Rebuking 'Sunnah' with Sunnah. Enjoyer of Islamic History and Discussions.
Joined November 2022
- Tweets18.2K
- Following552
- Followers7.2K
- Likes45K
Yes, being good or bad has no bearing on whether you remain in the army, neither friendship to the Prophet (as).
Your argument rests on wishing not on reality. The Muslims recalled the battle of Yarmouth ‘inhazemna’ meaning we were defeated.
Khalid should have fought till death like the previous two leaders. ‘Tactical retreat’ is a farce
Khalid didn’t win Mutah, 🤭
Being sword of Allah must take on islams ethics and guides. It means nothing without it. Or else other ‘Islamic conquerors’ deserve it more
Does a persons deeds make up a person?
So if I had a friend and he stole next to me and I say “I’m innocent of the stealing” does that now mean I approve of the person?
Disassociate from a persons actions is what makes up a person.
You know that your ideas are contradictory to Islam. It’s clear even to you.
If he was really sword of Allah why would the Prophet (as) disassociate from his action committed by the sword ?
Use your brain please
Khalid: flees battles, kills innocents, kills a Sahabi, rapes a woman = sword of Allah
Don’t you have any shame???
You yap a lot and you have never read classical works only stupid cherry picked accounts.
You haven’t even read the Karbala story from classical works either… it’s funny.
Khalid was indeed a person who fled Mutah 🤭.
Have you realised I keep my responses concise ? Shall I bore you with long paragraphs?
Disputing Sunnah retweeted
في فاجعه هزت مشاعر ووجدان شيعه اهل البيت عليهم السلام بعد اقدام السلطات الكويتيه مساء الاثنين على اعدام فضيله الشيخ حسين المعتوق مع عدد من المؤمنين بتهمه حضور جنازه الوليه الفقيه السيد علي الخامنئي في كربلاء والنجف
انا لله وانا اليه راجعون
#الكويت
بأي ذنب قُتل يا أحفاد يزيد
May Allah curse you for propagating a lie that Khalid, who killed many innocence to be the sword of Allah
Okay so Muslims should go on to murder and be given leeway.
At what point does a persons actions make up a person to you? Like literally the most evil of deeds
Malik didn’t abandon Islam. Umar wanted Khalid killed for his actions. Even Abu bakr paid blood money which shows they were Muslim.
Khalid was just a rapist who killed for money and women
Nothing new.
I’ve read history. You’ve just got some Sunni writing copes for you.
I literally have the scans of first hand accounts from Sunni history
We already know the mainstream view.
You’ve not read history in detail from classical works to know the real reason he killed them.
You can’t prove the Prophet as viewed it as ijtihad
What Khalid did was not ijtihad, neither did the Prophet (as) infer it’s ijtihad.
Whereas Khalid did go on to kill people just because they belonged to a tribe
If you’re not saying Khalid did ijtihad, why bring it up? You clearly inferred the Prophet (as) viewed Khalid’s actions as ijtihad.
I’m not making up reactions, I’ve read the history.
Sure it’s a figure of speech, but they did indeed accept Islam, but Khalid killed them for one reason. They came from a tribe. If it wasn’t for soldiers refusal Khalid would have succeeded in killing them all
A ‘cope research’ would still be infinitely better than your lies.
The Prophet (PBUH) called it a ijtihad. He condemned what happened and the actions, but forgave Khalid (RA) for his grave error. He was not stripped of any command role and was used elsewhere. Why would you send Khalid (RA) to negotiate that? That makes zero logical sense. That would inflame the situation more no matter how sorrowful or apologetic one is. Ali (RA) being sent there wasn’t stripping him of anything?
An entire village? Come on, even your own scholars don’t say that or believe it. Why lie more? 😂
Where did you say ‘the prophet (as) made a judgement’?
What Khalid did is not ijtihad, you don’t understand it. I don’t need to repeat myself again.
Ijtihad isn’t about making up your own rules or reactions . Khalid killed people out of revenge
So Khalid got double reward for killing people - an act that the Prophet (AS) distanced himself from ?
According to your beliefs.. LMAO
Say your beliefs loud and clear
(No the Prophet (as) didn’t call what Khalid did as ijtihad an neither what Khalid did was ijtihad)