陈凯文 KC (@kc41165) header
陈凯文 KC (@kc41165) profile picture

Julius Caesar once said: Foolish man only believe what he wishes.

Joined August 2017
Photo by 陈凯文 KC (@kc41165)Photo by 陈凯文 KC (@kc41165)Photo by 陈凯文 KC (@kc41165)Photo by 陈凯文 KC (@kc41165)Photo by 陈凯文 KC (@kc41165)Photo by 陈凯文 KC (@kc41165)Photo by 陈凯文 KC (@kc41165)Photo by 陈凯文 KC (@kc41165)Photo by 陈凯文 KC (@kc41165)
陈凯文 KC retweeted
In the minds of many Westerners, the Chinese Communist Party controls every move Chinese people make. In reality, this is impossible, and actually doing so would be counterproductive to control—just like if your father tried to control your every move, the relationship between the two of you would only become more tense. China now has thousands upon thousands of AI companies. The CCP only needs to control a few of the main and key ones; the rest can be left to the market. Those small AI companies that must sink or swim on their own in the market have enormous demand for computing power. Unable to obtain the domestically produced chips that the government prioritizes for allocation, they have the incentive to buy chips on the black market.
1
1
1
78
陈凯文 KC retweeted
Replying to @AnthropicAI
Your AI hates Whites & Asians, especially Chinese, heterosexuals and men. This is misanthropic and evil. Fix it. Frankly, I don’t think there is anything you can do to escape the inevitable irony of Anthropic ending up being Misanthropic. You were doomed to this fate when you chose your name. The Name of the Wind.
3,334
5,687
1,361
64,894
5,229,659
陈凯文 KC retweeted
I believe the @nvidia board is not acting in the best interest of shareholders nor in a manner consistent with their fiduciary duties. What we know is that the board fired Jensen or forced his resignation for violating company policy and/or in response to the accusation of an affair with a spy. They did so without careful consideration of the impact on the company, its customers, its shareholders or other stakeholders. They rushed to judgment without the benefit of careful due diligence or even with a basic understanding of the facts. How do we know this? We know this by how quickly Jensen was fired and how little was known at the time of his firing. It takes time to convene a board meeting. There was time, maybe, for one Zoom. And this is a decision that should have been made by a board sitting in person and carefully deliberating the facts once they are known. And they should have slept on the decision and met again the day after to discuss the facts, the risks and the other implications of their decision. The timing and lack of information did not allow for careful board deliberation. While boards can fire a CEO for an inappropriate relationship with a subordinate, it should not be an automatic decision. That is why we have boards comprised of humans and not agents. A board should consider whether or not such a relationship was consensual or whether it was an abuse of power dynamics. And a board has to consider what the impact of the firing is on all stakeholders. If I were in this board, I would not have rushed to judgment based on articles in the media. I would have made sure the board had all of the facts so it could make a careful and informed decision. Boards of Delaware companies have a duty of care which means they must make informed, prudent and good faith decisions. This clearly did not happen here. What law firm is advising this board? Or is the board even taken good legal advice? It doesn’t look like it. And now the board is compounding its failures by insisting that there is no possibility for Jensen’s return as CEO. Why is it in the best interest of the company to foreclose the possibility of Jensen’s return and to do so before all of the facts are known? This is yet another breach of their duty of care. Furthermore, the board has launched an investigation whose scope is unknown. Investigations can be extremely damaging to a company and should be carefully targeted to address whatever facts need to be known rather than be overly broad in scope. In short, this looks like a series of major governance failures by directors that panicked due to headlines in the media. They likely felt compelled to do something because they were afraid of looking bad in the media, not because it was the right thing for them company. They couldn’t stand the heat. The board’s conduct here is shocking for a company of this scale and importance to our country and the world at large, particularly at this moment in history.
