David Heriot retweeted
Replying to @LiberationScot
The parliament isn't the building or the people who administer it. The parliament is the people we elect. If the people of Scotland are sovereign and we elect a majority of pro-independence MSPs, we have a pro-independence parliament. It cannot be other than a pro-independence parliament. Even the BBC cannot deny that it is a pro-independence parliament.
It could be argued that because it is a pro-independence parliament, it cannot simultaneously be "an arm of the British state". But there is a better argument.
If the people of Scotland are sovereign, as I will always maintain, then they are the ultimate political authority in Scotland. The people are the source of all democratic legitimacy, and all legitimate political authority derives from the people.
When we elect a parliament, we endow it with a political authority which derives directly from the sovereign people of Scotland. We empower the parliament to act for and on behalf of the people of Scotland. In effect, we authorise it to wield our sovereignty. The people use the parliament – the legislature – to give political and legal effect to their sovereignty.
The Scottish Parliament is wholly owned by the sovereign people of Scotland regardless of where it sits or who owns the building in which it sits.
Let's try a little thought experiment. Let us imagine that New Scotland Party (NSP) has stood candidates in a Scottish general election and has taken all 129 seats. Every NSP candidate takes an oath of allegiance to the people of Scotland prior to the parliamentary oath, in every sense of that word.
In fact, such a prior oath isn't really necessary. The parliamentary oath is an oath of allegiance to the sovereign. But the monarch is not sovereign in Scotland. The people are sovereign. Thus, an oath of allegiance to the sovereign is an oath of allegiance to the people.
But a prior oath is a 'cleaner' way for MSPs to nullify the oath they are required to swear in order to do the job they were elected to do. The parliamentary oath becomes performative and meaningless.
Getting back to our thought experiment, we now have 129 NSP MSPs, all of whom have taken a prior oath of allegiance to the people.
As NSP candidates, they stood for election on the Manifesto for Independence. This means that they have a mandate to assert the legislative competence of the Scottish Parliament in matters relating to the constitution; in effect, a universal declaration of independence, even if it is not presented as such.
The parliament also has a mandate to repudiate the Section 30 process as an unjustifiable and unlawful constraint on the exercise by the people of Scotland of their right of self-determination.
So, we now have a parliament in which sit 129 MSPs prepared to defy the British state and proceed with enacting legislation to dissolve the Union, subject to ratification by the people in a proper constitutional referendum. We have a parliament of 129 MSPs who are prepared to break the British state's rules in order to break the Union.
Of course, the UK Government might mount a legal challenge. Although there is good reason they would hesitate to do so, as the action taken is justified by being the only way the people can have the means and opportunity to fully and freely exercise their right of self-determination. Thus, the constitutional issue becomes a human right issue. Or more accurately, it is formally identified as a human rights issue.
Now to the point of our little thought exercise. Given all of the above, would you still insist that the Scottish Parliament is not our parliament? That claim starts to look quite silly.
You might argue that this is all fantasy and that it is impossible for one party to win every single seat. And you'd be right. But this is a thought experiment. So, let's think.
What is it about the number 129 that is important? It's not that one party has taken all the seats. Because 128 seats would have the same effect. As would 127, 126, all the way to 65. 129 is significant because it is all the MSSPs but because it is a majority. And other than the very specific and mainly irrelevant circumstances in which a qualified majority is required, all majorities are equal (see what I did there?).
So even if the number above is reduced to 65, the effect remains the same.
What does this thought experiment tell us? It tells us that it is not the case that the parliament is not ours, but that the people we elect don't act as if it is ours.
It is no surprise that the British parties don't act as if the Scottish Parliament were ours. It is shocking that the nominally pro-independence parties do not.
If we take back our government by electing a majority of people who are prepared to act as members of our parliament, we can take back our parliament by asserting its primacy founded on the mandate of the sovereign people of Scotland.
Power is not given. Power is only taken. Power that is given is, on being accepted, an affirmation of the superiority of the giver.
I'll deal with other points more briefly.
The Scottish Parliament is Scotland's legislature. There cannot be a second legislature. Only the Scottish Parliament has the democratic legitimacy required to enact the legislation which dissolves the Union. That is why we must repossess it. Why we must take it back.
We cannot conjure a new legislature from thin air. Why would we want to when we have one already? Why would we not do the simpler thing and take back our parliament from those who have usurped it and twisted it into an arm of the British state? That is not its normal state. It is only an arm of the British state because it has been hijacked and turned to that purpose. It only continues to serve that purpose because nobody has challenged England-as-Britain's right to use it as they will. They have no such right unless we allow it. Our political elite allows it on our behalf because they lack the courage to disallow it.
