Miki πŸ‡ͺπŸ‡· (@miaphysite3) header
Miki πŸ‡ͺπŸ‡· (@miaphysite3) profile picture

β™° (Orthodox)

Joined April 2021
Photo by Miki πŸ‡ͺπŸ‡· (@miaphysite3)Photo by Miki πŸ‡ͺπŸ‡· (@miaphysite3)Photo by Miki πŸ‡ͺπŸ‡· (@miaphysite3)Photo by Miki πŸ‡ͺπŸ‡· (@miaphysite3)Photo by Miki πŸ‡ͺπŸ‡· (@miaphysite3)Photo by Miki πŸ‡ͺπŸ‡· (@miaphysite3)Photo by Miki πŸ‡ͺπŸ‡· (@miaphysite3)Photo by Miki πŸ‡ͺπŸ‡· (@miaphysite3)Photo by Miki πŸ‡ͺπŸ‡· (@miaphysite3)Photo by Miki πŸ‡ͺπŸ‡· (@miaphysite3)
See you next summer ig
2
1
4
539
Miki πŸ‡ͺπŸ‡· retweeted
Delighted to announce that my new article on Christian monasticism in western Arabia during the 5th-8th centuries is now published in Arabian Archaeology and Epigraphy: doi.org/10.1111/aae.70035. I will be uploading the accepted version online once the embargo period ends.
8
29
1
140
4,904
Miki πŸ‡ͺπŸ‡· retweeted
talk about missing the obvious. the entire parables is enoch having visions of a distinct figure from himself until his ascension when he, still identified by a different title, has the messianic description of α‹˜α‰°α‹ˆαˆα‹° αˆˆαŒ½α‹΅α‰… (born for righteousness). has he never read paul?
Replying to @NegedeYehuda
Clearly you have not read the text carefully. Yes, 71:14 uses α‹ˆαˆα‹° α‰₯αŠ₯ሲ, but that is the same expression used for the exalted Son of Man in 62:5 and 69:29. Thus, 71:14 applies to Enoch the exact expression already applied to the eschatological Son of Man. So the lexical distinction you’re trying to make simply doesn’t work. But more importantly, context determines whether the expression is generic or messianic, and the context of 71:14 deliberately points back to the previously described eschatological Son of Man (cf. 46:3), not merely to β€œhuman offspring.” Watch the video you’re commenting on to learn more.
1
1
4
1,093
β€œWhen I hear any question dealt with by the Maphrian [St. Gregory Bar Hebraeus], it seems to me as if I were learning wisdom at the mouth of Aristotle, his great aim being to propound sound sense, not troubling about the sophisms which the teachers of our own times are apt to be obsessed with."
1
8
684
Miki πŸ‡ͺπŸ‡· retweeted
πŸ‡΅πŸ‡Έ Syriac history in Palestine A thread 🧡
15
42
2
194
5,348
β€œThe reason for which we are said to have become heirs of the curse and of condemnation and of death is not that the sin and condemnation and death passed to us, as if these fell to our nature by lot, for man's nature was from the beginning free from all these things, but that the method by which intercourse takes place derived its origin from sin, as I have said, a method which cut away the blessing of immortality, so that the race of men is preserved from dissolution by the procreation of children. We therefore were in consequence born mortal from a mortal father. These things are defined both by the holy John in the Commentary on the Epistle to the Romans, and by the holy Cyril in the letter to Succensus.” β€” St. Severus of Antioch, Letter LXXVIII, to Conon the Silentiary.
1
10
688
Miki πŸ‡ͺπŸ‡· retweeted
If I deserve hellfire then tell me what Leo deserves for affirming quite literally the same thing in your screenshots of Nestorius.
Replying to @BruceSaiFun
agen warrants a worsened punishment in hellfire by such calumnies. the condemned Christology of nestorius can be seen in the statements below. whether or not the old man wanted to say he agreed with chalcedon does nothing against us, we’ve never affirmed these statements
7
7
71
7,056
Okay, so this was not the thesis of the video. The video goes through various aspects of Nestorius’s Christology: - the Theotokos-Antropotokos-Christotokos variance, - his expression of two hypostases/physis - his expression of two ousiai/physis - his expression of one person. - his expression of one hypostasis if it meant one person. - his rejection of Cyril and Eutychius. - his acceptance of Leo, his Tome, and Flavian. The topic of the Theotokos is a small part of the whole.
