Jignesh Lodhari retweeted
Days shut in a year:
Hospital: 0
Border post: 0
Police station: 0
High court: 155
Supreme court: 159
Jignesh Lodhari retweeted
Congratulations to Deepinder Goyal for publishing a hypothetical paper on the gravitational theory of aging in a high impact journal. Only, there is nothing in it on gravitational theory of aging as indicated in the title.
This is the textbook example of of exploiting "science" and "scientists" towards initiating a scam. This is long, but you will really learn a thing or two.
I read this BS so that you dont have to. Here are my comments on this paper which showcases the lowest level of evidence in medical science and proves nothing, nor can claim to prove anything it states in the future.
But before I start, let me get this out of the way:
Neither author Satchidananda Panda nor first author Laura van Rosmalen are brain hemodynamics specialists; their established academic domain is circadian biology, photoperiodism, and metabolism (and the paper awkwardly weaves circadian blood-flow rhythms into the narrative to bridge their background). Panda's corresponding contact on the paper is listed as a personal Gmail address rather than his official Salk Institute email. Combining a billionaire founder (Goyal), his hardware engineer (Kumar), a paid scientific consultant from an adjacent field (Panda), and that consultant's student (Rosmalen) - while omitting the paid consultancy from the journal's disclosure - strongly indicates commercially driven authorship (to drive Temple wearable sales) rather than independent academic consensus.
[1] The paper admits there is no evidence proving that everyday standing causes harmful blood-flow drops in major part of the brain. yes, repeatedly.
[2] The authors have confused cause with effect and admit that lower brain blood flow in older adults does not automatically mean the brain is being starved - an aging, shrinking brain often simply needs less blood. Despite this admission, the rest of the paper still treats lower blood flow as a root driver of aging rather than a symptom of it.
[3] The theory blames Earth's gravity for aging the brain, yet the paper admits that removing gravity in space causes rapid muscle loss, bone loss, heart deconditioning, and enlarged brain ventricles - a hallmark of brain aging. When both normal gravity and zero gravity cause similar structural brain changes, gravity cannot cleanly explain brain aging.
[4] If upright posture and vertical distance between the heart and brain drove aging, horizontal animals like mice and dogs would dramatically outlive upright humans, and tall giraffes would age far faster than short mammals, yet humans are among the longest-lived terrestrial mammals. Moreover, the paper notes that cellular aging occurs across all species down to single cells, which have nothing to do with upright posture or brain circulation at all.
[5] The authors treat normal physiology as chronic injury (shows lack of expertise in the topic). The paper frames the normal 10–17% drop in brain blood flow upon standing as a damaging "Orthostatic Perfusion Deficit". At the same time, it admits that standing up is physically helpful because it lowers brain pressure. Authors cannot seem to make up their mind on this garbage hypothesis - which is untestable (see later).
[6] The paper points out that prolonged sitting lowers brain blood flow, yet also notes that older adults who regularly do moderate aerobic exercise - which is performed upright against gravity - show no significant age-related decline in brain blood flow. This indicates the real issue is physical inactivity, not gravity itself.
[7] Unfalsifiable circular logic - which makes this theory pseudoscientific. The hypothesis builds a closed loop where gravity reduces blood flow, which causes aging, which worsens blood flow. Whenever evidence contradicts the model - such as high blood pressure or normal aging adaptations - the authors hedge that it can be both helpful compensation and harmful pathology at the same time, making the theory nearly impossible to disprove.
[8] To promote wearable tracking, the authors suggests placing optical sensors over branches of the external carotid artery on the scalp/temple as a proxy for brain blood flow. However, the authors' own anatomy summary states that the brain is supplied by the internal carotid and vertebral arteries (not the external carotid, which feeds the face and scalp), and they admit surface optical devices cannot measure deep tissue perfusion. So Goyal effectively debunked his nonsense Temple device in this paper.
[9] The authors propose risky interventions and flawed animal tests. The paper proposes daily head-down tilting (30–70° inversions) to counter gravitational stress, even while warning it carries severe risks like stroke, glaucoma, raised brain pressure, and blood clots. Its proposed test of tilting naturally horizontal mice is impossible to replicate in humans because of the 25–30 cm heart-to-brain distance of standing nature.
