Pinned Tweet
How Far Behind Is China in the AI Chip Race? Cambricon, Huawei, SMIC and Nvidia
youtu.be/oSaiOl9jHXU
In this video:
• Cambricon Q3: 3.53B yuan (~$530M) in sales, ~40% net margin, but a miss vs. expectations and a cash-flow dip
• SMIC's 29.9% gross margin and Huawei's group revenue
• Training vs. inference, and where Huawei's Ascend 950 fits
• The evidence: CloudMatrix and SemiAnalysis's independent test
• Why there's no single "years behind" number
• CUDA, TileLang, vLLM and ZLUDA: can software loosen Nvidia's grip?
• Nvidia's leadership change and what's actually on the record
• The factory constraints, and Taiwan, Korea and Japan's role
• What to watch in Nvidia's earnings Tuesday
Tony Nash retweeted
Far be it from me to assume someone posting from Lithuania might understand the intricacies of U.S. export control laws, so please indulge me extending you this helping hand.
And despite your clear command of some of the U.S.' more colorful idioms, I'll keep it simple.
1. As an exporter of controlled dual-use technology, Nvidia is subject to compliance with the Export Control Reform Act of 2018 (ECRA). ECRA is a more scoped implementation of the broader Export Administration Regulations (EAR), which itself is statutorily based on the International Emergency Economic Powers Act (IEEPA, also the basis of most of OFAC's authorities at Treasury). The Commerce Control List (CCL) defines the categories of dual-use products that require a license to be lawfully transferred to a foreign party.
2. Unlike the IEEPA-based tariffs of last year, the law and processes governing ECRA are well-understood by all stakeholders and treated as settled law by both industry and the U.S. Government.
3. The Bureau of Industry and Security (BIS) at Commerce is the empowered entity to implement ECRA, and has two agencies that govern this process: Export Administration (licensing and certification to export covered products/technology/methods), and Export Enforcement (federal law enforcement agency that investigates potentially criminal and civil violations of ECRA).
4. Criminal violations have three tests: Willfulness, Knowledge, and Harm to the Regulatory Regime. If one or more of these three tests cannot be established during an investigation, potential violations are considered for civil penalties. In both cases, IEEPA's penalty statutes apply.
5. When applying for an export license, an exporter such as Nvidia has to provide all details of the proposed transaction, including the end user, any intermediaries to the transaction, the covered export product in question, quantities, value, and other related information. A licensing officer reviews the information at hand, often has some back and forth with the export license requester to confirm specific details, and ultimately determines if a license is: issued, flatly denied, or returned without authorization (a half-denial that allows for reapplication).
6. When exporting against a license, the exporter (or their designated agent, such as a freight forwarder) logs into the Automated Export System (AES) system managed by Customs and Border Protection (CBP). The exporter or its lawful agent provides the export license from BIS, a companion End Use Certificate issued by BIS in the name of the authorized end user, and other required documents along with the shipment information. This package comprises an Electronic Export Information filing (EEI) and is all harmonized on the back end in CBP's Automated Customs Environment (ACE).
7. ALL OF THESE STEPS are treated under law as an AFFIRMATIVE REQUIREMENT of compliance on the part of the exporter. Which means it's NOT an ASSUMPTION that Nvidia do all it can to ensure its covered exports do not ultimately end up in the hands of unauthorized parties—IT'S LITERALLY THE LAW.
8. None of these steps requires a security clearance, because it's all plainly spelled out in the regulations. And if there's any question on the part of an exporter or end user, there's an entire ecosystem of thousands of forwarders, legal professionals, BIS personnel, and customs brokers who specialize in U.S. export control compliance.
9. Having established that Nvidia, like any other exporter, does in fact have an obligation under U.S. law to establish rigorous controls on their export processes, your entire ignorant point collapses on itself, with only one actually material question:
To what extent do the agents at Export Enforcement, or FBI and HSI (who are also empowered under ECRA to enforce export control laws), as well as prosecutors at the Department of Justice, have reason to believe that Nvidia may have engaged in conduct that potentially represents ECRA violations?
Replying to @maphumanintent
You assumption is that Nvidia is supposed to engage in national security checks?
Do they have clearance for it?
