Transparency Task Force (@TransparencyTF) header
Transparency Task Force (@TransparencyTF) profile picture
Denmead, Hampshire, England
Joined May 2015
Transparency Task Force retweeted
<Shameless plug coming up> What better Christmas present to buy someone than a nice book? My story, "Truth and Li(e)bor" is on sale at Amazon and elsewhere: amazon.co.uk/Truth-Li-bor-So… Enjoy the holidays with your loved ones, and stay safe.
3
5
📢THERE'S STILL TIME TO BOOK YOUR PLACE AT TONIGHT's ONLINE EVENT! "Why We Must Protect the Wellbeing of Whistleblowers; dedictaed to Simon Andriesz R.I.P." TONIGHT | 6pm–8:30pm UK time | ONLINE | FREE TO ATTEND What happens to those who speak out against wrongdoing? Who protects the people who expose misconduct, malpractice, fraud and regulatory failure?And what are the consequences when the very institutions responsible for protecting them fail to do so? Join us this evening for an important online event bringing together whistleblowers, campaigners, journalists and advocates from the UK and around the world. Our exceptional line-up includes: • Andy Verity, BBC Journalist and Broadcaster • John Robertson, Simon Andriesz's friend, adviser and representative • Jasthi Alom, Former FCA Supervisor • Professor Brendan Lyon, KPMG whistleblower • John Christmas, EBRD whistleblower • Matt Connolly, LIBOR campaigner (via pre-recorded statement) • Artur Nadolny, RSA Whistleblower Files • Dr Ian Foxley, founder of Parrhesia • Dr Jacqueline Garrick, founder of Whistleblowers of America • Dr Georgia Richards, Preventable Deaths Tracker • And many more. We'll also be examining the FCA's handling of Simon Andriesz's whistleblowing, the treatment and wellbeing of whistleblowers, regulatory accountability and the potential for further Parliamentary action. Everyone is welcome. You don't need to attend the entire session, and a recording will be available afterwards. BOOK YOUR PLACE NOW: transparencytaskforce.org/wh… Please share this post to help us reach others who care about whistleblowing, transparency and accountability. #Whistleblowing #Whistleblower #Whistleblowers #WhistleblowerProtection #ProtectWhistleblowers #WhistleblowerWellbeing #SpeakUp #FinancialMisconduct #RegulatoryFailure #FinancialConductAuthority #FCA #FinancialServices #FinancialCrime #Accountability #Transparency #Justice #PublicInterest #CorporateGovernance
📢UPCOMING EVENT: "Why We Must Protect the Wellbeing of Whistleblowers; dedicated to Simon Andriesz R.I.P." 📅 Tuesday 17 November 2026 ⏰ 6pm-8pm GMT 📍 Online via Zoom Following the important @appgonifandffs summit held in Parliament on 2 November, we are bringing the conversation forward to examine what needs to happen next to ensure whistleblowers are properly protected. Dedicated to the memory of Simon Andriesz, this event will explore the serious consequences of retaliation against those who speak out in the public interest, and the urgent need for greater accountability from regulators and employers. We will revisit the issues raised at the parliamentary summit, examine the FCA's independent review into its handling of Simon's case, and consider the practical reforms needed to ensure whistleblowers are listened to, taken seriously and protected rather than punished. How do we create a society in which speaking out is recognised as an act of public service, rather than something that puts individuals at risk? Join us for this important discussion. Click here 👇for full details and to book your place: transparencytaskforce.org/wh… Please share with anyone who may be interested.
