Andrew Stoddart retweeted
Anthropic: The Committee of Public Safety IPO
Anthropic went public today.
It’s the first company built by “effective altruists” to go public. Thus, I’m certain most investors have no idea what they’re buying, or how dangerous the company’s charter is, not only to investors, but to humanity.
Effective altruists believe that capitalism is a flawed system because it relies on self-interested actors competing in markets. They believe they’ve created a better system, a way of creating value that’s based on doing what’s best for the “common good,” not greedy shareholders.
Anthropic is a Delaware “public benefit corporation.” Its charter assigns it a purpose: the responsible development and maintenance of advanced AI for the long-term benefit of humanity.
Its directors are required to balance three things: the financial interests of shareholders, the interests of everyone materially affected by the company’s conduct, and that purpose.
What in the heck does that actually mean?
It means that the company’s directors can do whatever they want. They aren’t accountable to the shareholders. They’re accountable “everyone,” which effectively means they’re not accountable to anyone.
A director who sacrifices your returns for the long-term benefit of humanity is deemed to have met his duties so long as the decision is informed and disinterested. Anthropic’s own prospectus concedes there is limited judicial precedent on how courts will judge that balancing. Thus, Anthropic’s board is completely unaccountable to its owners.
And… who selects the board…?
A Long-Term Benefit Trust holds a single share of Class T stock. That share carries no economic rights and no expiration date. It gives the trust the power to elect and remove four of Anthropic’s seven directors: a majority of the board. The filing describes the trustees as financially disinterested,with backgrounds in AI safety, national security, public policy and social enterprise. The men and women who pick the majority of the board of a $1.5 trillion company have not a dollar of their own at risk in it.
And the other directors?
The seven co-founders hold a single share of Class F stock through an entity called Founder LLC. That one share carries 50.1% of the vote on nearly everything else shareholders decide, including the election of the other three directors. The filing says that voting power will not be subject to dilution. Counting their own shares, the founders control about 61.3% of the vote. Each has pledged to give away 80% of his or her stock. A founder keeps a seat in the LLC so long as he holds just 2% of his IPO-era shares.
One of the most powerful technology companies that’s ever been created is going to be controlled by a group of completely disinterested directors who believe they know what’s best for the common good.
What could possibly go wrong?
Here’s what one of the founders of the world’s largest altruism movement believes about the near-term future, thanks to technology:
“Man at last will begin to harmonize himself in earnest… He will try to master first the semiconscious and then the subconscious processes in his own organism, such as breathing, the circulation of the blood, digestion, reproduction, and, within necessary limits, he will try to subordinate them to the control of reason and will… in order to reduce the fear of death to a rational reaction of the organism towards danger… Man will become immeasurably stronger, wiser and subtler; his body will become more harmonized, his movements more rhythmic, his voice more musical... The average human type will rise to the heights of an Aristotle, a Goethe... And above this ridge new peaks will rise.”
Dario Amodei, the chief executive of Anthropic (ANT), believes exactly the same ideas.
In 2024 he published an essay called Machines of Loving Grace. In it he wrote virtually the same words: weight, physical appearance, reproduction, and other biological processes will be fully under people’s control. He predicts the next 50-100 years of biological progress in 5-10 years, and a doubling of the human lifespan to 150.
What’s the problem?
That first description of the coming technological revolution (above) was written in 1924 by the leader of the world’s first effective altruism movement, Leon Trotsky. It’s from the closing pages of his book Literature and Revolution. Yes, the communists were avowed altruists. They sought to create a “perfect man” that would always act for the common good. “The average human type will rise to the heights of an Aristotle, a Goethe, or a Marx.”
Trotsky built the Red Army. In September 1918 he ordered the families of officers who defected to the enemy be arrested, so every officer knew his wife and children were hostages. Then he hung them all. For the greater good, of course.
