How Sovereign Is India's Digital Future?
This week on 'Big Tech, Real Cost' with Meraj Shah | A panel discussion on India's push for digital sovereignty and what it means in an increasingly interconnected technology ecosystem. From data, cloud infrastructure and AI models to chips, compute and global technology platforms, the discussion examines where India has built capabilities and where it remains dependent on foreign technology. We also look at the cost of building domestic alternatives, the role of government and private investment, whether regulation can strengthen India's strategic autonomy without stifling innovation, and why India may need to embrace both openness and greater technological capability. If digital sovereignty is a spectrum, how far should India go?
The panel discussion features @malikpayal (Ex-CCI) and @AA_speaks (NASSCOM).
Catch all the action on September 22 at 3:30 PM IST & September 26 at 1:30 PM IST.
#BigTechRealCost #WION #BigTech #AI #Algorithms #IndiaTech #TechPolicy #ArtificialIntelligence #techitout
How Much Digital Sovereignty Does India Really Need? Hear @malikpayal's Take.
Catch all the action on 'Big Tech, Real Cost' on September 22 at 3:30 PM IST & September 26 at 1:30 PM IST.
BIG TECH, REAL COST is a WION special series hosted by Meraj Shah on how the platform and AI era is attracting our lives: from the algorithm in your living room to the power grid running the data centres.
Across eight panels, some of India’s sharpest voices on technology, law and policy argue it out: who controls what you see, who owns your data, who profits when Indian work trains foreign AI, what happens to entry-level jobs, how should we regulate social media, and who pays for the electricity and water that AI consumes.
Featuring Murugavel Janakiraman (BharatMatrimony), Apar Gupta (Internet Freedom Foundation), Payal Malik (former Head–Economics, Competition Commission of India), Ashish Aggarwal (NASSCOM), Kush Amlani (Mozilla), Pranesh Prakash (Anekaanta Advisory), Meghna Bal (Esya Centre), Abir Roy (Sarvada Legal), Nidhi Sudhan (Citizen Digital Foundation), Prasanto Roy and others.
#BigTechRealCost #WION #BigTech #AI #DataPrivacy #IndiaTech #TechPolicy #ArtificialIntelligence #techitout
Tuesday: PM IST | 10 AM GMT
Thursday: PM IST | 10 AM GMT
@BhartiAparajita | @apar1984 | @KonarkBhandari | @malikpayal | @AA_speaks | @roy_sarvada | @Kathuria18 | @pranesh | @BalMeghna | @prasanto | @juhibhatnagarr | @bebaak_suri
New Podcast Episode | Can India do AI without Anthropic?
Artificial Intelligence is critical — can India build a strong and independent AI ecosystem without relying on global AI leaders?
Key discussion points:
🔹 India’s AI capabilities and ecosystem
🔹 India’s comparative advantage in the AI stack v Building Resilience
🔹 The role of frontier models
🔹 Building India’s AI infrastructure, innovation capacity and institutional, policy and regulation systems
🔹 What does Sovereign mean?
In our latest podcast, @malikpayal, Visiting Professor at ICRIER, and Gaurav Aggarwal (@fooobar), Chief AI Scientist at Reliance Intelligence, join @pujamehra Mehra, Senior Fellow (Consultant), to discuss the opportunities, challenges, and future of AI in India.
🎧 Listen to the latest episode: youtu.be/ng5zxOzGoUc?si=0qKV…
So this is what shook the startups……time is running out to capitalise on the demographic dividend.Let‘s do it! @PiyushGoyal @GoI_MeitY @DPIITGoI
𝐈𝐧𝐝𝐢𝐚 𝐯𝐬. 𝐂𝐡𝐢𝐧𝐚: 𝐓𝐡𝐞 𝐒𝐭𝐚𝐫𝐭𝐮𝐩 𝐑𝐞𝐚𝐥𝐢𝐭𝐲 𝐂𝐡𝐞𝐜𝐤
India is 10 years behind China in terms of economic development and entrepreneurship. We need to solve ecosystem problems first before we leap towards futuristic technologies.
