ReluctantlyBob (@Bob1089) header
ReluctantlyBob (@Bob1089) profile picture

observer of global affairs...always curious, inter-connections of security/development/democracy/finance...complexity of our time calls for humility not ego...

Joined May 2011
Photo by ReluctantlyBob (@Bob1089)Photo by ReluctantlyBob (@Bob1089)
ReluctantlyBob retweeted
I guess China's not part of the dangerous and divided world...
23
39
4
262
2,505
The thing is, this "tilt to Beijing" is bred in the bone within a powerful circle inside the Liberal Party. They were tilting to Beijing for years before they could use the Trumpist flotsam as a pretext. Where will Canada be when the Yanks right their ship?
“Then you have a tilt to Beijing.” Carney once called China our greatest security threat. Now he's looking to Beijing as an alternative to Washington.
42
117
5
398
8,524
ReluctantlyBob retweeted
🇨🇦 MET AN ELDERLY CANADIAN AT TORONTO PEARSON AIRPORT. HE SAID SOMETHING ABOUT CANADA I’LL NEVER FORGET. Our flight was delayed. He was sitting beside me, wearing a faded Canadian flag pin on his jacket, reading the news on his phone. I asked him where he was going. “Florida. Visiting my grandchildren.” “Nice. Escaping the Canadian winter?” He laughed. “Son, I’ve survived 70 Canadian winters. It’s the politics I’m getting tired of.” I smiled. “So you’re not a fan of Mark Carney?” He put down his phone. “Let me tell you something.” “I’ve worked for 45 years. Paid my taxes. Raised three children. Built a business. Never asked the government for much.” “Canada gave me opportunities I’ll always be grateful for.” “So what’s changed?” I asked. He pointed toward a young family sitting across from us. “Look at them.” “Both parents probably work. They’re travelling with two kids. They’ve got a mortgage, groceries, insurance, daycare and taxes to worry about.” “Forty years ago, a family could reasonably dream of owning a home on one good income.” “Today, even two incomes don’t guarantee that.” I nodded. He continued. “Young Canadians are graduating with debt, competing for jobs and wondering whether they’ll ever afford the life their parents had.” I asked him whether he blamed the Liberal government. He smiled. “I blame governments when they make poor decisions. I give them credit when they make good ones. That’s how democracy should work.” Then he said something interesting. “These days, criticize Carney or the Liberals and someone will tell you you’re being anti-Canadian.” “Does that bother you?” He looked at the maple leaf on his jacket. “Son, I’ve been wearing this flag longer than some of those politicians have been alive.” “I didn’t need permission from Pierre Trudeau to love Canada.” “I didn’t need permission from Stephen Harper.” “And I certainly don’t need permission from Mark Carney.” Our boarding announcement came over the speaker. He stood up, picked up his carry-on and turned toward me. “Let me ask you something.” “What?” “If you love your home, and the roof starts leaking, do you stop loving your home?” “Of course not.” “You fix the roof.” “And if the people you hired to maintain it keep making things worse?” “You hold them accountable.” He smiled. “Exactly.” Then he said something that stayed with me. “CANADA IS OUR HOME. THE GOVERNMENT IS JUST THE MANAGEMENT.” “You can love your country without loving the people running it.” As he walked toward the gate, I noticed the maple leaf on his jacket again. And suddenly, I understood. Politicians come and go. Governments rise and fall. But Canada belongs to Canadians, not to whichever political party happens to be in power. I LOVE CANADA. I DON’T HAVE TO LOVE ITS GOVERNMENT. And questioning its leadership doesn’t make anyone less Canadian. It means we still care enough to demand better. 🇨🇦 #Canada #Patriotism
341
1,080
71
4,280
245,104
ReluctantlyBob retweeted
🧐 How is this even debatable? I know it’s nearly impossible to deprogram the elbows-up crowd, but how can ANYONE look at this and still think it’s a good idea? “There is a risk of domestic worker displacement, as selected companies would have the ability to hire foreign workers with no labour market check or plan to improve the skills of Canadians” How exactly do they think those displaced Canadian workers are supposed to feed their families? This isn’t “immigration.” It’s a deliberate policy choice to undercut Canadian workers for the benefit of foreign investors. And it’s disgusting. @WiretapMediaHQ
💥NEW ATIP: Chrystia Freeland's WEF briefing notes reveal the government is pitching fast-track immigration and cheap labour to foreign investors. Worse—IRCC knows that, with no LMIA, Canadians will be displaced and wages will be suppressed—and they're doing it anyway.
49
513
13
1,474
18,245
ReluctantlyBob retweeted
Canadians are so ill-informed...
If Trump “gets squashed” in the midterms, Canadians won’t be living paycheck to paycheck…. Listen to these people CBC managed to find. We are cooked in this country.
