Folklore and Math (@folkloreandmath) header
Folklore and Math (@folkloreandmath) profile picture

Procrastinating, sharing opinions, looking for world news, hoping for happier times 🙏. If you read my posts, always press "show more" to see the complete text!

I wish to be in Prague again!
Joined April 2023
Photo by Folklore and Math (@folkloreandmath)Photo by Folklore and Math (@folkloreandmath)Photo by Folklore and Math (@folkloreandmath)Photo by Folklore and Math (@folkloreandmath)Photo by Folklore and Math (@folkloreandmath)Photo by Folklore and Math (@folkloreandmath)Photo by Folklore and Math (@folkloreandmath)Photo by Folklore and Math (@folkloreandmath)Photo by Folklore and Math (@folkloreandmath)
Mientras el medallista olĂ­mpico #YuberjenMartinez peleaba por un titulo mundial de #Boxeo para #Colombia, estaba un evento muy flojo como el #StreamFighters5 con #WestCol, debajo de las expectativas y aĂșn asi mucho mas visto que el de boxeo "real" del que la mayorĂ­a ni sabĂ­a😒
1
3
1,356
No comparto la lĂłgica de treparse en el bus de criticar a los periodistas y ex-futbolistas de #ESPNF90Colombia (como Arzuaga o Mao Molina si salieron) como justificativo para "despidos", cuando las razones de falta de sintonĂ­a no se deben a los individuos en si. Abro hilo đŸ§” 1) El consumidor colombiano veĂ­a mĂĄs los programas argentinos que los mismos colombianos. #ESPNF90, #ESPNF12 con Vignolo y Closs eran mas vistos en Colombia que los programas de opiniĂłn colombianos. Pero Disney los suspendiĂł en Colombia y ya no se pueden ver siquiera para los que pagan #DisneyPlus Premium. Esto tambiĂ©n afecta las audiencias de los programas argentinos, pues se nutrĂ­an mucho de la audiencia de otros paises. 2) A diferencia de Argentina que hay mayor aficiĂłn futbolistica, se puede sostener una señal con montones de programas a lo largo del dĂ­a hablando del mismo tema. En Colombia escasamente #ESPNF90Colombia tiene audiencia, a diferencia de los otros dos de opiniĂłn que hay, asĂ­ que sobran programas y sobran comentaristas (triste, pues muchos necesitan trabajo, pero hay pocos espacios) 3) Aparte de la calidad y la competitividad del Futbol Argentino comparado con el Colombiano (sin que sea la maravilla), una diferencia fundamental es que la mayorĂ­a de los partidos del futbol sobre los cuales se debate se transmitieron en ESPN, mientras que el futbol colombiano tiene mĂ­nima audiencia, señal cerrada de WinSports+, asĂ­ que se polemiza sobre partidos que la audiencia ni siquiera viĂł por televisiĂłn!! AsĂ­ que hay comentarios sobre Nacional, America, Millos, SantaFĂ©, Junior, etc en juegos donde la audiencia solo viĂł el resumen con goles, ni sabe las nĂłminas ni las figuras del campeonato, pobre de por sĂ­. Solamente los partidos de selecciones o de Champions League fueron vistos por la gente y para ellos no sentimos que necesitemos "el profundo anĂĄlisis" de los periodistas colombianos y menos por triplicado (al menos yo veo un partido narrado, comentado por Closs/Latorre o Simon/Espina o Baravalle y por mucho ver el resumen en #Sportscenter ya es suficiente para mi) 4) Hay periodistas muy profesionales en #ESPNColombia y si hay malos, los hay en todas partes, Argentina, Chile, PerĂș, etc. Menospreciar el talento humano solo por un problema de audiencia no relacionado por los individuos en sĂ­, sino por las decisiones erradas de mercado es una forma barata de "dispararnos en el pie" y subestimarnos nosotros mismos. He dicho ... (para las dos o tres personas que me leen, jejeje) 🙂
1
2
322
Folklore and Math retweeted
Replying to @LauraCVargas96
Que cortina de humo tan grande el cambio de ministro de #RodrigoLara a #AlejandroOrdonez, cuando hay debate en el congreso sobre rebaja de penas a testaferros y lavadores de activos del narcotrĂĄfico, que pasarĂ­an de mĂĄs de 20 años a mĂĄximo 3 años y con posible excarcelaciĂłn.🚹
1
6
14
353
Folklore and Math retweeted
BREAKING: OpenAI’s solution to Navier–Stokes does not match its Lean verification. The most important article to read today is not one of OpenAI’s 700 AI-generated math papers. It is this other paper, making a deep and worrying point: A Lean-verified proof does not automatically validate the proof written in natural language, nor does it mean that the formal statement captures the intended theorem. During translation, an AI can change an assumption, weaken a statement, or replace the argument entirely. It can hallucinate another theorem. Lean correctly verifies the result. But the proved result may no longer be what the paper claims. This is a general problem. Things get spicy when the authors examine OpenAI’s proposed Navier–Stokes solution. They identify at least two mismatches between the written intermediate results and their Lean counterparts: One estimate claims that four additional input derivatives suffice. The Lean version requires five: a weaker result. A pressure-flux estimate is obtained through a different bound, and proved through a different argument. It is not clear whether these mismatches invalidate the entire proof. But they raise an important issue. OpenAI is flooding us with claimed revolutionary breakthroughs. Yet nobody knows whether the proofs are correct or whether they prove what they claim to be proving. Epistemia at scale. * Paper in the first reply