These kinds of revolutions always devours their own. Stalin had Trotsky expelled from the party in 1927 and deported from the Soviet Union in 1929. In 1936, a Moscow show trial sentenced him to death in absentia. In May 1940, Stalinist gunmen sprayed his bedroom in Mexico City with machine-gun fire. Then, on August 20, 1940, Ramón Mercader, a Soviet secret-police agent who had worked his way into Trotsky’s household, drove a mountaineering ice axe into his skull as he sat reading at his desk.
Effective altruism, like communism, began with an appealing idea: give to charity using evidence, not sentiment. Its leading thinkers concluded that because the people who will live in the distant future vastly outnumber the people alive today, the most important moral work is preventing events that could wipe out that future.
Of course, if you accept that logic, then virtually any present sacrifice can be justified by the trillions of hypothetical lives on the other side of the ledger. It’s a preposterous idea. And it reveals a profoundly naïve false belief in their own judgment.
In March 2022, the economist Tyler Cowen asked Sam Bankman-Fried, then effective altruism’s most famous donor, whether he would take a bet with a 51% chance of doubling the Earth and a 49% chance of destroying it, and keep playing double or nothing. Bankman-Fried said yes. Eight months later his exchange, FTX, collapsed. A jury convicted him on seven counts of fraud and conspiracy. A federal judge found Bankman-Fried stole $8 billion and sentenced him to 25 years.
It’s arrogance to the level of insanity to believe that you know what’s best for everyone. It’s arrogance beyond the level of insanity to believe you have the right to other people’s property because you know what’s best for them.
Look at Anthropic's charter. Is there a meaningful difference between what Sam Bankman-Fried did and what Amodei has done with the structure of Anthropic? I don't think so. These people believe they know what's best for everyone. And they're going to do what's best for the "common good."
And where do these ideas always lead? To totalitarian systems of control.
In 1762, Jean-Jacques Rousseau wrote that society rests on a general will, and that whoever refuses to obey the general will shall be compelled to do so by the whole body. Thirty-two years later, his most devoted student, Maximilien Robespierre, told the National Convention: Terror is nothing other than justice, prompt, severe, inflexible; it is therefore an emanation of virtue.
Robespierre’s Committee of Public Safety arrested about 300,000 people. Roughly 17,000 were tried and executed. Thousands more died in prison or without trial.
The Bolsheviks replaced the general will with the dictatorship of the proletariat. Same idea: a vanguard that could see the good the masses could not.
Mao Zedong’s Great Leap Forward promised to move China into industrial abundance – for the common good. Planners in Beijing set the targets, and the peasants starved. Demographers estimate the famine of 1958 to 1962 killed somewhere between 15 million and 45 million people.
You might object that these were fanatics with guns, and that the people running Anthropic are scientists with data centers. But, it’s only a matter of time before they will create a reason to start killing people.
In the early twentieth century, American scientists, reformers and philanthropists embraced eugenics: the idea that society could breed out disease, poverty and crime with the help of science. It called itself evidence-based. It was impartial and long-termist, concerned with the welfare of generations not yet born. It was all for the common good.
The Supreme Court ruled on it in 1927. By a vote of 8 to 1, the justices let Virginia sterilize a young woman named Carrie Buck. Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes, the most celebrated legal mind of his era, wrote: Three generations of imbeciles are enough. Somewhere between 60,000 and 70,000 Americans were sterilized against their will.
C.S. Lewis best explained the unique danger of these kinds of ideas. "Of all tyrannies, a tyranny sincerely exercised for the good of its victims may be the most oppressive... those who torment us for our own good will torment us without end for they do so with the approval of their own conscience."
Alas, there is no such thing as the common good.
There are only goods, plural: the particular wants of particular people, which conflict constantly.
You want a cheaper car. The autoworker wants a higher wage. The retiree wants a safe yield, and the founder wants your savings for his start-up.
No committee – and no data center – can add those wants into a single number called “the good” and then maximize it. The wants are not knowable in advance, even to the people who hold them, until they have to choose.
But you cannot choose for others. You can only choose accurately for yourself.
That is, acting in your own best interests is a vital part of the system.
