Marc S. Bathgate (@msbathgate) header
Marc S. Bathgate (@msbathgate) profile picture

Lesser 1/4 to @kkbathgate. Dad to 4. Converted Utahn. Finance & tech geek; avid skier, podcast lover. Alternatives skeptic & investor. Not investment advice.

84098
Joined March 2011
Photo by Marc S. Bathgate (@msbathgate)Photo by Marc S. Bathgate (@msbathgate)Photo by Marc S. Bathgate (@msbathgate)Photo by Marc S. Bathgate (@msbathgate)Photo by Marc S. Bathgate (@msbathgate)Photo by Marc S. Bathgate (@msbathgate)Photo by Marc S. Bathgate (@msbathgate)Photo by Marc S. Bathgate (@msbathgate)Photo by Marc S. Bathgate (@msbathgate)
Marc S. Bathgate retweeted
It is critically important that everyone thinking about AI become familiar with the term “handoverism.” Many in the AI community believe that humanity should—or inevitably will—hand control of the world over to AI itself. Some view this not as a risk to be avoided, but as an outcome to be welcomed. Are we actually designing toward this future? This worldview is particularly relevant at Anthropic. Co-founder Tom Brown said: “There’s going to be a handoff where humanity will hand off control to transformative AI at some point.” In his seminal essay, Machines of Loving Grace, CEO Dario Amodei contemplates: “It could be a capitalist economy of AI systems, which then give out resources (huge amounts of them, since the overall economic pie will be gigantic) to humans based on some secondary economy of what the AI systems think makes sense to reward in humans (based on some judgment ultimately derived from human values).” Are you prepared to receive your “resources” from an AI system, based on criteria it determines? The full title of the poem Dario borrowed the title from is "All Watched Over by Machines of Loving Grace." Do you want to be "watched over" by AI? If Anthropic's founders believe that the ultimate destination is the transfer of human control to AI, the world deserves to know. Washington, D.C. deserves to know. American citizens deserve to know. And if that belief informs Anthropic's corporate objectives, it belongs in the Risk Factors section of its S-1. It isn't there today. I am decidedly anti-handoverism. I'm not here to tell you what your view should be. But I believe anyone making consequential decisions about AI—especially those drafting, advocating for, or enacting AI regulation—should be required to disclose where they stand on this fundamental question. A wonderfully thoughtful piece on the subject by @RuxandraTeslo: writingruxandrabio.com/p/han…
120
238
65
1,589
140,349
Marc S. Bathgate retweeted
This Far Side from 1990 sarcastically predicted the future…
120K/yr to play video games is wild
1
1
8
1,941
Most of what we fight over is scarcity, and most scarcity is a technology problem wearing a 'political costume'. Water, energy, food, land. Solve the technology, and a lot of the arguments get very quiet.
67
62
7
596
24,191
Marc S. Bathgate retweeted
Everyone keeps pointing to the collapse in emerging VC managers as evidence that venture fundraising is dying. But I think we’re missing a big part of the story. Most smaller emerging managers weren’t raising primarily from pensions and endowments. They were raising from family offices, founders, and wealthy individuals. And those investors haven’t necessarily stopped investing. Many have simply changed how they invest. Why commit millions to a 10-year blind-pool fund when you can pick individual deals through SPVs? Yes, institutional capital has moved upmarket. But I suspect a meaningful amount of the capital that once backed emerging managers has moved into SPVs, direct investments, and syndicates. The number of funds closing is down dramatically. That doesn’t tell us how much capital has actually left the market versus how much has simply moved outside traditional fund structures. That’s the data I’d really like to see.
927 emerging managers closed a fund in 2022. Only 211 have in 2026, down 77%. The LP money didn't disappear. It just moved upmarket.
27
14
6
104
19,078
If someone asks you how much a single family's life is worth to the United States Navy, tell them the exact price: ten million dollars of steel. On April 29, 1975, as Saigon fell, a tiny two-seat wooden-and-fabric Cessna plane with almost no fuel left circled desperately above the American aircraft carrier USS Midway. Inside that tiny cockpit, a father named Major Buang-Ly had crammed his wife and five small children, including a baby. He scribbled a note on a map, wrapped it around his pistol so it would not blow into the ocean, and dropped it onto the carrier deck. A young American sailor picked up the crumpled paper and ran it up to Captain Lawrence Chambers. The note read: "Can you move these helicopter to the other side, I can land on your runway, I can fly 1 hour more. Please rescue me. Major Buang, Wife and 5 child." The flight deck of the USS Midway was completely jammed from bow to stern with military helicopters. A Cessna has no tailhook to catch carrier wires, and its pilot had never landed on a ship in his life. By every military regulation, Captain Chambers had been in command for only five weeks. Throwing millions of dollars of U.S. government aircraft into the sea without permission from Washington could end his career in a court-martial. Chambers looked up at the tiny plane circling in the wind with five children inside. He did not call an accountant in Washington. "Clear the deck," the captain ordered. Hundreds of young American sailors in yellow and green jerseys ran to the edge of the ship, put their shoulders against massive Huey helicopters, and shoved ten million dollars worth of machinery straight off the cliff into the South China Sea. Captain Chambers turned the giant carrier into the wind at twenty-five knots. The tiny Cessna came down, bounced once on the steel runway, and rolled to a safe stop with feet to spare. When the cockpit door opened and five small children stepped out onto the deck, three thousand American sailors roared so loud it drowned out the engines, and immediately passed around a hat to collect cash for the family's new life in America. When the math says a child's life is too expensive, an American throws the math into the ocean.