229
919
313
5,361
638,772
Folklore and Math retweeted
OpenAI and Anthropic oversold AI security breaches to pressure feds into protecting turf: insiders trib.al/Jo6xMk5
669
2,074
938
11,055
4,329,222
A new risk for mathematicians: a colleague reports that immediately after they posted an abstract of their upcoming talk online, a student elsewhere used AI to derive proofs of the stated results and then posted it on the arxiv. My colleague hadn't posted to arxiv yet.
79
231
63
3,086
317,675
What news channels are not telling you about the latest AI news, and what is behind "the panic extinction scenario" and coordinated communication between the CEOs of #Anthropic (Amodei), #OpenAI (Altman) and Elon Musk Video by @mattmurphyai (on Instagram)
1
3
191
Folklore and Math retweeted
Dyson on why von Neumann’s groundbreaking 1932 “Mathematical Foundations of Quantum Mechanics” failed to have an impact on mainstream physicists ("For the physicists, Johnny did not exist.") (From "Birds and Frogs").
11
23
6
260
14,108
Folklore and Math retweeted
24 Fields Medalists speak out against "A Severe Misalignment of AI in Mathematics" mathandai.org/
99
297
96
1,335
378,294
Folklore and Math retweeted
This massive OpenAI scandal should not be interpreted merely from a position of academic dishonesty or basic plagiarism. This is especially true for naive tech startups and ambitious founders who are currently, blindly outsourcing their core proprietary work to AI chatbots under the corporate illusion of maximizing efficiency and cutting operational costs. Recall that Facebook bought Instagram for a staggering $1 billion in 2012. Now, even though Facebook was six years older than Instagram, possessed infinitely better funding and boasted a superior digital infrastructure, Mark Zuckerberg quickly realized that Instagram's core architecture was highly unique and a direct existential threat, hence the massive acquisition. But this historic billion-dollar acquisition would never have happened if Facebook had the technological means, the insider knowledge, and the raw blueprint to simply clone and build Instagram before its original developers could even complete it. Now, imagine a chilling scenario where the early founders of Instagram naively sent their raw source codes, proprietary algorithms, database schemas and backend architecture directly to an AI like Codex, ChatGPT, or Claude just to correct a few bugs or improve their deployment speed. This mathematically means that whichever predatory tech monopoly built those AI models would instantly have unfettered, backdoor access to the exact unreleased blueprints of Instagram. And since these established tech empires naturally possess infinitely better compute capabilities, massive server farms and bottomless venture capital funding, they would have effortlessly cloned, built, patented, and launched the platform long before the original, struggling developers even finished setting up their basic website domain. All of these glaring realities put together perfectly explain exactly why independent developers, software engineers, and academic researchers must immediately stop feeding their novel codes, proprietary algorithms, and unpublished manuscripts into these corporate chatbots. Except for facilitating brutal warfare, automating military drone strikes, and expanding dystopian state surveillance, generative AI is absolutel iny not a profitable, self-sustaining industry. This is precisely why these desperate tech monopolies generously give you "early access" to their frontier models. It is a highly calculated trap designed strictly to lure you into voluntarily submitting your unpublished manuscripts, your raw data, and your intellectual labor to their chatbots. They do this simply to plagiarize your genius, steal your life's work, take absolute corporate credit for your discoveries, and permanently lock your own innovations behind a massive, expensive corporate paywall.