5,080
9,452
1,215
73,712
5,263,845
You wanted disclosure? You got it. How the Anthropic Money Network Got Behind the Jensen Huang Pile-On Two receipts per name: the money they took, and the words they said. 1. Kevin Roose and Casey Newton The money: $480,000 from Tarbell for their new NPR show. The words: Newton said Huang's resignation "feels like a proper end to the 'lol nothing matters' era." Roose said Huang "had to go." On air, the credits thank Tarbell. On X, where 400,000 followers actually read them, it's just "with @NPR." In October, Roose was "thrilled to be a Tarbell grantee." He said it to the funder. Not to his readers. 2. Alec Stapp, Institute for Progress (an AI policy think tank) The money: more than $21 million from Coefficient Giving, including $10.5 million this July. His co-founder now runs Coefficient's public policy, and sits on IFP's board. The words: four posts in two days. "Chinese spy." "Blackmail." Huang's "cover-up." And what investigators would find "once they start issuing subpoenas." Coefficient didn't come up once. 3. Shakeel Hashim, Transformer The money: "primarily funded by Coefficient Giving" (formerly Open Philanthropy), whose money comes from Anthropic investor Dustin Moskovitz. The words: he demanded Huang disclose his conflicts of interest. He didn't mention his own. His own About page promises: "In stories where we report on our funders or interview someone who works there, we will disclose the relationship." That's a standard he apparently drops when pushing the exact regulatory agenda those funders bankroll. His rule, not mine. 4. Kelsey Piper, The Argument The money: $1,000,000 from Open Philanthropy, June 2025. The words: in 2019 she said Vox's Future Perfect section "probably would not take funding" straight from Open Philanthropy. This fall she wrote two big pieces on Anthropic. Neither mentions the million. 2019 Kelsey had a rule. 2025 Kelsey had a grant. 5. Sigal Samuel, Vox The money: her earlier Anthropic pieces carried a note that her section gets money from a foundation "whose major funder was also an early investor in Anthropic." The words: on November 14, Huang week, she wrote about Anthropic's "$1.4 trillion IPO." The note is gone. 6. Zvi Mowshowitz The money: a $200,000 "unconditional gift" from Jaan Tallinn, who led Anthropic's first funding round. The words: anyone who thinks Effective Altruism and Anthropic took Huang down has "Anthropic Derangement Syndrome." Calling it paranoia while cashing the check. There's a syndrome for that too. 7. The newsrooms Tarbell pays $75,000 to $135,000 to place AI reporters inside newsrooms. NBC, Fortune, CNBC, The Verge and The Guardian all ran stories this month by reporters it pays, current or former. None said so in the stories. NBC added a note only after OpenAI complained. Fortune put a line on an author page, because that's all Tarbell's own rule requires: the one page nobody clicks. The Dispatch put it right with the story. See? It's not hard. Where Tarbell's money comes from: $23,100,930 from Coefficient to date. More from Jaan Tallinn's fund. And a speaker for its fellows: Jack Clark, co-founder of Anthropic. 8. The rest of the chorus Rob Wiblin, 80,000 Hours ($7.7 million from Coefficient): "His mistress's firm ended up with ~$5b worth… WITAF is this." Miles Brundage, AVERI ($5 million from Coefficient): "Everyone paying attention knew that NVIDIA captured Commerce long ago." Peter Wildeford, co-founder and board member of IAPS (an AI policy institute; $34 million from Coefficient): "NVIDIA as a whole has been nothing but ruthless and dishonorable." Ryan Fedasiuk, Foundation for American Innovation (backed by Jaan Tallinn and Dustin Moskovitz, both Anthropic investors): "An abject governance and national security failure." Nathan Calvin, Encode ($516,000 recommended from Tallinn's fund): Huang's conduct should "irrevocably call Jensen's judgement into question." Jordan Schneider, ChinaTalk ($3 million from Coefficient): "How did the CFO not know…" Different logos. Same checkbook. Not one of them mentioned it. t's the standard they just demanded from Jensen Huang. One reporter forgets? Coincidence. Megaphones, newsrooms, think tanks, one funding network, one target, one week, in the middle of Anthropic's IPO One detail they left out: Anthropic formally launched its IPO on October 26, filing publicly with the SEC. Just a coincidence.? I'm just grading them on their own homework. Rules for thee. Grants for me. You wanted disclosure? You got it.
🤖 Made with AI
51
475
63
1,443
141,748
陈凯文 KC retweeted
🇺🇸🇷🇺🇨🇳 Was America kept away from Russia and China on purpose for 125 years? Political analyst Susan Kokinda says yes, tracing it back to Hamilton, Lincoln and McKinley and pinning it on the British Empire: “Every single pretty much every single major war that you’ve seen since the end of the 19th century has been manipulated under British geopolitics.” If Trump’s “transactional” style lets America cut its own deals with Moscow and Beijing, isn’t that the first real break from London’s game in a century? @sjkokinda
🇺🇸 Cutting the dollar loose from gold in 1971 let a “financial parasite” latch onto the whole world. Political analyst Susan Kokinda says Trump is fighting back with economic sovereignty, and she thinks a gold linked dollar could be next: “The globalist model is you have essentially a powerful financial parasite sitting on top of the world, and they’re just sucking the lifeblood out of every sector and out of every country.” Tie the dollar to gold and the money printers lose their favorite tool... would Wall Street go down without a fight? @sjkokinda
34
274
20
835
63,861
陈凯文 KC retweeted
Replying to @michele_geraci
China has a mechanism that you simply cannot understand, designed to ensure that its rulers serve the people. The top leader can only emerge by passing through layers of rigorous tests within a vast bureaucratic system and ultimately winning recognition from all sides. This mechanism is far more reliable than the Western electoral system. It not only guarantees the quality of the final outcome, but also prevents the leader from merely serving the interests of a particular group.