[10] Non-existent isotope: Box 2 in paper states that PET scans using C-labeled water are the gold standard for measuring brain blood flow. Water contains no carbon; the actual tracer is O-labeled water. None of the authors understand chemistry.
[11] The authors have misapplied citations. To support tilting cages as a chronic gravity model in rodents, the paper cites Houpt et al. (2012), which is actually a study on rats tilting their heads inside a high-strength magnetic field.
[12] Nitish Kumar is publicly named by Goyal in Sept 2026 as one of the core four scientists who built and validated Temple's proprietary "Brain Flow" technology which has now being removed from the device's main website and which we know was a fraud technology.
[13] Major undisclosed financial conflict of interest. In a concurrent medRxiv preprint posted Sept 4, 2026 and revised Nov 18, 2026) validating the Temple wearable, the Competing Interest Statement explicitly declares: "Satchidananda Panda is a paid scientific consultant to Temple Pvt. Ltd."
[14] Undisclosed collaborative conflict of interest: Laura van Rosmalen is a postdoctoral researcher inside Satchidananda Panda's lab (working under a paid Temple consultant) and co-authored the same Sept/Nov 2026 medRxiv validation study of the Temple wearable - a study funded by Temple Pvt. Ltd. (grant f. no. 01/2026, dated Jan 29, 2026) in which Temple supplied the devices and returned processed data files.
[15] Additionally, the paper's Funding section lists only the Wu Tsai Human Performance Alliance and the Joe and Clara Tsai Foundation for van Rosmalen and Panda, omitting Temple Private Limited's concurrent research funding to their collaborative validation study and its employment/backing of Deepinder Goyal and Nitish Kumar. @ElsevierConnect
To summarize: Rather than reading like independent science, this paper reads like a sales pitch for Deepinder Goyal's ₹85,000 "Temple" wearable. It invents marketable metrics like "perfusion age" and argues that people need continuous tracking of brain blood flow using optical sensors worn on the head—even including an illustration in Figure 4C of a small sensor stuck to a woman's temple streaming live data to a phone, mirroring his exact product. The authorship raises further red flags: Goyal, a tech founder with no background in brain-circulation research, is listed as a co-author alongside his own company employee and two Salk Institute scientists who specialize in biological clocks rather than brain blood flow—one of whom works as a paid consultant for Temple, a financial tie disclosed in a separate study but left out of this paper. Published online on November 13, 2026—just days after Temple opened commercial pre-orders on November 1—the paper hands Goyal's unproven theory and pricey gadget a convenient stamp of academic credibility right as doctors were calling them out.
My advice to "truly humane" Indian billionaires with lot of money for research is to put it in for cancer research and promote institutional research into valuable topics that can change human lives. For example, a new study on a pill showed that it could help reverse Stage 4 pancreatic cancer.
theguardian.com/society/2026…
But people like Goyal are not truly humane. They are vultures in suits. The exploit science to make more money for themselves. It is really sad to see this happen.
Jignesh Lodhari retweeted
The story of ‘On My Way To Heaven’.
Our final Group Therapy 15 interviews are coming soon.
Jignesh Lodhari retweeted
Funny to note that the great grandson of Prime Minister Nehru who gave up the UNSC seat in 1950s and relegated India to be a third world country at the mercy of China and America should be the one to comment on a leader who has done his best to improve the prestige of India globally by making it a power which cannot be ignored. From being deemed as a third world country to being recognized by all 3 leaders in the table as its biggest friend, a power to be feared and tough to be bounded in trade deals respectively, India under PM @narendramodi has come a long way. Last thing we now need is to hear the lectures of those who put family first and India last.
Jignesh Lodhari retweeted
राहुल गांधी विदेश में जाकर कहते हैं- “India is sitting on an economic disaster.”
Disaster का आकलन भाषण से नहीं, आर्थिक आंकड़ों से होता है!
IMF ने अक्टूबर में भारत की growth forecast बढ़ाकर 7% की। यानी अनुमान घटाया नहीं, बढ़ाया!