8
9
277
Transparency Task Force retweeted
1,375 WHISTLEBLOWER REPORTS. 80 ACTED ON. FOI figures seen by @TheBanker: @TheFCA took direct action on 6% of new whistleblowing reports in the year to March 2026, down from 13%. Backlog: 1,400 cases. @TransparencyTF @stevemiddi1 @MLorrM @Victoria_Rixon @JohnCleese thebanker.com/content/1790bd…
12
1
7
368
Transparency Task Force retweeted
JOIN US TONIGHT ! Tonight at 6pm UK time I will be on a free online event, Why We Must Protect the Wellbeing of Whistleblowers, dedicated to the memory of Simon Andriesz. It runs until 8:30pm on Zoom, and more than 60 people have already booked. Apart from me, many others will speak. They include Andy Verity of the BBC, John Robertson, Andy Agathangelou, Jasthi Alom, Ian Foxley, Iain Mitchell KC and many others. You will also get a chance to hear my broken English. If you are a victim of misconduct or regulatory failure, a whistleblower, or someone who supports them, please join us. We will discuss what the FCA review must achieve and how whistleblowers can be protected. Please share this post with anyone who should be in the room. The booking link is in the comments. Thank you Alex Zitkus and the Transparency Task Force for organising it. @stevemiddi1 @MLorrM @TransparencyTF @nw_nicholas @Wftproof @J_Robertson_UK @TweetDreams333 @TracyAustin_ @CompassnInCare @beyondfreefall @sharmilaxx @CastletonLee @stugoo17 @andyverity @newlands_chris Book your free place here: transparencytaskforce.org/wh…
4
19
1
23
949
📺 Financial Services and Markets Bill: Second Reading You can access a speech by Kirsty Blackman MP here: parliamentlive.tv/event/inde… We are very grateful to Kirsty for speaking up for consumer interests. @KirstySNP
2
3
106
📺 Financial Services and Markets Bill: Second Reading You can access a speech by Mike Martin MP here: parliamentlive.tv/event/inde… We are very grateful to Mike for speaking up for consumer interests. @ThreshedThought
64
📺 Financial Services and Markets Bill: Second Reading You can access a speech by Bobby Dean MP here: parliamentlive.tv/event/inde… We are very grateful to Bobby for speaking up for consumer interests. @Bobby_Dean
4
226
📺 Financial Services and Markets Bill: Second Reading You can access a speech by Seema Malhotra MP here: parliamentlive.tv/event/inde… We are very grateful to Seema for speaking up for consumer interests. @SeemaMalhotra1
1
2
120
Transparency Task Force retweeted
16 years. That is how long Chris Richardson has been fighting over what happened to his business and the Coniston Hotel. Now the Metropolitan Police has reopened an investigation into alleged fraud. That alone should make people pay attention. Chris kept going after failed civil proceedings, previous investigations, regulatory reviews and years of being told, in one form or another, that the matter was finished. It was not finished for him. Now detectives are seeking bank documents through a High Court production order, including material connected with @TheFCA-commissioned Promontory review. And then comes another deeply uncomfortable issue... .. Records. @thetimes reports that Promontory, which carried out the FCA review, destroyed documents after its work was completed. If evidence relevant to allegations this serious existed, who authorised its destruction? What did the FCA know? What records still survive? And how many other GRG victims may have faced the same problem when trying to prove what happened to their businesses? It goes directly to how evidence was handled, how GRG cases were reviewed, and whether SMEs were ever given a fair chance to challenge what happened to them. Chris Richardson’s persistence deserves enormous respect. @jameshurley also deserves credit for continuing to investigate cases that powerful institutions would probably prefer everyone forgot.
VERY IMPORTANT DEVELOPMENT! You are so, so right @MLorrM . This (yet another) superb article by @jameshurley at @thetimes is significant on several levels: 1) It speaks to what can happen when you just refuse to give up; Chris Richardson’s tenacity, persistence, determination, focus and resilience over many years has been outstanding. We all salute you in your refusal to give up and back down, Chris - it is really inspiring and gives us all more of that one special ingredient we all need – hope. 2) It speaks about the power of the media in getting stuff ‘out there’ and once again we find ourselves very grateful to the amazing work of James Hurley. James, we know you know this already, but we are all off-the-scale grateful to you for your huge and seemingly insatiable appetite to continue to expose what needs to be exposed – thank you from us all, again. 3) It speaks to the other-side’s attempts to dodge justice through destroying records. IMHO it was never, ever right for Promontory to destroy records, or be allowed to do that. One wonders why @TheFCA allowed thato happen? I’ve just spoken to Chris and he’s allowed me to quote what he just said: “The FCA allowed Promontory to destroy the records.” 