Be Reasonable England (@BeReasonableEng) header
Be Reasonable England (@BeReasonableEng) profile picture

We oppose attempts to criminalise parents who smack their children.

England
Joined November 2022
.@BrexitStewart highlighted a new review from @christianorguk, examining 37 peer-reviewed studies. “Despite hysterical headlines suggesting one smack can ‘scar a child for life’, the review noted the studies… have never shown that physical punishment causes negative outcomes”
3
2
295
.@ladylilo2 warned that removing the ‘reasonable chastisement defence’ “is another step towards a nanny state, where the balance between parental responsibility and state intervention is quietly but significantly shifted away from families and towards government control”
1
1
67
.@BrexitStewart challenged claims that a smacking ban is needed to protect children from abuse, since abuse is already illegal.
1
39
.@Fox_Claire warned that hundreds of parents in Wales have been sent for ‘re-education’ under the ban. Because this can appear on enhanced DBS checks, a mum who smacks her child to stop them running into the road could be barred from working as a care assistant or childminder.
2
3
9
1,119
Be Reasonable’s Ciarán Kelly goes head to head with smacking ban campaigner Rosey Davidson on @SkyNews. He warns that putting loving parents in the same camp as abusers is going to make it even harder for children in real danger to be helped. youtu.be/-69ppEKJV7A
107
Sociologist Dr @AshleyAFrawley responds to celebrity calls for an English smacking ban @TalkTV She argues that a mum should be able to tap her toddler on the hand to make a point without her life being ruined by being convicted of criminal assault youtu.be/w7ugO_1GBFA
1
79
A smacking ban “does a grave injustice to good parents by making them out to be abusers when they're not”. Be Reasonable's Simon Calvert speaks to @TalkTV's @iancollinsuk about the NSPCC's latest calls for an English smacking ban. youtube.com/watch?v=WSI93IWL…
109
Our spokesman Simon Calvert warns Radio 2 listeners that a smacking ban will put thousands of parents each year in the cross-hairs of the criminal justice system for nothing more than tapping a child on the back of the hand.
53
A mum who taps their tot on the back of the hand—that is the kind of reasonable parental discipline that smacking ban campaigners want to criminalise, warns Be Reasonable’s Simon Calvert. @BBCLookNorth
4
3
261
‘Reality Will Be Less Help For Children Who Need It’ Be Reasonable's Simon Calvert on @TalkTV with @Iromg, explaining why an English smacking ban would only divert police and social work resources away from protecting abused children. youtube.com/watch?v=vWrMScXT…
2
115
MPs are expected to debate an amendment today to criminalise smacking in England. (1/3) youtu.be/hPCvoWM7qzI
8
2
3
6
6,710
‘Calls for a smacking ban are motivated by ideology, not scientific evidence’ Sociologist Dr @AshleyAFrawley on @BBCRadio4 youtu.be/xeJshPEDNMs
5
11
1,037