1
1
5
738
马来西亚华人张慧清11月17日带着13位家人,来到两个月前在昆明偶遇外公照片的地方。
40
54
4
819
52,907
陈凯文 KC retweeted
Over the past week, I’ve been overwhelmed by the love and support of friends, industry colleagues, and people I've never met. Thank you to everyone who has shown kindness to my family and me. It means the world to me. I came to the United States 53 years ago, and becoming an American citizen is one of the greatest gifts and proudest moments of my life. NVIDIA has been my life’s work. Building it into the company it is today alongside my colleagues has been a privilege and an honor. Nowhere but in America could a company like NVIDIA be possible. I love our country, and I love NVIDIA. I did not live up to the standards expected of everyone at NVIDIA, and I have made serious mistakes in my personal life. I created problems for the Board that I deeply regret. I own my mistakes completely, and I am committed to cooperating with the Board’s independent investigation. Since my departure, I’ve seen an outpouring of calls from NVIDIA’s employees, investors, business partners, and customers for me to return as CEO. Many continue to reach out to me directly as the company navigates complex technology, market, competitive, and geopolitical dynamics. NVIDIA is a once-in-a-generation company. If the Board of Directors decides that my return is in the best interest of our shareholders, our employees, the company, and America, I would be honored to answer these calls and return as CEO. Thank you again to everyone who has shared their good wishes. I am profoundly humbled by your support. To my family: I love you, and I will spend the rest of my life being worthy of yours. Jensen
61,088
121,712
24,495
1,174,320
58,741,903
陈凯文 KC retweeted
Replying to @haniashen
From the very moment Han civilization was established 2,200 years ago, it was preoccupied with resisting invasions by northern nomadic peoples. That is why the Great Wall was built. The costs of these defenses, together with the necessity of maintaining hundreds of thousands of warhorses and hundreds of thousands of regular troops nationwide every year, consumed the greater part of the national tax revenue of this agrarian people. This enormous sacrifice ran uninterrupted through more than 2,000 years of history, until 300 years ago, when the Manchus from the north finally defeated this exhausted civilization and established the Qing Dynasty. The few examples of outward conquests you listed are truly insignificant compared with the resistance efforts Han civilization sustained against external threats over those 2,000-plus years.
1
1
303
陈凯文 KC retweeted
Different camps have different views on what constitutes “America’s interests.” Jensen Huang and some Americans believe that selling chips to China can reduce the Chinese incentive to develop their own chips and bring China’s AI ecosystem under U.S. control—an outcome they see as more beneficial to the United States than restricting chip exports to China. In a democratic society, different opinions should be heard and discussed, rather than silenced through rumor-mongering and smears.
2
1
1
287
陈凯文 KC retweeted
听说,黄乐被证实不是间谍,第二个情妇也被证实不是情妇只是朋友,第三个情妇被证实子虚乌有,100万英伟达芯片卡在中国香港进不了内地也说明英伟达没有通共…… 但是,黄仁勋还是下台了。 所以,绕了一大圈,就纯纯是为了整他?
414
443
30
5,052
344,090
My hot take from the cheap seats on Jensen Huang. The memes are fun but the actual story has a long runway to play out. 1. Currently, there is no indication at all Jensen broke the law. None. Zero. (Yes, that could change. But if there was evidence it would have emerged in the leak.) The memo was written and distributed internally last spring. 2. There is no evidence that Alice Huang is a CCP spy. Maybe she is. Maybe she isn't. Importantly, why wasn't Jensen briefed by US Intel on the potential honeypot? 3. The NYT illegally received a leaked intelligence memo from the White House. The innuendo was Alice was a spy and Jensen was compromised. 4. The leak needs to be investigated. The leaker prosecuted. 5. I don't give a shit about people having affairs. As far as we know Jensen didn't hang out with Jeffrey Epstein like Bill Gates. So the haters can pound sand. 6. Democrats on the intelligence committee admitted publicly there is no evidence currently that Alice is a CCP spy. Fact check me. It's true. 7. The timing of this leak is dubious at best. 8. The motive of the leaker is political and tied to the Blue Wave. They either have an axe to grind with China, or they are an anti-AI pro-stone-age Decel. 9. Decel Democrats and useful idiot Republicans will use this to push totalitarian controls on chips. Ultimately this is what I think motivated the leak after the Blue Wave. This should scare everyone, regardless of political affiliation. (Unless of course you want central committee congressional committees who can flip a switch with thought control and censorship.) And most importantly. . . 10. If Jensen was slandered and he did not commit any crimes, he must be reinstated as CEO of INVIDIA. Full stop.