4) And through that failure to disclose, is this not (yet another) egregious miscarriage of justice involving banks? And if so, how many other SMEs have been cheated out of justice through the control of evidence in this way? 5) It speaks to a theme that applies in so many cases – the allegation of manipulative sale of assets at below market value. That makes this case far more important than its own case. Just imagine the potential if it could somehow be a pathfinding, precedent-setting case that others may follow. We’ll make this breakthrough a key talking point at Thursday’s 5pm TTF meeting on Zoom. If you are in any way a victim of banking malpractice and/or regulatory failure and would like to join US on Thursday (19th November 2026) at 5pm and are not already part of that group please get in touch through our website transparencytaskforce.org/co… Should the @CommonsTreasury Committee led by @Meg_HillierMP get interested in this? @ArturNadol7566 @stevemiddi1 @Carlier_J87 @BankConfidenti1 @CarshaltonArt @johnmcdonnellMP @premnsikka
20
35
941
VERY IMPORTANT DEVELOPMENT! You are so, so right @MLorrM . This (yet another) superb article by @jameshurley at @thetimes is significant on several levels: 1) It speaks to what can happen when you just refuse to give up; Chris Richardson’s tenacity, persistence, determination, focus and resilience over many years has been outstanding. We all salute you in your refusal to give up and back down, Chris - it is really inspiring and gives us all more of that one special ingredient we all need – hope. 2) It speaks about the power of the media in getting stuff ‘out there’ and once again we find ourselves very grateful to the amazing work of James Hurley. James, we know you know this already, but we are all off-the-scale grateful to you for your huge and seemingly insatiable appetite to continue to expose what needs to be exposed – thank you from us all, again. 3) It speaks to the other-side’s attempts to dodge justice through destroying records. IMHO it was never, ever right for Promontory to destroy records, or be allowed to do that. One wonders why @TheFCA allowed thato happen? I’ve just spoken to Chris and he’s allowed me to quote what he just said: “The FCA allowed Promontory to destroy the records.” 4) And through that failure to disclose, is this not (yet another) egregious miscarriage of justice involving banks? And if so, how many other SMEs have been cheated out of justice through the control of evidence in this way? 5) It speaks to a theme that applies in so many cases – the allegation of manipulative sale of assets at below market value. That makes this case far more important than its own case. Just imagine the potential if it could somehow be a pathfinding, precedent-setting case that others may follow. We’ll make this breakthrough a key talking point at Thursday’s 5pm TTF meeting on Zoom. If you are in any way a victim of banking malpractice and/or regulatory failure and would like to join US on Thursday (19th November 2026) at 5pm and are not already part of that group please get in touch through our website transparencytaskforce.org/co… Should the @CommonsTreasury Committee led by @Meg_HillierMP get interested in this? @ArturNadol7566 @stevemiddi1 @Carlier_J87 @BankConfidenti1 @CarshaltonArt @johnmcdonnellMP @premnsikka
The Times' revelation today that the Metropolitan Police has reopened its investigation into the Coniston Hotel sale - RBS case - should prompt some uncomfortable questions in Ireland about Ulster Bank's Global Restructuring Group Ireland (GRGI). 🔹In 2014, Ulster Bank commissioned Mason Hayes & Curran to review allegations that GRGI had artificially distressed otherwise viable businesses and put them on a journey towards insolvency. 🔹The review examined 32 customer files from a population of 1,965 customer connections, interviewed 39 staff and reviewed approximately 140,000 pages. 🔹But what did that review actually investigate? It focused on the allegations in the Tomlinson Report. 🔹It did NOT constitute a forensic investigation of the origination, accounting treatment & subsequent operation of the concealed derivative-related credit lines in the Ulster Bank scandal.
1
21
1
51
1,942
✒️ FCA ANNUAL PUBLIC MEETING 2026 - RESPONSES TO UNANSWERED QUESTIONS Here’s a snippet from the website: “Watch the recording of the meeting: webinars.fca.org.uk/annual-p… and read the transcript: fca.org.uk/publication/trans… This includes opening remarks from Ashley Alder, our chair and Nikhil Rathi, chief executive followed by questions from delegates. The meeting brought together consumers, firms and stakeholders from across the UK to discuss our Annual report and accounts 2025/26 and the issues shaping financial services. It was the first time the event has taken place outside London.” You can access the responses to the unanswered questions here 👇 fca.org.uk/events/annual-pub… 🗣️ Andy Agathangelou says: “If you ask the FCA a question whether at the meeting in person or in writing that hasn’t been answered, we suggest you write to the FCA asking for an answer. If you have no joy, consider escalating matters to the FCA’s complaints process and then the Financial Regulators Complaints Commissioner.”
