Mark Fessey (@mark_fessey) header
Mark Fessey (@mark_fessey) profile picture

Trying to minimise the mystery in plan-making (and, dare I say it, even aim for understanding, interest, debate, support!)

Maidenhead, South East
Joined November 2009
Photo by Mark Fessey (@mark_fessey)Photo by Mark Fessey (@mark_fessey)Photo by Mark Fessey (@mark_fessey)Photo by Mark Fessey (@mark_fessey)Photo by Mark Fessey (@mark_fessey)Photo by Mark Fessey (@mark_fessey)Photo by Mark Fessey (@mark_fessey)Photo by Mark Fessey (@mark_fessey)Photo by Mark Fessey (@mark_fessey)Photo by Mark Fessey (@mark_fessey)
My take on yesterday is that it's going to be really challenging, and so we have to get behind local plans. The boosts to need are so significant for many LPAs already struggling with LP-making, and many are also already having a tough time under the presumption.
1
1
93
The presumption is crucial to motivate plan-making, but growth coming forward without a plan leads to some really bad outcomes. Also, sites unexpectedly being permitted at appeal under the presumption is often a major spanner in the works for LP-making.
1
60
We have to support local plan-making and acknowledge the time and effort that will have to go into boosting supply and collaborating on unmet need.
55
An adjustment to the standard method will require very careful explanation if made alongside a change to policy in respect of how it is applied. Also, need to be clear on: A) its use for the purposes of local plan-making; versus B) its use where the local plan is out-of-date.
1
1
3
324
Need to tread carefully if both changing the standard method for calculating need and policy re how LPAs deal with need as part of plan-making / deciding the housing requirement. Last time the SM was branded a mutant algorithm! Careful explanation 🙏 thetimes.com/uk/politics/art…
1
1
4
239
Well said @zacksimons re mandatory targets being about messaging. I think equally important is messaging that: A) fundamental to planning is balancing need with wider factors; and B) the Gov't can and will give guidance on how to strike the balance, e.g. on need v Green Belt.
1
176
In particular, it's just not possible to weigh-up 100s of comments on 100s of sites, ahead of then thinking about how they might deliver in combination. The risk is: A) a pretense of influence (even with digital best practice); or B) LP-making reduced to voting on sites.
1
174
There will always be a place for public comment on site options, but the focus might be on mutually exclusive site packages more so than the detailed work leading up to them. Also, a good interim step for public consumption can be exploring sub-area (e.g. settlement) options.
1
135
Final suggestions are then: A) new encouragement for public engagement via councillors and interest groups; and B) the NPPF acknowledging these issues and setting out key principles for plan-making in response.
103
FT article "Inside the mind of a nimby" ends well with this. Local plans are a solution, as this is where alternatives can be explored and trade-offs acknowledged. However, we must also be realistic about limits to local plan engagement, given 100s or 1000s of moving parts.🧵
2
4
7
879
So much planning chat on the airwaves. Carol Vorderman yesterday, Nick Ferrari earlier, Steve Reid on BBC WatO (the answer is brownfield + greybelt) and now coming up on Tom Swarbreck (LBC).
1
1
2
583
Looking forward to @BBCPM tackling planning "head on" this week, after it being a key issue in constituencies they've visited. In case of any help, here's a long explanation of one of the top two misunderstood policies. It's not Green Belt, but... housing targets. 🎯
3
4
9
1,652
Neither of these are good options though. The former would be admitting defeat, whilst the latter is untrialed, and would risk perverse outcomes. Even after compromising on myriad objectives, there would still be some plans that just physically cannot provide for need in full.
2
138
And finally, the middle option: Amend the NPPF & guidance to raise the evidential bar that must be reached in order to generate or not provide for unmet need. This might not require consultation and could get our plan-led system moving and working(ish) ahead of strategic plans.
1
122