112
147
17
991
45,461
陈凯文 KC retweeted
What if Jensen was removed from NVIDIA because he threatened the interests of powerful US tech companies and intelligence agencies, not because he threatened national security? I’m starting to change my mind about Jensen being removed from NVIDIA. The more I examine it, the more I wonder if this was really about national security, or about protecting US tech companies from competition, specifically open source AI models from China. OpenAI, Anthropic and elements of the US government, including intelligence agencies, have a common interest in removing Jensen because he supported selling advanced AI chips to China. US intelligence agencies have an obvious interest in people around the world adopting AI from US tech companies because it makes global surveillance easier. The same applies to intelligence agencies across the Five Eyes, given their existing relationships with US tech companies. This could explain why MI5 is using Instagram to tell British businesses they must adopt AI in the name of national security, while the British government tells the public they must embrace AI to remain relevant and protect themselves from cyberattacks powered by the same AI. And here’s the contradiction. The British government isn’t promoting British AI companies. It’s signing multibillion-pound deals with US tech companies, expanding their influence over the UK’s digital infrastructure while encouraging businesses and the public to become more reliant on their services. The commercial interests are obvious. So are the intelligence interests. At first, I thought Nvidia’s chip exports to Chinese companies could represent a possible national security threat. Now I think the opposite is more likely. Was Jensen targeted because his commercial decisions threatened powerful US interests? My initial thinking focused on what happened and the conclusions I could draw from the available evidence. I’m now wondering if this was a coordinated hit job. We can’t know anything for sure yet, but the commercial and intelligence interests are the most likely motives based on everything we’ve seen so far. One thing I’m certain about is that the world will be worse off if China is stopped from accessing the same technology as the West, especially in a supposedly globalised capitalist economy. The world needs open source AI models and international competition. We can’t afford to allow a handful of US tech oligarchs and the US government to control the entire world of AI, especially when AI is being embedded in almost everything we do digitally. If restricting China’s access to Nvidia chips also restricts competition from Chinese open source AI models, who benefits the most? OpenAI, Anthropic, Central Intelligence Agency, Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI), National Security Agency, and Israel.
81
157
18
615
41,497
Alice Huang was working with China's national bourgeoisie to procure ("smuggle") Nvidia chips into China - to circumvent controls imposed by both US and China on them. The purpose of this "grey market" procurement network was not so much to bypass US trade restrictions, but to bypass Chinese ones. The real story here is not the palace intrigues and conspiracies in the West, but those in China. Beijing holds the cards - and the chips. Before US export controls began, China accounted for more than a quarter of Nvidia's total revenue. It held 95% of China's market share. And the US regime was putting all of it in jeopardy. China's contribution to Nvidia's revenues subsequently dropped to less than 10%. No wonder Huang expressed open displeasure at US policies, something that few US CEOs dare to do in public. Nvidia needed China, but China decided it no longer needed Nvidia. After a few years of US export controls, the tables had turned. The balance of power had shifted. China decided to reduce reliance on Nvidia, in order to foster innovation and self-reliance. China itself started banning Nvidia chips. And it was the US that did a belated U-turn and was desperate to sell them to China (not flagship models like the Blackwell, only the chips one generation behind, like the H200). However, Nvidia customers in China were still desperate for Nvidia chips. They lobbied the Chinese government hard, but of course it doesn't work that way in China, where the government controls the national bourgeoisie, not the other way round (as in the US). China wanted them to work and innovate harder to outcompete Nvidia. It would allow a few chips here and there, but it made clear that the tide was turning, and that this cannot continue for long. You can't rely on the West forever. This was not a blanket ban, but rather, a phased, selective reduction of dependency on Nvidia. China instructed its national bourgeoisie, including key names like Alibaba and Bytedance (smaller firms faced less scrutiny), to stop purchasing and even cancel orders for certain Nvidia chips, including the infamous RTX Pro 6000D - that Nvidia had desperately designed just for the Chinese market to comply with US export controls (absolutely cannot make this shit up: China rejected the very chip that Nvidia specifically created for it only to comply with US trade laws). The formidable H200 also suffered the same fate, atleast 600,000 of which - worth a bonkers $20-30 billion - have piled up so far in Hong Kong's warehouses because China wouldn't let them in. So China's national bourgeoisie - major Nvidia customers - hatched a plot with Nvidia to try to get hold of as many of its chips as they could, by hook or by crook. And people like Alice Huang and her company (there are many like them) were the intermediaries. Nvidia was getting squeezed from both sides, by both countries. The above network allowed both Nvidia and its Chinese customers to exploit legal "loopholes" and lack of enforcement. Nvidia could thus continue earning at least some revenue from the Chinese market. Of course China knew about these shenanigans, that the players assumed were happening behind its back. Eventually its tolerance started reaching its limits. The CPC wasn't going to let US actions derail its own national development. Technology of the white devils may be purchased tactically, but cannot be allowed to undermine long-term strategic goals. Just like the Chinese people, China's semiconductor industry was also going to stand up. Then let the chips fall where they may.