3
6
258
Transparency Task Force retweeted
Yesterday, we said goodbye to @SAndriesz ⠀ His service at St Mary The Boltons was a wonderful tribute to his life. Every speech was excellent, heartfelt, personal and full of the Simon we all knew. I genuinely don't think Simon could have wished for a better send-off. ⠀ During the service, I asked the congregation to thank everyone who had supported Simon over the years. That thank-you wasn't just for those in the church. It was also for the many people reading this who gave Simon their time, advice, encouragement and support, often quietly and without expecting anything in return. ⠀ There are far too many of you to name individually, but please know that when I asked everyone to say thank you yesterday, I meant you too. I am personally grateful to every one of you. (you know who you are!) ⠀ 𝐘𝐞𝐬𝐭𝐞𝐫𝐝𝐚𝐲, 𝐈 𝐬𝐚𝐢𝐝 𝐠𝐨𝐨𝐝𝐛𝐲𝐞 𝐭𝐨 𝐦𝐲 𝐟𝐫𝐢𝐞𝐧𝐝. ⠀ 𝐎𝐧 𝐌𝐨𝐧𝐝𝐚𝐲, 𝐭𝐡𝐞 𝐫𝐞𝐚𝐥 𝐰𝐨𝐫𝐤 𝐛𝐞𝐠𝐢𝐧𝐬. ⠀ This year, I have had to say goodbye to two friends: Simon Andriesz and Glenn Smith. Both were lost in circumstances that, in my view, should never have been allowed to arise. I believe both were failed by the very institutions that were supposed to protect them. ⠀ Two friends. Two losses. Two too many. ⠀ In both cases, I have seen serious concerns about fraud, deceit and retaliation dismissed or defended with phrases such as “robust advocacy” and “just doing our job”. Legal professional privilege has also been invoked to resist scrutiny. ⠀ Legal professional privilege serves an important purpose. But It must never become a shield to legitimate questions about wrongdoing or accountability. ⠀ You may have seen me and my friends banging on about whistleblower protection. I make absolutely no apology for that. ⠀ We will keep banging on about it for the foreseeable future! Until those in power, with the authority to change things, finally do so. ⠀ Yesterday was for Simon. Tomorrow, the fight for change continues.
1
7
15
392
Transparency Task Force retweeted
ANOTHER WHISTLEBLOWER FAILED BY THE FCA AFTER SIMON ANDRIESZ: THE ANDREW PAGE FILE Andrew Page's (@andrewmtpage) identity became known when a spreadsheet on the Financial Conduct Authority's own website listed him as a whistleblower. Simon Andriesz @SAndriesz was told he had lost his whistleblower protection after his identity became known. Andrew has now come to me for help, as Simon did before him. He has sent me well over 100 documents: FCA letters and emails, complaint files, and rulings from the Complaints Commissioner and the Information Commissioner's Office. I have read every one. They record what the FCA wrote and did, in its own words and on its own dates. My conclusion from them is that @TheFCA works against whistleblowers. Start with one fact. On 28 July 2016 at 13:01, Andrew emailed a member of the FCA's whistleblowing team. At 13:39, 38 minutes later, the email was forwarded inside the FCA with the marking FCA RESTRICTED - ENFORCEMENT. The FCA was investigating Andrew at the time. No FCA document in his file explains the forward. The rest of the trail runs the same way. The FCA took 27 days to send its first reply to his complaint. It ruled the complaint about the forward out of time. A spreadsheet on its website held his name in hidden fields for more than 10 weeks. He had 4 FCA complaint references between 2017 and 2022. On the documents in his file, no body has examined the forward on its merits. This is the short version. It starts with who Andrew is. Who Andrew Page is Andrew Mark Thomas Page is a former independent financial adviser from Shropshire. In a letter to the Complaints Commissioner in March 2017 he wrote that he had almost 30 years in the industry. He ran his own firm, Financial Page Ltd (FRN 623858), which traded as Andrew Page. His chronology dates its direct authorisation by the FCA to 4 July 2014. By his own account his career began in 1989 as a financial consultant at Prudential Assurance. He joined Allied Dunbar as a financial adviser in 2001. From 2003 to 2009 he was an independent financial adviser in Shropshire, then a partner at St James's Place Wealth Management until 2012. From 2012 he was an independent financial adviser in Shropshire again. On 6 December 2013 he signed an introducer agreement with the firm behind a group of investment funds, and from then on he advised clients on them. He says he put about £100,000 of his own money into the same funds. His email to the FCA of 28 July 2016 says so in writing. In 2015 the FCA began investigating Andrew and his firm. In the same year he gave the FCA's whistleblowing team information about the funds and the people behind them. The FCA's Whistleblowing Team confirmed in September 2020 that it had recorded him as a whistleblower from 2015, under case number 6671. For the whole period that follows, the FCA held two records on one man. One said he was a whistleblower. The other said he was a subject of