Brenden retweeted
The so-called “calculator riots” of 1986 serve as a powerful reminder that today’s anxieties about artificial intelligence replacing human thinking are far from new.
In April 1986, a determined group of math educators staged a vocal protest outside the National Council of Teachers of Mathematics (NCTM) annual convention in Washington, D.C. Led by influential textbook author John Saxon, demonstrators carried signs declaring, “The Button’s Nothin’ ’Til the Brain’s Trained.”
They were opposing the NCTM’s new recommendation to incorporate electronic calculators into mathematics education at every grade level, including homework and exams.
The protesters worried that reliance on calculators would erode students’ mental arithmetic skills, numerical intuition, and deep conceptual understanding, potentially creating a generation of “calcuholics” overly dependent on machines.
The NCTM countered that calculators would free students from repetitive, low-level calculations, enabling them to tackle more complex problem-solving and higher-order thinking. Ultimately, the debate led to a pragmatic compromise: students would first master core mathematical concepts and mental strategies before using calculators as tools for more advanced work.
This balanced approach allowed technology to enhance, rather than replace, mathematical reasoning.
Today, as schools navigate the rapid rise of generative AI, the 1986 calculator compromise offers a valuable blueprint: prioritize genuine understanding first, then thoughtfully integrate powerful new tools.
Brenden retweeted
A list of evidence based peragogy that I'd wager 90% of educators in America don't know but should:
🍎 John Sweller’s Cognitive Load Theory
🍎 Barak Rosenshine’s Principles of Instruction
🍎 Retrieval practice and interleaving
🍎 Explicit instruction
🍎 Frequent opportunities to respond
🍎 Cold calling
Why don't American teacher prep colleges teach these things?
Brenden retweeted
Retrieval practice doesn’t “strengthen memory.” It changes what information the learner treats as reliable when they’re under cognitive pressure. 🧵⬇️
Brenden retweeted
Twitter is a hilarious place. I’ve got lots of replies saying “who is saying you don’t need multiplication facts? Nobody is saying that.”
Lots of people in my real life believe it! Principals that RUN SCHOOLS believe it! Curriculum consultants believe it!
Brenden retweeted
One of the biggest drivers in my shift toward explicit instruction has been simplifying everything. I used to try to gamify, activify, and engagify every lesson—bells, whistles, and all. It wasn’t sustainable, and it wasn’t especially effective. I taught under the impression that I had to “make it fun.”
One of the best lessons I taught all year happened today, and here’s what it required: a visualizer, a blank outline map of the Caribbean, and all the critical content I know to explicitly teach my students with. That’s it. Add in lots of questions, choral response, turn-and-talk, concrete examples, active observation, and show calls, and you have everything you need for an effective and engaging lesson.
In previous years, I would have turned this simple Caribbean geography lesson into a high-energy, activity-based experience: stations, a gallery walk, or some kind of puzzle or game. There would be movement, noise, and “engagement,” but most of the new information would be lost in the shuffle. Working memory would be so overloaded that very little would actually stick.
Now I know teaching explicitly and simply is the most effective way to make learning happen.
Brenden retweeted
Misuse of p-values is a prevalent issue in scientific research. P-values are often misunderstood and misapplied, leading to incorrect conclusions. A p-value measures the probability of obtaining results at least as extreme as the observed ones, assuming that the null hypothesis is true. Common problems with p-values include:
✅ Overemphasis on significance: Researchers often focus on whether p-values are below a threshold (e.g., 0.05), ignoring the effect size and practical significance.
✅ P-hacking: Manipulating data or experimental conditions to achieve statistically significant p-values.
✅ Misinterpretation: Believing that a low p-value proves the alternative hypothesis or that a high p-value confirms the null hypothesis.
✅ Ignoring context: Failing to consider the broader context of the study, including prior evidence and the research design.
The graph shown in this post is a modified version of this Wikipedia image: es.wikipedia.org/wiki/Valor_…
Want to deepen your understanding of statistics with R? Sign up for my online course, "Statistical Methods in R."
Learn more by visiting this link: statisticsglobe.com/online-c…
#datasciencetraining #Data #DataViz #Python #Statistical #pythoncode #datavis #database
Brenden retweeted
We should ask children to memorise the multiplication tables. Fluent recall isn’t old-fashioned, it’s essential. It frees working memory, speeds up problem solving, and gives every child a solid foundation for fractions, algebra, and everything that comes after.
If you want children to think deeply in maths, start by giving them facts they can retrieve instantly.
Brenden retweeted
“Teachers will do everything they can to get the Dots up for kids…..it’s the middle managagement that gets in the way.” @amandavande1
(*Insert massive round of applause from 200+ people) @researchEDCan
Brenden retweeted
We naturally acquire through pure inquiry/discovery biologically primary knowledge, like spoken language or basic social skills, but biologically secondary knowledge, like math, science, or history, must be systematically taught. Curiosity alone can’t replace that foundation.