4
30
4
153
6,695
陈凯文 KC retweeted
Are you stupid? I’m literally standing in a Tibetan language museum at the biggest university in Tibet. And guess who paid for it? The Chinese government. How is that “banning” Tibetan language?
Replying to @TheDanteMunoz
You just don't know. It's going to be banned, just gradually. China is eliminating Tibetan language education, once new generation no longer know how to speak Tibetan, they will remove all those signs.
72
287
13
3,827
125,737
陈凯文 KC retweeted
4만 7천 명 돌파: 엔비디아 이사회를 포위한 'Stand with Jensen' 공개 청원 일론 머스크가 공개 서명을 선언하며 불을 붙인 젠슨 황 복직 청원 사이트(standwithjensen.com)의 열기가 폭발하고 있다. '33년의 헌신은 답을 들을 자격이 있다'는 제목으로 이사회에 날린 직격탄이다. 1. 무섭게 치솟는 서명 규모 (현재 47,093명 돌파) 단순 팬덤이 아니다. 현직 엔비디아 직원 3,185명, 전직 직원 494명, 주주 26,259명, 지지자 17,155명이 이름을 올렸다. 현직 수석 디렉터와 프린시펄 엔지니어들까지 실명으로 동참하며 내부 반발이 공식화되는 모양새다. 2. 실리콘밸리 거물들의 연대 일론 머스크(테슬라·스페이스X)를 필두로 팀 스위니(에픽게임즈), 개리 탠(Y콤비네이터), 암자드 마사드(레플릿), 개빈 베이커(아트레이데스) 등 업계와 월가의 핵심 인사들이 주주 자격으로 총출동했다. 3. 이사회에 던진 3대 핵심 요구 첫째, 독립 조사로 명확한 증거가 나올 때까지 젠슨 황을 CEO로 즉시 복직시킬 것. 둘째, 조사 범위와 일정을 공개하고 젠슨에게 공정한 소명 기회를 줄 것. 셋째, 비밀유지 뒤에 숨지 말고 주주와 직원의 이익을 어떻게 고려했는지 공개 설명할 것. 4. "책임은 묻되 적법 절차를 지켜라" 청원서는 33년의 공로가 면책특권은 아니지만, 의혹만으로 창업자를 밀어내는 것은 '여론 재판'일 뿐이라고 지적한다. 사내 게시판과 머스크의 참전에 이어 5만 명에 육박하는 집단 압박이 이사회의 침묵을 깰 수 있을지 주목된다. 서명 및 전문 확인 standwithjensen.com/#sign $NVDA #엔비디아 #젠슨황 #일론머스크 #StandWithJensen #AI반도체 #미국주식
68
428
21
2,257
140,234
陈凯文 KC retweeted
Uyghurs are not descendants of the Turks!! Two key points: First, the Turks (or *Türks*) were an ancient tribe that ceased to exist by the mid-eighth century. Second, the primary ancestors of the modern Uyghurs were the Huihe (Uyghur) people of the Sui and Tang dynasties. During the era of the Turkic Khaganate, the Huihe were a tribe oppressed and enslaved by the Turkic state. With the support of the Tang dynasty, the Huihe—in alliance with other tribes—overthrew the Turkic Khaganate.
7
4
2
40
1,228
陈凯文 KC retweeted
下面是郑成功进攻荷兰之前发的檄文,可以驳斥你的第1、2点: 《与荷兰守将书》(郑成功致揆一劝降书,俗称檄文,1661 年)泉州郑成功... 执事率数百之众,困守城中,何足以抗我军?而余尤怪执事之不智也。 夫天下之人固不乐死于非命,余之数告执事者,盖为贵国人民之性命,不忍陷之疮痍尔。今再命使者前往致意,愿执事熟思之。 执事若知不敌,献城降,则余当以诚意相待。否则我军攻城,而执事始揭白旗,则余亦止战,以待后命。我军入城之时,余严饬将士,秋毫无犯,一听贵国人民之去。若有愿留者,余亦保卫之,与华人同。 夫战败而和,古有明训;临事不断,智者所讥。贵国人民远渡重洋,经营台岛,至势不得已而谋自卫之道,固余之所壮也。然台湾者,中国之土地也,久为贵国所踞。今余既来索,则地当归我,珍瑶不急之物,悉听而归。 若执事不听,可揭红旗请战,余亦立马以观,毋游移而不决也。生死之权,在余掌中,见机而作,不俟终日。唯执事图之。
1
1
1
446
陈凯文 KC retweeted
Almost all countries progressed under some kind of totalitarian dictatorship. Japan progressed under American occupation totalitarian dictatorship and aristocratic rules. South Korea’s Miracle on the Han River was achieved under military dictatorship. Taiwan progressed under KMT totalitarian dictatorship. Singapore progressed under single party rule. All rich Mid East countries progressed under totalitarian dictatorship. The rest third world countries are all poor and many of them are democratic. Does this phenomenon tell you something different form western propaganda?