Moody’s ने भी FY27 का growth अनुमान 6.5% से बढ़ाकर 7% किया।
S&P Global ने भी भारत की growth का अनुमान 7% किया।
Goldman Sachs भारत की 2026 growth 6.9% रहने का अनुमान जताया।
ये संस्थाएँ न RSS की शाखा से आई हैं.. न ही ये Media (जिस पर हर बात का ठीकरा फोड़ दिया जाता है)…न ही मोदी सरकार के राजनीतिक प्रवक्ता !
ये संस्थाएं अपने आर्थिक मॉडल, बाजार, निवेश और आंकड़ों के आधार पर आकलन करती हैं।
चुनौतियाँ हैं, बेरोज़गारी पर सवाल हैं, महंगाई पर सवाल हैं लेकिन सवाल पूछने और भारत को economic disaster घोषित करने में फर्क है!
Jignesh Lodhari retweeted
Rahul ji, you ask the Prime Minister to choose a venue for a debate. There is already one: Parliament, where you happen to be the LoP.
Just yesterday, Home Minister Shri @AmitShah offered a special session to debate SIR and EVMs. Why not show the same enthusiasm for a debate in Parliament that you show while issuing challenges on social media?
Demanding answers also carries an obligation to hear them.
There have been several occasions when you and your party have walked out of Parliament while the government was responding to your allegations. How do you claim to be so eager for a debate when you don’t even stay to hear the other side?
It doesn’t stop at walkouts. You and the INDI Alliance have repeatedly disrupted proceedings, leading to entire sittings being washed out. If you are so keen on debating, why not allow Parliament to function in the first place?
And then there’s the mock Parliament you recently held at the Congress President’s residence. Frankly, that was more a ‘mockery of Parliament’ than a ‘mock Parliament’. You found the time and enthusiasm for that exercise. Surely, the real Parliament deserves at least as much.
You speak endlessly about protecting democracy and the Constitution. But that respect should also reflect in how you treat the institutions they have established.
As for the issues you frivolously raise, bring specific allegations and evidence to back them up. Simply throwing together a long list of accusations doesn’t make your case any stronger. As LoP, you are expected to show some seriousness and responsibility.
You say, “Daro mat.”
Then bring the facts, face the scrutiny and stay to hear the answers. In the House, uphold the standards of debate you demand from others.
24 घंटे हो गए मोदी जी। मैंने आपको चैलेंज दिया है।
आप कहते हो कि opposition देशद्रोही है। किसी भी स्टेज पे आप जगह चुनिए, डिबेट कीजिए मेरे साथ।
देशद्रोही कौन है? विदेशी फोर्सेस का कनेक्शन किसका है? और किस प्रकार का कनेक्शन है? जल्दी से जल्दी कीजिए, डरिए मत।
दोनों मिलेंगे, मीडिया होगी, देश के युवा होंगे, टेबल होगी, एक साइड आप बैठोगे, एक साइड मैं बैठूंगा। जिसको आप जज बनाना चाहते हो, बना दो। मोहन भागवत जी को बिठा दो, चलो। और फिर डिबेट करते हैं।
सवाल उठेंगे फाइनेंशियल सिस्टम पर, फाइनेंशियल स्ट्रक्चर पर, US डील कैसे हुई, क्यों हुई, इतनी जल्दी क्यों हुई, सिर्फ आपने क्यों की, कैबिनेट को क्यों नहीं बताया, अडानी का केस बंद क्यों हुआ, Epstein - ऐसी बहुत सारी चीजें हैं जिसपे खुलकर डिस्कशन होगा।
आ जाइए, डरिए मत।
दूध का दूध, पानी का पानी कीजिए।
आप एलिगेशन लगाते हैं ना मेरे ऊपर, आ जाइए, सब साफ हो जाएगा।
बाकी चीजों पे आपने defamation केस लगा रखा है, शायद 45 defamation केस मेरे ऊपर हैं।
मगर इस डिबेट मामले पे, foreign कनेक्शन पे आप defamation नहीं लगा रहे हो। लगाइए ना, वहाँ भी डिस्कस करेंगे, खुल के। ये सब डिस्कस करते हैं, आइए।
हैप्पी दिवाली, मोदी जी।
It’s been 24 hours since I challenged you, Modi ji.
You say the Opposition is anti-national. Choose any stage, any venue, and debate me on this - Who is anti-national? Who has connections with foreign forces? And what is the nature of those connections?
