Ryan Monarch retweeted
Prices of everyday core goods, which haven’t risen in years, now are creeping upward, even before many of President Trump’s threatened tariffs have fully landed on.wsj.com/43ycHtl
Ryan Monarch retweeted
Economists point to the confusion and uncertainty over tariffs as the reason for the stock market's recent decline. newsweek.com/chart-shows-how…
Ryan Monarch retweeted
Replying to @scottlincicome
Ryan Monarch retweeted
Economists say tariffs could get in the way of Trump's promise to make housing more affordable. newsweek.com/chicago-develop…
Ryan Monarch retweeted
The tariffs are targeting a rule that allows Chinese retailers like Shein and Temu to avoid paying duties on packages worth $800 or less. newsweek.com/de-minimis-exce…
Ryan Monarch retweeted
JIE is pleased to announce that the 'Dynamic Quantitative Trade' Conference successfully took place in @WIeconomics on November 21-22. We are thankful to organizers George Alessandria and Kim Ruhl. Please look out for the special issue edited by Doireann Fitzgerald!
Ryan Monarch retweeted
Retaliatory tariffs & global supply chains mean the standard Econ 101 models are too rosey argues @BrianCAlbrecht. It's even worse. In the standard graph, domestic producers are winners. In reality, most producers lose, too.
Econ 101 is wrong about tariffs.
But not in the way protectionists think.
The reality is even worse than what we teach in class. Here's why:
economicforces.xyz/p/econ-10…
Ryan Monarch retweeted
You, a genius reasoning from accounting identities: “Tariffs raise GDP by reducing imports.”
Me, a humble reader of economics research: “Tariffs seem to reduce exports.”
aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.12…
Ryan Monarch retweeted
(1/3) Oren Cass had a piece recently in the Atlantic (theatlantic.com/politics/arc…) that mischaracterizes what we know (and don’t know) about tariffs. Maurice Obstfeld and I respond here (the Atlantic declined to publish).
piie.com/blogs/realtime-econ…
Ryan Monarch retweeted
It wasn't an assumption. They are protectionist in the the 19th century sense and they lowered imports and exports, as one might have predicted.
Replying to @besttrousers
LOL.
Except the stupidiest mistake in our tariff discourse is so many otherwise smart people assuming Trump’s tariffs are protectionist in the 19th century sense.
Ryan Monarch retweeted
Forthcoming in AEJ: Applied Economics: "Rising Import Tariffs, Falling Exports: When Modern Supply Chains Meet Old-Style Protectionism" by Kyle Handley, Fariha Kamal, and Ryan Monarch. aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.12…
Ryan Monarch retweeted
RIP Jonathan Eaton.
He leaves behind an impressive legacy that transcends beyond the trade literature. A thread to honor his immense contributions: 🧵
Ryan Monarch retweeted
New: "Longevity and the value of trade relationships" by Ryan Monarch (@ryan_monarch) and Tim Schmidt-Eisenlohr (@eisenlohr_tim). How do firm-to-firm relationships affect trade adjustments?
doi.org/10.1016/j.jinteco.20… 1/2
Ryan Monarch retweeted
Great program and conference of EIIT. My student Jin Liu (sites.google.com/view/jinliu…), who won this year’s EIIT best graduate student paper award, will present her exciting research on multinational innovation and production there.
Very much looking forward to the EIIT 2023 meeting at @MaxwellSU of @SyracuseU
The full agenda here: freit.org/EIIT/2023/AgendaEI…
Thanks to the organizers @TBesedes @ryan_monarch
Ryan Monarch retweeted
Very much looking forward to the EIIT 2023 meeting at @MaxwellSU of @SyracuseU
The full agenda here: freit.org/EIIT/2023/AgendaEI…
Thanks to the organizers @TBesedes @ryan_monarch
Ryan Monarch retweeted
New #IFDPPaper: Who's Most Exposed to International Shocks? Estimating Differences in Import Price Sensitivity across U.S. Demographic Groups: federalreserve.gov/econres/i…
Ryan Monarch retweeted
🚨New Working Paper on Supply Chain Adjustments to Trade War🚨
We’re starting the see the contours in aggregate trade data of what it looks like for supply chains to adjust using what I will say are the new 3D’s of trade policy & supply chain catchwords: “de-risking”, “de-coupling”, and “diversification.”
