Ben McIlwain @[email protected] retweeted
A frustrating but important debate is breaking out over the tragic building collapse in Flatbush.
The community is outraged. It should be. But at whom?
For some, it's the owner. The owner in this case appears to have been a negligent operator with many violations and major infractions. For them, the safety of the building is to blame.
Others are blaming the developer and gentrification. For them, the new building going up, perhaps improperly, confirms their fear that the community is being changed around them at a pace their finances cannot keep up with.
Politicians will tell the community to blame whoever is most beneficial to their own political careers. There will be hearings and new laws. In a few weeks everyone will have moved on.
Here's the reality.
More than half of the housing New Yorkers live in is at least 80 years old. Those buildings are in constant use, and they are under regulatory pressure to operate on the thinnest margins possible.
The only thing more important than safety in this city is promising a voter you are going to keep their rent low. But programs need to be paid for, and property taxes need to be paid. So while those promises are made to one side, costs continue to rise in the same buildings that are being starved of resources. Then if a renter isn't paying, lawmakers tell them the building can wait years before another cent is paid.
Again, the building's operational safety is irrelevant when it comes to making sure a renter pays the lowest rent possible, or nothing at all.
At the same time, rents in newer buildings are astronomical. That is partly because politicians have made other promises to other special interests, guaranteeing they will be paid extremely well to build new housing. Other building costs that the government controls or can influence, like insurance, spiral out of control. The same lawmakers demand that the laws making New York's insurance environment the most expensive on planet Earth remain untouched.
If old buildings are told to pound sand when they need more resources to operate safely, and new buildings are told they are not welcome, how exactly is New York housing ever going to improve?
Old buildings need more money if we want them to be safe and long lasting. This is just a fact.
For years New Yorkers have been told the devil's bargain they must make is to live in a more affordable, poorly run building or a newer, higher-priced but safer one.
It shouldn't be a choice.
Much older cities around the world have been able to preserve much older housing. That is in part because their housing doesn't run on a model of economic attrition. Government takes an active role in helping owners preserve buildings instead of strangling the building and demonizing the owner when they can't.
That has to be the case in New York. If not, I fear this cycle of tragedy, rage, press conference and forgetting will keep playing out for renters for the rest of our lives, to the benefit of no one but the people who profit from making promises they can't keep.
Ben McIlwain @[email protected] retweeted
Something is going horribly wrong in the Senate race in Michigan. And I am going to keep calling it out.
On the one hand, the Republicans are conducting a campaign of blatant anti-Muslim fear mongering. Mike Rogers, Donald Trump and the rest of the GOP need to knock it off. Mike needs to personally and repeatedly denounce hate against Muslims.
But now, at the same time, we have TWO ads from the Democratic side that ALSO traffic in hate and intolerance â causing alarm for some Black and Jewish voters.
Seriouslyâ WTF ????
The first ad was from Rebellion PAC (NOT the official Abdul El-Sayyed campaign). It suggested that Americans canât buy groceries because the USA sends so much money to Israel.
That is a lie. The USA spends less than 00.1 percent of our federal budget on support for Israel. But this ad pretends bananas cost too much because the Jewish state is bleeding us dry. TOTALLY nuts. And yet â this kind of thinking has always put Jewish lives at risk. Blaming Jews for everyoneâs economic problems has a long, bloody history.
Abdul did try to separate himself from the ad. He accurately noted that his campaign didnât produce it. But the problem is: if you listen, Abdul actually NEVER DENOUNCED the CONTENT of the ad. He never said, âThis ad is wrong.â
He just said, âHey, it wasnât me.â đŹđŹđŹ
That ad â and Abdulâs refusal to forthrightly denounce it â is scaring some Jewish Democrats in Michigan, who now are more reluctant to vote for him.
In other words, that one ad alone is jeopardizing our partyâs shot at taking back the U.S. Senate.
BUT IT GETS WORSE!
Then Abdulâs formal, official campaign put out its OWN ad â which features none other than the vile and contemptible Tucker Carlson (!!!). As you know, Tucker Carlson is a rabid, anti-Black bigot who also traffics in anti-Jewish stereotypes. He is anathema to most Black people and most Jews.
