It is really annoying what a punching bag communization becomes for people who have no answers for it beyond clichés that no longer hold.
2
48
What's curious is how many times she has these immediate explanations and exact quotes on hand but interprets them as if she hasn't looked at the paragraphs below or above the quotes, or read any other part of the cited work.
This Post is from an account that no longer exists. Learn more
1
2
251
They are talking about two *very* different things. What she calls a state is what Marx says must be replaced by working class rule. The worker's state is designed intentionally to make what she calls a state impossible.
1
2
23
I guess when Josh makes tweets like this, though, I feel vindicated about attacking him years ago, to the point he blocked me. Sometimes I'm like "maybe I went overboard on that one and they weren't as bad as I was making them out to be." Nah.
1
16
He can't just be pointing at mass lumpenzation and going "these destitute people will automatcially create communism." He's saying capitalism *will* lumpenize them, and that capital will then, inadvertnetly, have its back against a wall.
1
2
25
He saw enough brutality and cynical maneuvering in Europe to understand what could happen. I think he is writing at all because he has a conviction but also a desperation in getting people to understand their power collectively.
1
1
18