It is not for us to "establish Scots sovereignty in the international arena". Nor is it for us to prove that "the Treaty of Union is a fraud". If we act in the manner of a sovereign state, it is for others to challenge our right to do so. It is for them to prove that we are not sovereign.
We don't need to prove anything about the Treaty of Union other than that a majority of people in Scotland want it dissolved. We don't attack. We act, and by the manner in which we act, we take the moral, legal, and constitutional high ground and dare them to attack. We make the constitutional issue a human rights issue by focusing on the right of self-determination and invite the British state to prove that we are not a people and Scotland is not a nation and so we don't have a right of self-determination.
We break their rules and challenge them to prove that those rules were fair. We invite them to say aloud in a court of law all the things that confirm Scotland is an annexed territory.
We strike off the chains of devolution and let them dispute our right to be free of those chains.
We act as if we are a sovereign people in the early days of a nation again, and we defy them to try and invoke the Treaty of Union.
Sovereignty is not passive. Sovereign is not just what we are, but what we do. If we do not act as a sovereign people, why would anyone think us sovereign?
Restoring Scotland's independence cannot be other than a great act of defiance. Our defiance.
PS - This response has turned out a bit longer than anticipated. Once I get started, it all starts to pour out. I just hope it is coherent.
Being so long, it may be difficult to read on X. Therefore, I intend to repost my response on my Substack under a link to your comment. If you have any objections, please let me know.
David Heriot retweeted
Really? When it comes to Scotland that’s a legal fiction supported by a lie.
There is no British monarch unless British means purely English. The Scottish Crown was ‘annexed’ to that of England (or as the HoC massages it, the English Coronation Oath ‘was extended to Scotland’), in flagrant violation of the whole purpose and supposed of effect of the Treaty and Union. (The creation of a single kingdom which required a single crown no ifs buts or maybes; Crown and kingdom are interdependent.) So two crowns remain. Which one owns the seabed? Legally the Scottish Crown, which is the legal identity of the Community of the Realm. i.e, the people not the monarch, own the sea bed.
That’s why the English Parliament had to pass an Act vesting oil and gas in ‘his majesty’ although English oil and gas are automatically ‘vested’ in the monarch as the Crown! Scottish oil and gas, 80.% of the total are vested in the annexed Scottish Crown. For the same reason Blair moved the maritime boundary of England to take part of the Scottish area. Utterly unnecessary if there were legally, and not just rhetorically a ‘single kingdom’ and a territorially united state of the U.K. Brits are brilliant at pretending to be all law abiding and all about legal authority. They are pirates.
Further proof of annexation/colonisation? Despite the continuation of the Scottish Crown, every English monarch since George I has taken a gobbledygook English invention they call the Scottish Oath of Accession (The real Oath is still on the states and still statutorily required). It’s a kind of concession to the conditions for the Scottish Crown - a crown he or she is not wearing, but administering as an English Crown territory.
Nothing exists to legalise this. There is no treaty that allows this. And in international law this is territorial alienation and a violation of a fundamental aspect of the right of self determination.
We have been fed utter bs by the British state as the fulcrum of all law, domestic and international. Expert voices, intimidating legal jargon and powerful positions substitute for clear eyed, hard headed fact and implication. In the name of God and the Scottish people when will we wake up and start comparing what we are told with what the facts, evidence and the precedents of international law tell us if we can just bring ourselves to discard the British (totally self contradictory) official constitutional narrative?
David Heriot retweeted
Police Scotland doesn't represent Scotland but the oppressive, repressive British regime open.substack.com/pub/dearsc…
Repost and follow please :)
HOW do we restore our independence?
Beg Westminster for a referendum that they won't 'grant' and which would be useless anyway?
Or do we stop asking and TAKE back our independence?
It's time to TAKE
manifestoforindependence.sco…
1
13
Do you think it’s time to take our independence? manifestoforindependence.sco…
And give @ManifestoForInd a follow
7
David Heriot retweeted
Replying to @80_mcswan
Westminster is desperate to keep 🏴
's resources... 👇🏻
David Heriot retweeted
🧵 The Aftermath of the 1707 Union – What Really Happened?
Most people assume Scotland gained prosperity from the Union. But the reality was far darker - one of betrayal, economic decline, and rebellion.
Let’s break it down. 👇
1/
David Heriot retweeted
If Scotland really is in a political union – which is what the UK is – then why is it that we get nothing from it for giving up our independence to be in it?