🤖 Made with AI
381
1,622
146
15,796
1,203,154
Since the American President announced the energy ceasefire a week ago, Russia has deliberately attacked Ukraine’s energy and oil and gas sectors 76 times. Last night alone, there were strikes on substations in the Vinnytsia, Zhytomyr, Khmelnytskyi, and Odesa regions. Tens of thousands of families remain without power. Energy workers and repair crews are working virtually around the clock to restore electricity supply. Overnight, the Russians also struck residential buildings in our regions. As of now, 12 people have been reported injured, including two children. Two people have been killed. My condolences to their families and loved ones. This morning, there was a strike on an agricultural enterprise in Volyn. All necessary services are working at the site. In total, over this past week, the Russians have attacked Ukraine with almost 2,700 attack drones, 1,700 aerial bombs, and 66 missiles, most of them ballistic. The main targets of these strikes are energy facilities – the Russians are trying to cause a blackout. And America should see that Russia is not taking any reciprocal steps in response to sanctions relief or agreements. On the contrary, they take every signal of an opportunity to make money as proof that their bet on war is paying off and they can keep fighting. It is because of this position of Russia’s that the war continues, not because Ukraine is rightfully defending itself. It is Russia that must face pressure for peace to have a chance. Thank you to everyone who understands this and helps.
1,922
8,277
375
26,986
578,116
Marc S. Bathgate retweeted
164
3,920
170
37,907
543,102
Marc S. Bathgate retweeted
9. Enter their made-up worlds. Silly, unstructured play matters more than any lesson plan. 10. Admit when you're wrong, to your kids and to your wife. They need to see it's OK and how you handle mistakes.
1
2
107
163,099
Marc S. Bathgate retweeted
For centuries, “innovator” was a slur rather than a compliment. A new analysis of more than 23,000 books suggests that Western culture has become much more receptive to new ideas over time, helping turn ingenuity into sustained prosperity.
3
10
29
3,300
Marc S. Bathgate retweeted
"You can only confiscate the wealth that exists at a given moment. You cannot confiscate future wealth — and that future wealth is less likely to be produced when people see that it is going to be confiscated." — Thomas Sowell
13
316
10
1,635
40,080
Marc S. Bathgate retweeted
Just hire him. He’s clearly the GOAT
2
15
380
10,017
Marc S. Bathgate retweeted
Send this to your best EU employees when they're back mid-September.
215
1,030
204
10,007
945,498
At a time when support for public schools is at an all time low, this result stands in stark contrast. Turns out people are far happier when they can make decisions for their kids than be told to comply.
What are families saying about the Hope Scholarship in West Virginia? ✅ 9️⃣8️⃣% of parents surveyed are satisfied. There is not much in this world with that kind of approval rating. @yes_everykid_f @HeidieLNesset @HuffmanJE wvtreasury.gov/About/Press-R…
4
14
387
Marc S. Bathgate retweeted
22
297
14
2,627
61,022
At Ground Zero, after the last living person was pulled out, the search dogs stopped eating. So the police did something nobody had written down in any manual. They climbed into the rubble, lay down, and pretended to be alive. More than 300 dogs worked the World Trade Center site. They came from every corner of the country, on trucks and in cargo holds, with handlers who had been trained to do one thing. Find people who are still breathing under the ground. That is what a search and rescue dog is built for. Not bodies. Life. They are trained on live human scent. When they find it, they bark, they dig, they light up, and the handler rewards them, and the whole thing means something. The last living person recovered from Ground Zero was a woman named Genelle Guzman-McMillan. She had been buried for 27 hours. A dog found her. She was the last. After that, the dogs kept going out on twelve-hour shifts, across sixteen acres of smoldering steel, at temperatures that burned their paws, and they found nobody. Nobody. Day after day. The handlers noticed it first. The dogs were changing. Their tails were down. They were not eating. They would come off the pile and lie flat and not look at anyone. A veterinarian named Cindy Otto, who spent ten days there working night shifts to care for the animals, put it plainly. The dogs had been sent to find life, and every day they were finding the opposite. It was breaking them. An NYPD officer named Famiglietti described what happened next. They pulled everybody off the rubble. Then they asked for volunteers. The volunteers, police officers, went out into the debris and hid themselves. Under beams. In voids. Curled up in pockets of concrete. They were told to lie down like they were hurt. Then the handlers sent the dogs in. Picture that. A grown man with a badge, a man who had spent the last week pulling friends out of that same pile, lying