Luke Smith (@luke_smith23) header
Luke Smith (@luke_smith23) profile picture

Book nerd and reviewer. Interested in human nature, evolution, WW2, morality. Blogs on evolution, cognition, and what makes us human.

Australia
Joined May 2012
Photo by Luke Smith (@luke_smith23)Photo by Luke Smith (@luke_smith23)Photo by Luke Smith (@luke_smith23)Photo by Luke Smith (@luke_smith23)Photo by Luke Smith (@luke_smith23)Photo by Luke Smith (@luke_smith23)Photo by Luke Smith (@luke_smith23)Photo by Luke Smith (@luke_smith23)Photo by Luke Smith (@luke_smith23)Photo by Luke Smith (@luke_smith23)
Chugging along and it’s absolutely brilliant. This will be the go-to for accessible, introductory, non-textbook, psychology books moving forward. Everyone should read this. @paulbloomatyale @HarperCollins
9
13
1
157
22,551
Luke Smith retweeted
Replying to @TheCinesthetic
The Gattaca soundtrack is also incredible by Michael Nyman
1
3
134
Luke Smith retweeted
This brilliant and beautifully written book persuaded me of the value of evolutionary psychology, and kindled my interest in the historical decline of violence.
1
51
9
500
38,354
My new book ALL THE FEELS is out 9/30: why evolution built every human feeling, from hunger to awe. I've got 25 free advance e-copies. Want one? Reply or DM me. The social contract: a candid Goodreads review before launch. First 25 hands up get one.
51
23
4
137
25,481
Luke Smith retweeted
2 points: There is obviously a broad leftist ideological bias within cultural anthropology, and this can influence the topics investigated and how they are interpreted. Anyone can see that, and anthropologists trained in reflexivity and attuned to their own positionality should be intellectually honest and self-aware enough to recognize this. There's some self-congratulatory insular navel-gazing where some anthropologists celebrate themselves for criticizing their own societies, and offer a selectively applied relativism with how charitably they write about some groups and demographics compared to others. There is also some borderline unreadable, jargon-heavy 'theoretical' perspectives that are pure in-group signifiers and illegible to anyone outside the field which don't help matters. This is all pretty much in line with the standard 'anti-woke' take on the field. However, Anthropology is, by far in my opinion, the single most important field for understanding human nature. Many people who make the 'anti-woke' critique here don't even read anthropology, are intellectually lazy, and looking for reasons to dismiss the field. The reality is the ethnographic record should be of essential interest to anyone who wants to understand human nature. Evolutionary psychologists, behavioral geneticists, economists, archaeologists, etc all need ethnography: they don't know what traits are universal, they don't know if the underlying traits they are interested in manifest the same everywhere, they don't know how social processes influencing and influenced by such traits work around the world, etc. Many big claims in such fields may have strong ethnographic counter-examples or areas where ethnography increases nuance and points to important patterns which need to be engaged with. Additionally, the great thing about ethnography is that even when theoretically bankrupt the empirical observations can be incredibly valuable. There is plenty of 19th and 20th century ethnography where the theories are total nonsense but are filled with essential first hand observations of long-gone societies which are timeless. So even some of the worst present day stuff plagued by ideological bias and bad theory can be useful. I think the criticisms of cultural anthropology I mentioned above are true but exaggerated, sometimes in bad faith. I think cultural anthropologists could do themselves a favor by better reflecting on these sort of critiques of the field and not just dismissing them as bad faith culture war complaints (even though, as I said, sometimes they are). I was writing about all this stuff back in 2017/2018 in Quillette and other venues when I was still in undergrad and I don't like complaining about anthropology much anymore, because I do think it's such an important field, and there is so much great work on the evolutionary side of anthropology that gets ignored by everyone.
18
34
5
198
13,072
Luke Smith retweeted
Gad is not a STEM professional; he is a pop psychologist who has published a handful of low-quality, non-replicable papers and spends most of his time pontificating with credulous podcasters about his culture war takes. He is the very thing he is complaining about.