Friedrich Hayek spent his entire career explaining why self-interest is integral to a functional free market. The curious task of economics, he wrote in 1988, is to demonstrate to men how little they really know about what they imagine they can design.
The knowledge that runs an economy is not understood by one man or group of men. It is not contained by any machine – not even a superhuman AI.
The knowledge that runs an economy is local, tacit and scattered. It surfaces only when people with something at stake make choices.
That is how what is “good” gets discovered: one transaction at a time, by people who bear the consequences of their choices.
Adam Smith wrote the most famous sentence in economics: It is not from the benevolence of the butcher, the brewer, or the baker, that we expect our dinner, but from their regard to their own interest. The merchant, Smith wrote, intends only his own gain, and he is in this, as in many other cases, led by an invisible hand to promote an end which was no part of his intention. Then comes the line that every American should know: I have never known much good done by those who affected to trade for the public good.
Anthropic’s shareholders are about to learn this lesson the hard way. And I hope they're the only victims.
Andrew Stoddart retweeted
Sverige har lyckats med något historiskt. På bara några år har vi förvandlat ett land med nästan gratis, stabil el till ett land där folk får ångest varje gång de öppnar sin elräkning. Det är en bedrift som få länder matchar.
Förklaringen är enkel och elegant: de rödgröna stängde kärnkraftverk som producerade el dygnet runt, året om, och ersatte dem med vindkraftverk som producerar el när det blåser lagom mycket. När det inte blåser importerar vi istället el från kolkraftverk i Tyskland eller gas från länder vi helst inte vill nämna. Resultatet? Rekordhöga priser i södra Sverige och politiker som förklarar att det här är precis så det var tänkt.
När elräkningen landar på 12 000 kronor i januari får man höra att det är Putins fel. Eller klimatets. Eller marknadens. Aldrig att det kan ha något att göra med att man medvetet monterat ner den enda energikälla som faktiskt levererar planerbar el i stor skala.
Nej, lösningen är mer av samma: fler vindkraftverk till havs, fler solpaneler som inte ger något i december, och fler utredningar om hur man ska kompensera hushållen för den politik man just genomfört.
Samtidigt exporterar Sverige el till kontinenten när det blåser bra, för att sedan köpa tillbaka dyr el när det är kallt och vindstilla. Det kallas ”europeisk solidaritet”. Svenska villaägare kallar det något annat när de sitter i mörkret med vinterjackan på och funderar på om det är värt att sätta på ugnen.
Det vackraste är ändå retoriken. Man talar om ”grön omställning” medan elpriset gör att folk tvingas elda med ved eller stänga av elementen. Man talar om ”framtidens energi” medan industrierna hotar att flytta. Och när någon påpekar att Norge och Finland har lägre priser tack vare mer kärnkraft, blir svaret att Sverige är mer progressivt.
Så nästa gång elräkningen kommer: tänk inte på den stängda reaktorn i Barsebäck eller Ringhals. Tänk på de vackra vindkraftverken som just nu står stilla. Det är framsteg. Det är moral. Och det är, enligt de ansvariga, det enda ansvarsfulla valet.
Andrew Stoddart retweeted
This is absolutely brilliant, by legendary Australian investor John Hempton, who explains the core financial paradox at the heart of the AI story (and which also, to some extent, may explain the Jensen Huang story).
The numbers say that about $7 trillion in AI compute is set to be built by 2030. For the industry to earn that back, given those chips have a roughly 5-year lifespan and cost a lot to run, they need to generate about $2 trillion of AI revenue a year.
Hempton says the only way you can get to these sorts of numbers is by selling AI as a productivity tool to businesses, meaning replacing workers.
And since, for reasons he explains in the video, no company fires people to save just 10% in costs, the savings have to be about double what businesses pay for the AI: roughly $4 trillion in savings on wages a year.
What does firing $4 trillion worth of workers mean concretely? Hempton calculated this equates to roughly 10% of the OECD’s total wage bill of about $40 trillion: one in every ten dollars paid to workers across the OECD’s 38 member countries.
