The Value Investor (@valueover_hype) header
The Value Investor (@valueover_hype) profile picture

šŸ’¼ Investor šŸ“Š Fundamentals over noise šŸ“‰ Buying fear • šŸ“ˆSelling greed āš–ļø Value over speculation šŸ¤ Practical frameworks for value investors ↓

Joined July 2023
Management tells you how it sees the business. Rivals tell you how it looks from across the market. The gap between those two descriptions is often where the next useful question lives. How I read a competitor's annual report: valueoverhype.substack.com/p…
210
In my view, most investors don’t have a returns problem. They have a survival problem. Leverage they can’t hold. A thesis they can’t defend at -40%. My rule: never own what I can’t hold through a crash. What’s yours?
41
"The most important quality for an investor is temperament, not intellect." ~ Warren Buffett Before I buy anything, I write down the price at which I’d buy more. If I can’t name it, I shouldn’t own it. Temperament is a decision made before the drop, not during it.
3
120
Kodak built the first digital camera in 1975 and filed for bankruptcy in 2012. The film moat was real. It guarded a profit stream technology was about to drain. Judge a moat against the next decade, not the last one.
1
3
202
The Dow lost about 89% from 1929 to 1932. Graham lived through it, lost money in it, and built his whole framework around it. In my view, his most useful idea is the simplest: price is what Mr. Market offers you. Value is what you decide it’s worth.
3
14
648
"Operations for profit should be based not on optimism but on arithmetic." ~ Ben Graham Lose 50% and you need +100% to get back to even. Optimism forgets this. Arithmetic doesn’t. I’d rather miss a 3x than take a 50% loss. Disagree? Tell me what the 3x was worth.
2
1
7
596
My first filter on any earnings beat: did free cash flow follow? If profit grew 20% and cash didn’t, I ask one question: what is management spending to keep growing? The answer is usually in the capex line.
1
3
161
ā€œYou get rich by owning good businesses, not trading stocks.ā€ ~ Warren Buffett My test before buying anything: would I still own it if the market closed for five years? If the answer is no, I’m not investing. I’m guessing. The key point: an ownership mindset starts with how you’d behave without a price to check.
1
2
18
580
"To get what you want, you have to deserve what you want." ~ Charlie Munger Munger often said ā€œI have nothing to addā€ at Berkshire meetings. I trust that more than any forecast. It’s what knowing where your edge ends sounds like. Most of us fill the silence anyway.
12
526
A business that can’t reinvest at high returns anymore needs a different CEO skill set. Running operations and allocating capital are separate jobs. In my view, most managers are only good at one.
88
Bogle’s first index fund raised roughly $11 million against a $150 million target. Wall Street nicknamed it ā€œBogle’s Folly.ā€ It needed no forecast and no star manager. It needed time and low costs. Most investors still pay for the opposite.
2
140
"A company that buys back its own shares is usually a good sign." ~ Peter Lynch Buybacks get applauded no matter the price. I think that’s a mistake. Lynch said a buyback is usually a good sign. The key word is ā€œusually.ā€ Repurchasing at 10x earnings and at 40x earnings are two different decisions. Check the price paid before you cheer.
1
5
219
Most ā€œscale advantagesā€ are not advantages. They are just size. If a rival can raise the same capital and match your unit cost, you have no moat. Real scale economies mean an entrant must already be big to be competitive. Test: could a competitor at one-tenth your size ever reach your cost per unit?
78
Test: when did you last sell a position at a loss and feel fine about it? If the answer is ā€œnever,ā€ you are probably optimizing for being right, not for making money. Marks’s line is easy to quote. It is much harder to follow.
5
267
"Value investors have to be patient and disciplined, but what I really think is you need not to be greedy." ~ Seth Klarman A 50% loss needs a 100% gain to break even. Greed asks, ā€œhow much can I make?ā€ Margin of safety asks, ā€œhow much can I lose?ā€ Only one of those questions keeps you in the game long enough to compound.
8
339
Unpopular view: operating margin is overrated as a quality signal. A business that gets paid before it pays its suppliers funds its own growth. A fatter margin can’t do that. I’d rather own the shorter cash conversion cycle.
1
86
Klarman: long-term investing is not about being right every day. Most read that as comfort. I read it as a warning. If you need to be right every day, you’re not investing. You’re trading, and paying taxes and stress for it.
1
1
105
"Our favorite holding period is forever." ~ Warren Buffett Buffett’s first stock purchase, at age 11: 3 shares at $38. He sold at $40. The stock later reached $200. The key point: the cost of selling early never shows up on a statement. That’s why most investors never count it.
3
9
480
The first question I ask before valuing anything: how many years can this business earn more than its cost of capital? Not ā€œis it good?ā€ How long. In my view, that single input moves value more than most growth forecasts.
1
116
Berkshire holds hundreds of billions in cash and gets criticized for it every bull market. The real issue isn’t the return on that cash. It’s that Berkshire never has to sell a good asset at a bad price to pay for a bad week.
7
251