Replying to @RosemaryGoring
The number of second homes in Scotland has dropped by 18,915 properties, or 47.5%, between 2005 and 2025. According to official Scottish Government housing statistics, the total fell from 39,842 in 2005 to 20,927 in September 2025. So very little supports your claim. – at Oban, Scotland
1
Roddy MacLeod retweeted
Replying to @theSNP
@thesnp policies have badly damaged the visitor economy - pointless STL licensing, extreme NDR rises, oppressive planning control and now punitive visitor levies.
Good to see the public pushing back on more business closures.
@StephenFlynnSNP
bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c6j4…
Roddy MacLeod retweeted
Last day to respond. @argyllandbute’s short-term let control area consultation closes at midnight tonight, Sunday 15 November.
“We do not propose to issue a correction or invite respondents to reconsider their submissions.”
That is the position an Executive Director has set out in writing, copying in the Chief Executive and the Council Leader.
The Council’s original June report identified 1,486 existing secondary lets in the proposed control area and considered what a 10% reduction, around 140 properties in its illustration, could mean for housing supply. It also considered circumstances in which existing operators could lose their licences at renewal.
Yet on 2 October, the Council told consultees that the proposal would only affect new secondary lets and would not retrospectively affect existing operators. We wrote on behalf of the Association of Scotland’s Self-Caterers on 5 October to ask how that assurance could be reconciled with the Council’s own report.
On 30 October, the Council’s Head of Development and Economic Growth told us that, if the area is designated, operators renewing their licences would have to show that they have planning permission, have applied for it or do not need it. The Council’s FAQs set out the same requirement.
If you were told the proposal only affected new lets, you might reasonably have decided there was no need to respond. If you already submitted your views, you might have answered differently had you known what the Council now says it would ask of you at renewal.
We wrote again on 10 November asking the Council to re-run the consultation or, at a minimum, to write directly to everyone who received the October assurance, extend the deadline and give people the chance to amend their responses. The Council extended the deadline by two weeks when it corrected its housing figures. Existing operators deserve the same opportunity to respond with clear information about what this could mean for their businesses.
If you run an existing self-catering business, please respond today.
If the October assurance influenced whether or how you responded, say so. Tell the Council what you need to know about licence renewal and what the proposal could mean for your business.
Respond to the Argyll and Bute Council consultation: argyll-bute.gov.uk/form/stl-…
@ASSCnews @SaveSCScotland
🔔 Have your say: Argyll and Bute Short-Term Let Control Area Consultation closes this Sunday! 🔔
There is still time to make your voice heard, but the deadline is fast approaching.
Argyll and Bute Council is consulting on proposed Short-Term Let Control Areas, and the ASSC is encouraging local self-catering operators, businesses and residents to take part before Sunday 15th November.
We have raised concerns about the wording of the consultation, particularly the risk of responses about housing affordability, recruitment and sustaining local communities being interpreted as support for designation.
It is important that you make your position clear. Whether you support or oppose the proposals, take the time to explain what you believe designation would mean for your local community.
🗓️ Deadline: Sunday 15th November
👉 Find out more and complete the consultation here: assc.co.uk/news/argyll-and-b…
Please share with others in Argyll and Bute and encourage them to have their say too.
@FionaCampbell74 @SaveSCScotland
1,500 holiday lets left in limbo.
Argyll and Bute Council told existing operators they wouldn't be affected by proposed controls. Now it says they will.
ASSC calls for a fresh consultation.
⏰ Respond by Sunday 15th Nov. Guidance and links:
assc.co.uk/news/argyll-and-b…
Replying to @WingsScotland
Ban things, control things, tax things. That the SNP for you. – at Swaziland
1
18
Roddy MacLeod retweeted
** Yesterday you didn't need planning permission. Tomorrow you may need it. Our policies have changed since you started your business, so you might not get it now…. **
The gap between @argyllandbute Council's assurances on its proposed short-term let control areas and its published licensing policy is deeply troubling.
The Council says existing operators will not be retrospectively affected.
Yet its licensing policy expressly anticipates existing licence holders having to apply for planning permission or a Certificate of Lawfulness after designation. Refusal could mean their licence is refused, varied or revoked. I read that as a clear route to affecting established businesses through licensing.
How are we supposed to reconcile those two positions?
The Council’s papers also models a hypothetical 10% reduction in existing self-catering properties, approximately 140 properties, returning to residential use.
Whose businesses does the Council envisage closing?
Whose livelihoods are at risk?
There is absolutely no evidence that these proposals will deliver affordable permanent homes. A business closing does not guarantee that its property becomes an affordable home, or even a permanently occupied one.
If the Council provides definitive, published confirmation that designation will not trigger blanket demands for existing, unchanged businesses to prove their historic planning status, including at licence renewal, we will welcome it.
Until then, I cannot advise established operators to take comfort from the claim that this only affects new proposals.
I believe operators have every reason to be worried, and every reason to respond.
Please respond to the consultation by 15 November 2026: argyll-bute.gov.uk/planning-…
I urge everyone affected to ask for evidence, clear safeguards and an honest explanation of what these proposals mean for existing businesses.
Respond to the consultation. It is critical.
#SelfCatering #ArgyllAndBute #ScottishTourism #SupportLocalBusinesses @ASSCnews @st_alliance @Argyll_IslesApp
Replying to @RosemaryGoring
Of course, the real reason for the housing shortage is lower occupancy rates than in the past.
1
21
Replying to @RosemaryGoring
This letter explains the situation that many know well. – at Swaziland
22
Replying to @RosemaryGoring
@rosemarygoring It's an urban myth that 2nd homes and short lets cause a housing shortage. I have more on this, if you're interested in setting the rural record straight. – at Sandton, South Africa
Replying to @RosemaryGoring
@rosemarygoring Your otherwise interesting article on housing today fails to mention the biggest driver of the crisis, falling occupancy rates. This is a big failing. 2nd homes and STLs are not the cause. – at Sandton, South Africa
2
28
Replying to @FionaCampbell74
I've watched all of item 18b of argyll-bute.public-i.tv/core… Officer Flanagan clearly states WTTEO: even if only 10% of the existing STLs become permanent dwellings; and all STLs will require detailed planning assessments when licences are renewed. Item 18b was voted forward.
13