down in it on purpose. Face down. Holding still. Waiting for a dog. And the dog comes over the top of the wreckage, and catches the scent, and barks, and digs, and finds a person who is warm and moving and alive. And the handler says good girl, good boy, and the whole team celebrates. They called them mock finds. They did it for the dogs. They did it so the dogs would remember what they were for. One of those dogs was a two-year-old golden retriever named Bretagne. She came from Texas with her handler, Denise Corliss. It was her first deployment. They worked ten days at Ground Zero. They found no survivors. But firefighters would come off the pile, stone-faced, not speaking, and see the dog, and something would break open in them. They would kneel down. They would put their face in her fur. One day a man walked up to Bretagne and started petting her. He told Corliss his best friend loved golden retrievers. Corliss asked where his friend was. The man pointed at the pile. "He's in there somewhere." He kept petting the dog. Bretagne went on to work Hurricane Katrina and Rita. She retired at 10. She was the last known surviving search dog of 9/11. On June 6, 2016, at age 16, she was carried into a veterinary office in Texas to be put to sleep. Outside, a dozen firefighters from her fire department stood in a line in their dress uniforms, in the heat, and saluted as she went past. They draped her in an American flag on the way out. Three hundred dogs went into that pile looking for the living. They found one. And when they could not find any more, the men they worked beside laid down in the rubble and let themselves be found, so the dogs would not lose heart. That is the whole story of Ground Zero, really. Nobody could save the dead. So they saved each other. 🇺🇸
534
7,095
561
39,798
1,515,963
Marc S. Bathgate retweeted
These senators are questioning the solution to the problem instead of the problem itself: decades of bureaucratic dysfunction that has continually failed communities at risk of wildfire. This is the worst fire season in decades, and it is straining the resources of an outdated and obsolete bureaucracy. In the last few years, we have had multiple major cities and large communities devastated by fire, and their answer is: change nothing - blame climate change. We owe our firefighters and the American people better. Let’s get to work.
Senators Demand Answers From The Wildfire Agencies As Entrapments And Fatalities Rise. What’s Missing? Asking How They Can Help. Letter comes on the heels of another wildfire fatality. thehotshotwakeup.substack.co…
17
16
1
125
7,189
Marc S. Bathgate retweeted
The ARR multiple fallacy ARR multiple is not the right way to think about sub-20% growers. Simple framework: If you’re growing sub-20%, you get a 10-30x EBIDTA or FCF multiple. If you use this rubric, Miro is very fairly valued by Bending Spoons. Only 30%+ growers get the luxury of an ARR multiple. The reason is that 30% growth means you’re doubling in 3 years and so the revenue base will be 2x in 36 months, and the margin structure will look different at 2x scale. Cash flow today is a rounding error against that. So you value the trajectory, and ARR is the cleanest proxy for trajectory. At 15% growth, doubling takes 5 years. That's close enough to "never" that the market stops paying for the future and starts paying for the present. The present is earnings. If you're not producing them, you're not a growth company anymore. You're a bad value company. The mistake founders make is anchoring to the multiple they had at 40% growth and thinking the ARR multiple just compresses. It doesn't compress. It gets replaced. You cross 30% on the way down and the entire valuation framework switches out from under you. Which is why the worst place to be is 20-30% growth with no FCF. Growth investors won't pay for it. Value investors can't. You're priced by whoever is least excited,a really painful place to be.
44
67
25
854
104,528
Marc S. Bathgate retweeted
The other thing that seems to have been largely forgotten is that we started getting the anthrax mailings right after. Just as we’re all reeling from something that seemed out of some dark climax of a Tom Clancy novel, suddenly we’re in a Robin Cook thriller, where just opening your mail can infect you with killer bacteria. Two postal workers got killed from inhaling it, just doing their jobs. The danger came in the most mundane and common form, white powder. If you spilled a packet of Sweet’N Low in a public place, everybody would get nervous a few minutes later. Again, kid, it was like the world stopped making sense; impossible things were happening, and you never knew where the danger was going to come from next.
81
349
50
3,006
151,560
Reduce the friction around your pitch deck. 1) Send it in PDF 2) If you want to annoy the LP, use docsend 3) If you want to really annoy the LP, use docsend and remove download rights 4) If you want to really really want to annoy the LP, use docsend, remove download rights, and have a stringent click through NDA
23
11
11
214
46,869