Ophelia (@orellanin) header
Ophelia (@orellanin) profile picture

:3

New York, USA
Joined April 2019
Photo by Ophelia (@orellanin)Photo by Ophelia (@orellanin)Photo by Ophelia (@orellanin)Photo by Ophelia (@orellanin)Photo by Ophelia (@orellanin)Photo by Ophelia (@orellanin)Photo by Ophelia (@orellanin)Photo by Ophelia (@orellanin)Photo by Ophelia (@orellanin)Photo by Ophelia (@orellanin)
Looks like the concrete details of Blanchard's research are worse than I thought - control group, but the obvious comparison is mysteriously missing - dubiously consensual research, and somehow they injected trans women with testosterone! (cc @tailcalled, am I missing something?)
Replying to @christapeterso
Of all of Blanchard’s autogynephilia papers, I think the supposed phallometric evidence is probably the single most convincing to laypeople. But it is not real pubpeer.com/publications/CAD…
9
1
8
16
21,114
Replying to @Malcolm_Ocean
Oh yeah, if you hadn't found Jessica Pin I should have pointed you to her. She believes that people are socially pressured into vulva surgeries, in a way that sometimes involves hiding their confusion and pressure,
1
1
3
7,915
and believes objective standards used to approve or deny surgeries will help this, and she *says so*. And I've never seen a trans medical gatekeeping advocate spell out their reasoning as explicitly as she does!
1
1
2
7,161
Replying to @alexandrosM
Yudkowsky != people who “agree” with his positions, many of whom are just playing games. I can’t say I think Eliezer is consistently making sense anymore but he’s mostly still honest an interesting - for the most part on most margins he’s trying to make sense.
1
1
6
5,860
Lying is coercion. Suppressing info is coercion. I feel like this frame of analysis deals with horrible nonsense like that easily, does it? How can we popularize this frame further, and will that help?
Replying to @yourfriendpiper
“Instead of calling the cops, Maria flyers his neighborhood, putting his name, his picture, and a description of what he did in plain view. Levine and Meiners find this gesture despicable. “Is her low-tech public shaming any better than the state’s sex offender registry?””
1
3
5,318
(Or for that matter, parallels in the context of notions like "our group of ten people meditating is by itself an act of healing the world", which have some truth to them but also conveniently keep any change pretty localized and non-threatening.)
1
1
2
24
4,578
Can anyone tell me about historical Buddhist branches or sects that were more "ambitious" in a way that threatens the status quo, and what happened to them?
Replying to @RomeoStevens76
Do you happen to have any names/search terms? I vaguely remembered seeing some mentions of this but couldn't recall any specifics.
2
3
16
34,677
I'm still mad about this exchange. Treating transition rates as a function of (present) social acceptance denies the foresighted strategy of transitioning because one anticipates us winning our fight ("social acceptance" is imo a poor abstraction/proxy for winning),
Replying to @orellanin @gnrtvty
> exact rate of social acceptance How do you know the exact rate of social acceptance over time? Btw I'd disagree if we make this about local social acceptance, I expect trans identification to rise in places where trans acceptance goes down, as long as those places have enough
1
4
6,092
and denies the collective strategy of making this prediction self-fulfil. Claiming "ideology" has no part is either a language game of defining "ideology" to mean people being wrong, or it denies our strategizing.
1
4
2,836
This is important because denying (falsely claiming the nonexistence of) our agency denies (thwarts) our agency.
1
2,544
one thing I've always been confused about is why does every country in the world have mostly the same immigration system? why are all the categories roughly the same? did america force them to do it? they couldn't have just converged on this right?
This Post is from a suspended account. Learn more
21
7
4
186
70,630
Ophelia retweeted
even more egregious, imo, is calling the compressed text "shoggoth tongue" or similar it doesn't unmask itself when you ask it to compress text! it's putting another mask on! it does this! (credit @ApriiSR)
2
11
156
6,353
Replying to @pawnofcthulhu
@pawnofcthulhu's proof looked v confusing to me so here's it translated into a form that makes sense to mere mortals like me (with a lot of details filled in). To start, let's do this for finite sets of Wang tiles (squares in a grid with matching rules) and generalize later.
You’re unable to view this Post because this account owner limits who can view their Posts. Learn more
1
1
2
2,909
Why do we need this multistep algorithm? I don't know, but wasn't able to prove this in a more direct way. Do we really need transfinite induction? I also don't know. The proof is general enough to also apply to Turing machines (ie, if a Turing machine never halts
1
1
1,943
and never repeats itself, there must be uncountably many possible sequences of states the Turing machine goes through), so maybe someone can make up some really messed up example that requires transfinitely many steps, but I haven't thought of one.
1
1,872