No Democrat should ever celebrate the words of a white nationalist who actively undermines the safety of Black people and Jewish people.
Moreover, given the importance of Black and Jewish Democrats to our victory in Michigan, the decision to include Tucker Carlson in any Democratic ad there is truly baffling.
Why am I speaking out about this now? Because I want Democrats to build a winning coalition â now and into the future. Chasing off any Black or Jewish voters is a path to defeat â both in the short term and the long term.
As proud Democrats, it can feel uncomfortable or risky to speak against intolerance in our own party, especially just days before a national election. It would be easier for us to let this stuff slide, shut up and close ranks.
But that would make us hypocrites. For 10 years, we Democrats have watched with dismay and disgust as Republicans (who know better) have refused to challenge ANY bad ideas or bad actions in their own ranks. As a result, their party curdled into a cult â one that is now wrecking the country AND falling apart.
As Democrats, we should not make the same mistake.
Anti-Muslim hate is wrong. Period.
Anti-Jewish hate is wrong. Period.
Tucker Carlsonâs white nationalism is wrong. Period.
All candidates in Michigan need to say that clearlyâ and then pull down/denounce any ads that normalize hate or elevate hate mongers.
Ben McIlwain @[email protected] retweeted
Israelâs valid military objective after October 7 was the rescue of its kidnapped people and the destruction of the military capacity of Hamas and the neutralization of the the threat to its civilians that Hamas demonstrated it represented on that day.
That meant no more rockets launched from Gaza at Israel. No more tunnel network for transporting, hiding and protecting troops, munitions and kidnapped Israeli hostages. And no more standing army of tens of thousands of bloodthirsty paramilitary fighters right on Israelâs border training and planning to slaughter civilians and drag children into spider-holes.
All of that had to be destroyed. Any action necessary to achieve that goal was proportionate. The collateral damage is unfortunate, but falls within parameters when balanced against Israelâs crucial security needs after suffering the atrocities of October 7, 2023.
If the death, destruction and loss was too much for the Palestinian people to bear, on every single day of the war, Hamas had the option to surrender and release the hostages. If Gaza had voluntarily disarmed and transitioned to civilian leadership that would cooperate with Israel on the decommissioning of Hamasâs munitions and tunnel infrastructure, Israelâs security objective could have been achieved with zero loss of civilian life.
Every single photo you see of the destruction in Gaza is something that Gaza chose. Every single death and every single destroyed building was proportionate and justified by the necessity of Israelâs security objective.
âNever againâ doesnât mean peace at any cost. That is the policy of Neville Chamberlain. âNever againâ means we will fight like demons before we will ever allow ourselves to be herded onto boxcars. âNever againâ means what happened to Gaza will happen to anyone who does something like October 7, 2023.
Gaza had the option not to do that. They are proud they did it and their supporters are rallying all over the world today to declare their intent to do it again. Gaza chose what happened and they are choosing what will continue to happen until they make a different choice.
Oh this was fun. Without spending too much time on it, here's mine. So many honorable mentions that didn't make the list (e.g. SimCity 2000). And for Drug Wars, it was specifically the TI calculator version, cheating in which got me into programming in the fire place.
Ben McIlwain @[email protected] retweeted
Replying to @Mr_Andrew_Fox
It is indeed striking and very useful. I upscaled the resolution so we can all use it more effectively:
Ben McIlwain @[email protected] retweeted
This idea that the government can solve crime without policing and incarceration by simply âinvestingâ in more programs is baseless and very, deeply wrongâas is the idea that governments _*cannot*_ provide public safety _*unless*_ we address the so-called âroot causesâ of crime (which politicians like this falsely assert are socioeconomic in nature).