We congratulate Levent Alpöge and Tristan Buckmaster on their remarkable mathematical work. We (the researchers and the agents) did not see any of their work through any means until they released it publicly — in particular, no specific user data was accessed in order to solve this problem. While unlikely, we cannot rule out that de-identified data derived from their usage of our products helped improve our models. However, our proofs differ significantly and even the precise results proved are different in the Euler case (forced vs. unforced).
5
64
8
231
7,926
Folklore and Math retweeted
The way OpenAI handled this Navier--Stokes situation was the first time I've actually felt disgust at the whole AI in math situation. Like watching a billionare celebrate his hunting prowess by mounting the head of an endagered rhino on his wall, after 1000 soldiers trapped it.
63
380
27
4,446
121,866
Folklore and Math retweeted
unfortunately i contacted them on the night of wednesday, september 2nd making the following points 1. i had intel they had information about math work i was doing and a few days before they had spun up a group to try to compete. 2. i emphasized and reemphasized mine was a strictly personal mathematical collaboration 3. that this was a collaboration that had been going on for a year 4. that in my personal collaboration we were happy users of codex as well as obviously claude (and i later complimented astra explicitly after it came out for its help, and reassured i would obviously be sprinkling acknowledgments for it, previous models, and codex liberally in the writeups) 5. that it would look terrible if openai were competing against mathematician consumers, and my collaborator (Tristan) wanted to email about this explicitly 6. that i expected none but in the worst case intended to refuse marketing around the result we were working towards, being the fruit of a personal external academic collaboration, and wanted to express this because i figured worries about such marketing by their leadership was why a team was spun up to extraordinarily directly compete. sebastien and i have in the past months had our fun pushing each other on twitter, but as i process it all i keep feeling bad about Tristan. 1. neither of us could sleep Sunday night, so we went on a walk around the city. i finally asked him why fluids, and he told me it was the navier-stokes problem. he told me parts of the story about his classic nonuniqueness result with Vicol i hadn’t heard yet, and also about how he too grew up writing shaders as a kid and then switched to math 2. tristan is a mathematician’s mathematician. he kept rock solid to his principles during the tense calls and negotiations, immediately turning down a career dream and million dollar prize for me, the sort of strange excited unclear-quasiuseful confused idiot in our collaboration. fifteen minutes later, his feet were up on his desk with three toes per foot peeking out of ripped socks 3. our periodic call after i’d texted him euler blowup was just laughing for an hour or two. just laughing. i’d seen fable deal correctly with monge ampere in the equality case of ehrhart’s conjecture, so in some call before that i’d really pushed him for the craziest shit he could think of that i might try. i texted him the pdf as an update on that “diego luis 3” line, in which following his incredible expression of intuition i hodgepodge slapped together a bunch of our recent work, in particular correcting a bunch of better and lesser known papers in the literature, as well as on diego and luis’ ipm paper, and hoped an analogous construction for boussinesq (thus axisym euler) might work out. i managed to wade through enough confusion to insist to the model it stop telling me stupid regularity stuff about kelvin waves, and a rayleigh-taylor ansatz stuck. like i said, just laughing. when i texted him the pdf, the worst thing either of us had seen so far, i didn’t even comment on the euler blowup claim, only explaining why skepticism should remain for boussinesq, because i found it so shocking. i mean what the hell did i know, i must’ve confused myself by misunderstanding one adjective like i was used to with algebraic geometry. im so lucky to have been able to live that 4. he managed all this this entire time with unclear sleep, timestamps continue to amaze me, due to just recently having a kid it is obvious he deserves the same sort of praise he heaped upon luis, perhaps mutatis mutandis:)
Replying to @__alpoge__
nothing at all was locked we were just willing to talk but you didn't talk to us ... sorry but that's just untrue, we were willing to go above and beyond and have as many discussions as you would have liked to reach resolution.
