⚡⚡
Black Holes Might Literally Split in Half — Physicists Just Found a Narrow Loophole in the Laws of Thermodynamics
We know black holes collide and merge into bigger monsters, ringing spacetime with gravitational waves. But what if the opposite can happen? What if one black hole tears itself into two?
A new theoretical paper in *Physical Review D* (“When Black Holes Admit Pair-of-Pants Topologies”) shows that the usual thermodynamic ban on this process has a tiny, extreme loophole.
Why splitting is normally forbidden
Black-hole entropy is proportional to the area of the event horizon (the Bekenstein–Hawking formula). For an ordinary, non-spinning Schwarzschild black hole, splitting into two smaller ones would shrink the total horizon area. Entropy would go down — a direct violation of the second law of thermodynamics. Nature simply doesn’t allow it.
The spinning loophole
For rapidly rotating Kerr black holes the math changes. Rotational energy alters the relationship between mass, spin, and entropy. The calculations reveal a narrow window where a split no longer decreases total entropy.
There’s a catch: the two newborn black holes must fly apart instead of immediately falling back together. Once that dynamical requirement is included, the window almost disappears. It survives only for black holes spinning *extremely* close to the maximum allowed rate (near-extremal Kerr holes).
Mathematically, the process is allowed. Whether nature ever realizes it is another question.
The “pair-of-pants” geometry
If such a fission occurred, the event horizon would evolve in a distinctive way through spacetime: a single connected surface that pinches and divides into two separate “legs.” Physicists call this a *pair-of-pants topology*. It is not a literal ripping of matter in ordinary space; it is a change in the topology of the horizon itself.
Other exotic routes
The authors also examine more speculative possibilities:
- In theories with extra spatial dimensions, the Gregory–Laflamme instability can make extended black objects unstable and fragment.
- Non-axisymmetric instabilities combined with superradiance (where a spinning black hole sheds energy into surrounding fields).
- Modified-gravity models that change the usual link between mass, horizon radius, and entropy, sometimes making a small fragment energetically preferred.
None of these guarantee that a split will actually happen — only that physics does not absolutely forbid it under the right conditions.
Could we ever see one?
The probability is currently unknown; it depends on physics beyond classical general relativity. Co-author Francesco Sannino notes that tiny primordial black holes formed in the early universe are more promising candidates than the astrophysical black holes we observe today.
Possible signatures could include high-energy radiation from the small fragments. Gamma-ray telescopes such as Fermi-LAT are suggested as one way to look for evidence that these rare “cosmic divorces” have ever occurred.
In short: black holes are still overwhelmingly more likely to merge than to split. But for the fastest-spinning ones, the thermodynamic veto is no longer absolute. The universe may occasionally allow a black hole to put on a pair of pants.