First, serious violence is NOT driven by socioeconomic factors. The research on this is clear. See, e.g., this literature review from Jens Ludwig assessing the effect of transfer programs on serious violence: annualreviews.org/content/joâŚ
Second, to whatever extent violence might be driven by socioeconomic factors (itâs not), the history of New York (and that of other cities) illustrates clearly that those factors need not be addressed to control crime. In 1990, NYC experienced 2,262 murders. By 2017, that number had gotten down to 292. I can assure you (as can anyone in the DSA), that during that period, NYC did not eliminate (or even substantially reduce) poverty, income inequality, etc. The homicide rate didnât spike during the Great Recession (when the unemployment rate doubled), and itâs gone down significantly since 2021 after spiking a year earlier despite the poverty rate going up every year since 2022. (see, e.g., robinhood.org/news/robin-hooâŚ)
The social science literature is unambiguous in its demonstration of the FACT that policing (and other forms of social control) reduces crime. Hereâs a short digest:
⢠Social Control Works- link.springer.com/article/10âŚ
⢠Hiring police saves lives (especially in black neighborhoods)- aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.12âŚ
⢠As recently as 2010, year-over-year increases in policing expenditures produced returns of 63% on each additional dollar spent- eml.berkeley.edu/~jmccrary/câŚ
⢠Expanding police patrols reduced crime on adjacent city blocks by between 47-73%- law.upenn.edu/live/files/894âŚ
⢠Surging officers to high-crime precincts reduces violence significantly- journals.plos.org/plosone/arâŚ
⢠Increasing police presence in an area reduces crime in both the area and on adjacent blocks: repository.law.upenn.edu/DocâŚ
⢠Meta analysis showing that policing disorder, specifically, reduces overall crime- onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/âŚ
⢠Stepping up patrols reduces shootings- publicsafety.jhu.edu/assets/âŚ
Then there are the empirically demonstrable incapacitation effects of incarceration, which reduce crime by keeping active offenders behind barsâŚ
So no, you donât need to address root causes to control crime; and yes, we should absolutely spend more on traditional crime control measures because they work better than anything else that can be done at scale.
Ben McIlwain @[email protected] retweeted
Well, it was inevitable, and it happened.
Time and again, Russia brings down another Ukrainian apartment building with a missile in the middle of the night, burying entire families beneath the rubble.
Ukraine strikes one of Russiaâs largest and most strategically important oil refineries, around 3,000 kilometres from its own borders.
One side deliberately targets civilians. The other targets the infrastructure that fuels the war.
If anyone still struggles to see the difference, theyâre choosing not to.
Somehow this might easily be the dumbest take I've seen on here all week. I truly wonder what this person thinks the "real" name for all delicatessens is.
Replying to @quasimatt
Calling bs because no one native to the entire tri-state area would say deli lmaooo
1
652
Ben McIlwain @[email protected] retweeted
What's happening right now is a catch-22.
Trump is desperate for a deal for domestic political reasons pre-election, but the more obvious that desperation becomes, the harder it is to reach any positive deal that would justify the outcome.
Trump was pushed into this position by Pakistan and others who convinced him to do a ceasefire without actually securing any of the conditions he needed for the deal. The military achieved what they needed and with little cost, but the agreement after was never secured. Trump believed it would all be agreed to over time. But the other side and the alleged neutral parties did it knowing he would be reluctant to return to war and they just needed to buy time until the election was in view. Now the IRGC believes, despite the weak economy, they can just wait it out without giving up much or anything. The constant media and leaks don't help, but it's causing a complete disconnect between what Trump is projecting and what's actually happening.
This is also cause problems for BN and Israel because, unlike the conspiracies, they followed Trump's lead on this and are now stuck in that posture. So Hezbollah is emboldened because despite starting the war and firing constantly on Israel, their sponsor terror state is using the mere promise of a deal to get Tump to restrain any response. So the mere promise of a deal is leading to one-sided demands on both fronts.
The one thing Trump has going for him is that the Iranian economy is legitimately in serious trouble with the blockade. So realistically he has 3 choices:
1) Restore credible threat of restarting military activity to force the IR to come to the table with real concessions regardless of political consequences domestically. Force re-open SoH.
2) Simply take any bad deal to declare victory, but I suspect this will also cause bad consequences domestically as you will have trouble selling your base on it and will suppress turnout in November.
3) Just buy time until after the election while maintaining economic pressure on the Islamic Republic with the blockade. Keep pushing for a real deal in the meantime. This does make it difficult to claim a win before the election, but Tehran loses their leverage after. The concern here is that the IRGC is likely to try to escalate and make more demands to force you into 1 or 2 as we saw last night. But it also requires acknowledging that you're not a few days away from a sudden deal.