Which, naturally, when you suddenly take that much income out of people’s pockets, would trigger a massive global recession.
And here's the paradox: in a massive global recession, there's no way businesses will pay $2 trillion a year for AI, so the return disappears anyway.
In other words, AI's only possible path to success given the numbers requires destroying the very economy that is supposed to pay for it.
HOWEVER - and here's where the Nvidia/Jensen Huang story might come into play (and, to be clear, this is now me speaking and not Hempton given this interview is prior to the whole Nvidia saga) - this all rests on a core assumption: that compute stays super expensive. Which in practice means Nvidia keeping its pricing power, with a 75% gross margin on its chips.
Break Nvidia's pricing power, and the $7 trillion bill, the $2 trillion in revenue and the 10% of jobs all shrink with it.
This would also put the whole China story in a different light. Maybe it's not so much a "we don't want the Chinese to be competitive with similar chips to us" story as it is a "we don't want Chinese demand to drive up chip prices" one. Or probably both.
And, as such, you could actually think about the US export controls not as a national security measure but as a good old subsidy for US AI players (together with a handicap for their Chinese competitors), a way to limit the price of chips.
This holds even with China itself blocking Nvidia imports, since Chinese firms simply rent the chips abroad instead, in places like Southeast Asia, which is precisely what this whole Alice Huang/Megaspeed story is about.
The main obstacle for all this was, of course... Jensen. Obviously, the guy wanted the exact opposite: as many buyers as possible, Chinese players included, to keep chip prices and Nvidia’s margins sky-high. He was also the one man with the clout to make that happen.
All hard to prove, of course, but I can imagine that quite a few corks popped this week in Anthropic's offices: nothing like the news that the man keeping your biggest cost sky-high is out when you're a week away from a $1.2 trillion IPO.
Andrew Stoddart retweeted
Replies off
@elonmusk this needs to stop with political accounts. They shouldn't be able to do this.
Proud to announce that students in England will be able to study Ukrainian at GCSE.
It’s a chance for pupils to explore Ukraine’s rich culture and history and, for the Ukrainian community to remain connected to their heritage.
This is another step in our enduring support for Ukraine as part of the 100 Year Partnership 🇺🇦🇬🇧
RT @stephenpollard: This may be the most damning statement ever uttered by a Labour minister. It's so revealing of the attitude of a govern…
This quoted post is unavailable.
Andrew Stoddart retweeted
🇬🇧 The OBR just dropped 200 pages on Healey's first Budget.
I read it so you don't have to.
Tax is at a record 37.9% of GDP by 2027-28, past the old high of 37.2%.
Then it climbs every single year to 38.6%.
Frozen thresholds are doing way too much to workers since they get a pay rise, hand more of it over.
1.8x the national minimum wage now classes you as a higher tax rate payer - what the fuck?
Borrowing @ £133bn this year. In March they said £115bn. Seven months later it's £18bn worse. And it's higher than March in every year of the forecast because neither the OBR nor treasury has a clue what they’re doing.
Debt interest at £39bn in 2019-20.
£109bn last year 😩
£160bn by 2031-32 😩😩£15bn of this year's bill is extra bc inflation's pushing up index linked gilts, and we know the uk has a structural inflation problem, partly due to the relationship between treasury and BoE.
Headroom is £14.5bn, down from £21.7bn at the last Budget.
Keep the fuel duty freeze going and it's £10.2bn.
The OBR gives Healey a 56% chance of hitting his OWN FUCKING rule.
Debt will peak at 97.3% of GDP, still 95.6% in 2031-32. Five years and it barely moves which is completely against his fiscal demands.
How it affects you?
Growth 1% next year with gdp per capita basically the same as it has been since 2019
Inflation 3.4% when March said 2%.
Zero real pay growth in 2027.
Living standards in 2030-31?
Just 2% above pre-pandemic.
But don't worry. You're getting a £100 council tax rebate.
