Amateur Opinion Haver (@neilcaff) header
Amateur Opinion Haver (@neilcaff) profile picture

I used to be good at the twitter

London
Joined March 2010
🗣️ "I asked a passenger to put his vape away and he physically attacked me." Newcastle Airport worker. No one should have to put up with this just for doing their job. Airlines and politicians joined us in Newcastle to say Abuse Doesn't Fly. 📣 Time for the airport and government to act and stand with us to support staff. Shout out & share if you agree ♻️
1
8
2
39
3,046
Amateur Opinion Haver retweeted
#RadioMoskva Hobson’s choice for Zelenskiy in Abu Dhabi You have to feel sorry for Zelenskiy. He faces a historically horrible Hobson’s choice in Abu Dhabi: take the Russian deal or watch what is left of Ukraine’s economy be utterly destroyed. He is being asked to give up the Donbas in exchange for a US-backed security deal to end the war. The issue is: how “real” is that deal? At stake is Ukraine’s future as a sovereign nation. If he does the deal then he is being asked to trust both Putin and Trump will keep their word. Putin started with his Pandora’s box campaign in August and it is now into a total war of destroying everything that is left. “I will destroy all of Ukraine’s basic infrastructure,” he said last week – and he is not kidding. And he can. In fact, he is, as there is already not much left of the power sector; Ukraine’s biggest steel mill just closed down; and the grain is rotting in the field as the Odesa port has been closed for months. The lack of interceptor missiles saga has moved into a farcical phase: Germany said last week it’s out of interceptors and can only send some in 2027. Portugal has some, but they are not available until 2028. And Trump’s offer to sell Ukraine 500 interceptors (which the EU still has to pay for) doesn’t kick in until mid-2030. I'm just finishing off a piece that tries to calculate how many men there will be left in the Armed Forces of Ukraine (AFU) in 2030 and the preliminary worst-case estimate, based on current attrition rates + desertion, says Ukraine will reach the “fight to the last Ukrainian” zero-point in April 2029. In the meantime, Zelenskiy is getting 12 rockets a month – it can fire one every three days. Russia has a stockpile of 200 ballistic missiles and is making 50 new ones a month. That is not counting drones, other missiles and the massive FAB3000 glide bombs it used to flatten a school and kill 55 people last week – including first responders in a double-tap strike. (Oddly a story that got relatively little play in the international media.) Zelenskiy has spent months touring the world (he was still on the road in Denmark yesterday) trying to get more money and missiles, with little success. It’s now clear that he is facing defeat in the face as the deadline of the first snows is now on us. That has led to a clear change of tone amongst the Western allies as I wrote yesterday. Now suddenly everyone has gotten pragmatic. One aspect where this is clearest is in the reopening of the lines of communication between Europe and Moscow – which to be clear has happened far too late, as with everything Europe has done in this war. Macron got roasted when he first suggested this last year, but now everyone is doing it, following the Stubb-Store-Putin call initiative last week. The UK said it too yesterday: “maybe it would be a good idea to re-establish communication, and not just at diplomatic level but at the military-to-military level as well…” Even Zelenskiy added his voice to the Kremlin’s yesterday (!), saying Europe should “hurry up” and appoint an interlocutor to deal with the Kremlin. Guys, the talks have already started. Deep winter is only about 40 days away. You have failed to give Zelenskiy anything he needs to continue the war. And you want to start the outreach now, but still haven’t appointed anyone to do it? It has been perfectly obvious what will happen in December to Kyiv since July. Have the military planners been asleep all this time – hibernation in reverse? This late in the game, ex-Chancellor Gerhard Schroeder is now the only one that could literally be sent tomorrow and buys some time, but that’s never going to happen. So, given the appalling situation Zelenskiy finds himself in – he has not been asleep, which is why he has sounded so desperate for months – he needs to do a deal in Abu Dhabi – or at least lay down the groundwork for the now inevitable meeting with Putin to decide on territories. That is what this whole discussion will boil down to, in a repeat of the proposed Istanbul deal mechanics. It is a very