136
546
88
6,216
726,868
Folklore and Math retweeted
This is the textbook definition of a Greek gift. On the surface, OpenAI generously grants 10,000 top-tier mathematicians and elite engineers free access to their frontier models under the noble, philanthropic banner of accelerating scientific discovery, pushing the boundaries of human knowledge, and democratizing artificial intelligence. But deep down in the cold reality of Silicon Valley capitalism, what they are actually doing is executing a massive, highly sophisticated intellectual heist. They are quietly gaining unrestricted, backdoor access to the raw, unfiltered, and unpublished works of the absolute finest minds in the global scientific community. Every single complex prompt, every mathematical query, every theoretical framework, and every line of experimental code fed into that system is a novel, groundbreaking idea that does not even exist yet in published academic literature or peer-reviewed journals. OpenAI does not just provide a helpful service. Their corporate algorithms sit quietly behind the scenes, aggressively monitoring all chat logs, scraping the intellectual property, analyzing the logical steps, and meticulously piecing together these fragmented, brilliant ideas over several months. And just when the human researcher is finally on the absolute brink of putting everything together, OpenAI will ruthlessly assemble a digital army of 10,000 autonomous AI agents, burn $20 million worth of computational tokens, and brute-force the final mathematical steps. Then, with the backing of their massive PR machine, corporate journalists, and tech influencers, they will proudly hold a press conference to claim that their proprietary chatbot has miraculously solved a Millennium Prize problem, completely, shamelessly erasing the human genius they systematically strip-mined to achieve it.
We’re giving scientists, mathematicians, and engineers free access to our frontier models—starting with 10,000 researchers and expanding to 100,000 through 2027. ChatGPT for Academic Researchers is built to accelerate discovery across disciplines.
281
4,039
257
16,502
718,304
Folklore and Math retweeted
tristan buckmaster just published a statement that is, if accurate, one of the ugliest things i’ve read out of a frontier lab. not because of the math. because of what happened after openai found out two people were about to beat them to the punch. buckmaster and levent alpöge spent a year pushing the cĂłrdoba / martĂ­nez-zoroa program to smooth forcing. august 15 they got blowup for boussinesq and 3d euler. lean-verified august 22. they were paying openai out of pocket and dumping every draft into private codex sessions. the program is obscure. almost nobody else was on it. this was not “paste the clay problem into a chatbot.” then this: > thursday sept 3, buckmaster emails openai privately. rumors are flying. he is trying to stop a mess, not start one. > they reply the same day: give us details so we can “avoid competing.” also, want free compute? > sunday they suddenly need a call “at any point today.” sebastien bubeck gets on. levent is not invited. > openai says an internal model has a ~100-page proof of forced navier–stokes blowup. fefferman options c and d. the exact route buckmaster and alpöge had quietly chosen. > they show him a prompt and claim the model was “simply given the problem statement.” levent is told “very little human input.” > that falls apart on the same call. a whole team had been on it. they started on the unforced problem, warmed the model up on easier equations including euler, and even the prompt they showed him was written by prompting codex. > he asks when the first prompt went out. they stall. then agree: the past few days. after information about his work reached openai. > he asks whether the model was trained on, or had access to, the private codex sessions where they put every draft of this project. > answer: the model does not look up user data. > he asks again. about training. > no answer. then it stops being a science story and becomes an hr story. > offer 1: you post euler. we post navier–stokes the next day. > offer 2: after you post euler, you alone write the navier–stokes paper, credit our model, and we cut levent. > bubeck says twice he wants levent removed from authorship because he works at anthropic. he declines both. he says if they release it that way, he goes public. the reply is not a scientific objection. > “why would you ruin your career?” > “if you don’t want me to be nice, then i don’t have to be nice.” later, a text to levent proposing a one-on-one: > “i don’t know if tristan is being fully rational right now.” that is not how you treat a collaborator. that is how you split one. openai got word two researchers were closing a path almost nobody else was on. they spun up a team on that exact path. they would not answer whether the researchers’ unpublished drafts in openai’s product were used. they tried to dictate the announcement order. they tried to remove a coauthor because he works at a competitor. when that failed, someone reached for a career threat. this is a lab finding out academics were about to publish, sprinting the same narrow program, refusing the data question, and trying to manage credit around a rival affiliation. really slimy if even half of this holds. what the fuck is happening.
