John Marshall (@rps333) header
John Marshall (@rps333) profile picture

Maps, Not Words

Ottawa, Ontario
Joined August 2011
Photo by John Marshall (@rps333)Photo by John Marshall (@rps333)Photo by John Marshall (@rps333)Photo by John Marshall (@rps333)Photo by John Marshall (@rps333)Photo by John Marshall (@rps333)Photo by John Marshall (@rps333)Photo by John Marshall (@rps333)Photo by John Marshall (@rps333)Photo by John Marshall (@rps333)
As Immigration Minister, I once spent a couple of hours observing interactions behind the CBSA secondary screening desk at YYC. It was immediately following the disenbarkment of an Aero Mexico flight, at a time (2009) when we were being flooded by Mexican asylum claims. I’ll never forget a father appearing at the desk with his wife and 3 kids, as he handed the CBSA officer a prepared statement in English (undoubtedly furnished by someone for a fee,) in which he claimed to be fleeing persecution as a gay Mexican. About 40 asylum claims were made off that one flight. The most common claim was on the grounds of sexual orientation. I went back to Ottawa, and immediately imposed a visa requirement on Mexican nationals. That resulted in an immediate 90% decline in Mexican asylum claims. Officials estimated that saved Canadian taxpayers $400 million annually in legal, social, health care and related costs. In 2016, the Trudeau government ignored warnings from officials and lifted the Mexican visa requirement. This resulted in an even bigger wave, peaking at 24,000 claims in 2023. In total, 60,000 Mexican claims were made under the Trudeau government before they finally admitted their huge mistake, and re-imposed a visa. Officials estimate that each claim represented an annual cost of ~$50,000. So on an annualized basis, a total cost of $3 billion. Most people haven’t event begun to grasp the mind blowing incompetence of the Trudeau government on immigration.
This is far more common than most realize. A LOT of fake asylum claimants know that the magic word to get into Canada is "I'm gay."
143
408
27
2,829
114,330
John Marshall retweeted
Canada's growing surplus of men in their 20s driven by immigration mostly from India deserves attention. What happens when a country has significantly more young men than women? India and China offer some useful lessons. My latest. thefp.com/p/this-week-in-can…
28
59
5
320
9,848
What this guy fails to realize is that if you invite 100 people to a dinner but only plan enough meals for 20, that someone pointing this out isn't "anti-guest".
Replying to @priorconfirmed
Well @MikePMoffatt has been anti-immigrant since at least 2024, blaming Canada's lack of housing and healthcare investments for decades on immigrants. I think he doesnt even realize the kind of things he says have been used to justify lynching of black men in the Jim Crow South.
29
90
4
902
14,818
Canada's immigration and non-permanent resident programs have prioritized bringing men, rather than women, to the country, leading to significant population imbalances. In 2015, there were 7,000 more 25-44 yo men than women. By 2025, that gap had grown to nearly 300,000.
79
203
48
969
57,208
John Marshall retweeted
Captured by Capella's newest satellite (C-21) this Colorized Subaperture Image (CSI) reveals destroyed aircraft at Khartoum International Airport in Sudan. See how SAR supports damage assessment and intelligence missions: hubs.la/Q04DPkG-0
12
1
54
3,793
John Marshall retweeted
Replying to @DanAlbas
A) The clawback thresholds are far too high. Why should young people fund a full OAS payment for snowbirds in FL who already have an annual income of $95k ($190k for a couple)? B) It is not up to the taxpayer to backstop the desired lifestyle of people who didn’t plan well enough for their retirement. Should we keep seniors out of poverty? Yes. Should we shovel taxpayer money into the accounts of people who already own home(s) and bring home more than enough to cover expenses? Absolutely not. It’s insulting to every young person just asking for governments to restore the social contract.
7
5
44
772
My growing radical proposal is we kill OAS entirely. The full program gone. In return we double GIS (~$11,000 extra per recipient). This would give genuinely poor seniors $2000 extra dollars per year AND save something like $50-60 billion dollars. I would then recycle some of this money in 3 ways: 1) increase CCB clawback thresholds from 38/83 to 45/90 2) cut PIT rates (specific numbers require a more detailed plan) 3) modestly increase defence spending Then we keep 1/2 the savings to reduce the deficit.
We spend an insane amount of money on OAS, sending welfare cheques to retired millionaires. We could cut OAS, boost GIS to seniors actually experiencing poverty, and still save tens of billions of dollars.
11
13
111
2,806
No province—not Quebec, not New Brunswick—should receive a penny of federal transfer payments if it refuses to develop its natural resources. New Brunswick’s refusal to develop its massive shale gas reserves while relying on federal transfers (largely funded by Alberta and Saskatchewan’s resource revenues) for 40% of its provincial budget is pure hypocrisy.