Jesus Christ.
Andrew Stoddart retweeted
Let me get this straight. Work all your life building a business. Sell that business to a rando - charged at 24%. Try to pass it on to your family - charged at 45%. Genuinely insane telegraph.co.uk/politics/202…
Andrew Stoddart retweeted
Replying to @Complex
Grok provided me with the full text.
A bit of life advice from Hol:
It’s a strange thing to realise and accept your mortality at 26 years young.
It’s just one of those things you ignore.
The days tick by and you just expect they will keep on coming; Until the unexpected happens.
I always imagined myself growing old, wrinkled and grey- most likely caused by the beautiful family (lots of kiddies) I planned on building with the love of my life.
I want that so bad it hurts.
That’s the thing about life; It is fragile, precious and unpredictable and each day is a gift, not a given right.
I’m 27 now.
I don’t want to go.
I love my life.
I am happy.. I owe that to my loved ones.
But the control is out of my hands.
I haven’t started this ‘note before I die’ so that death is feared - I like the fact that we are mostly ignorant to it’s inevitability.. Except when I want to talk about it and it is treated like a ‘taboo’ topic that will never happen to any of us.. That’s been a bit tough. I just want people to stop worrying so much about the small, meaningless stresses in life and try to remember that we all have the same fate after it all so do what you can to make your time feel worthy and great, minus the bullshit.
I have dropped lots of my thoughts below as I have had a lot of time to ponder life these last few months. Of course it’s the middle of the night when these random things pop in my head most!
Those times you are whinging about ridiculous things (something I have noticed so much these past few months), just think about someone who is really facing a problem. Be grateful for your minor issue and get over it. It’s okay to acknowledge that something is annoying but try not to carry on about it and negatively effect other people’s days.
Once you do that, get out there and take a freaking big breath of that fresh Aussie air deep in your lungs, look at how blue the sky is and how green the trees are; It is so beautiful. Think how lucky you are to be able to do just that - breathe.
You might have got caught in bad traffic today, or had a bad sleep because your beautiful babies kept you awake, or your hairdresser cut your hair too short. Your new fake nails might have got a chip, your boobs are too small, or you have cellulite on your arse and your belly is wobbling.
Let all that shit go.. I swear you will not be thinking of those things when it is your turn to go. It is all SO insignificant when you look at life as a whole. I’m watching my body waste away right before my eyes with nothing I can do about it and all I wish for now is that I could have just one more Birthday or Christmas with my family, or just one more day with my partner and dog. Just one more.
I hear people complaining about how terrible work is or about how hard it is to exercise - Be grateful you are physically able to. Work and exercise may seem like such trivial things ... until your body doesn’t allow you to do either of them.
I tried to live a healthy life, in fact, that was probably my major passion. Appreciate your good health and functioning body- even if it isn’t your ideal size. Look after it and embrace how amazing it is. Move it and nourish it with fresh food. Don’t obsess over it.
Remember there are more aspects to good health than the physical body.. work just as hard on finding your mental, emotional and spiritual happiness too. That way you might realise just how insignificant and unimportant having this stupidly portrayed perfect social media body really is.. While on this topic, delete any account that pops up on your news feeds that gives you any sense of feeling shit about yourself. Friend or not.. Be ruthless for your own well-being.
Be grateful for each day you don’t have pain and even the days where you are unwell with man flu, a sore back or a sprained ankle, accept it is shit but be thankful it isn’t life threatening and will go away.
Whinge less, people! .. And help each other more.
Give, give, give. It is true that you gain more happiness doing things for others than doing them for yourself. I wish I did this more. Since I have been sick, I have met the most incredibly giving and kind people and been the receiver of the most thoughtful and loving words and support from my family, friends and strangers; More than I could I ever give in return. I will never forget this and will be forever grateful to all of these people.
It is a weird thing having money to spend at the end.. when you’re dying. It’s not a time you go out and buy material things that you usually would, like a new dress. It makes you think how silly it is that we think it is worth spending so much money on new clothes and ‘things’ in our lives.