The dispute over the title β€œMother of God” precipitated the Nestorian controversy, but it was never the be-all and end-all of the issue. To reduce the controversy to that one title is revisionism, and Agen now seems to have unfortunately adopted precisely that revisionist line. The real issue was, is, and remains Nestorius’ doctrine of the union in Christ: not a true hypostatic union, but what amounts to a merely moral conjunction of the divine and human. The dispute over Ξ˜Ξ΅ΞΏΟ„ΟŒΞΊΞΏΟ‚ was a mere symptom of that deeper Christological defect.
3
2
20
1,423
And Agen’s end point is that: Nestorius teaches one hypostasis when it is used for one person in the sense used in the Trinity, and two hypostases when it is used in the sense of a fully individual substance bearing its own individual and common properties. Which is rather exactly what Theodoret explains to John of Aegea in his letter concerning his subscription to the creed of Chalcedon.
1
1
9
210
At the very least, go watch the video and understand the thesis if you actually want to critique it for what it says instead of what you imagine it is saying. I mean, I am pretty sure you are capable of analysing things thoroughly on their own terms.
1
9
187
β€œTherefore, I do not generally seek this office for utility or propriety, nor can I, as is commonly thought, pride myself on so exalted a seat. Rather, I lament within myself that I bear no trace of apostolic perfection. I tremble not at touching this holy throne but at suffering while seated upon it. Let him who would glory in apostolic honors and jurisdictions conduct himself as an apostle and burn with zeal for the faith amid dangers. Otherwise, let him be mocked, for he wears a lion's skin but is a tomb full of dead bones, whitewashed only on the outside (Matt. 23:27). How shall I, seated on the throne of Ignatius the God-bearer, attain his stature? Does water differ from fire? My lax life is nothing like his fervent, heavenly one. I say nothing of Hippolytus, that bishop and martyr, whose perfection Rome sent us as a reward for Antioch's aid when Ignatius went there, suffered martyrdom, and strengthened the Christians. Let us flee vain glory, brothers, and at all times know ourselves. β€˜For those who know themselves are wise’, as the proverb says. Let us despise the fleeting honors of this world and look to those that are eternal.” β€” St. Severus of Antioch, Homily [9] on St. Gregory of Nazianzus and St. Basil the Great, delivered in the sanctuary of St. Ignatius of Antioch.
Replying to @miaphysite3
He says this about St. Gregory, because, he states, St. Gregory has walked β€œtowards heaven in an awakened manner” and looked β€œupon the light of the Trinity” with an awakened eye and humbly grasped what is accessible but didn't seek excessively what is inaccessible. 7/8.
2
1
6
867
Miki πŸ‡ͺπŸ‡· retweeted
At just 12 years old, St. Mohrael chose Christ over earthly freedom, marriage, and even life itself. Her courage in the face of persecution remains a powerful witness to Christian faith. Read her Akathist: orthodoxreflections.com/akat…
3
9
253
In a video concerning the ignorance of the hour and the day in Christ, @mattjhedges11 states that the Agnoetae were heretics, not for their belief in a real ignorance of Christ's humanity, but rather of his divine nature. But is this true? The answer is *it is not*.* I will further explain this down the thread 🧡. 1/11.
1
4
1
21
2,103
This is further reinforced by his letter to Pope St. Theodosius, wherein he states that he regards Christ as 'ignorant' and 'not ignorant' in the same way he regards him as 'passible' and 'impassible.' That is, ignorant and passible in his humanity, and omniscient and impassible in his deity. Thus, on this basis, he undercuts @mattjhedges11's interpretation of the matter based on Isidore's rather faulty understanding of the matter. 7/11.
2
1
3
231
A correction note here: St. Theodosius is rather presenting a view of them than quoting him. But the point stands.
53
Therefore, the Agnoetae [and Themistius] were not condemned for, and did not think of, the deity as ignorant. For the Chalcedonians, they were condemned at the 6th EC, whereas for us, they were condemned by Pope St. Timothy/Theodosius in 535/38. 10/11.
1
1
3
194
Coming back to the video, Matt makes a statement about how the Reformed and the Agnoetae teach different doctrines (see the screenshot). But seeing what I have shown in this thread, there seems to be no actual difference at all. At least not a meaningful one. Link: youtu.be/WJcDAS4lmu8?is=hdMA…. I think this suffices for now. I have noticed a faulty reading of St. Cyril [among others] as well in the video, so I will make another moderate thread on his reading of the biblical proof texts on the topic. 11/11.
1
4
195