we've been saying this for YEARS. the court finally acknowledged that newjeans were left in limbo, with no explanation or clarity about their own debut. FINALLY
According to news outlet Ilyo Shinmun, the court acknowledged that NewJeans' members were left waiting indefinitely without a proper explanation about their debut, despite Source Music having initially promised their parents that they would debut as HYBE's first girl group.
The court also found substantial grounds to consider Min Hee-jin's claims that Source Music had neglected the NewJeans members to be substantially true.
kaum lu juga masih ada yg manggil tokkimek, banisrael, dll.
tweet yg lu qrt pun nyalahin si creative director nya tuh, kan lu lu pada yg selama ini ga pernah ngecall out si belift kalo soal ginian dan malah diem diem bae🙄
Replying to @xqdU_Ubpx
Kak klo mau bawa2 ss-an coba yg memang bisa dipertanggung jawabkan baik omongannya ataupun sumbernya
Dan lagi, klo mau complain langsung aja ke belift & hybe, ngapain harus merendahkan illit dgn penggunaan slur "sillit"?
Kalian ini kontradiktif bgt, membela njs tp jahat ke illit
bi retweeted
paling abis ini dibilang "kan newjeans gak nyiptain konsep itu!!" but somehow apapun yang belift kasih ke grup mereka tuh selalu bisa lu temuin di visuals/concept/aestheticnya newjeans, what a coincidence 😅
Replying to @banhee5oo
like dpmo…. ive never seen any kpop idols or group woth this much detailed outfits as newjeans
bi retweeted
itu aja bukan akun spoty dani yg asli😭😭 kita aja streaming-nya di akun yt dazzibelle.
akun whitemamba kok dijadiin source, pantesss. 👀
bi retweeted
Ini loh yang diperjuangin sama anak2 NJ,karena mereka sadar sebusuk apa industri kpop kalo ga ada yg pasang badan buat anak2 remaja kaya NJ. And I'm glad Lngshot punya JayPark,yang posisinya ga akan pernah bisa digeser sama siapapun di Morvi kecuali sama Woojin🤣
bi retweeted
NewJeans, Girls Generation and 2NE1 are the only kpop girl groups ever to win Artist of the Year (Daesang) at the MAMA awards.
bi retweeted
PLEASE READ‼️‼️
1. The plagiarism debate started in the public
2. Even if MHJ’s opinions were facts Belift didn’t prove them wrong 😭
4. NJ were supposed to debut first
3. SouMu admitted to delaying NJ to debut LSF bc of contract periods
4. Court agreed SouMu neglected NJ
Looking at Why Min Hee-jin Won the ₩2.5 Billion Damages Lawsuits… Attention on Publicizing Plagiarism Allegations and Records of NewJeans’ Debut Preparations
ilyo.co.kr/?ac=article_view&…
Reporter Kim Tae-won
Former ADOR CEO Min Hee-jin (currently CEO of OOAK Records) won both damages lawsuits totaling ₩2.5 billion filed against her by HYBE-affiliated labels BELIFT LAB and Source Music. The ruling drew attention as the first first-instance verdicts issued after the management-control dispute between HYBE and Min Hee-jin escalated into damages lawsuits involving its subsidiary labels. The court based its decisions primarily on the circumstances surrounding the controversy over allegations that ILLIT plagiarized NewJeans, how the controversy developed into a public dispute between the parties, and contemporaneous records supporting the changes to NewJeans’ debut schedule and the lack of explanation provided for those changes.
According to the first-instance judgments in both cases obtained by Ilyo Newspaper, what the court examined most closely in the BELIFT LAB case was how the allegations that ILLIT plagiarized NewJeans first emerged and subsequently developed into a public debate. Even before Min Hee-jin publicly raised the issue through her statement on April 22, 2024, and her press conference on April 25, controversy over the similarities between the two groups had already been circulating extensively online.
According to the judgment, NewJeans’ members’ parents were also concerned about the controversy and sent Min Hee-jin an email on March 31, 2024, asking her to raise the issue with HYBE. Min Hee-jin subsequently sent emails on April 3 and April 16 of the same year to HYBE officials and BELIFT LAB executives, attaching materials comparing the similarities between the two groups and requesting corrective action.
Based on these circumstances, the court viewed Min Hee-jin not as someone who had first revealed new information regarding the plagiarism allegations against ILLIT, but as someone who had joined an already ongoing public debate over the similarities between the groups and expressed her opinion in her capacity as the head of NewJeans’ agency at the time. The court also assessed that her raising the issue served as an opportunity to expand public debate on the matter.