254
426
38
2,660
39,251
ReluctantlyBob retweeted
What is so bananas about an article arguing that Canada needs even more government involvement to improve its economy is that, by many key metrics, the government's economic footprint is the largest it's been in 25 years. Employment, CAPEX, Consumption, and Taxes are just a few examples I've shared in the chart below. What does Canada have to show for it? A Productivity Emergency. Anemic private-sector CAPEX. Pitiful competition in Banking, Telecoms, and Transport. Net FDI Outflows. A 30-year low in R&D spend. Business birth collapse. Zero Equity IPOs. NYMBYs. Impact Assessments. Ethnic vetos. Mushrooming manufacturing regulations. Withering economic freedom. Censorship. Mass media bias. Historic hospital wait times. It goes on and on and on. Canada's problem is NOT a lack of government; it is that there is way too much government involvement. They pick winners, punish productivity, suppress talent, scare away what moves, tax what doesn't and squander billions; it's everywhere and in everything. And the results? abysmal. It may be time for a different approach.
64
278
25
1,064
21,232
ReluctantlyBob retweeted
Why? Because the effing Liberal government refuses to exert its exclusive jurisdictional authority over interprovincial pipelines. The Libs want it both ways: to continue playing footsie with FNs and eco activists while pretending to support the O&G sector.
FFS - It’s a pipeline that will help fund our lives. And those for many generations. Grow our economy. Why does anyone believe they have the right to VETO? If the pipeline gets cancelled will objectors agree to never take funds from Canada for any reason? calgaryherald.com/news/bc-fi…
8
31
3
138
1,422
ReluctantlyBob retweeted
The Canadian government's mass immigration policies of the last 10 years were highly regressive. Having seemingly learned nothing, they are dead set on turning back on the taps rather than letting the country heal. On cue, the media has begun parroting the government's narrative and gaslighting anyone who disagrees. This suggests that they remain blissfully unaware that the Bank of Canada has written extensively about how (mass) immigration has negatively affected housing, rents, inflation, labour supply, wages, and productivity. So I've compiled an inexhaustive list to help these folks. 🏘️- Monetary Policy Report, October 2023 🔗bankofcanada.ca/wp-content/u… ▶️"The strength in rent and other housing costs is partly due to strong housing demand, which is supported by rapid population growth, and a structural lack of housing supply" 🏘️- Staff Analytical Note, December 2023 🔗bankofcanada.ca/wp-content/u… ▶️"The rise in immigration is nonetheless contributing to pressures in inflation components linked to house prices, given that it is adding more to housing demand than to housing supply in the context of structural imbalances in the Canadian housing market." 🏘️ - Speech by Toni Gravelle, December 2023 🔗bankofcanada.ca/2023/12/econ… ▶️"When a country’s population is growing quickly, the supply of housing also needs to increase to avoid a worsening in affordability. Shortly after immigration began ramping up in 2015, Canada’s vacancy rate—a measure of how many apartments and houses there are available to rent or buy—started to fall." 🏘️ - Monetary Policy Report, January 2024 🔗bankofcanada.ca/wp-content/u… ▶️"A larger increase in newcomers than in the past is adding pressure to the structural supply constraint in housing. This has helped to push the overall housing vacancy rate to record lows, which has underpinned house prices and led to higher rents (Chart 3-A)." 🏘️ - Staff Analytical Note, April 2024 🔗 bankofcanada.ca/2024/04/staf… ▶️"Meanwhile, the composition of immigrants coming to Canada has changed considerably since 2015. Historically, growth of the immigrant population in Canada came mostly from permanent residents....While the wages of the earlier immigrants are closer to those of Canadian-born workers and have been increasing over time, those of non-permanent residents are much lower and have fallen over this period. Because real hourly wages are typically correlated with labour productivity, this piece of evidence is consistent with non-permanent residents working in less productive occupations." 🏘️ - Monetary Policy Report, July 2024 🔗bankofcanada.ca/wp-content/u… ▶️"The increase in housing demand from newcomers is being felt across all types of housing, but the largest initial impact tends to be in rental markets. This is because most newcomers start out as renters." 👨‍🌾 - Staff Analytical Note, May 2025 🔗bankofcanada.ca/wp-content/u… ▶️"if newcomers’ conditional wages reflect their labour productivity, the productive capacity of the Canadian economy grew less than it would have if recent newcomers had the same socio-economic characteristics as in the past." ▶️"However, this gain has been particularly acute for certain industries such as accommodation and food services, business, building and other support services, and retail trade. Labour productivity in these industries—which are comprised of a sizable share of lower-skilled occupations—is lower than the average in the business sector." 