Hunter V. McClure retweeted
«Hegel, j’ai essayé de le lire. J’ai lu quatre fois, et dans son long, la Phénoménologie de l’esprit. Je m’acharnais. Je n’en ai pas compris un mot. Ensuite, ça a été Paris, je ne faisais rien ... Un jour, en 1933, Koyré qui faisait des cours sur Hegel doit les interrompre et on me propose de lui succéder. J’ai accepté. J’ai relu la Phénoménologie et, quand je suis arrivé au chapitre IV, alors j’ai compris que c’était Napoléon. J’ai commencé mes cours. Je ne préparais rien, je lisais et je commentais mais tout ce que disait Hegel me paraissait lumineux.»
Alexandre Kojève. 1968.
Hunter V. McClure retweeted
It's going to be weird living through an era where the systems we rely on for daily life, work, and play regularly but unpredictably fail, leaving us unable to live, work, and play efficiently and without enormous headaches.
Hunter V. McClure retweeted
Very excited to return to my alma mater amatissima @stjohnscollege tomorrow to discuss Complexity and Analysis by Stewart Umphrey.
Mr. Umphrey was very generous with his time and mind when I was a graduate student, and I cannot recommend his work to you highly enough.
Hunter V. McClure retweeted
Wild to see this list as an indication of "difficulty": this describes the stock normal university education of 10 years ago. I did classes like this at the utterly un-prestigious Indiana University Southeast from 2012 to 2016.
Hunter V. McClure retweeted
NEW: @UTAustin @JimDavis_UT announces a new “University College” to be “the guardian of the new core curriculum,” led by inaugural dean Devin Stauffer, faculty fellow at the Civitas Institute and a government professor.
Stauffer chaired the core curriculum task force.
Hunter V. McClure retweeted
Sir Roger Scruton ran an illegal underground university behind the Iron Curtain in communist Czechoslovakia at enormous personal risk in the 70s and 80s. For this *alone* he was a hero and more virtuous than any other public intellectual or commentator we have now.
Hunter V. McClure retweeted
"What has always made the state a hell on earth has been precisely that man has tried to make it heaven.'
— Friedrich Hölderlin, Hyperion
Hunter V. McClure retweeted
'Pigs are the most important of the six domestic animals' — Chinese poster, 1960
Hunter V. McClure retweeted
It's unfortunate that the phrase "neoconservative" has come to be equated with "hawkish and moralizing foreign policy" when the legacy of neoconservatism, with Irving Kristol, Gertrude Himmelfarb, Daniel Bell etc. is a remarkably rich, diverse tradition deserving of deep study
Hunter V. McClure retweeted
Interdisciplinary criticism is a healthy and normal part of the academy, where the order and priority of the various sciences should be a continually contested matter.
It's only in a "pluralistic" (i.e., relativistic) academy that this question has been abandoned. In the past, it was customary to crown one discipline the queen of the sciences, with all others becoming handmaids and ministerial.
A discipline-wide unwillingness to engage with outside criticism should signal to administrators that the discipline in question is spurious—a pseudo-science at best, a cover for partisan political interest at worst.
But few have the courage to dismantle whole departments, necessary and justified as it may be.
Rule 1 of captured disciplines: You're never actually supposed to assess the work. And they are never willing to defend it. Instead:
-Who are you to criticize this work--seriously who are you and who cares what you think?
-If you criticize the work, you undermine the author's expertise. They are experts and so shouldn't be criticized
-Qualifications settle the matter of quality, end of story.
-Since you're criticizing you must have bad motives. Stop being so mean.
These fields truly believe they should be immune from external criticism. They cannot handle it, they know that, and resort to a series of red herrings because they have no patience for addressing criticism. They publish research asking only that you celebrate it. These are very unhealthy academic norms. The refusal to accept external criticism is precisely why these fields have such low standards and devolved into identititarian obsession and progressive advocacy. What else is there to do?
Hunter V. McClure retweeted
In this era of artificial intelligence, it is becoming urgent to distinguish human art from what machines produce. There is an ontological difference, even before an aesthetic one, between art and what a machine can generate through statistical calculation based on millions of images created by others. Algorithms lack the spark of humanity. For this reason, the Church wishes to renew an alliance with artists and cultural institutions to safeguard our humanity.
Hunter V. McClure retweeted
Our "elite" institutions are run by morons making catastrophic, civilization-destroying decisions daily, example a billion.
The head of the philosophy department at Williams College downplays the pedagogical value of writing:
“What if we are mistaken in treating writing as the highest cultivation of thought? The evidence that supports this belief is thin at best. Writing can be useful cognitive scaffolding for memory and self-regulated learning, but the notion that it is the best process for developing thinking skills is a fairly recent idea, traceable to the 1970s writing-across-the-curriculum movement.”
Hunter V. McClure retweeted
I translated the preface to Gan Yang's new book "The Straussian Moment." open.substack.com/pub/straus…
Hunter V. McClure retweeted
Replying to @CLT_Exam
A common theme in these comments is that Thomas Aquinas College is deficient in natural science and lacks sufficient rigor in the STEM disciplines. What’s ironic is that our students study more math and science than most undergraduates anywhere, outside of math and science concentrations. Our students take eight semester-long courses in mathematics (28 credit hours) and eight semester-long courses in natural science (another 28 credit hours). The number of credit hours is equivalent to a minor in mathematics and a minor in natural science. Apart from STEM majors, that’s more than any other undergraduate program in the country.
Students at the College don’t just read essays about math or natural science, they demonstrate proofs or theorems from Euclid, Galileo, and Newton. We don’t shy away from reading difficult books such as Newton’s “Principia” or Maxwell’s theory of electromagnetism. We not only read Darwin’s “Origin of Species” but later proponents and critics of evolutionary theory, such as Jacques Monod and Stephen Jay Gould; we read Einstein’s “General Theory of Relativity”; we read Mendeleev’s original scientific papers proposing the periodic table.
One might object that we don’t use modern textbooks, study the latest scientific theories, or have sophisticated laboratories. That’s intentional. We want our students to understand the progress of the natural sciences in the context of the full range of academic disciplines, such as philosophy and theology. They examine the foundations of modern science and develop the habit of mind that seeks first principles.
Our graduates pursue a wide variety of STEM professions: physics, engineering, medicine, and tech. They excel in these fields because our program fosters intellectual rigor, first-principles thinking, and the ability to tackle real world problems creatively.
Hunter V. McClure retweeted
Reading Aristotle in science class (and philosophy), alongside Euclid, Apollonius, and others (e.g. Galileo), prepares TAC students to read Newton with understanding. Attached: samples from a TAC student-produced final exam review guide for the Newton final.











