87
361
19
1,686
56,782
John Marshall retweeted
I live in Ontario. I also have some advice, to be taken with a grain of salt. Whatever you’re going to do, do it quickly and decisively. You have 4 years to show what you can do. Rip the bandaid off now, you have a massive majority. DRIPA, SOGI, tanker ban, whatever. Get it over with now. Leftists have short attention spans and they’ll forget all about it in 3 years. Best wishes, B.C. Now is your chance.
Congratulations to Jennifer Whiteside on being named Interim Leader of the BC NDP. I sat across the floor from her for a long time and she is a serious person who works hard for the people she represents. A good opposition makes for a better government, and I expect her to hold us to account while we get to work delivering what we promised British Columbians.
32
88
3
710
14,183
John Marshall retweeted
More importantly, the number of asylum claimants in Canada is absolutely off the chain. Just five years ago, it was 160,000. It's now *500,000.* And these are the worst kinds of immigrants: The ones most likely to do crime, be on welfare, to hold extremist beliefs.
I was actually really surprised to discover that the number of foreign workers in Canada is *higher than it's ever been.* All Carney has done is slow the intake (and even that's still pretty high).
42
269
6
1,319
17,380
John Marshall retweeted
But can we agree that promoting LNG and mineral exports out of a mostly ice-covered port in Churchill using icebreaking, is a lot riskier than sending double hulled oil tankers out of Prince Rupert, which can already accommodate shipping containers that carry 50,000 barrels/8000 m3 of petroleum fuel in their own tanks? Can we agree there are different standards being applied for political, rather than scientific or technical, reasons?
96
277
16
1,356
30,864
John Marshall retweeted
Progressives blaming Eby’s defeat in the election timing are totally missing the point. The whole purpose of the early election was to try to overcome the government’s unpopularity rooted in its poor outcomes. The real problem was the cumulative cost of Eby’s ideological agenda. His government was the last holdout of the failures of Trudeauian progressivism: a subordination of economic growth in favour of deficit financed welfare spending, a dogmatic commitment to climate change and its anti-development effects, excessive identity politics and an overly self critical posture towards Canadian history, and its radical experiment with the harm reduction model. Election timing and campaign choices didn’t defeat the Eby government. A broad cross-section of British Columbians—from rural parts of the province to downtown Vancouver—rejected it based on the self-evident failure of its ideas.
69
224
28
1,266
63,282
John Marshall retweeted
“You can’t build a provincial economy on whale watching and coffee shops.” We need to be a province that builds, makes and creates. We need a provincial industrial strategy and we need to get serious about the loss of industrial land to real estate speculation. Once industrial land is converted to other uses, it is extraordinarily difficult, if not impossible, to get it back. And without that land, where exactly do we expect the next generation of manufacturers, skilled tradespeople and industrial employers to go? This is one of the most consequential challenges we face in British Columbia, with a lot of damage already done. I hope the new government makes it an urgent priority.
Do you have the video clip where you said "You cannot build an economy on whale watching and coffee shops"? Want to use it for this week's podcast episode. I suspect it'll go viral LOL 📈
90
280
34
1,886
91,698
John Marshall retweeted
Cut fucking taxes and let the market decide instead of you, who know absolutely nothing about the venture capital sector.
109
298
16
2,250
45,269
John Marshall retweeted
I read the Hansard from when the UK House of Lords read through the British North America Act. One of their only objections was to point out how dumb the Senate idea was. To which the colonial secretary told them to shut up because this was what Canadians had worked out.
Replying to @TristinHopper
The whole Senate arrangement in Canada is organized political corruption, and a finger in the face of Canadians that support it. Membership by appointment by PM is an invitation to abuse, JTrudeau set a new low for that, among other things.