Also, Indians do not have access to local capital to offer funding to futuristic founders. It’s sad but true.
If you looked at China 10-15 years ago, they were doing the list on the left. Just a matter of evolution and building in layers. Hardware will start to scale in India sooner.
Merit-based appointments are taking China far ahead in tech and innovation, while India hires its policymakers on the basis of nepotistic policies.
Indian startups are just efficiency-based startups.No real innovation in deep tech and AI is happening at a large scale.
There are a few here-and-there small-scale startups that are focusing on space, AI, and EVs. But without proper incubation and capital, they are not going to make it big.
—
India’s startup ecosystem indeed lags behind China’s, largely due to a decade-long gap in economic development and a weaker foundation for innovation. While China has leveraged merit-based systems, substantial capital, and layered growth—starting with hardware and scaling to deep tech—India struggles with limited local funding, nepotism in policy-making, and an over-reliance on efficiency-driven startups rather than groundbreaking tech like AI or space.
Small-scale efforts in futuristic fields exist, but without robust incubation and investment, they’re unlikely to compete globally. India’s potential is undeniable, yet it must prioritize fixing structural issues—access to capital, talent nurturing, and ecosystem support—before chasing the cutting edge. Evolution takes time, and India could catch up, but it needs a strategic shift now.
1
176
On AI Markets and Competition, Nobel laureates thoughts below. Quie in line with our recently released report form the ICRIER Prosus Centre for Internet and Digital Economy
icrier.org/publications/ai-m…
#AI #competition #industrialpolicy @GoI_MeitY @CompPolicyInt
A summary of my thinking on shared prosperity, work and AI in ten bullet points.
This is partly motivated by the fact that I have received questions from several people on these issues, and I feel like it may be useful to lay out my thinking in simple terms in one place. We are also about to have a new administration in the United States, so perhaps it’s a good time to think about some aspirations (even though I view it very unlikely that the incoming administration will move us in this direction).
1. Shared prosperity is key.
By shared prosperity I mean economic growth from which most groups (e.g., men vs. women, different ethnic groups, different education groups, different regions, etc.) benefit more or less in the same way (e.g., their incomes growing at similar rates). Economic growth that just enriches one group greatly and generates only small benefits for many other groups is not shared prosperity. This is mostly an ethical precept, but it can also be justified because a peaceful, harmonious society does require shared prosperity. It is also a realistic one. It does not require that all inequalities are wiped away at one fell swoop.
2. Shared prosperity cannot be achieved just with redistribution.
It needs to be rooted in the labor market, in (good) jobs and in wage growth. The safety net and some amount of redistribution are important. But these are not sufficient to generate shared prosperity. Even in social democratic Nordic countries, where redistribution is most robust, it is not the source of shared prosperity. Wage and employment growth have been much more important historically. Redistribution-based shared prosperity doesn’t make political economic sense either: if some portion of the population is continuously impoverished, they wouldn’t have the political power to ensure that robust redistribution remains.
Moreover, even if we had a system where pre-tax inequality was growing a lot but there was enough redistribution to ensure the disposable incomes of all demographic groups grew robustly, it would have other serious problems. People without jobs and those whose pre-tax incomes were not growing wouldn’t feel that they were contributing to society. Worse, we would head towards a truly two-tier society with just some fraction of the population flourishing economically and receiving all the social status as they are the source of all earnings and tax revenues out of which others are receiving redistribution.
3. AI is here to stay and will be very impactful.
I have little doubt that AI will be a defining technology for our future. It can also deliver significant productivity benefits, though I think whether it will do so or not is contingent on how we develop it, and its full effects will take a while to be materialized. There is a lot of uncertainty about AI’s effects. In my opinion, it is also difficult to know what AGI (artificial general intelligence) would mean and when it may arrive, and this adds to the uncertainty about AI.