enforcement. He says his firm went into administration in 2016 and that he was made bankrupt in November 2022. He says he has written to prime ministers and attorneys general for years without result. I hold his letter to Boris Johnson of 15 April 2021. He says he also wrote to Keir Starmer and to the Attorney General, Lord Hermer, and that the Investigatory Powers Tribunal decided not to take the matter further. I believe Andrew. I also asked for the paper, and he has sent it. 38 minutes Andrew says that in 2015 he came to believe there was a large fraud connected with the investment funds he had recommended, and that he reported it to the FCA as a whistleblower. I have not tested that claim and I make no finding on it. This article looks at how the FCA treated the person who reported to it. On Thursday 28 July 2016 at 13:01, Andrew sent an email to ..... ..... at the FCA. The subject line read Information provision. The signature block of ..... ..... names the Intelligence Interface and Whistleblowing Team. In the email Andrew complained about his own FCA investigation, attributed the words fill your boots to ..... ....., and asked for permission to speak to financial journalists. At 13:39, ..... ..... forwarded the email to a colleague addressed as Helen. The covering text reads: Helen, Please find the email below. The forward carries the marking FCA RESTRICTED - ENFORCEMENT. Andrew's address is on its To line. Andrew says ..... ..... copied him in by mistake. He said the same in a letter to the Prime Minister on 15 April 2021. Andrew says Helen is Helen Tibbetts of the FCA's Enforcement division. The Upper Tribunal's published judgment of 4 May 2022 names Helen Tibbetts as the Enforcement manager dealing with the FCA's investigation into Andrew and his co-applicants. That is 38 minutes. The chain and its timestamps are in Andrew's file. I am not a lawyer and I draw no legal conclusion from them. They leave questions open. Who is the colleague addressed as Helen? Why did a whistleblower's email carry an enforcement marking within 38 minutes? Did any of it reach the team investigating Andrew? He says it did, and that some of it was used against him in interviews. No FCA document in his file answers these questions. Andrew says the colleague worked in the Enforcement Team and was investigating him. The FCA may say that sharing information inside the organisation was proper. It has not said so in any document I hold. The recording, the disc and the handwritten note On 1 December 2015, Andrew met ..... ..... at the FCA's offices at Canary Wharf. Andrew says a second FCA officer, ..... ....., a former detective, also attended and that the meeting lasted 1 hour and 6 minutes. The FCA recorded the meeting. In emails of 6 and 9 March 2020 it confirmed it had found the recording. The copy came on an encrypted DVD, with the password sent separately, and the disc would only play on a Windows computer. It reached Andrew by courier on 10 March 2020. The earlier phone call is different. The FCA says it holds no recording of it. Its email of 21 March 2020 dates the call to 16 September 2015 and points to a handwritten note made by ..... ..... Andrew says ..... ..... told him to *fill his boots*. His email of 28 July 2016 ties the remark to starting an Action Fraud case. His 2019 complaint, as the FCA recorded it, ties it to notifying the Serious Fraud Office. He now says he asked at the end of the 1 December 2015 meeting whether he should report the criminal acts he says he and others had evidenced, that he went on to contact both the Serious Fraud Office and Action Fraud, and that an associate who attended the meeting with him can confirm what was said. The FCA's account differs. In 2017 the Complaints Commissioner recorded the FCA's answer that a Whistleblowing Team member recalled a brief telephone call with Andrew after the team had met him, did not recall using the phrase and apologised if it was used. The call was not recorded, so the FCA could make no conclusive finding. On Andrew's account the remark came before his Action Fraud report of 22 December 2015. If it was said at the meeting, the FCA's own recording holds it. Hold it up to the light FCA investigators interviewed Andrew under compulsion. His complaint, made on 24 April 2019, was that the FCA later served transcripts of those interviews on third parties with parts blacked out, and that the blacked-out text could still be read. He said it showed through when held up to the light. On 14 May 2019 the FCA's Data Protection Officer said he could not reproduce that. The letter of 17 May 2019 then said something different in kind: we identified a technical issue with the software used to redact these documents. As a result of this issue it would, with a sufficient level of IT understanding, be possible to read the redacted text. The FCA added that it had no evidence anyone had read the redacted text and that