.@GadSaad agrees with Orwell: it takes an intellectual to come up with truly stupid ideas. When academics are disconnected from reality or accountability, bad ideas spread like parasites. While STEM professionals have to answer for their mistakes, humanities professors build theories that no one ever has to test. That lack of accountability is exactly how toxic ideas take over a university and eventually a culture. If these professors can't survive the scrutiny of their own ideas, should they be teaching our children? Watch here 👉l.prageru.com/49RBlY7
141
183
8
1,683
99,339
Luke Smith retweeted
In Gad Saad's book Suicidal Empathy he does clarify that he's not against empathy across the board, just when it is detached from rationality. But with its hyperbolic title (US immigration enforcement may have been too lax in recent years, but that's hardly "suicide"), and the current political context (which he surely is aware of) in which Trumpian and evangelical attacks on empathy are being used to justify cruel, destructive, and irrational policies -- together with the taunting and trolling style that Trump seems to have unleashed -- criticism is warranted. quillette.com/2026/05/06/pla…
1
83
78
768
194,353
Luke Smith retweeted
1. After I posted my critical review of @Anthrofuentes Sex is a Spectrum, a colleague pointed out that his figure of adult heights by sex (bottom panel👇) can't be right: there aren't that many US adults shorter than 4' or taller than 7' Turns out Fuentes' data are made up 🧵
22
81
18
559
87,962
I stay off X for months and months and come back to this version of Shermer…..
In this episode of @GadSaad show we are going to get to the bottom of the deepest of all truth questions: If Gad identifies as a woman, can he get pregnant? He has already demonstrated how he can become more female with wigs and lipstick. Can he make the next transition?
1
115
the ending of interstellar
What's your favourite final scene in a movie?
32
390
21
4,505
160,516
Luke Smith retweeted
It’s going to be pretty difficult to top this.
James Cameron tells us the purpose of his film adaptation of ‘GHOSTS OF HIROSHIMA’ will be to remind audiences of the “stark reality of what these weapons do to other people” “You can forget a lot in 80 years. This is one lesson we can’t forget. We can’t afford to forget”
33
59
7
1,048
71,370
Luke Smith retweeted
"But if you didn’t know Tooby had a heart of gold you’d be forgiven for thinking he made a pact with the Devil to get a mudslide of hardcore, real-life outrages to help him illustrate this or that point in his book." -@dsznycer cep.ucsb.edu/2024/03/23/reme…
3
7
588
Part of my life I don’t really show. Started playing in a band doing covers about a year ago and recently started playing live (after 20 years). Lots of fun.
1
167
There is no legit evolutionary psychology podcast. My friend @DavePietrasz and I thought this was a dire situation, so we set out to fix it. I’m excited to announce the start of Evolutionary Psychology (the podcast). I wrote a little something about it on my blog. (Link below).
18
30
5
241
27,827
Luke Smith retweeted
My worldview in four texts
My worldview in four texts
4
4
7
57
25,600
Are you a student or professor in psychology -- or any of the social sciences? If so, you've definitely seen this mistake before. It's all over the textbooks and journal articles. You might have seen it formulated in any of these ways: - Is that behavior evolved or learned? - Innate or acquired? - Biological or environmental? - Evolutionary or sociocultural? This is 100% the wrong way to think about it. My newest publication (out now in American Psychologist, @APA_Journals) shows exactly why this is wrong and suggests a better, more accurate alternative: laithalshawaf.com/uploads/1/… Pls consider RTing for greater spread. Thanks! 🙏
4
36
4
111
10,652
Luke Smith retweeted
In my opinion the reason why film critics are overwhelmingly worthless is because they care too much about narrative and not enough about the technical stuff
I’ve noticed that young cinephiles are obsessed with this technical stuff. As opposed to character, themes, symbolism etc.
1
4
61
4,236
The first four books I read on evo psych were The Blank Slate, The Red Queen, The Moral Animal, and Buss’s The Evolution of Desire. I’ve been learning from @ProfDavidBuss for 10+years, and the fact he’s constantly teaching the next crop of evolutionist thinkers is so inspiring.
4
205
Luke Smith retweeted
Replying to @StefanFSchubert
I've got a list here though it's biased towards hunter-gatherers and needs updating. The attached images are all good ones from different parts of the world with very different cultures traditionsofconflict.com/blo…
6
13
1
119
5,783