simple trade off: Zelenskiy gives up the Donbas - and everyone involved, including Stubb is very clear about this point – in exchange for a really tough security deal. Despite all Trump’s very obvious flaws, the White House has actually stepped up and promised “Article 4 and Article 5-like” security promises – presumably at bilateral level although Secretary of State Marco Rubio and the Kremlin have both now changed tack and both are now saying “Europe has to be involved”. That is new, as until now both of them have done everything they can to exclude Europe. Kushner said last month if Zelenskiy agrees to give up Donbas then “the deal is done.” So, is it all agreed? Not so fast. Zelenskiy posted a whinge on X yesterday that highlights his dilemma. "Ceding Ukrainian land for peace is just abstract words. It's not only about reality, even more about philosophy… This is why when Americans ask, 'Can you exchange Donbas for security?' I said right there, 'Can you tell me what it means? What security? Nato?' 'Not Nato, but similar to Nato.' 'Similar? But you don't want the answer about Donbas to be 'similar'. You want a clear answer about Donbas. This is your goal. And this is Putin's goal for today. What will you do if we have security guarantees but not Nato?' … “Nobody trusts Putin to stop if we leave Donbas. He will pause. Then he will come back in one year, two years, or five years. And who will be guilty?" You can see that he is scared of being sold up the river. What exactly does “Article 5-like" mean? Remember that Article 5 does not automatically trigger military action, but only consultations where the members then take action “deemed necessary.” What Zelenskiy wants, and needs, is a security deal that will automatically trigger WWIII if Russia invades for a second time. Anything less means that Russia could restart the war in two years’ time and walk all the way up to Dnipro, taking half of Ukraine in the process, which they would never get back. Now put these US promises into the context of the new “Donnie Doctrine” of the National Security Strategy (NSS) released last December, where the Trump administration made it crystal clear that it was pulling back from Europe and that Russia was “Europe’s problem now.” Moreover, this is not idle chat. In the same month, in another under-reported story, the Pentagon issued a “hard deadline” for Europe to take over responsibility for its own conventional forces' security by 2027. What that means in practice is the US will withdraw its logistical support for Europe – which is currently under the sole control of one US general. Countering a Russian invasion doesn’t work with a committee of 30 members running the show. Which is where we are now. European Nato has done nothing to prepare for this change, apart from one meeting in Budapest earlier this summer. So, Trump’s security deal is pretty meaningless as it seems likely that the Pentagon will immediately default to Europe to respond to a second Russian invasion – as it has already done since Trump took over. In this case what has Europe offered Zelenskiy to bolster the security deals on offer? So far, nothing. There is starting to be lots of talk from the Europeans that Ukraine will have given up land, but while people like Rubio are clearly talking about security deals, people like Stubb pointedly failed to mention it at all. “Give up land and… [on security, silence].” That means we are still at Macron’s suggestion of a “reassurance force” (force de reassurance) to ensure Ukraine’s security – a band of some 7,000 European troops living in a hut on the Polish border that are mandated to stay as far away from the Russians as possible. The Russians were almost laughing out loud when this was first suggested as it’s so ridiculous and promised to target them first anyway should it come to blows. Half a dozen FAB3000 bombs in an afternoon would probably do the trick. Zelenskiy is looking at all this and has to decide if he is willing to take the gamble: take the US at its word; hope the EU will actually say something sensible about security… today…; and believe any promises Russia makes to get this deal over the line. It’s not very reassuring is it? But that was what Hobson’s choice was: take the horse by the stable door, or take nothing. The one ray of hope in this otherwise gloomy story is there is a chance that Putin will stick to his word if he does the Russian security deal that is part of the package. If peace with Ukraine comes, that clears the way for the Kremlin to do the so-called $12 trillion-worth of deals in the Dmitriev package. That