it had told the ICO. An ICO letter of 20 November 2020 confirms that the FCA notified it and that the ICO investigated and advised the FCA. A regulator that handles confidential material for a living admitted in writing that a flaw in its own software let covered text be recovered from documents about a man it was investigating. That man was also on its books as a whistleblower. The documents do not prove that anyone read the covered text. The admission stands without that proof: the text could be read. The hidden columns On 25 February 2020 the FCA's Chief Operating Officer, Georgina Philippou, wrote to Andrew under reference 205891285. A spreadsheet answering a Freedom of Information request had gone out in September 2019 and was published on the FCA's disclosure log in November 2019. It contained two hidden fields, a name and a summary of a complaint. The FCA says it found the problem on 9 February 2020, more than 10 weeks after publication. The letter says the hidden information identified Andrew as someone who had contacted the FCA's whistleblowing team. The FCA apologised. It rated the risk as low, said it had found no copies of the file elsewhere online, reported itself to the ICO and added monitoring. The breach was not Andrew's alone. The FCA told the press in February 2020 that confidential information of an estimated 1,600 people who had complained to it may have been accessible (Scottish Financial News, 26 February 2020). For Andrew the exposed item was the fact that he had gone to the whistleblowing team. The ICO wrote on 20 November 2020 that the FCA had: failed to comply with its data protection obligations in its disclosure of the personal data in question The ICO took no formal action and pointed Andrew to the courts if he wanted compensation. Now set that against what the FCA's Whistleblowing Team wrote in September 2020. Its emails of 23 to 30 September say the FCA does not confirm to outside bodies that someone is a whistleblower without approval. Before telling the Insolvency Service that Andrew was one, the team asked for his consent. He gave it on 25 September 2020. Asking was the right step. It also makes the earlier failure harder to explain, because months before, a spreadsheet on the FCA's own website had already said it. This is where Andrew's case meets Simon's. Simon was told he had lost his protection after his identity became known. Andrew's identity became known because the FCA published it. Told he was too late On 24 April 2019 Andrew complained to the FCA in three parts: the redacted transcripts, the forwarding of his email to enforcement, and the fill your boots remark. The FCA's first reply came on 21 May 2019, 27 days later. Its decision letter of 31 May 2019 sent the redaction complaint to the data protection team, ruled the complaint about the forward out of time under its 12-month rule, and closed the fill your boots complaint as already investigated. He took it to the Complaints Commissioner. The final report of 2 September 2019 is published (Complaints Commissioner report FCA00597). It did not uphold any of the three parts. On the forward, the Commissioner found that the 12-month rule applied. On fill your boots, the Commissioner said the matter had been decided before and could not be reopened. The forward happened on 28 July 2016, so by 2019 the limit had long passed. The Commissioner found the FCA applied it correctly. What follows is that, on the documents in Andrew's file, no body has examined whether sending a whistleblower's email into an enforcement channel within 38 minutes was proper. The pattern continued. An FCA decision letter of 1 November 2022, reference 208591943, ruled a further complaint out of time. It lists three earlier complaint references: 204491204, 205891285 and 206700190. Across 2017 to 2022 Andrew had 4 FCA complaint references. Each answer was procedural. Nobody with the power to say has said whether his information was handled the way the FCA says it handles whistleblowers' information. A decade of letters The FCA could ask permission when it chose to. On 25 January 2021, FCA Legal asked Andrew's consent before sharing one of his letters inside the organisation. No document in his file shows anyone asking on 28 July 2016. On 24 March 2021 the FCA launched a public campaign called In confidence, with confidence, asking people in financial services to report wrongdoing (FCA press release). At 10:12 the next morning Andrew emailed the FCA's chief executive, Nikhil Rathi, under the subject line Help. He copied the FCA's chair, another FCA executive director, a parliamentary committee, several MPs, his local police and crime commissioner and the Insolvency Service. The email opens: Once again, and out of sheer common decency could I please have an acknowledgment and response to this piece of correspondence.Yesterday, I read with interest the news that the FCA are encouraging