Mathieu retweeted
I’ve managed $500M+ in ad spend across 200+ brands over 20 years. Some of them my own.
For Dr. Axe:
Before: $4.1M spent, $15.2M back.
After: $12.9M spent, $55.7M back.
3x the spend. And the return went up, not down.
Most brands watch ROAS fall apart when they scale. Ours climbed from 3.67 to 4.30.
The budget wasn’t the secret. The thinking was.
And most of what goes viral on X about “scaling” right now gets that thinking backwards.
Here’s what half a billion dollars taught me that nobody’s posting about:
A format is not a strategy
Every few months the timeline falls in love with a format.
Pixar ads. Song ads. Fake news ads. Now drama ads.
Brands copy the format, then wonder why it flops for them.
Here are 3 of the Dr. Axe ads:
A crying selfie in a car. $1,967 spent, $47,938 back.
A woman on her bathroom floor. $6,003 spent, $69,488 back.
A plain green box with text on it. $2,432 spent, $44,836 back.
Completely different looks. Same thing underneath: they said what the customer was already thinking.
The format is the wrapper. The angle is what sells.
Your customers already wrote your best ads
The best hooks I’ve run lately came almost word for word from Reddit.
Women kept posting the same thing:
Their cabinets were full of supplements. They didn’t know what was working. And they were still exhausted.
So we stopped selling another bottle. We sold the way out of the cabinet.
The ads built on that one idea: $59K spent, $351K back.
A simple before and after from that angle turned $14K into $107K.
Across the 10 ads below: $117K spent, $696K back. Almost 6x.
And these 10 are a small sample of what ran inside that $12.9M.
Read your reviews. Read your competitors’ reviews. Read Reddit.
Your customers are telling you exactly what to say. Most brands never listen.
Volume without research is expensive guessing
Everyone says “make more creative.” True.
But 500 ads on the wrong angle is just 500 ways to lose money faster.
Here’s one of my own brands last New Year’s:
Dec 30: $802
Dec 31: $4,842
Jan 1: $38,177
One creative change.
Not a new product. Not a sale. Not influencer buzz.
One ad, built from research: who’s buying, what they’re saying, what’s stopping them. Then we let it run.
That’s when creative and algorithm line up.
Every winner has an expiry date
The ad printing money today is already wearing out.
The fix isn’t panic switching formats. It’s having your next angle ready from the research before you need it.
The brands that scale don’t wait for a winner to die. They’re already testing its replacement.
Study the customer, not the platform
Algorithms change every quarter. People don’t.
I’ve lived through every Meta update that was supposed to change everything. iOS 14 included.
The fundamentals never moved: the right message, to the right person, at the right moment.
If you’re trying to scale this Q4:
Stop copying formats. Find the angle first.
Mine your reviews and Reddit before you brief a single ad.
Build your next winner before your current one dies.
I’ve spent 20 years doing this behind the scenes. Time to start sharing it here.
Follow along. Lots more coming.
Big Brainssss
CLAYMATION ADS ARE PRINTING RIGHT NOW 👀
Your feed is full of AI-perfect UGC.
Then a clay face shows up.
You stop. Not because it's better. Because it's different.
And nobody wonders "is this a real person?" It's clay. That honesty is part of why animated ads work.
This one took zero prompt work.
We pasted a foundation brand's URL into Pinnora and pressed one button.
It came back with:
→ the hook: "Stop buying five shades of foundation."
→ the villain: foundation that goes orange by the afternoon
→ the demo: half the face matched, half not
→ the ending: the old bottles go in the donate box
No storyboard. No editor. No prompt.
Reply "CLAY" and I'll make one for your product.
There's a new version of this post
1
18
RT @pinnoradotai: CLAYMATION ADS ARE PRINTING RIGHT NOW 👀
Your feed is full of AI-perfect UGC.
Then a clay face shows up.
You stop. Not…
Mathieu retweeted
Dropping $100k on whoever brings me the AI idea that actually breaks ecommerce.
Not an app. Not a chatbot. A paradigm shift.
DMs open.
There are 100+ AI UGC tools.
Exactly 0 of them write the prompt for you.
We've been quietly building one.
It researches your product, applies neuroscience to buyer psychology, and writes the prompt that actually converts.
Opening 50 beta seats.
Follow to soon get a chance to get into private Beta tester group
The ad below: made in 2 minutes.
No manual input. No prompt guessing. 100% AI.
🤖 Made with AI








