Mark Crombie (@mark_macrombie) profile picture

I sometimes feed the sparrows too- it gives me an enormous sense of well-being.

Birmingham
Joined April 2014
Photo by Mark Crombie (@mark_macrombie)Photo by Mark Crombie (@mark_macrombie)Photo by Mark Crombie (@mark_macrombie)Photo by Mark Crombie (@mark_macrombie)Photo by Mark Crombie (@mark_macrombie)Photo by Mark Crombie (@mark_macrombie)Photo by Mark Crombie (@mark_macrombie)Photo by Mark Crombie (@mark_macrombie)Photo by Mark Crombie (@mark_macrombie)Photo by Mark Crombie (@mark_macrombie)
Mark Crombie retweeted
Grim reading, to be honest. It feels like we're ushering in a Big Tech takeover of one of the last bastions of meaningful human connection: education. Another opportunity to commodify something that should be a public good. There's an underlying assumption here that AI will inevitably be smarter than humans, so why bother with human teachers at all? But surely education is about much more than delivering information efficiently? Young people are completely right to be suspicious of Big Tech, its resource hungry data centres and the enormous power concentrated in private hands. And now education is next on the menu. Health, education, human interaction itself.. is there anything the billionaire class won't try to turn into a market? The question I'd ask is who actually benefits from all this? And at what point do we stop asking whether AI can replace teachers and start asking what we lose when it does? 🤷🏻‍♂️
8
11
4
41
4,484
"Keir Starmer was an unusual politician – in that he wasn't particularly one." Alan Milburn, who today published his report into young people, work and benefits, tells @lewis_goodall why he has "no doubt" Andy Burnham can pull off the changes he recommends
45
26
14
151
86,305
Mark Crombie retweeted
I first met Andy Burnham and Alan Milburn when they were political apprentices under Tony Blair and Gordon Brown. One is now prime minister and the other has written a report that he defines as the culmination of his life’s work. Milburn’s “From a Welfare State to a Working State” is big in its ambitions, broad in its scope and the length of a Tolstoy novel. Ostensibly, it is about ending the scandal of one in eight young people who are not in education, training or work, the NEETS, of whom 60% have defined themselves as never likely to participate in work. This is a waste of human capability of tragic scale. And as an indictment of how we run Britain is worse than in any other comparable rich country. In his words: “The NEET crisis is a moral problem with dire economic and fiscal consequences”. Milburn’s prescriptions are bold. And their implications go well beyond just the mandate he was set, by the last PM Keir Starmer. He frequently points out that a welfare system snd NHS that is failing young people isn’t much more satisfactory for older generations, and he can’t resist telling his former ministerial colleague Burnham to hurry up and reform all of it. He has too many recommendations to list here. But here are some of the headlines. Schools are not vocational and work-oriented enough. The NHS is not preventative enough, especially when it comes to mental illness. And when young people are diagnosed with ADHD, or depression or milder forms of autistic spectrum disorder, they are too readily put on benefits and left to stew at home. No individual or institution has a responsibility to help them create a life of gainful employment. They are abandoned. Fixing all this, in Milburn’s prescription, would not be cheap. Much of today’s fractious debate between the government and opposition parties is around the unaffordability of a welfare bill rising too fast against the constraining backdrop of the UK’s substantial government debt and sluggish growth. Under the Milburn plan, the near £6bn-a-year annual cost of supporting young people into work - through a new Youth Opportunity Service, substantial subsidies to employers who give unemployed young people a chance, plus health and education expenditures - will exceed benefit savings and incremental tax revenues till at least 2036. And it is by no means certain these reforms would pay for themselves even in ten years, because they are dependent on inherently unreliable projections of future growth and future tax. So the argument in their favour is, as Milburn says, largely a moral one. But here, for the left of the Labour Party, the Greens and (probably) the LibDems is the painful rub. Milburn wants wholesale reform of the disability and incapacity system as it applies to young people, because he thinks it acts as a powerful disincentive to taking employment. His proposed new youth allowance of roughly £80 a week could in theory see young people lose hundreds of pounds of weekly benefits payments. Most would lose much less than that. Also Milburn promises to protect the most vulnerable for life, and those who get into work should be better off. But there are social risks. The most important is that the new benefits system, which will be legislated soon but won’t be implemented till after the next election, will make young people poorer before the new structures for facilitating employment are working effectively. And there is another risk. Milburn is embracing Burnham’s devolution strategy. The new Youth Opportunity Service will not be a one-size-fits-all, but will be shaped by mayors and strategic authorities for the needs of their areas. 1/2
132
60
24
399
226,091
Falling back in love with NFL football again, and my team the 49ers Brock is such an exciting QB to watch. #49ers
3
226
Phew! Magnificent win Ideally would like to have seen 11v 11 but this is part of the game and finding a way to win (especially in this context) is a sign of a champions mentality. #ENGSPN
3
820
Brilliant late saves from Trafford He’s a super talented keeper. Pickford (and England) needs competition and finally he’s got some. #ENGSPA
2
360
Well that’s football!
