Ryan O'Rourke (@rtorourke) header
Ryan O'Rourke (@rtorourke) profile picture

Full-time indie webmaster since 2016. Musings on: SEO, web design, UX/UI, coding, mindset.

Canada
Joined September 2011
Photo by Ryan O'Rourke (@rtorourke)Photo by Ryan O'Rourke (@rtorourke)Photo by Ryan O'Rourke (@rtorourke)Photo by Ryan O'Rourke (@rtorourke)Photo by Ryan O'Rourke (@rtorourke)Photo by Ryan O'Rourke (@rtorourke)Photo by Ryan O'Rourke (@rtorourke)Photo by Ryan O'Rourke (@rtorourke)Photo by Ryan O'Rourke (@rtorourke)Photo by Ryan O'Rourke (@rtorourke)
Ryan O'Rourke retweeted
A message to HCU-impacted sites: There will be many posts today and the rest of the week giving you the heads-up on the impending Google Search Core Update. Amongst those posts will be implications that there may be "recoveries or partial." Many professionals will claim that this Core Update is desperately needed despite previous updates following the same trend of decimating independent publishers. Please do not wait for these Core Updates. Save yourself the pain. If you have any other skills, ventures, or career paths, pursue them. Do not fall for the SEO trap peddled by professionals advocating for science closer to unproven witchcraft. These SEOs will share many graphs and examples highlighting recoveries. Be careful with the data you receive. 100% of the time, these are websites not explicitly targeted by the September 2023 HCU. They will use recoveries from the March 2024 Update as comparison points. It's irrelevant. Ask yourself this: If Google can fix many things in search in a short period of time, then why have they not fixed the fundamental error in search impacting legitimate HCU sites? Why has the Site Reputation Abuse algorithm not been rolled out? Seriously, ask yourself why. Danny Sullivan was flagrantly expecting it to be followed by manual penalties—why wasn't it? Why did the Reddit Deal lead to the biggest organic growth in search history? Why did Reddit block all search engines apart from Google? Why has the Google Autocomplete feature suddenly been questioned concerning politics? Once you have the answers, ask yourself why on earth Google would care about your HCU-impacted site. I'm saying all this because I've seen far too much pain and livelihoods lost due to hope. Do not let this organization lie to you and control your life.
14
9
5
101
11,764
If you’re still pinning your hopes on blogging returning to “normal,” please read this and follow Nate’s advice. 🙏🏻
Every time I tweet about the HCU it goes viral, but I wish more of y’all would listen to the part where I say you should be building elsewhere and not waiting for Google to change its mind about your sites I don’t have the answers. And I know it’s hard. But I do think the Internet is moving towards a future where you needs to sell a product or service to survive. Or at least build a passionate community. That’s hard and you need to get started on it soon! As one example, we are building to sell tours in Puerto Rico. To do that, our local writer is now starting a certification course — funded by us —to become officially licensed as a guide. Best case scenario we won’t be ready to roll until 2025!* Obviously that’s an extreme example, but it takes time no what you do — especially if you are coming at it from a content creator background. Get started now! Stop wasting your time just waiting on Google. Even if the HCU reverses, the traffic won’t look the same because of AI Overviews, intent shifts, from sources around the web, and the many many ads now above you. If you’re still alive and kicking, use your energy to focus on building something else! Think what you have to offer the world and figure out a way to charge people for it. *that was just an example btw. I’m not building in public. Wasn’t an invitation to analyze my site to death either.
2
1
361
Ryan O'Rourke retweeted
💬 Don't speak Googlish? Let me translate Google's latest blog post, titled "AI Overviews: About last week" What Google said: "AI Overviews as a jumping off point to visit web content, and we see that the clicks to webpages are higher quality — people are more likely to stay on that page, because we’ve done a better job of finding the right info and helpful webpages for them." What Google meant: "AI Overviews discourage users from clicking through, so only the most motivated segment of users will visit your site now. We'll keep all the other clicks and let our AI and ads do the answering. Oh, and you're just gonna have to trust us because we won't be sharing any data on that. Thanks for letting us plagiarize your content!"
