Paul Sullivan (@pencilprimate) header
Paul Sullivan (@pencilprimate) profile picture

Production designer for Maya and the Three on Netflix. Art Director for Thelma the Unicorn. Production Designer and Art Director for The Book of Life.

Los Angeles
Joined April 2009
Photo by Paul Sullivan (@pencilprimate)Photo by Paul Sullivan (@pencilprimate)Photo by Paul Sullivan (@pencilprimate)Photo by Paul Sullivan (@pencilprimate)Photo by Paul Sullivan (@pencilprimate)Photo by Paul Sullivan (@pencilprimate)
I Art directed this character while working with my good pal @BenShaferArt He’s finally here!
6
330
Paul Sullivan retweeted
The US Copyright Office on AI πŸ”₯πŸ”₯πŸ”₯ "Making commercial use of vast troves of copyrighted works to produce expressive content that competes with them in existing markets, especially where this is accomplished through illegal access, goes beyond established fair use boundaries."
🚨 BREAKING: The U.S. Copyright Office SIDES WITH CONTENT CREATORS, concluding in its latest report that the fair use exception likely does not apply to commercial AI training. From the report's conclusion: "Various uses of copyrighted works in AI training are likely to be transformative. The extent to which they are fair, however, will depend on what works were used, from what source, for what purpose, and with what controls on the outputsβ€”all of which can affect the market. When a model is deployed for purposes such as analysis or researchβ€”the types of uses that are critical to international competitivenessβ€”the outputs are unlikely to substitute for expressive works used in training. But making commercial use of vast troves of copyrighted works to produce expressive content that competes with them in existing markets, especially where this is accomplished through illegal access, goes beyond established fair use boundaries. For those uses that may not qualify as fair, practical solutions are critical to support ongoing innovation. Licensing agreements for AI training, both individual and collective, are fast emerging in certain sectors, although their availability so far is inconsistent. Given the robust growth of voluntary licensing, as well as the lack of stakeholder support for any statutory change, the Office believes government intervention would be premature at this time. Rather, licensing markets should continue to develop, extending early successes into more contexts as soon as possible. In those areas where remaining gaps are unlikely to be filled, alternative approaches such as extended collective licensing should be considered to address any market failure. In our view, American leadership in the AI space would best be furthered by supporting both of these world-class industries that contribute so much to our economic and cultural advancement. Effective licensing options can ensure that innovation continues to advance without undermining intellectual property rights. These groundbreaking technologies should benefit both the innovators who design them and the creators whose content fuels them, as well as the general public." - My comments: Although this is a pre-publication version, the report states: "The Office is releasing this pre-publication version of Part 3 in response to congressional inquiries and expressions of interest from stakeholders. A final version will be published in the near future, without any substantive changes expected in the analysis or conclusions." It's GREAT NEWS for content creators/copyright holders, especially as the U.S. Copyright Office's opinion will likely influence present and future AI copyright lawsuits in the U.S. As I've written before, licensing deals seem to be the future of AI training. πŸ‘‰ Read the full report in the link below. πŸ‘‰ NEVER MISS my updates and analyses: join my newsletter's 61,000+ subscribers using the link below.
40
958
27
3,970
232,228
Paul Sullivan retweeted
Animation finally getting some acknowledgment from the MSM!
7
105
5
504
38,126
Paul Sullivan retweeted
1/3 HUGE update on our case! We won BIG as the judge allowed ALL of our claims on copyright infringement to proceed and we historically move on The Lanham Act (trade dress) claims! We can now proceed onto discovery! The implications on this order is huge on so many fronts!
26
2,274
317
9,082
1,608,359
Happy Friday to those who celebrate ❀️
68
126
19
1,115
109,441
a mini thread of artwork done for #thelmatheunicorn from @lynnvwang + team
1
1
2
582
a few prop+concept ideas i pitched. The 'Huge Sellout Records' building is variations based on a great design from AD @pencilprimate
1
1
2
400
THELMA THE UNICORN adds sparkle to substance. Directed by Jared Hess and @lynnvwang Review by @MNMillerFilmRev insessionfilm.com/movie-revi…
5
2
6
881
β€˜THE SUPER MARIO BROS MOVIE’ earns the biggest opening for an animated film ever. Read our review: https://teapawt.net/t.co/4Bxh7jIQLd
432
3,528
1,510
50,611
9,924,741
Paul Sullivan retweeted
Check it out, new #SuperMarioMovie trailer!! This whole epic fight was storyboarded by the incredibly talented Jeff Mednikow ⭐️
11
73
619
35,792
Warp into the new official #SuperMarioMovie trailer. ❀️ this tweet to Power-Up with exclusive updates from The Super Mario Bros. Movie
2,969
33,260
13,218
170,601
Paul Sullivan retweeted
The official teaser trailer for The Super Mario Bros. Movie is here! #SuperMarioMovie
644
7,841
3,966
35,654
Join us October 6th at 4pm ET for the teaser trailer premiere of Nintendo & Illumination’s upcoming Super Mario Bros. film, releasing April 7, 2023.
1,382
11,417
7,507
57,239
Ohio State Senator using a Zoom background of his home office while driving, debating a bill for harsher penalties for distracted driving. These are our elected leaders πŸ˜‚
343
2,115
435
11,914
Good morning. Don’t take yourself too seriously. We all end up dead. Let’s get after it relentlessly today πŸ”₯
123
164
20
2,082