Get the booklet at projectarbroath.scot
David Heriot retweeted
Still think that asking/demanding/begging the UK for another indyref that somehow will restore our independence is a good idea? There's only way to restore our independence and that's to take it. It's in the booklet from Project Arbroath at projectarbroath.scot
David Heriot retweeted
Still think that asking the British government for another indy referendum is a good idea? (Hint: it really isn't). Inform yourself and others with 'How to take back our independence' from Project Arbroath. Thousands of people already have. Why not join them?
It's for you if you still think asking Westminster for indyref2 is a good idea (hint: it isn't). Get the booklet at projectarbroath.scot. Over 3,000 of your fellow Scots have one
7
David Heriot retweeted
On Friday the Salvo Special: ‘the UN Decolonisation Process’ will be available on youtube.com/@indyscotnews?fe…
Alf Baird, John Brown and I answer questions put by Norrie Hunter on Liberation Scotland’s international campaign.
Hello people that follow me. Would you mind following Project Arbroath please? They’re @ProjectArbroath
And would you also ask your followers to do the same?
Project Arbroath published the first of their wee blue books at the end of last year. See projectarbroath.scot for more
9
David Heriot retweeted
Salvo Research Group:
“The people of Scotland must awaken to the reality that Holyrood, rather than being a true parliament for Scotland’s interests, is a carefully constructed mechanism to sustain the illusion of a union, BUT that in fact, drains Scotland’s resources & systematically undermines its cities, towns, & communities. With every passing year, Scotland receives less, while City of London & England trading as the fake construct commonly known as the “uk” profits more & more.
The so-called block grant is nothing more than a managed allowance, specifically designed to keep Scotland dependent while City of London / “uk” forcibly extracts wealth from our land, waters, & industries.
This is not a partnership. It is a deliberate economic stranglehold, ensuring Scotland remains a nation of concern in terms of health, wealth, & well-being. The statistics prove it, Scotland’s people suffer lower life expectancy, rising poverty, underfunded public services, & declining infrastructure, all while our vast natural wealth is siphoned off to sustain London & the South of England. This is no accident. It is a calculated policy of suppression, facilitated by the elites, the media, & the oligarchs who benefit from Scotland’s continued subjugation.
Scotland is a land of plenty, yet her people receive only enough to survive. A slow, systematic destruction of our nation is underway, not by open warfare, but through economic deprivation, forced austerity, & the erosion of our industries & communities. The very fabric of Scotland’s identity is being unraveled, and our people are being erased, subtly but relentlessly.
The truth is that Scotland does not need permission to leave this destructive and one-sided arrangement. The so-called “United Kingdom” is not a legitimate union , it is an imperial construct, never properly ratified as a treaty under international law, never lodged with the United Nations, & never agreed to by the people of Scotland under any democratic process.
The world must recognise that England, Britain, & Westminster are the last remnants of a colonial empire desperately clinging to power. Their use of vetoes at the UN to protect their own interests & destroy the futures of other nations & peoples is nothing short of an abuse of international governance, & Scotland’s continued captivity within this failed state is an international scandal.
That this deception has been allowed to persist without demand for proof of a legitimate treaty raises serious questions about accountability & credibility in upholding international law - the United Nations has a massive opportunity now to right this wrong for the world.
Scotland’s future is not one of decline but of massive potential. The resources, innovation, & talent exist for Scotland to thrive as an independent nation, free from the constraints of a decaying empire. The people of Scotland must now take ownership of their own destiny. The choice is clear—remain in a broken, exploitative system designed to ensure Scotland’s decline, or step forward as a sovereign nation, reclaiming the wealth, dignity, & future that is rightfully ours.
The world is watching. It is down to us & the time is now.!”
David Heriot retweeted
It’s for you if you think that all decisions about Scotland should be taken by Scotland and not by some other country.
Get the A6 booklet from projectarbroath.scot. Or get two and give one to someone else. Or get a bundle for your campaign hub for your next stall.
David Heriot retweeted
We're sharing our message throughout Scotland! Our booklet distribution, and our message is rapidly reaching all corners of the country. We are the decision-makers in Scotland. #Scotland
Get your own copy of the booklet today at buff.ly/3YKtF3G
David Heriot retweeted
Project Arbroath is for those who believe Scotland should make its own decisions. If you're curious about Scotland's union with England or its political journey, this booklet is your guide to understanding and action.
Get your copy today at buff.ly/3YKtF3G
David Heriot retweeted
In just 40 pages, Project Arbroath covers how Scotland entered into a union with England, the Claim of Right and why it’s important, how we’ve fared in the UK (not well), and finally, how we can take back our sovereignty.
buff.ly/3UWXYmH