1
46
陈凯文 KC retweeted
Modu Şanyu (Mete Han) Kimdir? Pantürkistlerin “Türklerin kurucu lideri” olarak kabul ettirmeye çalıştığı Modu Şanyu’nun (Mete Han) Türk olduğunu gösteren herhangi bir tarihsel belge yok. “Türk” adının Göktürklerle bağlantılı açık kayıtları, Mete’den yaklaşık 700 yıl sonra, MS 6. yüzyılda ortaya çıkıyor. Mete’yi anlatan Shiji ve Han Shu gibi Çin kaynaklarında ise onun Türk olduğu söylenmiyor. Bu konudaki tartışmaların ana başlıklarına bakalım. Türk anne, Çinli üvey anne: Kaynakta olmayan bir hikâye Prof. Ahmet Taşağıl’ın konuk olduğu 7 Haziran 2024 tarihli Sıra Dışı Gündem programında (evet, izlemek zorunda kaldım) sunucu, Mete’nin annesinin Türk, babası Touman’ın (Teoman) ikinci eşinin ise Çinli olduğunu söylüyor. Taşağıl da buna katılıyor. Oysa Shiji şöyle yazıyor: “Şanyu’nun Modu adında bir veliahdı vardı. Sonra çok sevdiği bir yanzhi’si [Xiongnu hükümdarının eşi] küçük bir oğul doğurdu.” Kaynakta ne Çinli bir üvey anne var ne de Mete’nin öz annesinin etnik kimliği belirtiliyor. Çinli üvey anneden rahatsız olan anlatı, Mete’nin Çinli eşini görmüyor Mete’nin kendisi, MÖ 198 dolaylarında Han Hanedanı’yla heqin adı verilen evlilik yoluyla bir barış antlaşması yaptı. Bu düzenleme kapsamında Çin sarayından prenses statüsünde bir kadın Xiongnu hükümdarına eş olarak gönderildi. Dahası, Baideng kuşatmasında Mete’yi Çin imparatorunu serbest bırakmaya ikna eden kişi, onun Xiongnu eşiydi. Shiji’ye göre Çinliler bu kadına değerli hediyeler göndererek müdahalesini sağlamıştı. Bu kadın ile daha sonra heqin kapsamında gönderilen eş aynı kişi değildi. Shiji’ye göre Xiongnu eşi Mete’ye şunu söylemişti: “Han topraklarını ele geçirsen bile şanyu orada yaşayamaz.” Bu da Mete’nin geri çekilmesinin nedenini gösteriyor: Çin gibi büyük bir devleti askerî olarak yenmekle onu yönetebilmek arasında fark vardı. Dolayısıyla Türk tarihinde bolca anlatılan, Çinli prenseslerin Xiongnu devletini ya da “Türk” devletlerini yıkmak için hanedana sokulduğu türünden anlatılar, bu olayların tarihsel bağlamını açıklamıyor. Çin’e ve Uygurlara yenilen Türklerin batıya göçünü bu yenilgilere değil de kuraklık gibi uydurma nedenlere bağlamak da tarih dışıdır. Diyelim ki kuraklık vardı; o zaman neden daha bereketli Çin coğrafyasına doğru gidilmedi de yine Afganistan ve İran gibi kurak topraklara gidildi? Shiji, Xiongnu’nun kökenini nereye bağlıyor? Shiji’nin Xiongnu bölümünün ilk cümlesi şöyle: “Xiongnu’nun ataları, Xia Hanedanı soyundan gelen Chunwei’ye dayanır.” Pantürkistlerin Modu Şanyu’yu (Mete’yi) Türk ilan ederken başvurdukları temel kaynaklardan biri, Xiongnu’nun kökenini Türklerle değil, Çin’in efsanevi Xia Hanedanı’yla ilişkilendiriyor. Göktürkler Xiongnu’dan mı geliyor? Mete’den yüzyıllar sonra yazılan bazı Çin kaynakları, Göktürkleri Xiongnu’ya ilişkili olabilceğini ifade ediyor. Zhou Shu (MS 636), Göktürklerin Xiongnu’nun ayrı bir kolu olduğuna ilişkin ''muhtemelen'' diye aktarıyor ve hanedanlarının soyadını Aşina olarak veriyor. Ancak aynı kaynak, Göktürklerin atalarını Xiongnu’nun kuzeyindeki Suo ülkesine bağlayan başka bir rivayete de yer veriyor. Sui Shu ise onları Pingliang’daki “karışık Hu” topluluklarıyla ilişkilendiriyor. Üstelik Xiongnu çok halklı bir siyasi birlikti. Mete’nin fethettiği 26 siyasi