Buy your friend something kind instead of another dress, beauty product or jewellery for that next wedding. 1. No-one cares if you wear the same thing twice 2. It feels good. Take them out for a meal, or better yet, cook them a meal. Shout their coffee. Give/ buy them a plant, a massage or a candle and tell them you love them when you give it to them.
Value other people’s time. Don’t keep them waiting because you are shit at being on time. Get ready earlier if you are one of those people and appreciate that your friends want to share their time with you, not sit by themselves, waiting on a mate. You will gain respect too! Amen sister.
This year, our family agreed to do no presents and despite the tree looking rather sad and empty (I nearly cracked Christmas Eve!), it was so nice because people didn’t have the pressure of shopping and the effort went into writing a nice card for each other. Plus imagine my family trying to buy me a present knowing they would probably end up with it themselves.. strange! It might seem lame but those cards mean more to me than any impulse purchase could. Mind you, it was also easier to do in our house because we had no little kiddies there. Anyway, moral of the story- presents are not needed for a meaningful Christmas. Moving on.
Use your money on experiences.. Or at least don’t miss out on experiences because you spent all your money on material shit.
Put in the effort to do that day trip to the beach you keep putting off. Dip your feet in the water and dig your toes in the sand. Wet your face with salt water.
Get amongst nature.
Try just enjoying and being in moments rather than capturing them through the screen of your phone. Life isn’t meant to be lived through a screen nor is it about getting the perfect photo.. enjoy the bloody moment, people! Stop trying to capture it for everyone else.
Random rhetorical question. Are those several hours you spend doing your hair and make up each day or to go out for one night really worth it? I’ve never understood this about females 🤔.
Get up early sometimes and listen to the birds while you watch the beautiful colours the sun makes as it rises.
Listen to music.. really listen. Music is therapy. Old is best.
Cuddle your dog. Far out, I will miss that.
Talk to your friends. Put down your phone. Are they doing okay?
Travel if it’s your desire, don’t if it’s not.
Work to live, don’t live to work.
Seriously, do what makes your heart feel happy.
Eat the cake. Zero guilt.
Say no to things you really don’t want to do.
Don’t feel pressured to do what other people might think is a fulfilling life.. you might want a mediocre life and that is so okay.
Tell your loved ones you love them every time you get the chance and love them with everything you have.
Also, remember if something is making you miserable, you do have the power to change it - in work or love or whatever it may be. Have the guts to change. You don’t know how much time you’ve got on this earth so don’t waste it being miserable. I know that is said all the time but it couldn’t be more true.
Anyway, that’s just this one young gals life advice. Take it or leave it, I don’t mind!
Oh and one last thing, if you can, do a good deed for humanity (and myself) and start regularly donating blood. It will make you feel good with the added bonus of saving lives. I feel like it is something that is so overlooked considering every donation can save 3 lives! That is a massive impact each person can have and the process really is so simple.
Blood donation (more bags than I could keep up with counting) helped keep me alive for an extra year - a year I will be forever grateful that I got to spend it here on Earth with my family, friends and dog. A year I had some of the greatest times of my life.
..’Til we meet again.
Hol
Xoxo
Andrew Stoddart retweeted
On my way to the office this morning, I passed a group of young people protesting, a Palestinian flag draped over their shoulders.
And I asked myself a question I can't shake: why does this generation always fall into the same trap? No matter the history. No matter the context. Even the ones from wealthy families, who went to the best schools, who were dealt every good card. Always the same trap.
I don't think it's stupidity. I think it's a mechanism. And a mechanism can be taken apart, piece by piece.
A. The observation: everything the state touches becomes unaffordable.
Look at economist Mark Perry's famous chart, the one people call "the chart of the century." It tracks US prices since 2000.
At the top, what explodes: hospital services, college tuition, textbooks, childcare, housing. Increases of +100%, +150%, up to +250%, far above general inflation.