The court also took into consideration that Min Hee-jin’s claims were not the only ones made public. BELIFT LAB actively rebutted the plagiarism allegations through official statements and YouTube videos beginning in May 2024, and its CEO also gave media interviews in November of that year. The court determined that the public had the opportunity to compare the arguments presented by both sides and reach their own conclusions, making it difficult to conclude that Min Hee-jin’s statements alone had created a biased perception in favor of one side.
In light of these circumstances, the court regarded Min Hee-jin’s statements as expressions of opinion rather than assertions of specific facts. Even if they were considered factual assertions, the court ruled that BELIFT LAB had failed to prove their falsity based on the evidence it submitted, and that the statements fell within the permissible scope of freedom of expression and were therefore not unlawful. However, the court did not reach a conclusion on whether ILLIT had actually plagiarized or copied NewJeans.
In the lawsuit filed by Source Music, the agency of girl group LE SSERAFIM, specific records concerning the formation of NewJeans became one of the grounds for the court's ruling. Source Music filed suit, alleging that Min Hee-jin had spread false information by claiming that she personally recruited the NewJeans members and by asserting that Source Music unilaterally changed the debut order and neglected its trainees.
The court, however, acknowledged Source Music's contributions to recruiting and training the trainees while also finding that Min Hee-jin had played a leading role in casting and assembling the debut lineup. In particular, the court recognized that Team N (the predecessor to NewJeans), which was being developed as a debut project, had originally been planned as HYBE's first girl group and as a group to be directed by Min Hee-jin, and that Source Music had communicated this debut goal to the trainees' parents during the trainee-contract process. It was also confirmed that a proposal was subsequently made to debut another girl group, Team S (the predecessor to LE SSERAFIM), first, prompting strong protests from Min Hee-jin. At the time, however, HYBE reportedly argued that it would be difficult to postpone Team S's debut because the members had shorter contract periods.
The lack of sufficient explanation to the trainees regarding these changes in debut order also influenced the court's decision. Discussions about changing the debut order had already begun internally at Source Music in June 2021, but a specific and official explanation was not provided to the trainees and their parents until September of that year, after the decision had been made to transfer Team N to ADOR. The court interpreted Min Hee-jin's remarks about Source Music neglecting the trainees as criticism not of inadequate training, but of the lack of explanation regarding whether the trainees would debut and the changes to the debut order.
During the litigation, Source Music also acknowledged that its CEO at the time had failed to personally explain the circumstances surrounding the delayed debut or the transfer of the trainees to them and their parents. Based on the consistent testimony of NewJeans' members' parents that the circumstances had changed from those originally presented when the contracts were signed, yet they had received no explanation from the company, and that the trainees had been left in a state of indefinite waiting without any explanation about their debut even as news emerged about members being recruited for another girl group, the court ruled that there were substantial grounds to consider Min Hee-jin's statements about the trainees being neglected as substantially true in important respects.
Both BELIFT LAB and Source Music expressed opposition to the first-instance rulings and announced that they would appeal. Since neither company was able to prove the falsity of Min Hee-jin's statements with the evidence submitted at the first-instance trial, attention is now focused on whether they will present new grounds on appeal that could overturn the judgments.
Meanwhile, Min Hee-jin's legal representative, Hwawoo LLC, issued an official statement regarding the outcome of the lawsuits, saying, "This ruling confirms that raising concerns and expressing one's assessment regarding the similarities between creative works—which were already being discussed in the public sphere—in order to protect the value of one's own artists, and calling for an explanation, is not something that should be subject to damages liability."
It continued, "HYBE has turned Min Hee-jin's raising of the plagiarism issue into an alleged attempt to seize control of ADOR and has continued pursuing civil lawsuits seeking enormous sums of money and filing criminal complaints. However, the court ruled that 'Min's raising of the issue was justified, and circumstances supporting it were recognized.' This should also be considered an important factor in the other ongoing civil and criminal cases between HYBE and Min Hee-jin."
bi retweeted
- Min Hee-jin won both lawsuits.
- The court viewed Min Hee-jin as participating in an existing public debate, not inventing a new controversy.
- NewJeans' parents were also concerned about the similarities and asked her to raise the issue.
- Min Hee-jin had attempted to address the issue internally with HYBE and BELIFT LAB but their reply was the April 22, 2024 audit.