That's not how people think about ratings though, and thus it isn't a metric suitable for this purpose. You need to find a different metric, that measures the overall amount of luxury/services provided.
(Also your reply settings are really locked down, I can only quote reply.)
That's exactly the point
A more expensive hotel should have a much higher rating that matches the increase in cost but none of them do, often worse ratings
1
408
One big issue with this analysis: People take the price into account when leaving their rating. An 8 at a motel is quite different than an 8 at a $3k/night ultra-luxury resort. So I don't think the metric of rating points per dollar has any meaning.
Agreed, and I can prove that luxury hotels are mathematically literally very bad value
For the amount of "more" money you pay for this luxury, you should be getting way way way more than you actually get (as measured by ratings)
Aman should have an average rating of 9.5 but in reality barely hits an 8 on average, so they simply cannot produce the "luxury" experiences they are trying to market and brand themselves for
It's essentially all smoke and mirrors, and reflects my experiences completely, you pay 10x more and get either 0.5x-1.5x more (eg many times 2x worse, sometimes a bit better) not 10x better!
Other luxury chains are slightly better but none of them even get close to a 9 rating with the famous Ritz-Carlton being especially bad: its average rating is a 7.68 for a median price of $549/night, terrible!
Real value can be found with Okura, Minor, Melia and even Marriott. Okura is interesting because well known as luxurious but median only $143/night
So as I always say, luxury is mostly a scam, it doesn't exist and you're best off spending much less for much better value (and often better experiences too)
Source: my new site stats page hotelist.com/stats
Ben McIlwain @[email protected] retweeted
can't believe i spent my whole life becoming Good At Computer only for Computer to become Better At Computer
Tryna watch the Knicks playoffs game right now and it's not broadcast on TV in NYC? WTF? I need cable to watch it? Who the hell still has cable??
163
Ben McIlwain @[email protected] retweeted
Wild how we would be better off if we just nuked all regs passed since like ~2005
Traffic is atrocious in my neighborhood (Kips Bay) right now. Total gridlock in intersections, multiple ambulances and city busses blocked, hard to even cross as a pedestrian. Congestion pricing needs to go to $20 immediately.
2
157
Ben McIlwain @[email protected] retweeted
There's a lot to say, of course, about how much this sort of thing -- safe, comfortable Westerners appointing themselves arbiters of which nations are allowed to exist -- has taken over the politics of the Western left.
Or about what Israelis see that they don't -- for example, why Israeli Jews who hail from the Arab world are more right-wing and hawkish than the ones thrust upon the land artificially by European empires (or whatever).
Or about how no other Jews in any meaningful numbers actually managed to survive the 20th century outside the Anglophone world -- and when most Jews were actually fleeing to Israel, the Anglophone world was closed to them. The great exception, of course, is Soviet Jews, who were trapped in place and had their culture violently and brutally erased from them, and then fled almost entirely when the Iron Curtain fell.
Or, come to think of it, about how the Jewish claim to the land isn't about some dusty old lineage, but to a great extent from every generation's own contemporary story; from nearly every chapter of the Jewish Bible and prayerbook read and studied in every synagogue on Earth for two millennia; from how every synagogue for two millennia prayed toward Jerusalem; from the medieval rabbis who at the end of their lives boarded a boat to the land of Israel so they can be buried there; from how no Muslim or Christian ever doubted that Jewish attachment until they needed to pretend to forget it in order to fight Jewish immigration.
There's even a lot to say about the fundamental fakery of Western romantic discourse on indigeneity -- about how Jews were told to "go to Palestine" by Polish and Iraqi nationalists who rejected them for not being indigenous enough to Poland or Iraq, and to "go to Poland" by Palestinian activists because they're not indigenous enough to be in the land of Israel. (No one told them to go back to Iraq, of course, though they were a quarter of Baghdad's population in 1930. The brownness of half of Israeli Jews upsets the comfortable assumptions of the Western indigeneity industry, so it's ignored.)
