, is that with these other institutions (CDC, aerospace, building codes etc) you actually can restore credibility to the institution because you can do objective failure analysis, perform corrective and preventative action, and figure out specific failure modes with high precision. Whereas I think the ability to do that in mental health is far far more limited. It’s too nebulous, too resistant to reductionism, too subjective. Which is exactly why the conclusion I always land at is…“opting out” and reducing the level of institutional power has to be a big part of the answer.
4
5
204
I hope it’s not true but this time of year I get sort of susceptible to REAL doom scrolling Land hits so hard I feel like I need an ice pack after each page
This is. My favourite internet essay. When I read it for the first time in 2018. Everything clicked in place and almost I’d say changed my life. So much density and philosophical beauty in such short space. I reread it every year.
1
277
Cooper Davis retweeted
I JUST HEARD SOMEONE SAY, “MAYBE YOU DON’T NEED MORE TIME TO HEAL, MAYBE YOU NEED MORE EXPERIENCES THAT SHOW YOUR NERVOUS SYSTEM A DIFFERENT REALITY,” AND YEAH… IT ECHOED IN ME
1
10
29
1,905
Cooper Davis retweeted
"We Should Argue More" Psychiatry has too few places where residents are encouraged to disagree. The Psychiatry Resident Debate Tournament is one of them, which I help organize. Thanks to @APApsychiatric for hosting, and to @PsychiatricNews and Brandon Prunty, DO, for writing about year one. This year's topic: the potential harms of social media for children, and how psychiatry should respond 🔥 Psychiatry residents come register and argue with us. Deadline to apply Nov 11. Link to article below.
6
9
24
1,117
The disease model of addiction arguably caused more harm than “chemical balance in the brain” or “born in the wrong body”. These simplistic explanations are liberating for the individual when they first hear about them but they’re damaging in the long run. Psychiatry’s arrogance causes long-term harm. Beware the simple explanation for complex human suffering.
Matthew Perry’s sister, Mia Perry Bowick, has told a new documentary about her brother’s life that his 2013 #Newsnight debate with Peter Hitchens was a “huge moment” in his decision to speak publicly about addiction and “show himself”. You can watch some of the debate here.
40
65
6
587
31,785
Ever tried to stop an antidepressant such as an SSRI or SNRI (or other psychiatric drug) and found reductions harder as you approach zero? For example, you’re tapering Effexor and found little difference when you reduced it from 225mg to 150mg. But later, you tried to drop from 75mg to 37.5mg and felt worse (and in different ways) than before you started the Effexor? You’re not imagining it. Brain imaging studies show that the effect of these drugs on the brain is not linear — it’s hyperbolic. At higher doses, much of the drug’s effect is already in place, so a larger reduction may change relatively little. But much smaller doses have a substantial effect, which means even modest cuts can have a dramatically larger impact on the brain as you get closer to zero. That’s where hyperbolic tapering can help reduce the risk of withdrawal: as your overall dose gets progressively smaller, the amount you cut each time gets progressively smaller as well. Our founder Laura Delano (@LauraDelano) touches on this in her recent conversation with Blake Mycoskie (@BlakeMycoskie) on No Magic Pill. See link below to watch the full episode.
8
20
1
42
1,284
Cooper Davis retweeted
chat is this real
163
709
87
7,789
474,794
I dont rly post abt music (except Talk Talk), & generally I don’t spend my (now more limited) online time listening to ppl noodling about Exception made Did u know u can just stop scrolling for 20 min and listen to something made by a human for other humans & also fun?
as a musican I am never satisfied with my work but actually I am extremely proud of this track. a handmade 23-minute adventure from spacey ambient to weird trip hop
1
1
12
573
Cooper Davis retweeted
it is absolutely imperative that you set up your timeline to encounter more old art, and less new AI slop. give your attention to artists who have labored painstakingly to actualize their vision, one intentional brushstroke at a time
John Martin - Satan Presiding at the Infernal Council (1824)
103
3,852
27
80,644
1,264,454
Cooper Davis retweeted
>“Radical new theory” Szent-Györgyi was talking about this in the ‘50s. Then Ling in the ‘60s. Then Harman and Peat in the ‘70s. Then Linnane et al. in the ‘80s. Then Wallace in the ‘90s. Mainstream medicine has been busy making hyper-specific patented drugs and chasing GWAS.
11
46
1
657
10,715
At some point I’ll want spoiler warnings on this kind of thing Culture is now so vastly outpaced by scientific advancement, it will take several generations to organically establish the necessary etiquette required to manage and adjudicate the value of understanding the mechanics of consciousness beyond a certain level of granularity Can I diminish the quality of my own thinking just by knowing more about how it works than is naturally evident?
313