Instinct was the “aha”/openclaw moment for non-AI pilled normal people. Product can get things done. Computer use allowed everyday consumer use cases possible.
The next level is not if personal assistants can do the job of a human concierge. Its about how better can they do it.
They need to capitalise on the much higher bandwidth than humans and theoritically infinite memory.
Instinct went viral almost overnight, and I have been trying to understand what actually made that happen. The more I dug into it, the more interesting it became because the real story seems to have started well before Noah ever publicly launched the product
I found this incredible drill-down by Brace where they analysed 5,000+ posts and 56,000+ relationship ties around the launch, and then I started going through the early posts, who was talking, who already had access, who knew whom, what people were actually saying and when Noah finally entered the conversation. There is a lot here for anyone who cares about growth and distribution
The first big public spark seems to be Elliot Comite on Aug 13. He had barely ~2K followers and posted that Instinct was his most “holy shit” AI product since Wispr Flow. Brace captured the post around 2.5 hours later and it had 1 like, 0 reposts and 2 replies. It was basically going nowhere. Over the next day it somehow starts moving and eventually ends up around 700K views
What makes that fascinating is that Instinct had already been quietly sitting inside a very specific network for months. Noah has spoken about starting with roughly 200 friends/family and giving every user 5 invites. Once Elliot posts, you start seeing people around the product who already knew it or were already using it. Sarah Guo was an investor and user. Pranav Reddy had apparently been spending almost every other Friday at the Instinct office. Jason Shuman says this is as close to THE personal AI assistant as he has seen. Sari Azout starts sharing everything it is doing for her family. A few days later Sheel Mohnot says he has sent it 677 messages in five days and calls it “OpenClaw for normal people.”
What I love is that none of these people are telling the same story. Elliot is saying holy shit. Sarah is talking about trusting it enough to transact. Sari is talking about getting hours of her life back. Sheel is talking about Comcast negotiations, doctors, wedding vendors and 677 messages. Then the privacy debate starts and suddenly people are asking how much autonomy they are actually willing to give an AI
So instead of the internet seeing 20 people repeating the same launch message, it starts seeing 20 different pieces of evidence that something unusual is happening. That is a very different kind of distribution
Most launches are still thought about as build product, announce it, activate creators/influencers and then amplify. Instinct seems to have almost inverted that. Put the product in the hands of the right small group much earlier, let them use it long enough to have real stories, let each of them pull only a few more people in, let those people create their own stories, and allow curiosity and access to compound before the founder even properly enters the conversation.
By the time Noah publicly introduces himself on Aug 26, people have already spent almost two weeks asking what Instinct is, how to get access and whether it is as good as everyone says. In that sense, the market had already done a lot of the launching for him.
I don’t think the lesson is that Instinct scripted virality. There isn’t enough evidence for that, and some of the people involved have described parts of it as accidental or organic. The more interesting thing is that they seem to have created the conditions in which virality had a very good chance of happening.
The 5 invites are a big part of that. Sari posts about the product, gets 100+ DMs asking for access and only has 5 invites. Someone gets one, uses Instinct, has their own crazy experience, posts it, and now they have 5 invites of their own. The product experience feeds distribution, and distribution feeds the next product experience.
The more I look at this, the more I think we massively underthink the first 100-200 users of a product. Who those people are, who they know, how deeply they use the product before launch, whether the product naturally gives them something worth talking about, and how access moves from one person to another can matter far more than a beautifully orchestrated launch day.
So maybe the better question is not “who can we get to post about us at launch?”
It is: who are the first 100-200 people we want using this before the world even knows it exists?
If you get that graph right, give them something remarkable enough to talk about and make it easy for them to pull the next person in, you may reach launch day and realise the market has already started the launch for you.
Also linking the Brace analysis in the comments because the amount of work they have done to map the propagation is insane and absolutely worth reading
Quarq retweeted
anthropic's backers are reportedly charging a 3–5% fee on top of the IPO price. even a $1.4T company has a delivery fee.
should've asked @askbro_io
As agent traffic increases, many businesses that rely on ads and monetise user clicks are going to die.
I don't think ads are going away, rather, they're going to change.
Running ads is renting real estate on the app's screen. This real estate is capped by the bandwidth of the human eye (which can only see about 10 products at once).
Whereas agents can explore 1000s of products before curating 3 suggestions for the human.
Ads in the future will be about being part of those 1000 products the agent explores.
Move over, B2B and B2C - the B2A economy is here
Agents are the primary users of the Internet, and soon will be the primary customers for every product
Our thesis @a16z on the massive opportunity here 👇 (cc @venturetwins)
most consumers are not really interested in email management, note-taking, or reminders
shopping and travel are the use-cases they're interested it
and a chat interface is not the right one for those
Quarq retweeted
production budget for @askbro_io's latest ad:
moustache: ₹40
balaclava: borrowed
handcuffs: a gamcha
cop: unpaid (@hrsh_ok)
criminal: unpaid, still tied up
meta says 10M+ people set up muse in a month and a half, and the #1 use case is shopping. more than a quarter of users buy through it, average purchase over $200. stripe had to raise credit limits in week one.
jefferies found about a third of the sites it tested block muse. the agent is ready, the websites aren't
"walmart's returns apply even when the agent doesn't act as intended." people will let agents shop wherever mistakes are cheapest to undo
As Amazon blocks AI agents from shopping on its site, Walmart is taking the opposite approach, introducing new technology that lets AI agents make purchases on customers' behalf, with controls over spending and transaction approvals.
spr.ly/6019BHXyoW
the new checkout agent we're building at @askbro_io doesn't pay on its own. it runs the flow, and when it hits payment or gets stuck it pings you: pay now, take over, or answer its question.
people don't want an agent spending without asking. they also don't want to sit and watch it work
the number from this i keep coming back to: messages per user on @askbro_io dropped 25%+ the same week cart adds almost doubled.
for a consumer agent, sometimes a long conversation means it failed
US banks say they can't tell whether an AI agent in your account was sent by you or went rogue. so morgan stanley, jpmorgan and citi are just blocking them.
india might have dodged most of this by accident. an agent can fill your cart, it can't type your UPI pin. every payment still needs you for one tap.
the US is now trying to build that layer after the fact
"instamart losses peaked in the september quarter"
said in the same breath as stepping up investment. both can only be true if orders per dark store grow faster than the store count
Swiggy Ltd expects its quick-commerce business, Instamart, to have peaked its losses in the September quarter, as it steps up investments to accelerate growth amid intensifying competition.
(@sowmyaram_ reports)
livemint.com/companies/compa…
every service in india still wants you to download its app. an agent that can open those apps for you turns most of them into a fulfillment layer.
that's where we're taking @askbro_io next
phoneuse is racking real iphones with real SIMs, tapped by a physical stylus, so AI agents can use apps that block emulators. their own example is "reorder my usual from zomato".
in india a lot of what people want done lives in apps, not websites. the agents that work here will need both
agents just find what humans left lying around, way faster than humans do
The agents got in through credentials and connection settings left exposed in app configurations, public code repositories, and overly permissive cloud roles.
spr.ly/6016BHMGon



