It turns out it's possible, according to the self-appointed indigeneity auditors of the Western left, for there to exist a people that's not indigenous anywhere, and so undeserving, even in the midst of the brutal genocide of millions, of any other place to escape to. (Does Caitlin know that the Jews who fled to Israel had literally nowhere else to go? If not, her crime is ignorance. If yes, her crime is a denial of history so that history can be repeated. I hope it's ignorance.)
There's a lot to say about her final point, that it wouldn't actually be dangerous for the Jews to become a Middle Eastern minority once more; about how minorities generally have fared in the Middle East over the past century, and whether it really is crazy for Israelis, especially those hailing from the Arab world, to suspect that a future as a Middle Eastern minority would be a dark and bloody one; and about how it is the likes of Hamas, not some right-wing Israeli rabble-rouser, that keeps telling Israelis this is the case.
But what would be the point?
What would be the point of saying all that to someone who has adopted the demolition of another nation as the engine of her moral world. Such a person isn't going to sit with any of the actual history or dilemmas of this land and ask herself whether there might be some gargantuan lacunae in her understanding.
Instead, let me offer a small and practical response in place of the great and grandiose dives into the depths of the Israeli soul.
I think, dear Caitlin, that for all the reasons above and a few more besides, we Israelis will keep our self-determination, this safety we have found in a world that for all its endless self-righteousness never actually saves anyone. And I think, too, that those activists, like you, who condition Palestinian self-determination on us losing our own only pushes off the day of that blessed and necessary independence.
Basically every Israel-Palestine debate goes like this:
"Israel did X."
"Yeah, because the Palestinians did Y."
"Yeah, because Israel did Z."
"Yeah but only because the Arabs did A."
But if you bring the debate back far enough in time, eventually you get to the part where the western world forcibly dropped a brand new ethnostate on top of a pre-existing civilization without the permission of â and to the extreme detriment of â the people who were already living there.
Sure you can go further back and say "Oh yeah well the Jews lived there thousands of years ago," but that's just silly. There's no valid reason to believe some Jewish guy in New York City even has any meaningful lineage connecting him to that land more strongly than any random Muslim in Turkey or wherever, and even if there was, it would still be absurd to cite ancient history as the basis for a territorial claim. I'm only a few generations removed from my ancestry in Ireland and Scotland, but it would be ridiculous for me to show up demanding the home of someone who lives there.
So the original source for the grievance is clearly the artificial creation of an ethnonationalist state in the mid-20th century, and the push by Zionists and western imperialists to make it happen.
And how has that decision worked out? You see the results before you. Generations of nonstop violence and abuse, culminating in the slaughter and chaos throughout the middle east today.
This means that creating Israel was a mistake. A mistake that needs to be corrected.
Zionists will collapse into a shrieking pile of vitriol and hyperbole when you say this, claiming you're calling for the extermination of Jews, but this is false. Certainly ending a national order premised on putting the interests of Jews before Palestinians and righting the wrongs of the past would inconvenience a lot of the Jewish people who've been living there, but there's no basis for the claim that it would entail their deaths. Apartheid South Africa was dismantled without the extermination of millions of white people, and there's no reason to believe the dismantling of apartheid Israel would entail the extermination of Jews.
The Israel experiment has been tried, and it has failed. It is time to try something else.
Ben McIlwain @[email protected] retweeted
America already went through long periods of imported sectarian violence. The Orange and Green riots, Haymarket, the anarchist wave around McKinleyâs assassination, which produced the Immigration Act of 1903 barring anarchists. The country has historically drawn a line at foreign-born political violence and its enablers, and that line has held across aisles for most of its existence.
NYMag doesnât grasp how deeply wrong this article is because itâs trapped in its own ideological bubble, one that treats pro-Palestine campus activism as inherently righteous âresistance,â frames any immigration enforcement under Trump as authoritarian persecution, and systematically downplays or denies the antisemitism, disruption, and foreign policy problems tied to these protests.
While Khalil waxes poetic about the life he misses, the piece never lays out his role as the lead negotiator for Columbia University Apartheid Divest during the 2024-2025 encampments and Hamilton Hall occupation. These werenât peaceful âanti-warâ vigils.
