Analyzing the academic affiliations of nearly 6,000 award-winning researchers in 18 major fields in the natural sciences, engineering, and social sciences from the 1820s to the 2020s, focusing on the 1960s onward, from Richard B. Freeman, Danxia Xie, @Hanzhe_Zhang, and @hanzhou2003 nber.org/papers/w35875
Han Zhou retweeted
Economics is the *only* scientific field in which the concentration of institutional affiliations of award-winning researchers (i.e., more winners at top universities) has increased over time.nber.org/papers/w35875
Han Zhou retweeted
Economics has an elitism problem.
It is the *only* discipline that exhibits a high and growing institutional concentration among its Nobel laureates.
It's basically a rite of passage to have been at one of only eight elite US universities to win the prize.
Han Zhou retweeted
Replying to @florianederer
This figure is also excellent. Economists are especially mobile. Broadly, elite researchers are more mobile in fields with less reliance on physical resources.
Han Zhou retweeted
When this is Figure 1 of your paper you know that you have a killer paper.
"All fields, EXCEPT FOR ECONOMICS, exhibit a low and decreasing concentration, which suggests a trend toward decentralized knowledge production."
conference.nber.org/conf_pap…
Han Zhou retweeted
Among all STEM and social science fields, the concentration of award winners in a few institutions is highest in Economics.
AND it’s the only field where this concentration is rising not falling.
Freeman, Xie, Zhang and Zhou #NBERSI


