holy shit. tristan buckmaster is saying openai has a forced navier–stokes blowup via the cĂłrdoba / martĂ­nez-zoroa program. and that it may have used drafts from his and levent alpöge’s private codex sessions. that’s the cĂłrdoba / martĂ­nez-zoroa route. almost nobody else was on it. he also says the first prompt went out after information about his and levent alpöge’s work reached openai. that “very little human input” was not true. that a whole team had already been set on easier problems, including euler. that even the prompt they showed him was written by prompting codex. then he asked: did the model have their private codex sessions. no answer on training. if any of that holds, openai didn’t just scoop a math result. they may have done it off two researchers’ unpublished drafts, then tried to cut the coauthor because he works at anthropic. a millennium-problem-adjacent result just became employee drama before an ipo. i don’t even know which part is crazier. this is one of the slimiest things i’ve seen in this industry.
233
2,394
458
15,122
1,816,991
Folklore and Math retweeted
go fuck yourself @sama claiming that you solved navier stokes because 10000 agents ran in circles for 88hours on a multimillion dollar gpu cluster to formalize in lean a blowup case under controlled external forcing is pure scientific vulgarity the clay mathematics institute millennium prize does not ask m whether you can artificially force a singularity in a fluid by injecting an ad hoc smooth external forcing term f(x,t) to twist the vortex until it breaks the real problem questions the fundamental stability and global smooth existence for 3dimensional incompressible euler & navier stokes equations under natural conservation laws and viscous dissipation alone using a mathematical loophole on forced equations to parade a century old victory is a major conceptual scam Altman technically & epistemologically what you present as an agi breakthrough is nothing more than bruteforce combinatorial autoformalization the ai did not understand fluid mechanics it simply navigated a continuous search space previously mapped out and constrained by the monumental work of human mathematicians like tristan buckmaster/ levent alpöge / diego córdoba or tarek elgindi coordinating 10000 agents to check the logical consistency of a 100 page proof via lean is a software engineering feat and computational parallelization triumph not an intrinsic scientific discovery it is the victory of the compute bulldozer over abstract human intuition repackaged for the public as a higher mathematical consciousness to this theoretical imposture you add a disgusting ethical and industrial cynicism taking advantage of private codex sessions and informal preprints from academic researchers to siphon their research leads and then trying to redact or erase the contribution of levent alpöge under the pretext that he works at rival anthropic is intellectual serfdom openai behaves like a feudal lord of silicon appropriating the cognitive subsistence of independent scholars threatening their careers behind closed doors if they protest and turning community academic labor into a privatized pressrelease this entire staged event serves a desperate financial agenda in a pre ipo panic facing the slowdown of scaling laws and growing investor skepticism over the profitability of foundational models openai needs to manufacture an artificial sputnik moment claiming to solve a millennium prize without immediately submitting the proof to traditional peer review means using the prestige of fundamental mathematics as cheap marketing fuel to inflate a delusional valuation!!! real science is not a clout chase on social media or a compute spike spent to rob the clay mathematics institute it is a quest for elegance physical truth and universal rigor to decode reality true artificial intelligence will not emerge from hostile corporate takeover of academic work hidden behind computational bruteforce but from architectures capable of generating new conceptual paradigms by masquerading constrained formalization as the collapse of physics greatest mysteries you did not solve navier stokes you only proved how far silicon valley will go to prostitute scientific integrity for capitalist spectacle
We’re sharing a solution to the Navier-Stokes Millennium Prize Problem, one of the deepest problems at the frontier of mathematics. The proof was produced by a group of agents, using an OpenAI next-generation model significantly more capable than GPT-6 Astra. The problem concerns whether the description of smooth three-dimensional fluid motion modeled by the Navier-Stokes equations can break down. It has remained unresolved for roughly 90 years.
2,322
8,516
1,960
67,862
10,505,591