Columbia Universityâs own Antisemitism Task Force documented widespread harassment. Jewish students faced spitting, slurs, ostracism, exclusion from spaces, and an intense climate of intimidation and violent confrontation. Khalil was filmed ranting aggressively at pro-Israel tables, with more incidents reported by eyewitnesses than caught on camera.
His activist network was steeped in extreme rhetoric calling to âglobalize the intifada,â âin our lifetime,â âfrom the river to the sea,â and to âeradicateâ Western civilization. They distributed materials aligned with Hamas and other designated terror organizations such as the Popular Front for the Liberation for Palestine, and refused to condemn Hamas or terrorism. Khalil downplayed campus antisemitism as âmanufacturedâ and justified October 7 in ways that tacitly when not overtly promoted terrorism.
NYMag like much of the liberal legacy media has persistently covered these protests sympathetically while treating Jewish student complaints and post-Oct. 7 antisemitism spikes with perfunctory hedging raked over the coals of overblown âZionistâ pushback narratives.
Theyâd never run a similar sob-story essay from an extremist leading anti-LGBTQ or anti-Black protests with comparable disruption. Here the cause of a foreign-born agitator advocating violence against protected groups in a manner that is wholly corrosive to the American project is sanctified, and Khalil is pitched in the horrifying register of Hamasâs ideological frame, as a martyr, as someone who just misses their old New York life.
It does not occur to them that the Bibas children are not here to essay about the lives they miss, or how grotesque it is that what he misses is the sense of security American freedoms he abused gave him to harass and disrupt the lives of American minorities.
It is a moral failure, so genuine and complete, that we see in these outlets that it marks an indelible cleavage in American society. There are those who will not, and cannot understand the words that I write here. And then there are those who cannot stomach the words and epidemic mindset of these media outlets and their subjects.
In the minds of either side, there is no room to question who is right and who is wrong. One advocates for moral clarity, the other advocates for moral relativism, with both set firmly on a confrontational course that appears increasingly unavoidable.
For me Oct. 7 was barbarism, âglobalize the intifadaâ is incitement, harassment of Jews is antisemitism regardless of the dressing, and non-citizens, even green-card holders, do not get a free pass to import foreign conflicts that undermine the national interest. The other side embraces moral relativism, for them context excuses everything, âresistanceâ is elastic enough to include terror apologetics, and enforcement against it is the real threat. Never the twain shall meet; that flag is planted where it rightfully belongs.
âLast March, a fog took hold in my head and never left. It settled there somewhere between the moment a DHS agent asked me, âAre you Mahmoud Khalil?â and the moment I realized that I would miss the birth of my first child,â writes Khalil.
A year ago, the Trump administration unlawfully arrested Khalil at his home and detained him for 104 days. âI walk free now, only after an army of lawyers sued the administration for targeting me because of my pro-Palestine speech. But the government is relentless in targeting me,â he writes. âSo when I walk, I watch my back.â
âWhen strangers approach me and ask, âAre you Mahmoud Khalil?â â the same words in the same expectant tone the DHS agent used before the handcuffs â I do not know if they want to shake my hand or spit in my face. I do not know whether they will say, âThank you for what you're doing,â or follow me through midtown aggressively shouting, âAm Yisrael Chai.â Both have happened. At first glance, I can never tell them apart.â
In a new essay, Khalil writes about grappling with these two truths: âThat I walk through the city afraid and that the city, in small and persistent ways, tells me I am welcome. That I am watched and that I am seen.â Read it in full: nymag.visitlink.me/tM03B5
Ben McIlwain @[email protected] retweeted
I am a Democrat. I served in the Clinton administration. I did not vote for Donald Trump and am highly unlikely to support him or his acolytes in the future. I also have serious disagreements with many of the Trump administrationâs domestic and foreign policies.
But it is profoundly disturbing that a growing segment of the far left appears to be almost rooting for Hamas, Hezbollah, the Iranian regime, and other forces fundamentally opposed to the United States and our allies. This seems to reflects a corrosive strain of anti-Americanism, dressed up in postcolonial theory, that risks blinding us to the moral realities of our world and the nature of our adversaries.




