In sum, we cannot think of the future of work and shared prosperity without understanding AI’s impact.
4. AI’s direction can be pro-worker or anti-worker.
A basic pillar of my thinking and my research is that all technologies are malleable – meaning that they can be developed in many different ways, with very different consequences about who wins and who loses. This is doubly and triply true for AI, which is a broad, flexible technological platform. AI can be developed for prediction tasks; it could be developed for generating text and images; it can be used as an informational tool, etc. In all of these cases, AI can be more anti-worker (meaning that it focuses on automating tasks and disempowering workers) or pro-worker (meaning that it can become an information technology for enabling workers to perform their tasks better and to be able to branch into more sophisticated and new tasks). How AI will be developed is a choice.
5. Currently it is being developed as an anti-worker technology.
The main way in which companies are thinking of monetizing AI is by automation and more powerful digital ads, and neither of which would contribute to a pro-worker agenda. Moreover, the way in which foundation models are developed and trained is shaped by the expectation and desire to reach AGI. But AGI would mean more automation – if AI can achieve general intelligence and perform almost all tasks as well as most humans, then it will take away these tasks from humans. This current path will therefore lead to job displacement and lower wages, and is thus inconsistent with shared prosperity.
6. To redirect it, you need policies.
Putting the previous two points together, we can conclude that while there was a direction for AI consistent with shared prosperity, we are not pursuing it. Moreover, the industry will not suddenly change direction. Therefore, there needs to be an intervention, and this can only come from government policies (across the world) to encourage new directions and also put regulations to prevent the more harmful uses of AI (some of which are synergistic with the anti-worker direction).
7. To redirect it, you need competition.
New technologies especially radically new directions typically come from new companies, not established incumbents. This is doubly so when the incumbents we are talking about are the largest corporations humanity has ever seen. Hence, the pro-worker AI agenda should be symbiotic with agenda of increasing competition and breaking the hold of the existing powerful incumbents on the tech sector and the direction of AI.
8. To redirect it, you need different architectural choices.
Perhaps even more controversially, redirecting AI may need architectural choices. To put it simply, pro-worker AI need to be an information tool in the hands of workers. This is impossible unless AI provides reliable, understandable and real-time information to workers in a range of occupations. The current architecture of AI (partly fueled by AGI dreams) is about AI acting autonomously and has also led to a black box structure of AI. Instead, the pro-worker direction AI needs the tools to provide advice to human decision-makers (rather than make autonomous decisions), and the best autonomous decisions are not necessarily the best advice/recommendation/information to workers. Moreover, pro-worker AI needs to be understandable by human decision-makers, which is not possible with current black box structure of foundation models complemented with fine-tuning and other kinds of ex post training of pre-trained models.
Stepping back, in an ideal world government intervention should be neutral towards different technological choices. After all, entrepreneurs and innovators know which technologies to develop and how to develop them much better than bureaucrats and lawmakers. But in certain situations where different directions of technologies have major social consequences (for example, in the choice of fossil-fuel versus green technologies), then government intervention may need to impact technology and design choices as well. Nevertheless, it is important that this is done in the most minimalist possible way, so that innovation incentives and choices are not impacted beyond the extent necessary for a more socially beneficial direction to emerge.
9. All of this requires democracy.
Since the current direction is chosen and supported by the largest and most powerful corporations in the world, only robust democratic pressure can lay the foundations of a redirection.
10. The Catch-22: AI endangers democracy.
Tech choices in the past, especially those surrounding social media, have been damaging to democracy and active political participation of the citizenry. The same is likely to be true for AI, and even more so. First, AI is likely to be a very powerful technology for manipulation, and this can exacerbate platform choices that can make money while discouraging democratic citizenship. Second, the current ethos in the AI sector is quite anti-democratic, with leading technologists and entrepreneurs believing that experts (themselves) should be empowered to make all key decisions and democratic processes get in the way of the necessary AI acceleration.
