Ultimate Philosopher (Wisdom Junkie; Logic Fan) (@ult_phil) header
Ultimate Philosopher (Wisdom Junkie; Logic Fan) (@ult_phil) profile picture

Aim: spread philosophical activity far/wide 👍: Steelmanning, Aristotle Philosophy for Kids: #P4C, https://teapawt.net/t.co/TDOrLY4gem rt=🍿 name at blog👇

USA
Joined September 2011
Photo by Ultimate Philosopher (Wisdom Junkie; Logic Fan) (@ult_phil)Photo by Ultimate Philosopher (Wisdom Junkie; Logic Fan) (@ult_phil)Photo by Ultimate Philosopher (Wisdom Junkie; Logic Fan) (@ult_phil)Photo by Ultimate Philosopher (Wisdom Junkie; Logic Fan) (@ult_phil)Photo by Ultimate Philosopher (Wisdom Junkie; Logic Fan) (@ult_phil)Photo by Ultimate Philosopher (Wisdom Junkie; Logic Fan) (@ult_phil)Photo by Ultimate Philosopher (Wisdom Junkie; Logic Fan) (@ult_phil)Photo by Ultimate Philosopher (Wisdom Junkie; Logic Fan) (@ult_phil)Photo by Ultimate Philosopher (Wisdom Junkie; Logic Fan) (@ult_phil)Photo by Ultimate Philosopher (Wisdom Junkie; Logic Fan) (@ult_phil)
Thank you Grok / Gee, ya think?
They resolve the same way all competing claims do under Mill: by free contest of the strongest arguments and evidence on both sides, not by one side's certitude or institutional power silencing the other. Hostility assertions themselves remain testable claims, not conversation-stoppers. Career sanctions or deplatforming still substitute coercion for error-correction and erode the legitimacy of whichever side resorts to them.
11
How intellectually & morally corrupted would people and/or institutions have to get, to avoid knowing what Grok says here? (And not only that, how corrupted would they have to be, to cancel all dialogue on this point & to unperson dissenters? Pretty damn corrupt, I'd think?)
This quoted post is unavailable.
9
Are we to believe that the American People are so fed up with Trump and his war in Iran that they're willing to overlook just how despicable & destructive the opposing party is in 2028 and beyond? (This is patently unconstitutional after the recent SCOTUS ruling BTW.)
This quoted post is unavailable.
1
29
Not even the community of Philosophers - in academia or otherwise - is big on Philosophy for Children or P4C (or a more general Philosophy for Everyone and/or Bootcamp push). This is even though there's been (all of) a Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy entry on P4C for years now and it has struck me in all that time and longer that it's a no-brainer, especially after one has seen it applied in action (like as told in, say, McCarty's 'Little Big Minds'). I don't have a comprehensive program for a P4C curriculum, and at this point referring to a LLM for guidance (along with advice about getting creative AF with one's prompts) about philosophy is probably as good advice as anything. But the point is, P4C and P4E and Bootcamp are all significantly important ideas to me that I keep bringing up from time to time with varying degrees of intensity, and yet I see ALMOST NOTHING from EVEN THE PHILOSOPHICAL COMMUNITY mentioning and promoting the idea. Am I the problem here, or am I maybe as on-the-ball as anyone might get nowadays without being a LLM? (Grok is really positive toward Philosophy and philosophical education, BTW. Does that count for anything???)
16
I suppose I wouldn't take such issue with the "woke" agenda as I do, if I didn't have every reason to suspect or believe that it comes at the expense of intellectual quality. I'm thinking right off of the pronouns being drilled into the kids while test scores stagnate/fall & there's still no Philosophy for Children (P4C) curriculum being talked about that I know of. But it should just be Philosophy curriculum because the 'educators' need it just as badly as the kids do. If they weren't so preoccupied with all that "woke" shit (treating people differently based on immutable characteristics, and canceling those who voice objections, is virtuous why now?), then they might have a better sense of priorities & programs for flourishing?
2
39
No pattern recognition from you!
I never listen to Tim Pool. But I did the last two days because he had congressmen on I wanted to hear. But then I noticed he has the same sponsors as Candace. Then I noticed he was all doom and gloom and the government is lying to you like Tucker. Remember Trump is going to Nuke Iran. Has Tim gone to the dark side? AKA the AF? Just thinking out loud. Are the same people paying Candace now paying Tim? Is this now what Tim is supporting?