is a ton of money – six times the value of the Russian economy. It’s not guaranteed that Putin will do these deals, but Kirill Dmitriev is serious about them. As the head of the Russia Direct Investment Fund (RDIF) sovereign wealth fund, that is what he does and I have watched him do billions of dollars-worth of deals with the Chinese and Arabs over the last ten years. Ironically, this would give the White House real leverage over the Kremlin, which have dramatically improved relations with both Riyadh and Beijing. Putin’s incentive to do a lot more business with the US also provides him with some leverage over Beijing, which he actually badly needs. And if he is in business with the US, that will provide him with a strong incentive not to rock the boat by invading Ukraine a second time as a second time round US sanctions would actually mean something. But this remains a pipedream for now and doesn’t help Zelenskiy one bit. It is my firm belief that business is a more powerful force to bring countries together than the threat of violence. Surely the lesson of Germany’s transformation from pariah and hated enemy during WWII to the lynch pin of the EU thanks to its prosperity proves the point. And the fact that the EU has been willing to gut its own sanctions on Russia for the sake of the profitability of its own companies on highlights how powerful this force is. This article originally appeared in Editor’s Picks, a free daily email digest of bne IntelliNews’ best stories from the last 24 hours. Sign up for free here. to989.infusionsoft.com/app/f… bneeditor.substack.com/p/hob…
24
6
4
26
6,018
They're calling it the most Israeli tweet of all time
הלילה, במהלך פעילות מבצעית יזומה של כוחות צה"ל לסיכול זריקות אבנים ואירועי טרור בפאתי הכפר בורקא שבחטיבת שומרון, זיהו הכוחות מספר מחבלים שהתכוונו לזרוק אבנים לעבר כביש מהיר בו נוסעים רכבים ישראלים. זאת, במרחב בו יידו אבנים לעבר רכבים ישראלים בעת האחרונה. הכוחות הגיבו בירי לעברם להסרת סכנה, זוהו פגיעות
63
1,961
59
12,659
401,480
Amateur Opinion Haver retweeted
Radio War Nerd EP #649 — Weaponizing Ukraine from 1947-present, feat. Stephen Kinzer @stephenkinzer [link👇]
1
5
13
2,969
Amateur Opinion Haver retweeted
🇫🇷 FLASH - LFI a dévoilé le programme de Jean-Luc Mélenchon pour la présidentielle de 2027. Parmi les propositions : - Autoriser jusqu’à 3 jours d’arrêt maladie autodéclaré, sans consulter de médecin. - Accorder 7 jours de congé après le décès d’un ami. - Porter le SMIC à 1.700€ net par mois, soit une hausse de 220€. - Ramener l’âge de départ à la retraite de 64 à 60 ans, avec une retraite à taux plein après 40 années de cotisation. - Réduire progressivement la durée du travail à 32 heures par semaine. - Instaurer un service écologique obligatoire de 9 mois pour les moins de 25 ans, rémunéré au SMIC. - Faire rembourser les soins à 100% par la Sécurité sociale. - Prendre en charge les séances de psychothérapie des moins de 26 ans. - Fixer un plafond de 12 millions d’euros pour les héritages. - Augmenter les APL de 10% pour aider à payer les loyers. - Bloquer les prix de certains produits essentiels afin de limiter les hausses excessives. - Revaloriser les salaires des fonctionnaires. - Garantir un revenu minimum aux jeunes grâce à une allocation. - Proposer aux étudiants des repas à 1€. - Limiter à 1 pour 20 l’écart entre les rémunérations au sein d’une même entreprise. - Soumettre les aides publiques aux entreprises à des engagements sociaux et écologiques. - Rétablir l’ISF afin d’accroître l’imposition des grandes fortunes. - Mettre en place la taxe Zucman pour taxer davantage les milliardaires. - Répartir l’impôt sur le revenu en 14 tranches pour augmenter la contribution des plus riches. - Engager une sortie progressive du nucléaire. - Atteindre une production d’électricité issue à 100% des énergies renouvelables d’ici 2060. - Interdire les vols entre 23h et 6h. - Suspendre les zones à faibles émissions (ZFE), qui restreignent la circulation des véhicules les plus polluants dans certaines villes. - Passer de la Ve à la VIe République en donnant davantage de pouvoir aux citoyens. - Supprimer le 49.3, qui permet au gouvernement de faire adopter un texte sans vote. - Intensifier la lutte contre les discriminations, notamment au sein de la police. - Reconnaître comme crime d’État le massacre des Algériens du 17 octobre 1961. - Renégocier les traités européens et refuser l’application de certaines règles européennes jugées incompatibles avec le programme. - Quitter progressivement le commandement militaire intégré de l’OTAN. - Soutenir la création d’un État palestinien aux côtés d’Israël.