At the bottom, what collapses: TVs, software, phones, toys, clothing. A TV today costs a fraction of what it did in 2000, for an infinitely better product.
Look at what separates the two groups. It isn't technology. It isn't complexity. It's one variable: how much the state is involved.
At the top, sectors that are subsidized, regulated, shielded from competition, where the state funds demand and blocks supply. At the bottom, sectors where companies fight every single morning to serve you better and cheaper.
B. The mechanism: why it's systematic.
When the state subsidizes demand without freeing supply, prices rise. Every time. Guaranteed student loans, and universities raise tuition. Housing aid plus blocked building permits, and rents skyrocket. Administered healthcare, and bureaucracy eats the budget before it ever reaches the patient.
In France it's even more vicious, because the price doesn't disappear: it hides. You never see the hospital bill, you pay it through payroll contributions. You never see the cost of school, you pay it through taxes. Public spending at 57% of GDP, one of the heaviest tax burdens in the world, more than €3.4 trillion in debt. And the result? Overflowing ERs, falling PISA scores, young people who can't afford to live in the city where they work.
The market didn't fail in these sectors. It was never allowed in.
C. Suffering demands a culprit.
A 22-year-old lives all of this in their bones. They can't find a place to live. Their degree either buries them in debt or opens no doors. The future feels blocked. That suffering is real, and I don't deny it for a second.
But human beings can't stand suffering without a culprit. They need a face. A scapegoat.
And this is where everything is decided: who taught them how to read the world?
D. Whoever tells the story picks the villain.
Schools are public. Universities are public. Culture runs on grants. Film goes through funding committees. Public broadcasting shapes the narratives. The people handing down the interpretive framework are, overwhelmingly, paid by the very system that creates the problem.
Do you really think that system is going to name itself as the culprit?
No. It names the capitalist. The boss. The landlord. "The rich." The multinational. The commercial West. Same role, same casting, every time.
E. One lens, a thousand causes.
And this brings me back to that flag. A generation taught to read every situation through a single lens, oppressor on one side, rich, Western, capitalist, oppressed on the other, will apply that lens everywhere. To housing. To climate. To conflicts on the other side of the world. The cause changes, the lens stays. That's why the trap is always the same: it's not the cause that draws them in, it's the way of thinking that was installed in them.
F. The perfect inversion.
Here's the irony. Capitalism is the force that drove down the price of almost everything it touched. The state is the force that blew up the price of almost everything it captured. And young people blame the first for the crimes of the second.
It's like blaming the firefighter for the fire because you saw him at the scene.
G. The ballot box confirms it.
In the US, a few weeks out from the midterms, a large share of urban young voters is getting ready to vote Democrat for more state, more spending, more regulation. New York elected a self-described socialist mayor, carried by young voters, on promises of rent freezes and city-run grocery stores. Rent freezes, the policy that has made housing scarcer everywhere it's been tried. The cure that worsens the disease.
In France, it's the same play in two acts. Part of the youth votes for the radical left, which promises more state. Another part votes for the center, which promises to "manage" the state well, and has dug the debt deeper than ever. Two different ballots, one shared assumption: the problem is the market, the solution is the state.
H. The way out.
These young people aren't stupid. They're right to be angry. They're just aiming at the wrong target.
The day they understand that their rent, their tuition and their hospital are expensive precisely because the state runs them, their anger will change direction. They'll stop protesting against those who create. They'll start protesting against those who capture.
That day, the greatest intellectual scam of our time will be over.
Andrew Stoddart retweeted
In the UK civil service is larger now than ever before. It’s almost impossible to be sacked with employees being 12 times more likely to die on the job.
They take more sick days and have some unbelievable perks : 🧵
Andrew Stoddart retweeted
Dear Secretary Bessent @SecScottBessent,
My name is Everett Stern. In 2010 I was a compliance officer at @HSBC. From a back office in New Castle, Delaware, I watched billions of dollars move to drug cartels, sanctioned regimes, and terrorist organizations. The enemies of the United States. I documented it, I escalated it, and when the bank would not act, I took it to the @FBI, the @CIA, and eventually the @SECGov.