9
16
120
3,373
I’ve increasingly come to worry about the rise of “judicial nihilism” (for lack of a better term) in Canada. We have a justice system that spends enormous energy considering the personal circumstances of offenders, their rights, identities, mental health, and prospects for rehabilitation. Yet it seems unconcerned with the victims whose lives have been destroyed, or the public that must live with the consequences when dangerous individuals repeatedly reoffend. I think we need to take judicial reform more seriously, rather than dismissing concerns about overreach and malfeasance as conservative fearmongering. The more I look at recent cases (many highlighted by @sarkonakj) the more concerned I become that our institutions are losing sight of some basic moral values in justice. I’ve been thinking about the principles that should guide us to a more liberal, rules-based approach to criminal justice (I’ll admit that this is hardly new thinking, but I can’t remember the last time I’ve seen them laid out): 1. Justice should begin with victims, whose suffering should never become secondary to the circumstances of offenders. 2. Protecting the public from dangerous individuals must be a central responsibility of sentencing, and we should lean towards caution. 3. Punishment must be a meaningful deterrent and reflect the gravity of crimes. Some crimes warrant permanent imprisonment (if not capital punishment). Some crimes are so heinous that the mere prospect of rehabilitation should not be considered. 4. Repeat offenders should face dramatically greater consequences, including long-term incarceration or asylum to protect society. Nobody with dozens of separate criminal convictions should be roaming freely. 5. Mental illness should determine treatment and facility type, not reduce punishment. The bar for criminal non-responsibility should also be much higher than it is today. 6. Sentencing must apply to those convicted equally, based on actions and responsibility, not race, religion, cultural identity, immigration status etc. The rule of law should be non-discriminatory, the right time to address the “root causes” of crime and pursue social justice is before crime is committed. 7. Parliament needs to figure out how to reclaim its authority, with courts exercising much greater restraint in constitutional interpretations. 8. Judicial “independence” must be balanced with meaningful accountability for serious failures and overreach. The judiciary is not supreme to legislature. I worry that too many political leaders have become uncomfortable defending the very concepts of order, punishment and personal responsibility, as though doing so is somehow incompatible with liberal moral values. They aren’t. A liberal democracy has two fundamental obligations. To protect people from the arbitrary exercise of government power, and to protect them from the violence and predation of others. We cannot fulfill one by neglecting the other. They are together the necessary preconditions for liberty. When the public sees rulings that seem fundamentally disconnected from shared expectations of right and wrong, it erodes trust in the system. Order and public safety are necessary conditions for freedom. The freedom to walk down the street, take public transit, operate a business or simply live peacefully in your own home means little if the government cannot protect you from disorder, violence and criminality. It’s often those with the fewest resources who suffer most when that protection fails. If we want Canadians to have faith in the rule of law, they need to believe that it applies equally, that serious wrongdoing carries serious consequences, that dangerous people will not repeatedly be allowed to victimize others, and that the system will not be careless with the lives and suffering of victims.
“Arnold and Joanne De Jong were in their seventies when three men they had once hired to clean their gutters came back to their Abbotsford home in the middle of the night in May 2022 and murdered them. Arnold was suffocated, his head wrapped in duct tape. Joanne was beaten, and her throat was cut. The killers left with the couple’s cheques, credit cards, and a power washer. The trial judge found they planned to murder the De Jongs because they knew they would be recognized in the course of their robbery. On Monday, the De Jongs’ daughters came to court expecting to watch those men receive justice in sentencing. Instead, they heard the judge declare that the law denying multiple murderers any chance at early parole violates the Charter’s ban on cruel and unusual punishment. The cruelty, apparently, lies in making men who suffocated an old man with duct tape and bludgeoned his wife wait 25 years before asking to go free. Sentencing has been pushed to 2027. Canadians settled this question a long time ago, and we settled it twice. A Liberal government in 1997 and a Conservative government in 2011, elected by different voters with different priorities, each concluded that people who kill more than once should be offered no early exit. That is what a free people does with its moral convictions: it argues about them, elects representatives who share them, and writes them into law. One judge has now informed Canadians that the answer they reached together, through two elected Parliaments, isn’t allowed.” - - - I don’t think there is any issue I’ve become more conservative on more than the sickness in our judicial system, even as I’ve become more left than I used to on economics/role of government. It feels like several times a week there is another story that represents a deep miscarriage of justice, ill consideration for victims, or neglects society’s need for and equally applied rule of law or real punishment as a deterrence to crime. I fear there is not enough recourse to judges who reinterpret the constitution to ideological ends better left to the actual legislature. This story honestly makes me sick and it saddens me that there are no practical accountability options for the judiciary in a case like this. @stevestaley thehub.ca/2026/10/21/how-can…
97
293
38
1,467
80,234
John Marshall retweeted
When you have unofficial public policy positions that housing prices are never allowed to go down and seniors’ entitlements are never allowed to be reformed you’re basically just buying time until the whole thing goes up in flames.
12
35
2
250
10,953
Replying to @acoyne
Really? You don't think adding 30,000 renters to a metro of 600,000 people in a single year might impact monthly rents? Is housing somehow immune to the laws of supply and demand?
57
89
8
1,777
25,320
John Marshall retweeted
Anti-Israel website ‘The Canada Files’ registers with Foreign Influence Commissioner after accepting sponsored content from #China. Registration is mandatory for any media “acting at the direction of, for the benefit of or in association with a foreign entity.” blacklocks.ca/china-backed-a… @Safety_Canada #cdnpoli
13
112
18
221
19,999