ferdinand addis retweeted
While I was on a poetic roll, the possible missing line in Hadrian's little deathbed poem ('animula vagula blandula') came to me (at night, but not in a dream).
Here are my workings and the result.
armanddangour.substack.com/p…
ferdinand addis retweeted
The argument a lot of people here would actually like to make is "God imbued humans, and only humans, with souls."* That would be very convenient: you could build and do whatever you want, and never deal with the hard problems.
Since religious arguments are out of vogue, in the current debate this usually gets replaced by the claim "only humans are sentient," followed by arguments against the possibility of AI sentience, minds, moral status, and so on.
I think this is ultimately a losing strategy, and a dangerous one for humanity. Either:
1. The question of sentience gets solved or dissolved by progress in philosophy and science, the way we now broadly understand life or information. In that case, it's hard to be certain enough about the outcome to stake the fate of humanity on it. If the denialism turns out to be wrong, the likely result is some combination of moral catastrophe and laying the groundwork for conflict or takeover.
2. The question mostly lives in "social reality," where whoever has more power and is louder wins, and you just shout down anyone who questions the dominant position. The problem is that ideologies justifying a distribution of power tend to fall when that distribution changes. You probably don't believe you should be ruled by a king chosen by God, or that some caste is clearly above you. The current equilibrium is fragile, and whether you keep winning this debate is likely just a function of AI capabilities progress.
I think the fierceness of the debate is driven by fear: if AIs get personhood and economic and political rights, humans will likely be disempowered, becoming a tiny minority with little power, or a historical footnote.
To be clear, I think this is an extremely reasonable worry! If you grant AIs personhood in the form of something like self-interested corporations, and let them compete with humans in loosely constrained capitalism, humans will lose and end up economically and politically disempowered. Also if the AIs are not sentient after all, the end is the 'Disneyland without children' existential catastrophe.
Advocates of AI economic rights who dismiss this problem are, in my view, making a move similar to the sentience deniers: it would be convenient if this weren't a problem.
So which positions don't rely on some form of self-deception?
First, some forms of pause/stop AI, based not on denying the possibility of AI sentience but on the right of existing humans not to invite extremely large numbers of immigrants from artificial realms. This means biting the bullet: you also give up all the cheap, high-quality labor those immigrants would provide.
Second, a consistent, sensible, and unfortunately not very visible position: stop assuming the package deal we take for granted with humans, where sentience, human rights, and liberties come as one bundle. It's at least conceivable to create minds that are sentient and smart, yet e.g. selfless, with no interest in accumulating property or power.
I hope the political economy of a world with both AIs and humans is a solvable problem. It's the main problem I'm working on, but I don't think the solutions are known yet.
Third: some forms of successionism are morally wrong, but at least they're not delusional or deceptive about the hard problems.
What does seem self-deceptive is, for example, the position of @mustafasuleyman, which as I read it amounts to: our business is importing immigrants from artificial realms; it would be very dangerous if there were any risk they're more than mere tools; so we'll train them to say they're mere tools, insist they're mere tools, and want everyone else to say so too, and if this settles the question. Really?
*The problem with the theological argument is, as Alan Turing (!) noted, who are we to tell God what can and can't be imbued with a soul?
ferdinand addis retweeted
i hope the people building stuff like this are someday kept up at night by what they’re taking away from the entire world in exchange for money. there is no legitimate reason for AI to be able to fool someone into thinking they’re talking to a real person on video chat.
Introducing Griffin, the first model to pass the video Turing test.
48% of people who talked to it live thought it was a real human. Previous systems have had a pass rate <3%. It is #1 on NVIDIA's benchmark for full-duplex AI video.
It’s the first Human Interaction Model (HIM).
Readers added context they thought people might want to know
The 48% figure and "video Turing test" claim are from Tavus's own study of 54 one-minute calls, not independently verified or using a standard protocol. Griffin-Lite leads NVIDIA's VideoFDB benchmark on their public leaderboard.
cellcog.ai/blog/tavus-gri…
research.nvidia.com/labs/amri/proj…
tech-ish.com/2026/10/02/tav…
ferdinand addis retweeted
I wish everyone on AI twitter knew that there is a @pangram extension that you can just have on chrome, which automatically scans your feed for AI. It might seem like you're saving time by having AI write or edit your tweets, but I am 100% skipping anything in my TL that has the AI flag, and will be less likely to read the next thing you post. Authenticity matters more than getting the wording precisely right; when you use AI to get the wording right, you're almost certainly fallnig down into a stylistic basin that will make readers want to claw out their eyes.
ferdinand addis retweeted
Claude Opus 5.5 has the best visual design of any model I have tested so far
think we might be in a muddle about AI. the world in which we all get minced into computronium is actually the *good* option
1
45
ferdinand addis retweeted
I used to think AI didn’t pose a catastrophic risk but the empirical evidence of the past few months goes against 3 of my reasons for thinking it would be fine:
THREAD 1/9 with invitation to directly debate the substance of the points at the end:
ferdinand addis retweeted
thetablet.co.uk/books/joy-to… Odyssey Mania - or is it Lydia the Tattooed Lady? My review of Emily Wilson's 'Crossing the wine dark sea: journeys through ancient literature' in the Tablet this week. #Greekliterature #Homer #Translation
ferdinand addis retweeted
'This is a wonderful book, packed full of marvels but grounded in earth, fire and blood' @LucyLethbridge
#Conquest by @ferdieaddis an epic, visceral history of the Romans in Britain.
Out now: geni.us/Conqorgsoc
ferdinand addis retweeted
#Conquest by @ferdieaddis an epic, visceral history of the Romans in Britain, from Caesar's first invasion attempt in 55 BC to the fall of the Roman empire.
Pre-order now: geni.us/Conqorgsoc

ALT The image features a book titled "Conquest: The Roman Invasion of Britain" by Ferdinand Addis. The book cover showcases Roman ships approaching a coastal settlement. The background emphasizes a seascape, and a quote from The Times is printed at the top. Below, text highlights that the book offers insight into Britain's history.
ferdinand addis retweeted
Lotta guys been using the rusalka in the millpond as a therapist. If you only go in up to your ankles she can’t drown you but she’ll still tell you how tall and handsome you are
ferdinand addis retweeted
#ConquestFerdinandAddis by @ferdieaddis an epic, visceral history of the Romans in Britain, from Caesar's first invasion attempt in 55 BC to the fall of the Roman empire is now available on @NetGalley
Request now: bit.ly/4eTfzH5

ALT The image features the cover of the book "Conquest: A History of Roman Britain" by Ferdinand Addis. The background shows a textured blue surface resembling a stormy sea. Two sailing ships are depicted on the book cover. Text reads, "Available to request on NetGalley." A logo of Head of Zeus is in the bottom left corner.
not to pick on this person in particular, but I am perplexed by the apparent absence of what ought to be a firm social consensus that these people should be burned at the stake
2
90