Let’s do this as soon as possible. Daro mat!
We’ll both be there. The media will be there. The youth of this country will be there. There will be a table. You’ll sit on one side, I’ll sit on the other. You can appoint whoever you want as the judge. You can even make Mohan Bhagwat ji the judge.
There will be questions about the financial system, the financial structure, how the US deal happened, why it happened and why so quickly, why you made the deal alone and didn’t inform the Cabinet, why the Adani case was closed, Epstein - and many other issues. We’ll discuss all of them openly.
Let the truth come out. Let everything be crystal clear.
You make allegations against me, don’t you? Come forward. Everything will become clear.
You’ve filed defamation cases against me over other matters. I think there are around 45 defamation cases against me.
But on this issue of the debate, on the question of foreign connections, you haven’t filed a defamation case. Go ahead, file one. We’ll discuss that openly too.
Happy Diwali, Modi ji.
Jignesh Lodhari retweeted
My ABGT 700.2 set is now on Youtube. Go and get it! youtube.com/watch?v=SLBKWZZM…
I’m not quite sure I can put into words what today means to me.
Music has been my whole life. From those early days of falling in love with records and DJing, to travelling the world and sharing that love with so many people, I’ve never stopped being grateful that I get to do what I do.
To receive my OBE from Prince William at Windsor Castle today, recognising nearly 50 years of doing something I absolutely love, is beyond anything I could have imagined. ❤️🔥
I’ve been thinking a lot about my mum and dad today. I know just how proud they would have been, and I wish they could have been here to share this moment with me.
This honour means so much, not just to me personally, but because of where our music has come from and how far it has travelled. To see dance music recognised in this way is something I’m immensely proud of.
To my family, friends, everyone who has believed in me, supported me and danced with me over the years, thank you. You’ve all been part of this.
My heart is very full today. I’m proud, humbled and deeply honoured.
Thank you, Carl.
Jignesh Lodhari retweeted
Hello friends, now that there are no more scientific updates from Deepinder Goyal on his scammy Temple device, I am moving on to completing my research papers this week. But I will keep a look out for any new "science" they bring so that I can simplify it for you.
Long, but worth your time because you should know how science fraud blends beautifully into seemingly good science papers also.
That said, Deepinder has uploaded various research papers on the Temple website.
temple.com/science-and-resea…
They have performed 4 studies on Temple. Three are in 'so-called' peer review (the trials are not even registered) and one is an internal white paper document from the company. The rest are "foundational research" - other published papers which Deepinder has used (exaggeratingly) to legitimize his device (deceitfully). Because the Temple "minions" are always citing from this webpage, I would like to clear the air on what the studies were done for and what was truly shown. This is for posterity.
[1] Temple vs. Five Flagship Werables - Heart Rate Accuracy Study - This paper is an unreviewed, in-house white paper funded, run, and analyzed entirely by Temple Private Limited (with generative AI assisting in the analysis and drafting) rather than an independent clinical trial. The methodology was tilted in Temple's favor: the company compared its own 1-second internal app data stream against Apple Watch Series 12 and Oura Ring 5 data pulled from Apple Health exports that only logged once every 5 seconds, and it forced participants to wear four wrist devices at the same time - pushing half of them onto the lower wrist bone where motion errors are much worse (for example, WHOOP MG's error more than doubled from 2.00 bpm on the upper forearm to 4.58 bpm at the bottom wrist position) and then pooling those worse readings into the headline numbers. Deepinder also applied custom "in-house thresholds" to strip out "failure episodes" before calculating accuracy, tested only 43 young adults during a single indoor treadmill run while excluding darker skin tones and outdoor or non-running activities, and ultimately only showed that an optical sensor taped over a scalp artery can read pulse rate - which proves nothing about Temple's flagship claims of tracking brain blood flow, vascular aging, or metabolic "Entropy" - or even heart rate accurately. This was the study that Deepinder (in)famously told his team to promote as "success" in the Company Slack group.
