
ALT A screenshot of a Discord message too long to fit in alt text, but here’s an abridged version: SICP is structured around an approach that is an *obstacle* to understanding the ideas it’s trying to communicate. It’s about the way that we invent a language and imbue it with meaning, and in particular the relationship between syntax and semantics. Those are a good set of ideas to teach, but SICP is based around “the metacircular evaluator”, which is a nonsense concept that doesn’t mean much. The metacircularity comes from a syntactic form called `quote` that can be used to acquire values of the syntax tree as values in the programming language. But `quote` is boring: it’s not meaningfully different from a data literal sublanguage, and it obscures the fact that the syntax is arbitrary rather than something with inherent meaning. This conflation of language and metalanguage is at odds with a pedagogical approach to teaching the nature of programming languages, interpreters, and compilers.
























