It is remarkable to me that that psychiatry has sustained the double-think of alluding to science while some acknowledge the ineptitude of the psychiatric edifice.
It could be so much better.
Powerful words from the guy who chaired the DSM-IV
Children “labeled with a serious condition for challenges that would better be viewed as a variation of normal”
“overdiagnosis can happen whenever there’s a blurry line between normal behavior and disorder”
“It is difficult to accurately diagnose [some psychiatric disorders]. There is no biological test; symptoms vary greatly in nature and severity; clinicians don’t always agree; different diagnostic tests may come up with different conclusions; and the diagnosis is not always stable over time”
“Diagnostic inaccuracy contributes to falsely elevated rates, which can lead to misconceptions that an epidemic is occurring.”
“As [diagnoses have] lost [their] dire connotations, some people turn to the diagnosis as a way to feel less shame”
“we should be concerned about the increasing tendency to mislabel socially awkward behavior”
“Diagnoses, especially in children, should be written in pencil”
3
131
Goodness! I hate that some people will not say what they really think…
Psychiatry is a totally corrupt specialty, ethically, scientifically and financially, with devastating consequences for the patients. bit.ly/4p8V1Nr. Stop it! @brokenmedics @SecKennedy @DrJBhattacharya @MartyMakary @cdcgov @WHO @NIH @martinkulldorff
2
124
There are so many psychiatric apologists who will remain silent at this.
This study finds that psychiatrists who worked on DSM-5 received $14M in undisclosed funding from the pharmaceutical industry; the very industry that has profited enormously from DSM's over-medicalisation of everyday life. bmj.com/content/384/bmj-2023…
Remarkable that this study is still being touted as evidence in support of medication for depression. Even the author, was moved to describe the added value of antidepressants over placebo as ‘trivial’.
Another meaningless ‘disorder’ with poor reliability, without aetiology or treatment. In the new form there will be a new demand for consultants, juniors, training, resources that suck the life out of every other discipline and service. There is no science in a name change.
This is absolutely shocking. I cannot think of anything more destructive. Is this psychiatry making a commercial move by inserting themselves irresponsibly in our lives, or some misguided initiative by someone who doesn’t know better.
Here is the problem.
Psychiatry/ pharma’ perpetuate the untruth that ‘science’ is advancing with new chapters, adding value to our care.
No, it is not science. They merely evolve the deception with layers of complexity and pseudoscience avoiding substantive reform.
Science isn’t replacing the story — it’s adding chapters, new characters, richer plots, and deeper connections.
5
138
A RCT comparing Saffron and SSRI’s in the treatment of MDD. No difference was found but saffron had fewer side effects. In particular, it had no impact on libido. Not the last word but interesting. Will someone try to patent it!
pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/3891…
1
95
You and the op-ed’s are almost right. There are anti-psychiatry people and reformers. It is psychiatry and acolytes who lump them together, because they don’t want reform and demonizing all critical voices suits their purpose. There is an irony here that few people will get!
Has anti-psychiatry turned from stimulant of change to a more harmful concoction? A timely and pointed op-ed by several prominent mental health voices here on X @jonathanstea @tylerblack32 @psychunseen The op-ed argues that today’s anti-psychiatry movement gets a lot wrong and actually ends up hurting the very people it claims to defend. While past critiques helped improve the field, the current wave often spreads misinformation, dismisses real suffering, and paints all psychiatric care as harmful. It ignores the science behind mental health treatments and overlooks how many people find real relief through therapy, medication, and support. In trying to tear everything down, it risks leaving people with no help at all.
medpagetoday.com/psychiatry/…
2
2
116
Good to hear this being said out load. As a matter of interest, heroin and cannabis will do the same. Just like prescribed medication they too are not related to the cause of psychological distress.
2
76
Not to be too anti-psychiatry.. and I don’t want to offend those with unquestioned faith/ allegiance with psychiatrists, but …
The sentiment and acknowledgement is good, but you appear to be proposing change, providing psychiatry retains its dominance and authority. This is no change at all. Psychiatry cannot profess to be the solution, having been the problem.
Replying to @BTP52
I hear your anger, and I don’t take it lightly. Criticism—especially from those who’ve been harmed—is essential if we’re ever going to build something better.
This isn’t about defending a system blindly. It’s about acknowledging pain, holding space for multiple truths, and staying open—even when it’s tough. That’s where real change begins.
3
140
Hard to describe how utterly misguided this. Just read the literature on stigma and mental health.
Hard not to agree with this, but it can be expressed differently. There are too many psychiatrists. They have no allegiance to science or unique claim on humanity, humility or connectivity. That which they do offer is too expensive.
1
99
This is true. The same is can be said about equating ‘anti-psychiatry’ with ‘ideology’. So easy to dismiss the ideologue. The irony is that in the absence of evidence to support its basic premise, psychiatry is an ideology of its supporters. The critique of this is not.
"The pejorative use of the phrase 'anti-psychiatry' [seeks to] denigrate the critic as irrational, unreasonable... thus weaponising the phrase in an attempt to misrepresent or delegitimise critical debate and dissent". 👇
madintheuk.com/2022/08/anti-…
2
79
Shall we simply swap carefully contrived stories of good and bad, each mocking the other?
I ask you re poor science, iatrogenic harm, overdiagnosis, bad side effects, informed choice and withdrawal issues; you reply with ‘you don’t care about my patient.’
Is this all you have?
1/2 A patient tells me that the auditory hallucinations are unwanted, distressing, & disabling. He finds the psy-medication to be helpful, with no significant side effects. According to antipsychiatrists I should tell him to avoid the medication because the illness is a blessing
1
83
Hard to disagree with this. We just need to define ‘most effective’, and make sure long term harm and informed choice is part of that algorithm.
All mental health professionals should be united in wanting patients to have the most effective treatment available, whether it’s medication, therapy, or ECT, or a combination of these.
1
57




