8
6
2
59
5,437
.@searchliaison the HCU feels more and more like the ML broke and it cannot be fixed. If this is true and you could confirm it, it would sure save a lot of sites a lot time and money lost. This is the sitewide classifier.
1
4
281
Well, that didn’t take long 😂
You’re unable to view this Post because this account owner limits who can view their Posts. Learn more
1
104
🔥 Where is @TheJusticeDept? For non-SEOS let me explain. @Google stole from content creators to train their AI. The created AI Overviews to summarize websites thus STEALING the click. Now they will put ads around the summaries. This is MONOPOLISTIC! searchenginejournal.com/goog…
8
12
63
2,693
If you’re a content creator or want to support them right now, this is the easiest thing you can do👇 (Bonus points for using Safari or Firefox instead)
What #Google is doing -- killing the sites they plagiarized to create its AI responses, and effectively forcing users to receive AI results -- is reprehensible. I switched to @DuckDuckGo as my default search. Here's how:
1
1
9
1,208
Wow. SGE is staging a wonderful debut 😂
This quoted post is unavailable.
79
Google: Mass produced content is spam. Also Google: Here’s an unedited and unsupervised AI-generated answer for your query that we synthesised from publishers without their express permission to do so, some of whom we think are spam and have demoted in search results.
9
73
4
352
46,853
When will someone step in to stop all this thievery?
Don't believe Google's lies about how SGE works - SGE just steals content & summarizes it! 🤥 LIE: At #GoogleIO they just said that SGE "fanned out and combed the web to find relevant insights from articles, forums, videos, and more - and it stitched all of this together in my AI overview." 👇 TRUTH: Really, SGE just stole this single article & summarized/condensed it - so readers won't have to click out to the actual website.
1
8
718
Ryan O'Rourke retweeted
It’s a brutal time to be a travel blogger right now. Google has basically nuked our corner of the internet, replacing our helpful, in-depth content with lean content from big sites and mass-produced AI spam from new sites. The SERPs are a shit show right now, and all the established bloggers who I’ve got to know over the past 7 years are nowhere to be found. This should really be a bigger story. Even if you’re currently in Google’s favor, you may also want to speak up…because they are coming for you next. As a corporate entity, Google’s goal is to achieve maximum profits. Google doesn’t have emotions, and it doesn’t know ethics or morals. Sure, there are good people who work there, but they are being incentivized to cut out the “middleman” and reap bigger bonuses $$. More public pressure is needed for them to roll back the HCU site-wide classifier that has decimated so many great websites. Anyways, thanks Google for the wake up call to focus on other platforms that aren’t trying to wipe out creators. If you want some unique travel content that you won’t find on the big travel websites, follow my adventures on Insta: instagram.com/global.viewpoi…
16
21
4
130
19,687
Unless these sites are pure spam, there’s no justification for drops like this. This isn’t just wiping out niche sites, it’s destroying families’ lives (and by extension communities) and transfers millions in revenue from the pockets of small indie creators to corporate coffers.
Well hello again Google Land! For the heck of it, I decided to run the visibility numbers for the 380 sites I'm tracking closely that were heavily impacted by the September HCU(X). I wanted to do that since we are almost two weeks out from the end of the March core update. Like I expected, none have bounced back at all. That's not shocking since the update is done... but I do believe we could see changes after Google reviews the form submissions. I shared about that earlier and in my latest post about the helpful content system being baked into core. But, I also just ran the visibility numbers comparing pre-September HCU(X) visibility to today. 270 of the 380 sites I'm tracking have dropped 90%+ since then (with many 95%+). Again, I don't believe all of those sites should recover, but some definitely should recover to an extent. Something seems very off with the systems assessing the helpfulness of content within Google's core ranking system. Let's see if things change after those submissions are reviewed...
