NC (@undecyn) header
NC (@undecyn) profile picture
Joined March 2021
Photo by NC (@undecyn)Photo by NC (@undecyn)Photo by NC (@undecyn)Photo by NC (@undecyn)Photo by NC (@undecyn)Photo by NC (@undecyn)Photo by NC (@undecyn)Photo by NC (@undecyn)Photo by NC (@undecyn)Photo by NC (@undecyn)
81-year-old veteran sucker-punched and carjacked by "teen suspects" in Chicago:
278
1,355
92
5,256
377,602
1/ How many times have you encountered this headline? It's often repeated by those who wish to downplay the the Islamic overrepresentation in group CSE In this thread, I will show how contemptibly misleading this headline is and reveal the truth behind the grooming gang scandal
318
2,313
1,005
6,523
922,582
What if thought experiments turn people into utilitarians? Hear me out: When you are working in closed environments, like inside a lab, or in a vm on your computer, or doing math on a piece of paper, your brain can (mostly) fit the whole system you're dealing with. Second (or n-th) order consequences don't matter. If something goes sideways you can scrap the whole thing and start over with little to no consequence. In an environment like that, you are the absolute authority that can hold the whole state in your head, and make complex calculations about the results of your actions. You learn to instrumentalize these disposable environments. They are only there so long as they are of use to your objective. You make the rules by combining your knowledge and intelligence, and if something doesn't work out, you can always start over. Many of humanity's technological and scientific advancements have come from working in such environments. Now think about open environments: Standup commedy, MMA, interviewing someone for a podcast, experimenting with mind altering substances. Things Joe Rogan might do. But also, trading in markets, building a company, etc. Things where the consequences of your actions are hard to predict, repeatability is low, second- and third- order consequences often overpower the first order, and where there is no "start over" button. People who do well in such situations tend to be thought of as "street smart" (as opposed to the "book smarts" of the first group). People engaged in these sorts of activities are always on the lookout for some weird phenomenon that they can leverage to their advantage, live and die by the quality of the feedback they get, and usually harbor a healthy sense of skepticism for high abstractions. Not because they necessarily can't grasp them, but because they have seen nice-sounding models crash and burn one too many times. Enter thought experiments: a book-smart person's of feeling superior to a street-smart person. Imagine Bob, a math olympiad champion, talking to his friend Sally, who is a parkour streamer and renowned online marketer. Bob: "What would you do if a trolley was out of control, going down the tracks, and 5 people were tied on its path, but if you flipped the lever right in front of you, the train could change course and only kill one person that is tied in those other tracks?" Sally: "Wouldn't I go to prison if I caused the other person to die?" Bob: "Imagine that for whatever you do there will be no consequences whatsoever" Sally: "Wouldn't it be weird for me to find myself in a situation like that? I'd consider whether I'm being played in some way" Bob: "Imagine you know for sure that this is a complete coincidence" Sally: "Is there anything else about the situation that might help me figure out whether I can save all the people?" Bob: "Imagine you look around and there's nothing useful whatsoever. The trolley is getting closer, you have to make a decision" Sally: "I have no idea what I would do" Bob: "No, you don't get it -- you *have* to answer. That's how thought experiments work." Sally: "Hmm, ok, I googled and apparently there is a way to slip the switch and force the train to stop? Here, look:" Bob: "Thought Experiments are about the Least Convenient Possible World. It is a moral weakness to refuse to engage them or try to wiggle out" Sally: "I guess if I was in the Least Convenient Possible World I'd let the trolley keep going. If I can't escape it, at least the 5 kids on the train tracks can find their salvation from that nightmare" Bob: "Let me explain how consequentialism works..." --- Notice what is happening here: In every turn, Sally is trying to entangle the problem with the real world, trying to understand the context, the detail, what came before, what comes after. Bob is closing off all paths. Basically he is turning a canonical open world problem into a closed world problem so that his utilitarian math-based solutions seem like the only way forward. And while it is true that in his artificial environment he can rig things up, upto and including overriding Sally's perceptions (remember - there is no way for Bob to know what Sally would notice in a real-world situation) to force his preferred answer to be the right answer. But when he pulls a bait and switch and claims that that scripted, artificial, first-order-effect-only environment corresponds to the real world in any way, shape, or form, he is doing everyone, including himself, a disservice. The real world is dominated by feedback, game theory, context, uncertainty, and long event series that don't come with an "undo" button. Our brains are very poor simulators of complex remote futures and the only information you can get from these non-experiment experiments is about what your brain thinks about stuff when deprived of sensory input. So the next time someone tries to force you to confess to moral intuitions you don't actually have, consider that they might have actually convinced themselves that their notebooks or laboratory environments have more similarity with the real world than they have any legitimate reason to. The impulse of the technocrat. To a rationalist with a calculator, every conundrum is a utilitarian choice.
doomers will repeat the same unconvincing argument again and again then complain you aren't bayesian enough lmao
147
236
105
1,476
298,196
How is this not a national story in Canada? Why have people barely heard about this? and why are his charges so seemingly insignificant given the incident and likely terroristic-inspired attack? Pictured: 28-year-old Bezhani Sarvar on Tuesday, January 23, 2024 Charges (or lack thereof): - reckless discharge of a firearm, - using/placing/throwing an explosive substance, - arson, - possession of incendiary material, - using a firearm while committing an offence and, - careless use of a firearm Incident: A crazed man with a taped manifesto walks into Edmonton, Alberta City Hall heavily armed, lit several handheld incendiary devices and then starts shooting several rounds while inside city hall. Luckily, the security guard on duty got the gunman to surrender and detained him until police arrived at the scene
321
1,382
112
4,322
500,160
Alt take: Cushy laptop jobs are necessary for family formulation nowadays. "Wages are stagnating, single-income households can't support families...If only more women were unemployed from remote, flexible, well paying jobs, they could have more kids!"