topluluğun Xiongnu hâkimiyeti altında birleştiği anlatılıyor. Dolayısıyla Xiongnu adı, tek bir etnik topluluktan çok geniş bir siyasi yapıyı ifade ediyordu. Han Shu’da Xiongnu hükümdar ailesi Luandi adıyla anılırken, Göktürk hanedanının soyadı Aşina’dır. Osmanlı hâkimiyetinde yaşamış Sırpların Osmanlı tarihinin parçası olması onları nasıl Türk yapmıyorsa, Xiongnu siyasi dünyasıyla ilişkilendirilen her topluluğun da aynı etnik kimliğe sahip olduğu varsayılamaz. Göktürklerin “muhtemelen Xiongnu’nun (Hunların) hâkim olduğu toprakların kuzeyinden gelmiş olabileceğini” söyleyen rivayetleri tarihsel bir gerçek gibi sunmak, pantürkistlerin nitelikli dolandırıcılığından başka bir şey değil. Mete, Türklerin kendi tarihsel hafızasında nerede? Mete’nin modern Türk tarih anlatısındaki merkezi konumuyla erken Türkçe kaynaklardaki yeri arasında büyük bir fark var. Orhun yazıtlarında ve Kaşgarlı Mahmud’un Divanü Lügati’t-Türk adlı eserinde Modu Şanyu (Mete) yoktur. Peki Mete, Türk tarihinin kurucu hükümdarı olarak ne zaman ortaya çıktı? Bu özdeşleştirmenin modern biçiminin oluşmasında Avrupalı oryantalistlerin önemli rolü oldu. Fransız sinolog Joseph de Guignes, 18. yüzyılda Çin kaynaklarını inceleyerek Xiongnu ile Avrupa Hunları arasında tarihsel bir bağlantı kurmaya çalıştı. Bu tür bağlantılar daha sonra Türk tarih yazımına da taşındı. Bu arada ilginç bir ayrıntı var: Joseph de Guignes, 1759'da Çinlilerin Mısır kökenli bir koloni olduğunu savunan bir çalışma da yayımladı. Çinlilerin Mısır kökenli olduğu tezi bugün tarihsel olarak kabul edilmiyor. Çinlileri Mısırlı ilan eden bu köken teorisi eleştirel biçimde incelenip reddedilirken, aynı dönemin Xiongnu-Hun-Türk özdeşleştirmelerini sorgulamadan gerçek olarak sunmak tutarlı değildir. İktidar halkın sevgisiyle değil, askerî şiddetle ele geçirildi Shiji’ye göre Touman, küçük oğlunu tahta geçirmek için Mete’yi Yüeçilere rehin gönderdi ve ardından Yüeçilere saldırdı. Böylece oğlunun öldürülmesini sağlamaya çalıştı. Ancak Mete kaçıp geri döndüğünde Touman onu on bin atlının komutanlığına getirdi. Kaynak, Touman’ın oğlunun cesaretinden etkilendiğini anlatıyor. Yine de sorulması gereken bir soru var: Oğlundan kurtulmaya çalışan bir hükümdarın ona böylesine büyük bir askerî güç vermesi ne kadar inandırıcıdır? Taşağıl, Mete’nin askerlerini eğitirken kendi atına ve eşine ok attırdığına ilişkin anlatılarda abartılar bulunduğunu kabul ediyor. Buna karşılık Mete’nin halk tarafından çok sevildiğini ve iktidara gelişinde halk desteğinin belirleyici olduğunu ileri sürüyor. Anlatılarda halk sevgisi diye bir şey yok. “Türklerde insan kurbanı yoktur” iddiası Taşağıl, aynı programda insan kurbanını Çin’e, İskandinavya’ya ve Amerika’ya özgü bir “vahşet” olarak anlatıyor ve “Türklerde hiçbir zaman olmadı” diyor. Oysa Shiji’nin Xiongnu bölümünde şu ifade yer alıyor: “Hükümdarın yakınındaki gözde görevliler ve cariyelerden onunla birlikte ölenlerin sayısı yüzlerce, hatta binlerce kişiye ulaşır.” Han Shu da aynı cenaze geleneğini aktarıyor: “Hükümdarın yakınındaki gözde görevliler ve cariyelerden onunla birlikte ölenlerin sayısı onlarca, hatta yüzlerce kişiye ulaşır.” Daha sonra yazılan Qian Han Ji ise bu sayının onlarca kişiye ulaştığını yazıyor. Kaynaklar arasında sayı farklılığı var. Ancak