174
Ryan O'Rourke retweeted
Replying to @effthealgorithm
I have been angry for too long. Nothing changes. I am going to be on the phone next week calling every elected official I can get a hold of to take more meaningful action against what Google is doing to publishers, creators, and small businesses. I work every day. I have had three people whom I loved more than anyone in the world die in the past two years. I haven't even had the opportunity to give myself enough time to grieve because @Google has devastated my business in order to reward absolute f-ing garbage and theft. I'll never give up on my business or its mission, ever. Google can lie and lie and lie and gaslight and collect their fat paychecks as they lie and gaslight more. Their greed knows no end. I will do my part to stop them from destroying the internet. @sundarpichai @googlesearchc @TheJusticeDept @sbagov @ftc @linakhanFTC #antitrust #ip #ai #copyright
3
5
1
29
1,751
Ryan O'Rourke retweeted
Well folks- the heartless, faceless search team at Google has spoken… The March 2024 Core Update has officially been completed. And the result? An online ecosystem that is significantly more hollow, less diverse, and less helpful than ever before. Small, independent voices have been nearly erased from the search results, while big corporations are now ubiquitous. Information is now being controlled by a small number of players who are providing thin, general, impersonal and mainstream content. This is all happening in an election year, too. What could possibly go wrong? Here’s some context: since last fall, Google has been systematically penalizing small independent sites who monetize with ads and affiliate marketing. For years, this business model has been mutually beneficial for websites and consumers, allowing bloggers and niche sites to provide high-quality content to readers for FREE in return for some in-content ads/affiliate links on their sites. However, Google and a handful of institutional investors have now chosen to go down the war path against any and all small websites who stand in the way of them achieving maximum profits. To achieve this, they are using a “manual classifier” to penalize all parts of these websites, making it impossible to compete against the big players who are financially tied to Google, including e-commerce giants that use Google Ads & user-generated content platforms like Reddit, which lack the EEAT (expertise, experience, authority, and trustworthiness) that Google claims to value. PR spokespeople for Google have gone to great lengths to avoid conversation about this issue. They have done nothing to help out small creators to rebound their traffic and understand why they have been hit so hard while big publishers have taken over all the search results. This is pretty evil in my opinion, and it doesn’t just harm small creators, it harms everyone. Without a free, fair, and open internet, people will be left in the dark. In the travel industry that I’m in, it means that internet users will now see lower quality advice. Big sites like Forbes, Travel + Leisure, and Conde Nast do not have a financial incentive to provide high-quality tips and hacks that saves people time, money, and hassle while traveling. Their content is generally lean/thin and doesn’t provide much nuance. And without small sites like mine to compete with, you can bet that their content will get a lot worse. If diversity and innovation truly matter to Google, then it’s time to stop sidelining the small, the independent, and the innovative. You have an ethical and legal obligation to make the internet an even playing field once again. Do the right thing, or face the karmic consequences. @googlesearchc
20
50
4
235
29,338
.@searchliaison @Google @googlesearchc Your algo is bad. It's taking down many legit sites. The training missed something. Take the sitewide classifier off. Start over. Or really, we are going to have to start looking at legal options.
Seeing so many stories like this - GENUINE publishers getting absolutely ruined by @google's garbage HCU update. HCU IS NOT ABOUT CONTENT - It's about BRAND AUTHORITY and UGC. I've audited COUNTLESS SITES hit by HCU, all had amazing content, good engagement. Don't be fooled.
