Soldier, Historian, Husband, Father, Scholar, Navy Civilian, PhD, War Gamer

Newport RI
Joined February 2009
The U.S. Naval Institute mourns the passing of Dr. Craig L. Symonds, distinguished naval historian, award-winning author, and professor emeritus of history at the U.S. Naval Academy. Through three decades of teaching and a lifetime of scholarship, he helped generations of naval officers and readers understand the people, decisions, and sacrifices that shaped our naval history. In May 2023, Dr. Symonds addressed the Naval Institute’s 150th Annual Meeting, reflecting on the enduring relationship between the Navy and its independent forum. His remarks became his most recent Proceedings article, “A Two-Way Street: The Navy–Naval Institute’s 150-Year Relationship.” In it, he described the Institute as “a sounding board and not an echo chamber”—a reminder of the value of thoughtful debate in advancing the naval profession. We honor his lasting contributions to naval history and extend our deepest condolences to his family, friends, colleagues, and former students. His legacy lives on in the people he taught and the history he brought to life. Read his article and revisit his 2023 remarks. usni.org/magazines/proceedin…
36
114
43
551
42,455
Jon Scott Logel retweeted
Are you ready for The Fall? Better "gird your loins" — for it has already happened. Done, and done. For a full retrospective, with Gaius and Germanicus, try this: youtube.com/watch?v=80pb9HGb…
4
2
6
761
Jon Scott Logel retweeted
Everyone loves asking: “If Grant was such a great general, how come he lost nearly every battle to Lee and suffered way more casualties?” Robert E. Lee himself had a very different answer. “I have carefully searched the military records of both ancient and modern history, and have never found Grant’s superior as a general. I doubt his superior can be found in all history.” — Robert E. Lee The entire question is built on two flat-out falsehoods. First: Grant didn’t “lose nearly every battle.” There was essentially ONE continuous campaign — from the Wilderness in May 1864 straight through to Appomattox in April 1865. Grant seized the initiative in the very first clash and never gave it back. Lee spent the rest of the war reacting to Grant’s moves. When Lee attacked in the Wilderness hoping the old forests and bogs would save him (like they always had), Grant didn’t retreat north like every previous Union commander. He simply disengaged, slid south, and flanked Lee again. Lee never dictated the terms of battle after that day. James Longstreet had tried to warn the Army of Northern Virginia: “We’ve never faced anyone like this man.” They didn’t listen. They learned fast. Second: The casualty comparison ignores that Lee was almost always the defender. Context matters. But the deeper truth is bigger than any single clash. Lee still fought war the old way — disconnected battles, win-loss record like a sports season. Grant fought the next war: coordinated campaigns across multiple theaters, using railroads, telegraph, navy, and engineers to keep relentless pressure until the enemy simply could not continue. Grant didn’t win by accident. He made contact and maintained it until victory was inevitable. Lee fought the last war. Grant wrote the blueprint for the next one. That’s why he was great. That's why he won. Change your mind yet? Drop your hottest take on Grant vs. Lee below. 🔥
495
619
82
5,830
672,996
Jon Scott Logel retweeted
We do not have enough ships. Our focus on COIN (ironically overseas) & the Army & belief in air power led to this. But we can fix it,especially with help from or ASIAN allies Japan & South Korea & even Australia @cdrsalamander @Lazarus_Navy
We do not have enough aircraft carriers.