Whistle-blowers to come forward, I find this astounding after all that has gone before. I have found no reply to that email in the file. On 29 September 2021 Andrew wrote to Mark Steward, then the FCA's Executive Director of Enforcement and Market Oversight, after reading an article by him about whistleblowing. Mark Steward replied on 1 October 2021 that, because of legal proceedings, it would not be appropriate for him or Nikhil Rathi to respond further. Andrew also used the Freedom of Information Act. He asked the FCA about draft instructions it had given a third-party firm in 2016, and the FCA refused to confirm or deny that it held them. On 4 June 2021 the ICO ruled that the FCA was not entitled to refuse, found that it had also breached the Act through delay, and required it to confirm or deny (ICO decision IC-50103-M2K3). The ICO did not order release of the documents. In the file I hold, the answers to Andrew's letters are acknowledgments, referrals and rulings on procedure. The promise and the paper trail The FCA's campaign page of 24 March 2021 says: Every report the FCA receives is reviewed and the FCA will protect individual whistleblowers’ identities.This includes not confirming the existence of a whistleblower when making enquiries, unless legally obliged to do so. The promise came after most of what is in Andrew's file. It is the standard the FCA set itself in public. Against it, Andrew's file shows an email forwarded into an enforcement channel within 38 minutes, a redaction flaw the FCA admitted in May 2019, and hidden fields on the FCA website that identified him as someone who contacted the whistleblowing team. Andrew is not the only case on the public record. In September 2024 the FCA published a review by Richard Lloyd, its senior independent director, of how the chair, Ashley Alder, handled whistleblowing communications from two former employees. Richard Lloyd concluded that Ashley Alder did not follow the FCA's existing policy to the letter in handling two complex cases, and that he acted in good faith (FCA statement, 23 September 2024). Then came Simon. By 6 October 2026 the FCA had acknowledged that advice given to Simon by an FCA official was incorrect. The official had told him he had lost whistleblower protection because his identity had become known. The FCA apologised, according to a statement from the all-party parliamentary group on investment fraud and fairer financial services (Scottish Financial News, 6 October 2026). Simon died in September 2026. The group called for an external inquiry and said regulators should not be marking their own homework. The FCA's non-executive directors commissioned a review. Lea Paterson CBE, an independent non-executive director of the FCA, will examine how the FCA dealt with Simon from at least 2017 to 2026, with a final report due in spring 2027 (FCA statement, 2 November 2026). Andrew's file covers the same regulator and a large part of the same period. It bears on one question the review has to answer. Was what happened to Simon a mistake by one official, or how the system works? What I am asking for My conclusion is the one I gave at the start. Andrew went to the FCA as a whistleblower. The FCA's own documents show his email in an enforcement channel within 38 minutes, his identity in a public spreadsheet, and his complaints turned away on procedure. On that record, the FCA works against whistleblowers. Public sources FCA campaign page, 24 March 2021 Complaints Commissioner final report FCA00597, 2 September 2019 Scottish Financial News on the FCA data breach, 26 February 2020 ICO decision IC-50103-M2K3, 4 June 2021 FCA statement on the Richard Lloyd review, 23 September 2024 Scottish Financial News on the FCA apology and the all-party group, 6 October 2026 FCA statement on the Paterson review, 2 November 2026 @TransparencyTF @stevemiddi1 @MLorrM @J_Robertson_UK @CartlandDavid @ClareCraigPath @Victoria_Rixon @Wftproof @johncock_wayne @pjhlaw @CastletonLee @JohnCleese @OlooneyJohn @johnmcdonnellMP @newlands_chris @andyverity @WarmingtonRjw
1
16
26
1,828
Transparency Task Force retweeted
Individuals are OK. Groups act different. Groups easily whipped into blood thirsty mob mentality. Human nature. DOJ/FBI is effective at using press releases on charging dates, as well as whipping grand juries and juries up for their purpose. The 'gag' order helps them achieve.
Replying to @MConnollyittm
The DOJ/FBI depends on certain things for its 98% conviction rate. One is the splashy press conference then SILENCE as the defendant is run through the sausage grinder. Then they celebrate inevitable conviction/guilty plea. Real time fact checking needed. justice.gov/archives/opa/pr/…
3
12
426
📺 Financial Services and Markets Bill: Second Reading You can access a speech by Dame Meg Hillier MP here: parliamentlive.tv/event/inde… We are very grateful to Dame Meg for speaking up for consumer interests.
2
2
159