[2] Evaluating Brain Flow Index from a Temple-Worn Wearable (Deepinder had mentioned he would explain the technology behind it - but I dont think he understands his own paper, so I'll do it for him). This non-peer-reviewed preprint was designed, funded, and conducted by Temple (authored by company employees, founder Deepinder Goyal, and paid company consultants/advisers) on 44 young men completely excluding women because hair interfered with the reference headset. Neither device in the study actually measured brain blood flow: near-infrared spectroscopy (NIRS) only estimates hemoglobin concentration changes, and the "brain layer" reference was a mathematical guesswork from Temple Science Team, assuming every participant had an identical 8 mm flat slab of scalp and skull and a fixed 1.5-to-1 brain-to-scalp absorption ratio. The authors threw out the third optical time-of-flight moment (variance) measure - the exact measurement that truly provides the deepest tissue selectivity, because it produced "implausibly inflated" numbers, and they placed the NIRS reference on the opposite side of the forehead rather than under the Temple sensor, making it impossible to rule out local temple skin blood flow. To get their correlations (manipulated) right, they shifted the data by up to ±30 seconds per session to cherry-pick the best alignment, then used one-sided statistical tests without correcting for multiple comparisons, failed to find a statistically significant difference between brain and scalp correlations when lying down and never measured blood pressure, carbon dioxide, or breathing - meaning whole-body blood pressure rushes during inversion-table tilts and deep squats simply pushed blood into the head and moved both sensors together. Nothing about brain flow or its measurement is proven here.
[3] Concordance Between a Temple-Worn Optical Wearable and Transcranial Doppler During Exercise and Postural Transitions. This non-peer-reviewed preprint funded by Temple Pvt. Ltd. and co-authored by a paid company consultant, tested only 20 analyzable young adults per protocol after dropping participants for movement-degraded recordings, and its own limitations section admits that the Temple Brain Flow index is "an extracranial optical signal whose cerebral component... the present protocols cannot isolate." Because vigorous cycling and lying flat drive blood into both the inner brain and the outer scalp skin at the same time, a surface skin sensor naturally rises and falls alongside Transcranial Doppler (TCD) ultrasound without ever penetrating to the brain. Furthermore, because Temple's closed-source algorithm outputs a unitless number rather than actual flow velocity (cm/s) or volume, the authors mathematically manipulated the scores. Even then, the timing between the two devices was erratic. Temple led the ultrasound by a median of 19 seconds during cycling but lagged behind by 9 seconds during posture shifts - while the devices were worn on opposite sides of the head, room temperature (25–30°C) and time of day were left uncontrolled despite skin blood flow reacting strongly to heat, beat-to-beat blood pressure were unrecorded, and Temple hid its LED-to-detector spacing so independent scientists cannot verify how deep its light actually reaches.
[4] Temple PPG Morphology Demonstrates a Stronger Cardiovascular Age Signal Than Wrist Sites. Written entirely by three Temple employees and posted on pre-print without peer review, this study claims the temple is a better site than the wrist for detecting "cardiovascular age", but it never actually measured the temple and wrist on the same people. Instead, it committed a classic apples-to-oranges error by comparing an internal group of 126 mostly young men wearing a Temple sensor against a separate public dataset (Microsoft Aurora-BP) of 240 much older, gender-balanced people wearing a different wrist sensor, alongside an exploratory public fNIRS dataset of just 13 people where 88 of 89 features failed multiple-comparison correction. Worse still, the Temple sensor recorded pulse waves at a coarse 32 Hz while the wrist sensor recorded at 500 Hz, and both were artificially resampled to 75 Hz - even though resampling cannot recover high-frequency pulse details lost at 32 Hz, which heavily distorts the second- and third-derivative waveform ratios the paper relies on (and the raw Temple signal even came out upside-down, requiring manual sign inversion - again manipulation). Finally, the study excluded everyone over age 60, failed to show a statistically significant difference in overall feature "richness" between the temple and wrist (the confidence interval crossed zero), and never measured actual arterial stiffness or vascular health, merely correlating scalp pulse shapes with chronological birth age - andn othing more.