2 MAJOR shifts are necessary to get our birth rates back above replacement level - taylor swift getting pregnant - millennial women getting fired from their cushy laptop jobs
1
283
Listening to this space and realizing that arguing w/these ppl is a complete waste of time. He admits that this lady was probably dealt a bad hand. And then in the next breath declares that her poor health is an indictment of her character. teapawt.net/i/spaces/1eaJbraqdAkJX…
182
Often DR/RW tweeters seem to think the reason some1 disagrees w/them is bc "U just don't get it!" As in, u don't understand the particular DR orientation on the subject. Maybe consider that the DR sphere is not closed, and there r many ppl who *do* get it, but simply reject it.
133
It's been quite a thing to see how many ppl distort & misinterpret what I wrote so they can insult & dunk on it, for that sweet sweet dopamine hit.
unavailable
74
Oliver Anthony's Rich Men North of Richmond song phenomenon of the past couple of days - & the rabid distorted defenses thrown at anyone not 100% enthralled by the song - has been a great reminder that people are desperate to be moved, emotionally. Desperate for authenticity. 1/
1
1
2
174
Too much of my time is wasted on this site. But if it's led to anything even a bit worthwhile, it's that Ive a better sense of the online emotional landscape, how it works. It's tragic & dull. Alarming & boring. Can't help but land in a cynical space, at least for a while. 3/
1
1
89
When ur desperate to have emotional pressure points pushed, u leave yourself open to manipulation. Is the alternative apathetic cynicism? Is that any better? Idk. But no big account riling u into anger has ur best interests in mind. Ur emotions r being farmed, on all sides. 4/4
1
1
110
If the virus was deadlier, and the vaccine was obviously very effective (sterilizing) with no side effects, then vax deniers would obviously be wackos. What he’s missing is that doubts about the vaccine that turned out to be true were suppressed by the ppl whose job it was to be honest. That censorship and lies delivered a lasting blow to public health’s credibility, which blew open the door to RFK Jr.’s craziness. Rogan and RFK Jr are not the problem - skeptics and wackos will always exist. The CDC, Fauci, the White House, the Surgeon General did far more damage, systematically, nation wide. They forced toddlers to wear cloth masks and closed schools for over a year, denied natural immunity mattered, stripped people of their jobs and made them outcasts in their families and communities, denied people the ability to visit loved ones dying in the hospital, and mandated healthy kids to get vaccines that they didn’t need. It’s not the Rogans and JFK Jr’s that are the big problem, it’s the systemic institutional failure. If Sam wants to gripe about something, it should be that people whose job it was to know better got it incredibly wrong, ruined lives and livelihoods, and paid zero price for it.
I couldn't believe Sam made another "if the virus killed more kids" argument, so I cut a longer clip. What he's saying this time is "in an extreme enough situation anything is justifiable". What he doesn't get is that we need principles because we have imperfect sensemaking.🧵
117
188
16
1,356
134,038
1/For those you don't follow @Ardescamus I am posting this (with permission) because it's worth all of our consideration (I'm not exiting social media myself, but do please read and think).
1
1
2
5
510
🚨BREAKING🚨 A breast cancer patient in Oregon has reported she was dropped by her health clinic for "transphobia" after criticizing a trans pride flag in the reception area. Marlene Barbera had been a patient at the Richmond Family Clinic for 12 years. reduxx.info/oregon-breast-ca…
169
788
92
2,076
168,033
Made me think of this Auden poem:
5
5
1
67
9,604
The plight of atomic veterans was portrayed by Martin Sheen and Emilio Esrevez in the 1989 T.V. film “Nightbreaker.” It’s a sad tale of the government stonewalling former soldiers who are dying from cancer due to their participation in these tests. @LaocoonofTroy
Footage from the Tumbler-Snapper Dog atomic bomb test, conducted at Yucca Flat in Area 7 of the Nevada Test Site near Las Vegas, Nevada on May 1, 1952. The bomb had a yield of 19 kilotons. The U.S. Marines in this footage belong to the 2nd Provisional Marine Battalion, 2nd Marine Corps Provisional Atomic Exercise Brigade (MCPAEB), a composite force of test troops pooled from the 2nd Marine Division (at the time based at Camp Lejeune in North Carolina). These Marines were participating in the Desert Rock IV ground maneuver exercise, which aimed to study how military/combat operations would be conducted in an atomic war zone, as well as to study the effects of atomic radiation. Such exercises involving infantry had been conducted since 1951, when the Nevada Test Site began atomic tests, but Desert Rock IV was the first time that Marines were involved. Essentially guinea pigs, unfortunately, and most (if not all) of these men eventually wound up with cancer because of these tests.
2
10
1
37
12,000
"Ok,so in order to save the planet from the horrible pollution of gas extraction/exhaust... We're gonna litter the globe w/massive wind turbines that'll only sometimes generate power, catch fire & emit toxic pollution, & be impossible to recycle, so they'll end up in a landfill."
Wind turbines are tall, isolated & composed of sensitive electronics, therefore extremely vulnerable to lightning. Studies found that lightning strikes account for 80% of turbine insurance claims. This happened in Crowell, TX in July 2022 [📹Brent Havins] teapawt.net/MikeCollierWX/status/1…
89
And there it is Mercola and myself probably cancelled because our banks are monitoring our social credit scores. telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/07…
11
65
7
147
7,684