You fucking muppet
Seems like this could take out some revenue opportunity ahead of the $ANT IPO. Nobody knows yet, but it seems to have FDR-esque regulatory stank all over it.
👇My latest. Also, subscribe to Main Street Alpha on GNG.
New from Main Street Alpha by Tony Nash (@TonyNashNerd): Going Into Earnings, How Fragile Are Nvidia's Accounting and "Credit Guarantees"?
gngresearch.com/articles/goi…
1
8
1,541
Tony Nash retweeted
Week Ahead: 5% Yields, $NVDA Earnings, Trump–Xi in Shenzhen and the Anthropic IPO
youtube.com/watch?v=_75ZI7Zz…
00:00 Rates up, stocks up
00:51 Where Friday ended
01:40 Last week's 3 tests
03:03 Nvidia after Huang
03:33 Washington's questions
04:20 Sunday night: Japan and China
05:05 Monday: Treasury, Warsh, RBA
05:40 Tuesday: retail sales, Home Depot
06:24 Nvidia earnings
08:06 Wednesday: Target, Lowe's, housing
08:36 Europe and 20-year bonds
08:57 Fed minutes
09:27 Shenzhen: Trump meets Xi
10:22 The Nov. 27 minerals date
10:48 Nvidia and export controls
11:54 Thursday: Walmart
12:32 Anthropic IPO
12:59 Friday: Lagarde, Cook
13:33 3 tests for next week
🎯 "few directors of major American companies have experience assessing political risk and the nature of regimes like communist China’s. They don’t learn it at business school or law school. Many directors have never worked or lived in a hostile environment like China’s"
Absolutely thrilled to be back on @WSJopinion pages again. My oped on #Nvidia & lessons for corporate boards, based on my experience in China & as a public company director. wsj.com/opinion/nvidia-shows…
Week Ahead: 5% Yields, $NVDA Earnings, Trump–Xi in Shenzhen and the Anthropic IPO
youtube.com/watch?v=_75ZI7Zz…
00:00 Rates up, stocks up
00:51 Where Friday ended
01:40 Last week's 3 tests
03:03 Nvidia after Huang
03:33 Washington's questions
04:20 Sunday night: Japan and China
05:05 Monday: Treasury, Warsh, RBA
05:40 Tuesday: retail sales, Home Depot
06:24 Nvidia earnings
08:06 Wednesday: Target, Lowe's, housing
08:36 Europe and 20-year bonds
08:57 Fed minutes
09:27 Shenzhen: Trump meets Xi
10:22 The Nov. 27 minerals date
10:48 Nvidia and export controls
11:54 Thursday: Walmart
12:32 Anthropic IPO
12:59 Friday: Lagarde, Cook
13:33 3 tests for next week
Tony Nash retweeted
A six figure coaching job in Texas for a school in Virginia and y'all are telling me no American could do this??
Only an H-1B?
The University of Virginia (@UVA) just filed a notice of intent to hire an H-1B "Performance Improvement Coach"
Salary: $131,744
The employment will occur remotely at a residential home in Georgetown, Texas.
No American citizen was qualified for this job.
Tony Nash retweeted
Jensen… sells chips to China, bangs subordinates and spies, commits fraud in NVDA chip financing, no successor plans and no insurance….
And the tech and finance world screaming for him to come back lol
Tony Nash retweeted
Great quick read from @TonyNashNerd at GNG Research!
Tony believes the AI boom's real bottleneck is the power grid, not chips. Data centers need giant transformers and lots of electricity, and both are in short supply.
Equipment makers like GE Vernova and Siemens Energy have huge backlogs and are charging more. Power companies like Constellation and Vistra are locking in 20-year deals with Amazon, Google and Meta.
The catch is that none of it helps until the grid approves the hookup, and in Texas those approvals are on pause. The companies already in line are making money, and everyone else waits and pays more.
Tony Nash on GNG Research
gngresearch.com/authors/tony…
This Week Ahead: Nvidia earnings, Trump–Xi in Shenzhen, the Anthropic IPO and what retailers reveal about the consumer. Stocks rebounded. Borrowing costs climbed. Can the rally survive 5% Treasury yields?
youtu.be/_75ZI7ZzoPE






