8,039
34,055
6,295
129,389
22,748,177
Amateur Opinion Haver retweeted
🚨🇪🇸BREAKING — Pedro Sánchez: “I don't know how the Pope voted... but I know what he defends... equality and respect for migrants.”
5
28
1
384
109,763
Amateur Opinion Haver retweeted
"But if we splash acid in his face, he’ll be fucking disfigured, unpresentable. Let him go around looking like that, the ugly bastard. Then he’ll be filming videos for his kids with his fucking face like that. I’d do it with pleasure, I swear.Or we could invite him for a fake event and shut him down in the Dominican Republic, Mexico and Cambodia with 90% certainty. In the Dominican Republic and Mexico, 100%.Or we could just beat the fucking shit out of the cunt, as harshly as possible, leave him a braindead retard." If these are the business partners of a country’s law enforcement agencies, it must be a mafia state. Or maybe mafia is too high-flung a term, and ‘bandit state’ might be more appropriate. Especially if the standard punishment for contractual disagreements is a hammer beating until ‘the legs became rags’. On November 4, the NABU (National Anti-Corruption Bureau of Ukraine) released a 1 hour video titled ‘Operation Carthage: Part II’. In September, the first part of Operation Carthage had revealed how Ukraine’s General Prosecutor Kravchenko curated scam call centres, skimming reasonable amounts of protection money. Though the scam call centres mainly targeted European citizens, the embattled Kravchenko fled to Europe, currently hiding out in Vienna. Now, the NABU has unveiled an even bigger patron of the $1 billion a month scam call center industry. This is the SBU (Security Services of Ukraine), Ukraine’s most powerful ‘law enforcement’ agency. Aside from defrauding naive Europeans, the SBU and its organised crime ‘brothers’ (the term used 74 times in the wiretapped conversations) engaged in drug trafficking, counterfeiting euros, contract killings, extortion through torture, hammer attacks, and plotted acid attacks on journalists. Many of these activities took place in the European Union. The criminals in question stayed out of the limp clutches of the Ukrainian law through constant assistance from the most senior figures of Ukrainian law enforcement. At the centre of this is Egor Burkin, alias ‘the Mexican’, leader of the Khimprom cartel, one of the world’s most powerful drug syndicates. Besides Burkin’s close relationship with the SBU, he also boasts of ties with Russia’s FSB (Federal Security Services). To round out the list of state secrets, whenever Khimprom wanted updates on the status of European investigations into their crimes, their friends in the SBU and Ukraine’s National Police sent them photographs they’d taken straight from a meeting with their trusted European colleagues. Full article eventsinukraine.substack.com…
3
83
8
268
38,577
Amateur Opinion Haver retweeted
Haley Stevens' betrayal is not an anomaly - it is a warning about Corporate Democrats enabling MAGA. Pass it on.