5
7
2
51
6,417
Ryan O'Rourke retweeted
Our message to Google is simple: remove the site-wide classifier that is being used to punish small, independent websites. If you feel there are major issues with our sites, at least give us a manual penalty and explain why. But as it stands right now, there are thousands of legitimate websites providing immense value that are essentially being shadow banned for no apparent reason (other than to benefit a handful of major corporations that Google is financially tied to). We aren’t asking for preferential treatment. We just want to compete on an equal playing field against the big sites, letting the users—rather than Google’s AI algorithm— decide what constitutes helpful content. There are dozens of ranking factors that can assess the user experience like time on page, bounce rate, etc. If we are going to lose to the big guys, it should be based on our own shortcomings, and not a side-wide classifier. No company should be able to flip a switch overnight that can decimate the livelihoods of thousands, if not millions of people. It’s not just site owners who suffer from these decisions; it’s all the writers, editors, web designers/developers, SEO folks, and virtually everyone else in the online space. All we ask is that you make this online ecosystem a fun and fair place to compete again. Give us the opportunity to make amazing content and be rewarded for our efforts. Without small, niche sites, the online world is going to become an uncreative, myopic place. Just a handful of large websites will dominate the information on the web, ultimately leading to less helpful content for consumers. If Google truly values diversity (like it says it does), then it shouldn’t be shutting out the voices of niche sites & small bloggers through a site-wide classifier. Please open your hearts and do the right thing. 🙏 @googlesearchc @JohnMu @Google
44
104
37
541
89,753
If you were wondering about the tragic consequences of a search monopoly gone awry for indie creators, this is it. (Also, after six months of progressively harsher claps and no documented recoveries, it’s now very clear that it’s past due time to pivot. And fast.)
It's a truly sad time for anyone that creates content that relies on Google. @retro_dodo is unfortunately on the brink of collapse because of recent changes to search results. Google is throwing their creators under the bus, in broad day light at scale. retrododo.com/google-is-kill…
3
9
788
Been feeling overwhelmed by personal challenges? Here’s some fantastic advice from @AmandaMGoetz…
If you are navigating a difficult time, here are 8 tips to get unstuck (based on learnings from my journey through divorce, infertility, selling companies and more) Try these when you need to kick the mud off and get back on the road to your goals. ​ ➡️ Tip 1: Acceptance You may not be able to change a highly stressful event, but you can change how you interpret and respond to it. Accepting this thing happened is the first step in moving through it. ➡️ Tip 2: Agency Remember you have the power to make life happen FOR you, not TO you. Start making small decisions about your life to take back control. Remind yourself of previous challenges you've overcome. Reflecting on your resilience reinforces that you possess the strength and capability to navigate difficult times. Use past successes as a source of inspiration and evidence of your agency. ➡️ Tip 3: Set realistic expectations When we are faced with a difficult situation it’s important to reassess what’s possible. Former you may be wanting to get a lot done but current you can only manage to do 30% of it. Reminder: If you only have 30% to give and you give all 30%....you gave 100%. Break your big goals into smaller more manageable to-dos to help you feel like you are still moving forward, even if a little slower than you originally desired. ➡️Tip 4: Allow Emotions If you started a fire in a fireplace but didn’t open the vent you’d likely hurt everyone in the room with the smoke. Resilience is built by opening your vent to not hurt anyone else around you. Feeling sad? Cry. Feeling angry? Go to a boxing class and hit something. Find outlets for letting the emotions out before they smoke up the room. ➡️​Tip 5: Find community Remembering that you are not alone in your struggle is key to moving through it. My only caution: do not center relationships on your trauma. My best friend and I were both going through a divorce at the same time and we would allow a 10 minute vent session and when the timer went off, we couldn’t talk about it anymore. Don't confuse venting and support with trauma bonding. ​➡️Tip 6: Celebrate progress Acknowledge and celebrate even small victories along the way. Shame depletes energy. Celebration generates it. Got outside today? Celebrate it. Showered? Let's fucking go. Stayed focused on a project for an hour? Rockstar! ➡️Tip 7: Seek help. There will be times where the mud gets too thick and you need some help getting unstuck. The best way to find a therapist is to ask others around you for a referral. Need a prompt? Try this: “Hey - feeling a bit stuck lately and realize I could benefit from an independent third party. Do you happen to know a great therapist?” No matter what you are navigating right now I hope you know you are not alone and you can use this season to build your resilience muscle. ​If you liked this, consider subscribing to 🧩Life's a Game newsletter - helping over 20,000 people achieve success without burning. Please share if this was helpful!
2
200
Being a good marketer shouldn’t come at the expense of being a good human. (The most aggressive guru tactics might check off the former but fail on the latter.)
1
2
127
Feeling more joy lately from brushing up on Python and JavaScript than working on SEO. Not a bad start to a Sunday afternoon 🤓
1
120