1
23
Are the "woke" NOT notorious for avoiding debate? I've only been paying attention for decades now. Back in the days when there was Political Correctness, at least basic dialectical norms were still in effect. The left's Long March saw to it to remove this pillar of Western Civ.
This is where LLM - particularly short-form ones - lack what I'll call human intuition, although there is often good overlap/alignment a lot of the time. My immediate impression of @NadiaWhittomeMP is that of a "woke" ideologue, & the "Woke" are notorious for avoiding debate.
18
Why doesn't everyone respond to a politician's post this way nowadays? Making prompts like this should be second nature to modern users of technology, yes?
Replying to @NadiaWhittomeMP
@Grok, how well do the OP's claims stand up under rigorous cross-examination? Is your general impression of @NadiaWhittomeMP that of someone who is dialectically rigorous where big but contested claims are concerned?
10
Have you had these claims rigorously challenged in cross-examination from critics - a method endorsed by every philosopher of worth - or did you silence/cancel the critics in some fashion? Because that's the first thing that matters to me here. I hope it's clear why.
On Trans Day of Remembrance, we mourn the 273 trans and gender-diverse people killed worldwide this year. Countless more have lost their lives as a result of everyday transphobia, state violence and exclusion - from inability to access healthcare and housing, to unsafe streets and workplaces. This isn’t a day for governments to offer “thoughts and prayers”. Trans people need them to act. In the UK, that means writing trans people’s rights into equality law, introducing a trans-inclusive conversion practices ban, and investing in specialist healthcare.
18
Re Grand Theft Auto VI So far I'm missing out on this part of the good life; I found GTA5 to be a hoot. I'd like to check it out if it isn't too much trouble/cost. But I don't think I'd suffer otherwise. But I've seen only a few clips so far so I can't really say for sure.
15
Turns out that Matt Walsh is vindicated specifically about the voters caring more about gas prices (that which is seen) than they do about Iran's not getting a nuclear weapon (something not seen by its nature if Iran *doesn't* have a nuke). It does not prove Walsh correct if that means proving that going to war against Iran was a bad idea. A man with utmost skin in the game, Donald Trump, has been willing to risk and lose political capital (in the short term) on the proposition that this is the best among options for handling the Iran matter. Also shown to be correct here is that Walsh has significant reach and he used that reach to - knowingly or not - throw people off the scent that Donald Trump is onto. The nature of the Iran regime and its agenda was revealed on Oct 7 if not before; it has wargamed out a strategy of holding the region and world nuclear hostage because they're deranged 12ers etc. How much did Walsh play up that angle? I know that Ben Shapiro has done that a lot and he's right to do so. There's a reason I have Klavan and Shapiro ranked as the top guys at DW. Maybe Trump profiting off cryptocoins while telling people to have patience with the gas prices explains people's dissatisfaction more. Or maybe the midterm dynamics along with effective Dem propaganda (all year long on YouTube the 'algorithms' were churning out Affordability Issue content even as overall inflation is well below peak Biden inflation), and a fracturing on the right involving people to varying degrees not hewing to a soundly-argued line from the likes of Shapiro and VDH, often turning instead to toxic influencers filling the Charlie Kirk void (and it's hard to believe that his absence hasn't hurt MAGA and pro-MAGA influencing pretty badly). Walsh would be among those not hewing rightly to the line presented by VDH and Shapiro and Trump himself. The best alternative course of policy when it comes to the 12ers who backed Oct 7 and were up to more mischief in the nuke dept is . . . what? What TRUMP proved is just how much economic and other damage these 12ers (can we stop calling them "Iran" and call them 12er lunatics who hijacked a state apparatus?) can inflict on the world as they pursue nuclear leverage. Can Matt Walsh sustain a steelman-yet-refute-the-opponent argument in light of this? Do I need to comb through past episodes of Friendly Fire to find Shapiro vs Walsh on the merits - i.e., why mainstream Americans *should* care at least as much about "Iran" (12ers pursuing nukes) as about temporary gas prices, and should be influenced in that direction. Trump himself is undercut by his crypto-business profiting and cannot be rehabbed on that point. But on the merits? And on the likes of Tucker Carlson fucking things up badly in the podcast-sphere when it comes to Trump's foreign policy? Walsh remains a friend of Tucker's which is all well and good but in the arena of being a public intellectual, criticism of Tucker's blatant ghastly dishonesty is eminently warranted. ("I never said is Trump the