üçünde de hükümdarın ölümü üzerine yakınındaki görevlilerin ve cariyelerin onunla birlikte öldüğü anlatılıyor. Bu pasajlar doğrudan Modu Şanyu’nun (Mete’nin) cenazesini değil, Xiongnu hükümdarlarının genel cenaze geleneğini anlatıyor. Bu geleneğin Modu Şanyu’nun cenazesinde de uygulanmış olması muhtemeldir. Mete’nin babasını öldürttükten sonra üvey annesini, kardeşini ve kendisine boyun eğmeyen yöneticileri ortadan kaldırması bir tasfiyedir. Ancak bu kadar insanın öldürülmesi ile Xiongnu cenaze geleneği birlikte düşünüldüğünde bir ortaklık görülüyor: Her ikisinde de hükümdarın ölümüyle birlikte onun çevresindeki insanlar da ortadan kaldırılıyor. Tarihi bize safsatalarla anlatanlar, bu bilgilerle ne yapacaklarını bilmedikleri için Modu Şanyu’yu herkesi kesen ama halkın desteğini alan biri olarak gösteriyor. Burada olan, büyük ihtimal babasının ölümüyle beraber, onun yakındaki kişileri de öldürerek, onları da tasfiye etmesidir, ama bu tasfiyenin zaten Xiongnu (Hun) geleneklerinde mevcut olmasıdır. Han Shu, Xiongnu’ya teslim olmuş Çinli general Li Guangli’nin öldürülmesini de anlatıyor. Kaynağa göre bir Xiongnu şamanı, ölmüş eski şanyunun öfkelendiğini ilan ediyor. Bunun üzerine Li Guangli yakalanıyor ve kurban ediliyor: “Sonunda Ershi’yi [Li Guangli’yi] öldürüp kurban ettiler.” Dolayısıyla Xiongnu tarihinde hem hükümdarla birlikte ölen insanlara ilişkin cenaze gelenekleri hem de dinsel amaçla insan öldürülmesine ilişkin anlatılar bulunuyor. Modern bir “Türk” kavramını alıp alakasız toplumlara ve tarihlere uygulamak, sonra da ortadaki tarihsel gerçekleri yok sayarak bunu insanlara anlatmak nitelikli dolandırıcılıktır. Xiongnu’nun bozkırda hâkim olmuş bir güç olması, “Pantürkistlerin Kriptomnezisi” yazımda anlattığım gibi, pantürkistlerin kendilerini Xiongnu sanmalarına yol açtı. Aile anlayışı: Shiji ne anlatıyor? Shiji, Xiongnu aile geleneklerini şöyle anlatıyor: “Baba öldüğünde oğul üvey annesiyle, kardeş öldüğünde ise hayatta kalan kardeş ölen kardeşinin karısıyla evlenir.” Bu, bozkır toplumlarında görülen ve antropolojide levirat gibi kavramlarla incelenen evlilik gelenekleriyle ilişkilidir. Levirat, insan kurbanı, yamyamlık gibi olgular tarihte dünyanın çok çeşitli toplumlarında ortaya çıkmıştır. Bunlar tarihin konusudur; bir toplumun diğerine sözde üstünlüğünün nişanesi de değildir. Modu Şanyu adı nasıl “Bahadır” oluyor? Taşağıl, Modu Şanyu adını “Bahadır” sözcüğüyle ilişkilendiriyor. Bunun, Niagara’nın “Ne yaygara!”dan, Amazon’un “Ama bu ne uzun!”dan, Medine’nin “E bir dinle!”den geldiğini söylemekten bir farkı yok. Ezcümle, Modu Şanyu, Çin kaynaklarında anlatılan Xiongnu halkının lideridir. Pantürkistlerin yalanlarını ve manipülasyonlarını dönemin kaynakları çürütüyor. Türkiye’de pantürkist tarih anlatımı hemen durdurulmalı. Eğitim sendikaları, yabancı tarihçiler ve pantürkist tarih anlayışına karşı açıkça tavır almış tarihçiler bir araya gelip gerçek tarihi yazmak için harekete geçmeli. Bu tarihçilerin Ermenice, Rumca, Kürtçe, Farsça ve Arapça gibi dilleri de bilmesi gerekiyor. Bu gerçekleşene kadar eğitim sendikaları bu tarihi ifşa etmeli. Çünkü bu tarih, Türkiye’deki eşit vatandaşlığı yok sayan ve insanları uydurma bir tarihsel üstünlük fikriyle uyuşturan bir ideolojidir.
9
11
1
81
11,382