The result was a $1.92 billion settlement. At the time, it was one of the largest in American history. It was also about five weeks of the bank’s profit. Not one banker was charged. Not one went to prison.
I paid a different price. I lost my career, my savings, and my place in the industry I had trained for. I was blacklisted. Every door in American finance closed at once. I slept on a camping cot in a 300 square foot apartment because I could not afford a bed, and I waited tables at @PFChangs to eat. I tell you this not for sympathy, but so you understand that I know exactly what it costs to do the right thing in American finance, and exactly how little the system does in return.
I made that sacrifice because I believed it would change something.
Yesterday, your department fined @BankofAmerica $1.2 billion for failing to report more than $5 billion in suspicious transactions, some of it tied by your own findings to Chinese laundering networks, narcotics, and the southwest border, alongside 475 apparent sanctions violations touching Russia, Iran, and global terrorism. The bank admitted it willfully violated the Bank Secrecy Act.
Fourteen years after HSBC. A bank with “America” in its name. And once again, not one individual charged.
Secretary Bessent, I want to say plainly what I believe you already know. The fines are not working.
A fine is paid by shareholders, absorbed by the balance sheet, and forgotten by the next earnings call. Bank of America reported earnings this morning. Nobody who set the alert thresholds, nobody who decided the 2024 cease and desist could wait, nobody who chose the backlog over the law will lose a single thing they value. Their lives are untouched. That is the entire reason the behavior repeats.
This is money laundering. This is blood money. Money that reaches a cartel buys fentanyl that kills Americans. Money that reaches a terrorist organization buys the next attack. This country has fought a war on drugs and a war on terror for decades, at enormous cost in lives and treasure, and all the while we have allowed the financing to flow through institutions we charter and regulate. Cut off the money and we win. We have never seriously tried.
There is also a question of equal justice that I cannot let go.
Before I walked into the FBI building to report HSBC, I stopped in front of the Great Seal on the wall and read the words engraved beneath it: “Justice is the defense of our liberty.” I believed that. I still want to. But every day in this country, people go to prison for crimes that are nothing next to moving money for the people who want Americans dead. A suit, a title, and a corporate badge should not be a shield from the consequences that apply to everyone else. If a street dealer goes to prison for what he sells, the banker who moved the cartel’s money should be standing next to him.
I also want to raise something that is rarely said in these conversations. Why has no one inside Bank of America come forward the way I did? The answer is that everyone in American banking knows what happened to me, and to the whistleblowers who came after. The last person who spoke up is the only policy anyone believes. That is a culture problem, and it starts with leadership, in the banks and in the agencies that regulate them.
This is not a political issue. It has spanned administrations of both parties. It is a national security issue, and I am asking you to treat it as one.
Three things would change the math overnight.
Refer individuals for criminal prosecution. Not the analyst in the queue. The executives who set the thresholds and chose the risk. One banker in handcuffs would do more than every fine in Treasury’s history combined.
End “too big to jail.” An institution cannot be too big to fail and too big to jail at the same time. If it is the first, it must be held to a higher standard, not a lower one.
And if Bank of America will not act as America’s bank, review its charter. A national charter is a privilege granted on behalf of the American people. It should be conditioned on not moving money for the people trying to kill them.
Secretary Bessent, you said yesterday that these actions send a clear message that even the biggest institutions are not above the law. With respect, the institution was never the problem. The people inside it are above the law, and they know it. Until that changes, I will keep writing letters like this one, and the next bank will keep paying the next fine.
I gave up everything I had to stop this. I am asking you to use the power you have to finish it.
Respectfully,
Everett A. Stern
HSBC Whistleblower
Founder and Intelligence Director, Tactical Rabbit
Andrew Stoddart retweeted
The UK taxpayer has footed the bill due to government mismanagement.
Over 10 years here are some of the worst cases: 🧵