- BELIFT LAB failed to prove her statements were false or legally wrongful.
- The court treated Min Hee-jin's remarks as opinions rather than factual accusations.
- Source Music also failed to prove its claims against Min Hee-jin
- The court acknowledged that Min Hee-jin played a leading role in NewJeans' casting and formation
- NewJeans (Team N) was originally planned to debut as HYBE's first girl group under Min Hee-jin's direction
- HYBE later proposed debuting Team S first
- The debut order was changed, and the trainees were not given adequate explanations at the time.
- Source Music acknowledged that its CEO did not personally explain the debut delay and transfer circumstances to the trainees and their parents.
- The court found substantial grounds to consider Min Hee-jin's statements about the trainees being neglected true in important respects.
- Both BELIFT LAB and Source Music intend to appeal.
- Min Hee-jin's legal team says the ruling protects legitimate criticism and freedom of expression
- Hwawoo argues that HYBE turned the plagiarism issue into a management-takeover accusation
Looking at Why Min Hee-jin Won the ₩2.5 Billion Damages Lawsuits… Attention on Publicizing Plagiarism Allegations and Records of NewJeans’ Debut Preparations
ilyo.co.kr/?ac=article_view&…
Reporter Kim Tae-won
Former ADOR CEO Min Hee-jin (currently CEO of OOAK Records) won both damages lawsuits totaling ₩2.5 billion filed against her by HYBE-affiliated labels BELIFT LAB and Source Music. The ruling drew attention as the first first-instance verdicts issued after the management-control dispute between HYBE and Min Hee-jin escalated into damages lawsuits involving its subsidiary labels. The court based its decisions primarily on the circumstances surrounding the controversy over allegations that ILLIT plagiarized NewJeans, how the controversy developed into a public dispute between the parties, and contemporaneous records supporting the changes to NewJeans’ debut schedule and the lack of explanation provided for those changes.
According to the first-instance judgments in both cases obtained by Ilyo Newspaper, what the court examined most closely in the BELIFT LAB case was how the allegations that ILLIT plagiarized NewJeans first emerged and subsequently developed into a public debate. Even before Min Hee-jin publicly raised the issue through her statement on April 22, 2024, and her press conference on April 25, controversy over the similarities between the two groups had already been circulating extensively online.
According to the judgment, NewJeans’ members’ parents were also concerned about the controversy and sent Min Hee-jin an email on March 31, 2024, asking her to raise the issue with HYBE. Min Hee-jin subsequently sent emails on April 3 and April 16 of the same year to HYBE officials and BELIFT LAB executives, attaching materials comparing the similarities between the two groups and requesting corrective action.
Based on these circumstances, the court viewed Min Hee-jin not as someone who had first revealed new information regarding the plagiarism allegations against ILLIT, but as someone who had joined an already ongoing public debate over the similarities between the groups and expressed her opinion in her capacity as the head of NewJeans’ agency at the time. The court also assessed that her raising the issue served as an opportunity to expand public debate on the matter.
The court also took into consideration that Min Hee-jin’s claims were not the only ones made public. BELIFT LAB actively rebutted the plagiarism allegations through official statements and YouTube videos beginning in May 2024, and its CEO also gave media interviews in November of that year. The court determined that the public had the opportunity to compare the arguments presented by both sides and reach their own conclusions, making it difficult to conclude that Min Hee-jin’s statements alone had created a biased perception in favor of one side.
In light of these circumstances, the court regarded Min Hee-jin’s statements as expressions of opinion rather than assertions of specific facts. Even if they were considered factual assertions, the court ruled that BELIFT LAB had failed to prove their falsity based on the evidence it submitted, and that the statements fell within the permissible scope of freedom of expression and were therefore not unlawful. However, the court did not reach a conclusion on whether ILLIT had actually plagiarized or copied NewJeans.
In the lawsuit filed by Source Music, the agency of girl group LE SSERAFIM, specific records concerning the formation of NewJeans became one of the grounds for the court's ruling. Source Music filed suit, alleging that Min Hee-jin had spread false information by claiming that she personally recruited the NewJeans members and by asserting that Source Music unilaterally changed the debut order and neglected its trainees.