👨‍🌾 - Staff Analytical Note, May 2025 🔗bankofcanada.ca/2025/06/staf… ▶️"Youth—individuals 15–24 years of age—represent a significant portion of the overall increase in unemployment since the start of 2023. This is a larger share than during other periods of rising unemployment (Chart 5). This is partly due to the high number of immigrants, who are generally younger than the rest of the population." 👨‍🌾 - Speech by Nicolas Vincent, May 2026 🔗bankofcanada.ca/wp-content/u… ▶️“The labour market is particularly challenging for young people”: The 2022–24 influx of young newcomers “intensified competition in Canada for lower-skill and entry-level jobs”. Youth unemployment has risen above 14%, and he expects it may normalize now that immigration has been cut. 🏘️ - Staff Article, September 2026 🔗bankofcanada.ca/2026/09/spar… ▶️"Strong population growth drove asking rents higher in recent years"
230
1,374
139
4,118
294,287
ReluctantlyBob retweeted
✅ Net zero and climate mandates that destroyed the economy/productivity. ✅ Mass immigration that changed demographics, suppressed wages, and increased tax payer burden/relying on said mass immigration to artificially manage declining fertility rates, rather than implementing pro-family policies that reduce the cost of living and support domestic family growth. ✅ Deindustrialization due to high taxes and over regulation—prioritizing foreign manufacturing and imports over domestic. ✅ allowing Chinese transshipment to displace your existing Manufactueres and run them out of business. ✅ expanding the public sector pulling labour away from the wealth generating private sector. ✅ Implementing lenient bail reforms that release violent repeat offenders back into the community, fueling lawlessness and exhausting police resources. Mark Carney, his elite advisors, and the Liberal Party of Canada are not simply diagnosing a “global rupture”… their policies are the very rupture they are talking about.
26
245
5
810
7,960
ReluctantlyBob retweeted
A few years ago, these people said we were in a post-national state and that there was no “Canada.” They tore down statues and cheered. They burnt down churches and cheered. They demonized great Canadians who built Canada and cheered. They turned on fellow citizens and cheered. Don’t believe a word they say.
108
437
33
1,674
31,033
ReluctantlyBob retweeted
So no to the 51st, but ok to a new Indian state? The Elbows cult is fucking weird.
114
454
5
6,700
64,013
Call me crazy (or bananas) but couldn't we maybe, just maybe, focus on creating the conditions which enable Canadians to have more kids instead?
680
1,397
73
11,288
195,842
ReluctantlyBob retweeted
Statistically, this claims is akin to an alcoholic drinking 40 beers in a single night, and then declaring his drinking problem solved after he manages a couple nights of only drinking 30 beers.
17
106
1
949
9,180
ReluctantlyBob retweeted
You need to hear this if you haven’t figured out why Labor’s “Modern Australia” doesn’t include Australians. Whilst you’re listening, remember all of the times Albanese has said these terms: Indian-Australian Muslim-Australian Jewish-Australian African-Australian Instead of just “Australian”. Part of the Managed Decline in order to globalise under Agenda 2030, they must tear down any sense of nationalism or patriotism to one’s own country. This is a UNIPARTY agenda. Any party which supports UN, WEF, WHO or any other globalised agenda cannot be trusted to govern in the interest of Australians.
56
487
23
1,557
25,755
ReluctantlyBob retweeted
Canada's "economy" is propped up by immigrants who don't mind living with 10 other people in a bungalow You either have to get rich in Canada, or live with your parents (or 5 roommates) The middle of our society has been decimated by immigration
49
186
6
1,453
21,288
Victor Davis Hanson lays out that no one in America told Canada to import the equivalent of 45% of its population from non-assimilating sources, abandon its fossil fuels and pipelines, chase solar power in a frigid climate, accept the lowest GDP growth among industrial Western nations, or accept being $30–40k poorer per person/family than Americans. Nor did anyone force Canada to lead the world in assisted suicide as a cost-saving measure. Those choices—and the resulting inability to fund open borders, defense, or fair trade—came from Canadian leadership, not from Washington.
222
2,881
197
6,534
115,059
ReluctantlyBob retweeted
This kind of HATE must NEVER happen again
319
1,200
86
4,088
62,243
ReluctantlyBob retweeted
JUST IN: Georges St-Pierre sends a message of support to @DeanAllisonMP for giving a voice to Canadians injured by COVID-19 vaccines.
80
723
24
3,807
51,855
ReluctantlyBob retweeted
‼️ WOW - From 2015 to 2025, the Liberals issued 10+ MILLION temporary resident, work and study permits. And that DOES NOT INCLUDE permanent residents. And Carney wants us to believe he walked away from the deal to protect our “cultural sovereignty?”
138
1,206
61
3,047
49,320