Brenden retweeted
Anna Stokke on Where Math Education Went Wrong - and How to Fix It
SUUUUCH a good episode!
educationrickshaw.com/2025/1…
Brenden retweeted
“So you skipped modeling because you wanted students to ‘discover’ it themselves?”
“Yes Dave.”
“Even though they had no prior knowledge of the concept?”
“Yes Dave.”
“And you’re surprised they didn’t understand it?”
“Yes Dave.”
Brenden retweeted
this 17 year old homeschooled girl refuted a conjecture that was unsolved for 40 years, and which professional mathematicians worked on for years without solving
she was rejected from most graduate programs she applied to, because she did not have a degree
Brenden retweeted
Replying to @MrZachG
Here was a lesson from my daughter's 1st grade fall math curriculum which is constructivist...little practice and oh yeah kids read around 45 words per min. Embarrassingly bad instructional design. Oklahoma Big Ideas. Might as well burn taxpayer dollars.
Brenden retweeted
The tale of two curriculums
One is based on a constructivist perspective, the other is Direct Instruction.
Same topic. Same kid.
One gives a thousand times more practice!!!
Brenden retweeted
The science of learning isn't about prescriptions, it's about probabilities. And this is where knowing the boundary conditions of any principle matters so much. Knowing when not to use it can be as important as knowing when to.
This is my problem with every lesson starting with retrieval practice "because science".
A principle applied everywhere becomes dogma; a principle applied within its limits increases the probability of it being effective, because it honours the conditions that make it work in the first place.
Retrieval practice is a key driver of learning but there are a lot of contexts where retrieval might be counterproductive: introducing new concepts or when prior knowledge is insufficient to make retrieval attempts meaningful rather than random guessing.
The boundary conditions matter precisely because they reveal the mechanisms underlying the effect. Retrieval practice works through the effortful reconstruction of knowledge from memory, which strengthens retrieval pathways. But if there's nothing meaningful to retrieve, or if the retrieval demands exceed working memory capacity, the mechanism breaks down. The practice becomes ritual rather than science.
Interleaving benefits discrimination between similar concepts, but becomes less valuable when categories are already easily distinguishable. Spacing enhances retention through forgetting and relearning, but may hinder initial acquisition when foundational knowledge is still forming.
Senior leaders saying "use retrieval practice when learners have established some initial knowledge of the material, when the cognitive demand matches their capacity, and when errors can be corrected through feedback" is less compelling than "start every lesson with retrieval practice." The nuanced version requires professional judgment; the simplified version offers algorithmic certainty.
This is where we need to move away from "what does the research say" but "under what conditions does this research apply/not apply to my context and how can I apply it?"
Brenden retweeted
New study: Retrieval practice doesn’t just boost memory, it helps learners notice when knowledge matters, making transfer more likely. Key takeaway:
➡️ Instead of only testing “What is X?”, also ask “Which situation best illustrates X?” or “Where would this apply?”
➡️ Teachers should think of retrieval as “application rehearsal,” not just checking memory.
sciencedirect.com/science/ar…
Brenden retweeted
Been reading a lot about predictive processing and I think it's almost certainly going to be the next frontier of learning science and instructional design, particularly with the emergence of LLMs. One of the best voices on this from an education perspective is @AdamWteach and this is another great post from him:
open.substack.com/pub/predic…
Brenden retweeted
GPT-5 just casually did new mathematics.
Sebastien Bubeck gave it an open problem from convex optimization, something humans had only partially solved. GPT-5-Pro sat down, reasoned for 17 minutes, and produced a correct proof improving the known bound from 1/L all the way to 1.5/L.
This wasn’t in the paper. It wasn’t online. It wasn’t memorized. It was new math. Verified by Bubeck himself.
Humans later closed the gap at 1.75/L, but GPT-5 independently advanced the frontier.
A machine just contributed original research-level mathematics.
If you’re not completely stunned by this, you’re not paying attention.
We’ve officially entered the era where AI isn’t just learning math, it’s creating it. @sama @OpenAI @kevinweil @gdb @markchen90
Claim: gpt-5-pro can prove new interesting mathematics.
Proof: I took a convex optimization paper with a clean open problem in it and asked gpt-5-pro to work on it. It proved a better bound than what is in the paper, and I checked the proof it's correct.
Details below.
Readers added context they thought people might want to know
Unlike the commenter's claims, the 1.75/L paper was released before ChatGPT came up with the 1.5/L proof.
While no paper for the 1.5/L bound existed, no human would've attempted to write a paper on it, because it is strictly worse than the existing 1.75/L bound.
x.com/sebastienbubec…
arxiv.org/pdf/2503.10138…