[5] Assessing the Accuracy of Photoplethysmography for Wearable Heart Rate Monitoring Based on Body Location and Body Motion in Uncontrolled Outdoor Environments. This short 2024 conference abstract (no even a proper study) by Zurich researchers had nothing to do with the Temple wearable, brain blood flow, or vascular aging - and it did not even test the temple region. Rather than proving that a head-mounted sensor is ultra-accurate, the study found that even the forehead sensor suffered a 7.1% median error in real-world outdoor conditions (which equals roughly 10 to 13 bpm of error during exercise heart rates of 140–180 bpm, nearly ten times worse than the 1.18 bpm error Temple claims from its indoor treadmill test). Most importantly, the authors concluded that irregular real-world body motion degraded signal quality across all body locations far more than sensor placement helped, directly undermining Temple's marketing claim that putting an optical sensor on the head solves real-world motion artifacts.
[6] Temporal Skin Temperature as an Indicator of Cardiorespiratory Fitness Assessed with Selected Methods. This 2022 Polish sports-science study in Biology did not use the Temple device or any wearable sensor at all; it used a stationary, non-contact infrared thermal camera from a distance in a 21°C lab to photograph the bare temple skin of 23 young men before and after a 3-minute cycling sprint. Using a remote thermal camera to justify a skin-taped wearable is physically flawed because sticking an adhesive plastic sensor onto the temple traps heat, blocks sweat evaporation, and ruins the natural radiative skin cooling and rewarming that the camera measured. Even more damaging to Temple's core premise, this paper explicitly explains that temple skin temperature rises after intense exercise because heat-dumping blood is shunted into the external carotid artery on the scalp while actual brain blood flow decreases to protect the brain from overheating - MEANING, this cited paper actually proves that blood flow and temperature at the surface of the temple move in the exact opposite direction of true brain blood flow during intense exercise. Everything opposite of what Deepinder claims.
Now that you know there is nothing more than these fraudulent, manipulated, methodologically weak, AI written papers and falsified scientific data on Temple device, do not let them cite these papers again as proof. These are garbage worthy.
The only way I see Temple device selling and succeeding is to remodel the device into the form of a leech and state that Ayurvedic principles of good and bad blood (ancient Jalauka Therapy - leech application) were applied as per Ayurveda texts and that the device measures primal energy imabalance as described in Ayurveda and Entropy is actually your Ayurvedic Doshas (without chutney). An example is shown below. Ayush Ministry will legalize, approve this and promote this (because those useless people are allergic to data and science) and 1% of the world and 99% of India will buy this scam-toy! I dont want royalties for this idea.
Until the next fraud paper drops, goodbye and goodluck.
Image courtesy: (at)drvarunacharya (Instagram)
Jignesh Lodhari retweeted
Good morning. Deepinder Goyal is a liar.
It was always about the brain, even though he now claims it was not.
His scam was caught in January 2026 after which he started calling out doctors rudely at that time also. He mentioned he will show the science of brain flow, Entropy assessment by the device at the time.
A few months later, he showed screen shots of what he calls the device can measure, which others cannot, called Entropy - screen shots from his own team - which can be easily made using Claude. Still no working device based proof. Zero evidence of parameters measured to showcase Entropy.
Fast forward 10 months later, November 2026, he is still making the same claims, no new evidence, no real data other than what his company wrote on the website. The company website (temple.com) still promotes the device for cognitive health, brain tracking and entropy.
I and other clinical-scientists HAVE gone through everyy detail of science published on Temple here temple.com/science-and-resea… and none of it proves this device can measure what it claims. Yes, heart rate and blood flow to the scalp from the temporal artery. But nothing more - because there is no data.
Temple is a beautiful scam, built over the years using influencer network, paid celebrity collaboration (obviously all of these will be denied) and a false marketing to convince people that this device does more than any other device. It does not do anything beyond the basics. This is a global scam and the government regulators must assess the claims made before this becomes a circus show for the West. Guys like MKBHD and Mrwhosetheboss who can really do work on this will rip it apart - so go give them the device and not your local chamcha influencers.
Jignesh Lodhari retweeted
Arnold on why muscles grow: hold the contraction until the muscle has to respond. “When it responds, it grows. Now if you just do the motion, nothing happens.” Stop going through the motions 🔥
Jignesh Lodhari retweeted
So, I went through the pre-prints and the Temple claim that it tracks brain blood flow does not hold water. @deepigoyal went on and on about brain flow and they even call their measure Temple-BF. Should've called it Temple BS instead.






