61
607
21
1,979
31,449
Amateur Opinion Haver retweeted
Two things to say about this: 1) I think Hadley is absolutely correct to compare this situation to her getting negative feedback at her work behaving like a hate-deranged monomaniacal psycho. It sounds like much the same thing. And thetimes.com/comment/columni…
9
20
3
250
42,415
باعتقادي، ملك الأردن يدفع بتعزيزات عسكرية كبيرة إلى شمال الأردن، على طول الحدود السورية، ليس لأنه يخطط لغزو الجنوب السوري، وإنما لأنه يمتلك معلومات استخباراتية عن استعداد الإسرائيليين لإطلاق عملية عسكرية كبرى، بالتعاون مع دروز السويداء، بهدف تطهير جنوب سوريا عرقياً، وخاصة منطقة درعا، واحتلالها وضمها إلى إسرائيل، ومن ثم إقامة اتصال جغرافي مباشر بين إسرائيل والدولة الدرزية التي ينوي حكمت الهجري إقامتها في السويداء. وهذا يفسر، باعتقادي، التحركات العسكرية الأردنية الأخيرة. فالأردن يستعد لاحتمال نزوح جماعي هائل من جنوب سوريا باتجاه أراضيه، وقد يصل عدد النازحين إلى مليون إنسان، وهو رقم ضخم جداً بالنسبة لدولة مثل الأردن، التي تعاني أصلاً من أزمات اقتصادية وضغوط سكانية كبيرة. ولذلك فإن الهدف من هذه التعزيزات قد يكون منع تدفق النازحين السوريين إلى الأردن، أو على الأقل تقليل أعداد الذين سيتمكنون من عبور الحدود، وليس الاستعداد لخوض حرب داخل الأراضي السورية. والأخطر من ذلك أن هناك أخباراً نقلها بعض المعارضين السوريين لحكومة أحمد الشرع، تفيد بأن الشرع على علم بالمخطط الإسرائيلي، وأنه بدأ بالفعل بتهيئة حلفائه وأركان نظام الحكم في دمشق لتقبّل الاحتلال الإسرائيلي المرتقب لجنوب سوريا، وعدم الدخول في مواجهة عسكرية لمنعه. وبحسب ما تنقله هذه الأوساط، فإن التبرير الذي يجري التحضير له هو أن الجيش السوري غير قادر حالياً على مواجهة إسرائيل، وأن الدخول في حرب معها سيؤدي إلى خسائر أكبر، ولذلك يجب السماح بحدوث هذا الاحتلال وتجنّب التصعيد العسكري، باعتبار أن خسارة الجنوب السوري ستكون مؤقتة إلى حين إعادة بناء الجيش السوري واستعادة قدرته على المواجهة. وهذا، إن صحّت هذه المعلومات، يعني أن أحمد الشرع قد يكون مستعداً للتخلي عن الجنوب السوري، ولو مؤقتاً، دون خوض مواجهة عسكرية حقيقية مع إسرائيل. والآن نصل إلى الجانب الإسرائيلي من المسألة، وهو برأيي مهم جداً لفهم توقيت هذه العملية المحتملة. الانتخابات الإسرائيلية الحالية أنتجت وضعاً سياسياً معقداً. فتحالف آيزنكوت، الذي وصل إلى 48 مقعداً في الكنيست، لا يمتلك القدرة على تشكيل حكومة إسرائيلية، وفي حال اضطر إلى خوض انتخابات جديدة، فإنني أعتقد أنه سيخسر المزيد من المقاعد، بينما سيحصل نتنياهو على مقاعد إضافية، مما سيعزز موقعه السياسي والانتخابي أكثر فأكثر. ولهذا هناك احتمال أن يتجه نتنياهو إلى استمالة أفيغدور ليبرمان، زعيم حزب «إسرائيل بيتنا»، الذي عُرضت عليه وزارة الدفاع، وإقناعه بالانضمام إلى ائتلاف حكومي معه، لتشكيل حكومة إسرائيلية وتجنيب البلاد انتخابات أخرى. ولكن ما الذي قد يدفع ليبرمان إلى قبول ذلك؟ هنا تحديداً يأتي الجنوب السوري. فليبرمان من أكثر السياسيين الإسرائيليين الذين طالبوا باجتياح الجنوب السوري واحتلاله منذ أكثر من سنتين، ومنحه وزارة الدفاع، إلى جانب حرية تنفيذ العملية العسكرية التي يطالب بها منذ سنوات، قد يكون الثمن السياسي الذي يستعد نتنياهو لدفعه مقابل انضمامه إلى الائتلاف الحكومي. أي أن نتنياهو قد يمنح ليبرمان فرصة تحقيق أحد أهم مشاريعه العسكرية والسياسية، وهو احتلال الجنوب السوري، مقابل مساعدته على تشكيل حكومة إسرائيلية جديدة دون الحاجة إلى انتخابات إضافية. وباعتقادي، فإن هذه التطورات مترابطة، والتحركات العسكرية الأردنية على الحدود السورية ليست منفصلة عما يجري التحضير له داخل إسرائيل، ولا عن الأخبار المتداولة بشأن موقف أحمد الشرع من احتمال اجتياح الجنوب السوري. الأمور بالنسبة لي واضحة جداً، وأعتقد أنه مع بدء الحرب مع إيران، ستطلق إسرائيل عملية عسكرية كبرى في الجنوب السوري، بالتعاون مع دروز السويداء، تستهدف تطهير منطقة درعا من سكانها، ودفع مئات الآلاف منهم باتجاه الأردن، ثم احتلال المنطقة وضمها إلى إسرائيل، وربط الأراضي الإسرائيلية مباشرة بالكيان الدرزي الذي يسعى حكمت الهجري إلى إقامته في السويداء. وهذا هو السيناريو الذي أعتقد أن الأردن يستعد له الآن، وهو أيضاً ما قد يفسر التحركات السياسية الإسرائيلية ومحاولات تشكيل ائتلاف حكومي جديد، بالتزامن مع الاستعدادات للحرب مع إيران.