antichrist." People who deny saying what they said cannot be believed about anything; do we know of any exceptions? Usually it's terrible people that do that.) On this sort of thing, Walsh isn't vindicated at all, but rather is part of a problem fracturing the coalition on the right. Also in the dynamic here is just how diabolically awful the Democrats are, how they ruin institutions, etc. We have Matt Walsh friend Tucker Carlson and others doing exactly as Charlie Kirk (who had all but a target put directly on his back by Democrats and leftists) would not have done, which is to promote the election of Democrats and leftists. Maybe Matt Walsh criticized *in general* the concept of turning power over to such devils, but did he lift a finger to criticize *Tucker Carlson in his role as public intellectual* in doing that? This whole "they're friends so I won't criticize their public-intellectual-relevant statements" is the same cowardly cop-out that we got from Megyn Kelly, and it's such cowardice that hurts the righteous cause (which is overwhelmingly on the GOP side vis a vis the Demonrats). And voters who express their disapproval of high gas prices by handing power over to Dem ghouls are just not acting as the most informed and reasonable people would, is all. And? (Actually I don't blame voters in TX for voting Talafreako if Paxton was such a shit candidate that he wouldn't show up for debates. Now that's just plain cowardice and do we want such a coward in the Senate? But Al-Sayed in Michigan, the Hasan Piker proxy? Walsh's un-criticized friend said to vote 'im right in. Tucker is not a combination of informed and reasonable. Did the "bed demon" merely attack him, or possess him?)
Replying to @MattWalshBlog
I hadn’t even read this whole thread in detail. He really caught me being totally correct and predicting the mid terms blowout in March. This thread is the most flattering and vindicating hit piece I’ve ever seen.
1
56
But what the fuck do I know. I'm just one observer among countless others, I'm sure, trying diligently to find patterns and causes.
4
Ultimate Philosopher (Wisdom Junkie; Logic Fan) retweeted
2003 Dilbert Classics Week
5
36
4
704
34,702
It's probably worth asking Grok whether the legal predicate for going after James Comey for perjury about leaks, or Letitia James for mortgage fraud, is stronger than whatever the Democrats came after Trump for. Steelmanning the Dershowitz side of the matter in the process ofc
Catherine Herridge is reporting that James Comey's friend and Columbia Law Professor Daniel Richman is "definitely a target" in the Florida-based investigation. Richman was allegedly Comey's conduit to leak information to the media. jonathanturley.org/2025/09/3…...
1
38
Ultimate Philosopher (Wisdom Junkie; Logic Fan) retweeted
Replying to @NYTimesPR
Tell us you know literally nothing about legal citations without saying that you know literally nothing about how legal citations work. Bless your hearts.
5
33
937
12,375
Institutions run by "progressives" have this whole thing about maintaining accurately curated information & interpretation- all the while using every bad-look tactic imaginable to evade dialectical accountability even when they're flatly wrong - the Fine People Hoax, e.g. In this instance, we have people aligned with the Federalist Society who would take issue with what "accurate representation" really occurred here. That means there's apparent controversy that can be resolved only through dialetical accountability, which is erased when cancel culture - a very, very bad look - is the MO among "progressives." But when they can't even get a flatly refuted hoax like "Trump called Nazis fine people" right, we're on a new level of anti-accountability very-bad-look ghoulishness - straight into partisan propaganda fraudulently masquerading as news of record. NYT & its "Accurate Portrayal" ilk has the blood of dead journalism on its hands, and they're a bunch of vile gaslighters. Accurate portrayal my ass.)
The Times’s article reported that Justice Scalia wrongly attributed the direct quote “dangerous and unusual” to Blackstone. That is a fact, and one that has also been recognized by a federal appeals court. This reporting is an accurate portrayal of what Justice Scalia did.
22
Ultimate Philosopher (Wisdom Junkie; Logic Fan) retweeted
"That is a fact, and one that has also been recognized by a federal appeals court." This strikes me as an odd reply. First, it doesn't seem like a fact, but more of a contested inference—one that a lot of people think is wrong, myself included. Second, was this "recognized by a federal appeals court"? I assume the NYT referring to a concurrence (and agreement with it from the panel) speculating that it *might* be a misquote, rather than concluding that it was. Passage below.
The Times’s article reported that Justice Scalia wrongly attributed the direct quote “dangerous and unusual” to Blackstone. That is a fact, and one that has also been recognized by a federal appeals court. This reporting is an accurate portrayal of what Justice Scalia did.
21
29
4
305
46,795