Motivated by the fact that trade at a granular level is mediated by within firm and firm-to-firm buyer-supplier linkages, a new working paper looks at the short-run adjustment of firms to the 2018-2019 trade war tariffs.
Key points:
1⃣US import growth since 1992 is very dynamic, i.e. churning from adding and dropping products and suppliers is very high. About 60% of import growth over time is driven by total contribution of net new firm importers and the net additions of new product line and source supplier imports.
2⃣When the trade war tariffs start to hit in 2018 to 2019, import growth in affected products declines by about 17% on average. That’s a lot of trade destruction. More than 50% of the fall is from a reduction in the dynamism of import growth prior to the trade war: fewer firms enter the import market, they add less new products, and a large handful to just quit importing and drop product lines that are tariffed all together.
3⃣Can’t the firms just find other suppliers unaffected by new tariffs? Yes and no. Firms can’t adjust easily if existing supplier networks are highly concentrated. We constructed firm level measure of supplier concentration (HH indices) in source countries. Where supply is heavily concentrated in few suppliers, import growth declines less across all margins of trade. That suggests is much harder to de-couple and diversify away (most from China) where there are few alternative suppliers, at least in the short-run.
4⃣The kicker is that most large US importers are also exporters. US exports are notably weak by the end of 2019 relative to a pre-trade war baseline (see first figure below). Tariffs are a cost shock to inputs and if firms can’t easily diversify away from tariffed product lines, we might anticipate their output declines across the board. That is exactly what we see in exports.
5⃣When we compute the tariff exposure of firms to the trade war tariffs based on their 2016, pre-trade war import patters, we find the implied cost of the tariffs is $900 per US workers at affected firms and almost $1600 per worker in manufacturing. These are non-trivial costs, over 2% of payrolls in manufacturing.
6⃣In the second graph below, you can see that the waves of tariffs and escalation are applied the exports start to fall where there is high exposure at importer-exporter firms (again, these are the largest employers and most productive firms in the US economy). It’s not just exports to China or in tariffed products that are going down. The decline is occurs over all destination markets for US goods.
7⃣It’s the equivalent, on average, of the rest of the world imposing a 2% tariff on all US exports. For more exposed products it could be as high as 4-5%. See the last graph below.
If we bring this forward into the present. Candidate Trump has recently proposed adding a 10% across the board import tariff on all US imports. Because it’s across the board, that shock would be equivalent increasing our import tariff exposure measure by exactly 10 percentage points. So high, that’s it’s actually off the charts below. We should be careful about out of sample generalizations, especially for large shock, but the implied effect would potentially be as large as a 10% equivalent tariff on all US exports (astute readers will not this is Lerner symmetry in action, a tax on imports is a tax on exports).
All of which is to say that the achieving the 3Ds of supply chain goals—decoupling, de-risking and diversification—could be a pretty expensive lunch.
Firm trade linkages between buyers and foreign suppliers and within importer-exporter firms played an important role in how US supply chains adjusted to new tariffs during the 2018-19 trade war, from @KyleLHandley, @farihakamal2011, and @ryan_monarch nber.org/papers/w31602
Ryan Monarch retweeted
Firm trade linkages between buyers and foreign suppliers and within importer-exporter firms played an important role in how US supply chains adjusted to new tariffs during the 2018-19 trade war, from @KyleLHandley, @farihakamal2011, and @ryan_monarch nber.org/papers/w31602
Ryan Monarch retweeted
Call for papers for 2023 EIIT at Syracuse us out, freit.org/EIIT/2023. Thanks to @ryan_monarch, @DevashishMitra_, and Kristy Buzard for hosting us.
Ryan Monarch retweeted
U.S. importers tend to stay with their Chinese suppliers over time, leading to higher import prices. In the September 2022 issue, by Ryan Monarch (@ryan_monarch) zcu.io/Ao0Y






