281
590
75
2,734
520,263
Amateur Opinion Haver retweeted
Replying to @Freedland
Doesn't this provide strong evidence that those who supported the 'Zionism is Racism' motion had a point? You pushed strongly against it a fortnight ago, Jonny. Would you still do so now? If Palestinians were actually even half-equal citizens, Netanyahu would now have packed his bags and we would might have a slightly less awful government
19
118
1
607
11,310
Amateur Opinion Haver retweeted
This is bs US has a total of c300 pac3 left in its stock pile. I makes c600 a year. If it agrees to sell Ukraine 500 then it commits an entire year production exclusively to Ukraine And all of its gulf allies & Israel & for its own war effort in iran desperate for pac3 Not gonna happen
The US Department of State has authorized the sale of 500 Patriot PAC-3 missiles to Ukraine. It looks like that some serious damage control has kicked in, after the disastrous decisions which led to the recent Starlink / Starshield incident.
2
4
18
1,238
Amateur Opinion Haver retweeted
This should be a headline in every major news outlet.
58
2,380
58
3,913
51,920
Amateur Opinion Haver retweeted
The saddest part about the Epstein class toadies is what they do to regular people like you and me. This guy was swept up in Milei's lies. Which isn't his fault. We place the blame squarely on the ruling class and ALL their toadies. Society will not forget what they've done. Ever.
"I've made a huge mistake" - Libertarian Milei voter, pawning both wedding rings to make rent
2
19
87
1,584
Amateur Opinion Haver retweeted
this is so bleak
559
2,038
945
33,903
3,211,230
Amateur Opinion Haver retweeted
I see everywhere the right wins, they push for a mix of aggressive war, looting and destroying the public realm, impunity for corruption and war crimes, roasting the planet with hydrocarbons, deforestation, destroying public education, ethnic supremacy and McCarthyist crackdowns.
3
34
147
3,049
Amateur Opinion Haver retweeted
¡Viva Lula, viva Brasil, viva la igualdad en América Latina! Foto: @nytimes
2,013
14,528
451
67,006
Amateur Opinion Haver retweeted
BREAKING: Brazil’s left-wing President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva won the presidential run-off against right-wing Senator Flavio Bolsonaro on Sunday, the electoral authority said, securing a fourth non-consecutive term. 🟠 LIVE updates: aje.news/vs1cfu
171
1,446
201
5,353
182,278
Amateur Opinion Haver retweeted
As a formerly young girl who’s grandfather thought it was okay to cop a feel when he hugged me when I started growing breasts, it’s deeply concerning the amount of people who think asking for consent before hugging someone takes something away from them.
37
421
9
6,065
46,430
Something disturbing is happening in North Italy. Amidst mass mobilization, high school students are receiving waves of alarming messages on their phones, warning of imminent violence, sexual assaults and chaos in public spaces. Many of these warnings appear to be fabricated. 1/
8
186
20
503
27,781