The court, however, acknowledged Source Music's contributions to recruiting and training the trainees while also finding that Min Hee-jin had played a leading role in casting and assembling the debut lineup. In particular, the court recognized that Team N (the predecessor to NewJeans), which was being developed as a debut project, had originally been planned as HYBE's first girl group and as a group to be directed by Min Hee-jin, and that Source Music had communicated this debut goal to the trainees' parents during the trainee-contract process. It was also confirmed that a proposal was subsequently made to debut another girl group, Team S (the predecessor to LE SSERAFIM), first, prompting strong protests from Min Hee-jin. At the time, however, HYBE reportedly argued that it would be difficult to postpone Team S's debut because the members had shorter contract periods.
The lack of sufficient explanation to the trainees regarding these changes in debut order also influenced the court's decision. Discussions about changing the debut order had already begun internally at Source Music in June 2021, but a specific and official explanation was not provided to the trainees and their parents until September of that year, after the decision had been made to transfer Team N to ADOR. The court interpreted Min Hee-jin's remarks about Source Music neglecting the trainees as criticism not of inadequate training, but of the lack of explanation regarding whether the trainees would debut and the changes to the debut order.
During the litigation, Source Music also acknowledged that its CEO at the time had failed to personally explain the circumstances surrounding the delayed debut or the transfer of the trainees to them and their parents. Based on the consistent testimony of NewJeans' members' parents that the circumstances had changed from those originally presented when the contracts were signed, yet they had received no explanation from the company, and that the trainees had been left in a state of indefinite waiting without any explanation about their debut even as news emerged about members being recruited for another girl group, the court ruled that there were substantial grounds to consider Min Hee-jin's statements about the trainees being neglected as substantially true in important respects.
Both BELIFT LAB and Source Music expressed opposition to the first-instance rulings and announced that they would appeal. Since neither company was able to prove the falsity of Min Hee-jin's statements with the evidence submitted at the first-instance trial, attention is now focused on whether they will present new grounds on appeal that could overturn the judgments.
Meanwhile, Min Hee-jin's legal representative, Hwawoo LLC, issued an official statement regarding the outcome of the lawsuits, saying, "This ruling confirms that raising concerns and expressing one's assessment regarding the similarities between creative works—which were already being discussed in the public sphere—in order to protect the value of one's own artists, and calling for an explanation, is not something that should be subject to damages liability."
It continued, "HYBE has turned Min Hee-jin's raising of the plagiarism issue into an alleged attempt to seize control of ADOR and has continued pursuing civil lawsuits seeking enormous sums of money and filing criminal complaints. However, the court ruled that 'Min's raising of the issue was justified, and circumstances supporting it were recognized.' This should also be considered an important factor in the other ongoing civil and criminal cases between HYBE and Min Hee-jin."
bi retweeted
The defendant (HYBE) portrayed the KakaoTalk conversations as evidence of a plan to poach NewJeans. But when the court examined what those conversations actually discussed, it found that the dominant subject was preserving or acquiring an interest in ADOR, not taking NewJeans away.
The court is essentially saying: The defendant's (HYBE) interpretation of the evidence is inconsistent with the actual content and direction of the KKT conversations.
Therefore, the evidence presented doesn't support the story they are trying to tell.
bi retweeted
Setelah di slutshaming, difitnah, dihate selama mhj vs hybe berjalan. masih dengan pdnya ngungkit rasa terima kasih karena udah dibantuin ngelawan smstan. padahal mah. Di awal nj debut jg bbrp dr kalian pake pencapaian nj buat ngerendahin bp. Sampe nj dikatain payola sama blink
bi retweeted
gw as bunnies yang defends nj dari 2024 muak bnget liat nya sekarang rewrite history melulu. padahal dulu adem ayem aja pas kasus nj mulai pda nyudutin nj banget. kyk lupa aja mereka pdhal yg mulai bully nj. inget jga twt cia hida ngatain hanni monster tembus10k like
bi retweeted
mind to explain? ALSO brand luar yg pada kerjasama dgn newjeans dan jarang collab dgn kpop kalo kamu mau perhatiin, ga lama mereka kerjasama dengan sillit, ulah siapa kalo bukan ulah uncreative unschooled your mama xerian hue? abis ini denial lagi liat aja
bi retweeted
Congratulations #NewJeans for winning ‘Song of the Year(Ditto)’ at the 2023 MAMA Awards🎉🎉🎉
#뉴진스 #MAMAAWARDS
#2023MAMAAWARDS





































