30
What a mature strong performance from #England If they keep this up, no national side can get to this level or have got the quality througout the side This could be a turning point for England players' mind The only thing they need to do is a clever, strong second half again where they dictate what happens as they have done on this first one
41
34
5
751
119,002
Bit silly from Anderson. Just let him go through. 3-1 with 10 men is fine. #ENGSPA
1
3
499
Thoughts and prayers with Danny Murphy #ENGSPA
128
So pleased for Ezri. Englands best defender. Thoroughly deserved 2-0 lead. #ENGSPA
86
Love seeing Rogers and Bellingham in the same team. As they should be. Two of our best players. #ENGSPA
2
162
A humdinger of a game. England showing again they can go toe to toe with the World champions. Game on! #ENGSPA
1
3
309
Mark Crombie retweeted
Funny how “teacher-led” education became researchers, consultants, think tanks and commentators telling teachers what teaching should look like. At some point, perhaps we could try the radical idea of listening to teachers.
28
87
5
578
15,783
Hozier and Jessie can feck off.
1
4
36
524
“I fell in love with the Beatles' music (and simultaneously, of course, with their four faces-cum-personae) along with my children, two girls and a boy, in whom I discovered the frabjous falsetto shriek-cum-croon, the ineluctable beat, the flawless intonation, the utterly fresh lyrics, the Schubert-like flow of musical invention and the Fuck-You coolness of these Four Horsemen of Our Apocalypse, on the Ed Sullivan Show of 1964. Together we saw it, The Vision, in our inevitably different ways (I was forty-six!), but we saw the same Vision, and heard the same Dawn-Bird, Elephant-Trump, Fanfare of the Future . . . “The notes healed, the words teased; or perhaps it was vice versa. But something teased, and something healed, year after year, Rigby after Rigby, Paperback after Norwegian . . . "Meanwhile, there was a slim volume of pure verbal genius by a new author called John Lennon: In His Own Write. If this weren’t enough to rhapsodize upon, there were the notes (and the sylph-siren voice) of one McCartney. These two made a pair embodying creativity mostly unmatched during that fateful decade . . . John and Paul, Saints John and Paul, were, and made, and aureoled and beatified and eternalized the concept that shall always be known, remembered and deeply loved as The Beatles. To me, they were the best songwriters since Gershwin. “And yet, the two were merely something, the four were It. The interdependence was astonishing, and in some ways appalling; do we really need all this to sustain us When We’re 64? Well, today I am almost 64, and three bars of 'A Day In The Life' still sustain me, rejuvenate me, inflame my senses and sensibilities. “The Beatles are no more. But this week I am still jumping, weeping, remembering a good epoch, a golden decade, a fine time, a fine time . . .” --#LeonardBernstein #Maestro #Conductor #Composer #ClassicalMusic #Genius #Polymath #Grammys #Tonys #Emmys #Influence #HallsOfFame #TheBeatles #GOATs Sources: The Beatles, Geoffrey Stokes; interview with Jonathan Cott, 1989
9
87
9
419
15,652
Mark Crombie retweeted
I worked on 119 PMQs in No10 and I would observe that winning individual PMQs (because you landed a blow or a joke) matters less than establishing an argument over a term (eg. He didn't fix the roof while the sun was shining). That's how you win at PMQs in the long run.
2
5
60
6,563
Mark Crombie retweeted
I'm doing PMQs on @TimesRadio later so I've been looking at how Burnham has changed style from Starmer. Starmer did almost 60 PMQs and this will be Burnham'a 6th but there are already some observable differences.
14
16
8
137
71,420
Mark Crombie retweeted
Unai Emery says he was angry after Manchester United scored a late equaliser, prompting him to leave the dugout before the final whistle because he “thought the game was done”. Emery also alluded to Suzuki being blocked by Senne Lammens, which, he states, would have been a foul in other European leagues. Story @TheAthleticFC #AVFC nytimes.com/athletic/7764790…
35
38
7
374
63,019
Didn't notice in real time but that is literally VAR's job and it gets no better with every viewing. If that was on Lammens we'd be fuming so got to be honest we got away with one there
This Post is from a suspended account. Learn more
749
2,241
114
34,236
1,965,926