2
1
6
301
Jon Scott Logel retweeted
He won the Civil War, broke the Klan, went bankrupt at 62, got terminal throat cancer, and wrote one of the greatest books in American literature in the final year of his life. He finished it 5 days before he died. Ulysses S. Grant was born 204 years ago today. His name wasn't even Ulysses S. Grant. He was born Hiram Ulysses Grant in Point Pleasant, Ohio on April 27, 1822. The congressman who nominated him to West Point wrote down the wrong name. Grant kept it. The "S." stands for nothing. He hated his father's tannery and loved horses. Graduated 21st of 39 at West Point. Fought in the Mexican-American War, then came home convinced it was an unjust war designed to expand slavery. He later said he believed the Civil War was divine punishment for it. He married Julia Dent in 1848, into a slave-owning Missouri family. His abolitionist father refused to attend the wedding. In 1859, broke and desperate, Grant freed the one enslaved man he'd briefly owned instead of selling him. He could have gotten a year's wages. In the Civil War he became what no other Union general was: relentless. Vicksburg (July 4, 1863) split the Confederacy in half. Lincoln then gave him every Union army. His Appomattox surrender terms: officers kept sidearms, men kept horses for spring planting, no one prosecuted. As president (1869 to 1877) he did something no president would do again until LBJ: used federal troops to crush the Ku Klux Klan. He suspended habeas corpus in 9 South Carolina counties, prosecuted Klansmen before predominantly Black juries, and broke the first Klan. His presidency was also rocked by scandal: Black Friday 1869. Crédit Mobilier. The Whiskey Ring. Belknap. Grant himself never took a dime. He was just disastrously loyal to corrupt friends. The pattern damaged his reputation for a century. After the White House, he toured the world for 2 years. Dined with Queen Victoria. Met the emperor of Japan. Then in 1884, a Wall Street partner named Ferdinand Ward ran what we'd now call a Ponzi scheme. Grant was wiped out. 62 years old. Penniless. Weeks later he was diagnosed with terminal throat cancer. Mark Twain offered to publish his memoirs. Grant wrote in agony, sometimes 50 pages a day, racing the disease to leave Julia an inheritance. He finished the manuscript July 18, 1885. He died July 23. The book made Julia $450,000, about $14M today. It's now considered one of the finest memoirs in the English language. For decades historians ranked Grant a failure. Since 2000 he's jumped 13 spots in the C-SPAN survey, the biggest rise of any president. Happy birthday, General 🇺🇸
541
3,429
303
20,564
1,079,543
Beautiful ship!
Replying to @imetatronink
Decades ago, I went through the "blueprints" and the 51's do have ballistic protection around vital spaces. It is not however enough to safeguard against your scenario, above. This is why we need 15,000 armored cruisers that can survive such blows. The US once excelled at building such ships, which were the envy of the world! That we cannot do so now is a judgment on US! @johnkonrad @mercoglianos @jslogel
1
46
Jon Scott Logel retweeted
Replying to @imetatronink
Decades ago, I went through the "blueprints" and the 51's do have ballistic protection around vital spaces. It is not however enough to safeguard against your scenario, above. This is why we need 15,000 armored cruisers that can survive such blows. The US once excelled at building such ships, which were the envy of the world! That we cannot do so now is a judgment on US! @johnkonrad @mercoglianos @jslogel
2
3
1
16
1,713
Jon Scott Logel retweeted
Nirvana was never the same for me after Charles Barkley left the band.
78
289
24
4,224
401,087
Also known as “ops normal” these days
QOD "This is batshit crazy!" Sal Mercogliano about the events of the last 24-36 hours in the Strait of Hormuz (SOH), Persian Gulf, and Gulf of Oman, but mostly the SOH.
1
54
Jon Scott Logel retweeted
My talk at a singular National Press Club event, and worth a listen. This event addresses the historical weight of America's War on Iran. I present this here as a deep-rooted Trifecta, where each strand malignly combines: 1)The American Emperor System, 2)The Existential Postulate of our American Religion, and 3)How a client foreign power hijacked the American Constitutional Order. My talk is here, beginning @04:17:26 youtube.com/watch?v=hOpsunua…
3
10
2
25
3,095
New piece in a special issue of Strategika on interwar Naval War College wargames. hoover.org/research/outmaneu…
10
25
1,554
Jon Scott Logel retweeted
Replying to @CurtMills
Actually, the kernel of the MIC was harvested in World War I, most strongly in shipbuilding and aviation. By the mid-1930s, there was a strong symbiosis between the War and Navy Departments and these two industries. Moreover, because American aviation was the world leader, this symbiosis gave the US a head start on its World War II achievement (80,000 combat planes built in 1944!). so I would say definitely that there was a Proto-MIC in full swing by FDR's second admin.!
1
1
3
227
Jon Scott Logel retweeted
Join Hoover Fellow @JackieGSchneid, professor @jslogel, and leading experts for a discussion on the @NavalWarCollege's interwar wargames and their lasting impact on U.S. naval strategy on Tuesday, March 24. Register: hoover.org/events/wargaming-…
3
7
2,422
Jon Scott Logel retweeted
Jaylen Brown lost his cool with the refs and got ejected, then tried to charge at an official and tried to push through his own security for a while before eventually heading back to the locker room
219
220
91
2,716
1,031,307
Jon Scott Logel retweeted
Replying to @walterkirn
If you haven’t yet, you should visit the Grant Cottage in Gansevoort, NY, outside of Saratoga Springs, NY. It’s where Grant wrote his memoirs and died. It’s like stepping back in time. It’s worth the visit. share.google/gwoVfCThlZp92m4…
1
4
137