This not only creates a Catch-22 (we need democracy to redirect AI, but AI has already damaged democracies) it also suggests that redirecting AI will be very difficult. But I still believe it’s not completely hopeless.
193
Payal Malik retweeted
This very fine book on land and power is out. I provided the following endorsement for the book:
“Land has always been a source of economic wealth. This captivating book demonstrates that it has also been a fountainhead of political and social power, profoundly shaping the organization and political structures of many societies.”
Very excited to announce the release of my new book today, Land Power! Based on 15 years of work, it tells the story of how land shapes societies, from racial hierarchy to inequality, development, gender & the environment.
In hardcover/eBook/audiobook. More in 🧵 @BasicBooks 🥳
So the MoU between Uber and Indian Armed forces being discussed and certain flags been raised. National Security and Data Sovereignty must be paramount in devising Industrial Policy in this digital age
#DigitalIndia
This quoted post is unavailable.
1
228
Payal Malik retweeted
In America, a small set of giant asset managers have amassed power over many major companies in the economy. Today, I put forth a proposed rule launching an inquiry into the impacts of this on competition, financial stability, and conflicts of interest in the banking industry.
I must say the comments on competition law is this episode show a total lack of knowledge about antitrust law, first your father an end consumer has not to be the plaintiff to open an investigation, the law is in rem not personam. The Commission's mandate is to correct markets
In the latest episode of @IdeasofIndia I am joined by my colleagues @kadambari_shah and @shreyas_nl @mercatus. We spoke about our expectations from the July 2024 Budget announcement by the new Modi government. And the kinds of policy reforms we hope to see on the policy agenda, like streamlining GST, an innovation/market-based competition policy, labor reforms that can help manufacturing firms scale, and much more.
mercatus.org/ideasofindia/ka…
1
4
684
Payal Malik retweeted
The best place to relax is near water.
After just 2 minutes of viewing water outdoors, blood pressure and heart rate drop. It's more calming to look at a lake, pool, or stream than trees or grass.
Beaches are popular for a reason. Wider bodies of water bring more tranquility.
Payal Malik retweeted
When academic economists show up at conferences/write antitrust papers on digital cases & policy, can we firmly ask they #disclose who is paying their “research grants”? Nothing new here but still seeing lot of proactive advocacy for X or against Y, yet “surely disclosure is beneath me”, at every conference. I am the only one who ever does. SMH in disbelief at what we have to pretend is unadulterated wisdom.
Payal Malik retweeted
Embracing New Horizons!
The India-EFTA Trade & Economic Partnership Agreement (TEPA) marks a historic milestone in our growing partnership with European Free Trade Association nations.
This landmark agreement, inked under the steadfast leadership of PM @NarendraModi ji, will pave the path for mutual growth & prosperity by:
🔷 Boosting Exports
🔷 Promoting Investments
🔷 Creating Employment
🔷 Fostering collaboration across key sectors
We saw how data and ecosystem champions evolved in the mobile spacecreating dependencies on and hegemony of the Big Tech. Is that going to happen again in AI ecosystem ? Cloud, CPUs, GPUs, Foundational models and AI Startup. Trajectory need not be the same.#COMPETITION
I normally don't respond to tweets os people whom I dint know, but for your sanity my advise who has seen all this and much more...kuch to log kahenge logo ka kaam hein kehana...so do what you want and dont care...Kangana in tanu weds Manu should be your role model :-)
I've been in Kanpur (my hometown) for about 27 minutes so far and have already been told I've put on weight and that I'm short do you want to me livetweet this experience in which my appearance is taken apart bit by bit
1
5
465
This remark amazes me. Kudos to @RBI maintaining balance between regulation and innovation, regulator doing its job well; fintech growth, regulatory sandboxes and other innovations owe it to prudent regulations; false binary is being created between regulation and innovation
This quoted post is unavailable.
5
370

























