Deb (@Elephantastick) profile picture
Joined July 2025
Photo by Deb (@Elephantastick)Photo by Deb (@Elephantastick)Photo by Deb (@Elephantastick)Photo by Deb (@Elephantastick)Photo by Deb (@Elephantastick)Photo by Deb (@Elephantastick)Photo by Deb (@Elephantastick)Photo by Deb (@Elephantastick)Photo by Deb (@Elephantastick)Photo by Deb (@Elephantastick)
Replying to @UKLabour
Rebuild this bridge, Andy EU VAT law exempts qualifying education under Article 132(1)(i) Yet @UKLabour added 20% VAT on independent school fees If we're aligning with Europe, do the right thing SCRAP VAT ON SCHOOL FEES #EducationNotTax
2
14
57
345
From @ShippersUnbound piece last year on EU negotiations: "Tuition fees was seen as a marginal issue by ministers, because the sums involved are not huge in the greater scheme of things. However, it is understood they ignored warnings from Lindsay Croisdale-Appleby, the British ambassador to the EU, who was quick to sense that the issue was important to Ursula von der Leyen, the president of the European Commission who has at least one child at university in England. A Brussels-based source said: 'It is not exactly a burning question for most Europeans but for the type of people around the table in Brussels university fees are a big deal because they want their kids to study in UK, especially at the more expensive Russell Group universities.'" The EU is laughing in Burnham's face by stalling the Labour 'reset' over this.
23
285
33
944
47,742
Many universities are being pushed towards financial collapse & politicians announce fee cuts to win applause Who pays the difference? Unless universities are properly compensated, this is irresponsible grand-standing
🚨 NEW: Andy Burnham has agreed to cut tuition fees for EU students from £38,000 to as low as £9,970 a year as part of the EU deal
5
10
2
52
2,545
Not correct. Pre-Brexit, EU students generated deficits, not surpluses for universities - because they paid home fees. They also cost the taxpayer billions as they largely failed to repay their student loans. (The critique of post-Brexit Tory student policy is fair).
Important to delve into how Brexit created an asylum crisis in the university system why Burnham increasing EU students is crucial to bringing it under control. Before Brexit our universities were heavily dependent on EU students. Brexit, with an end to the home fees, meant that the amount of EU students was always going to contract sharply threatening university finances. The Tories pushed a solution: dramatically expand the number of students from poorer developing countries with much worse human rights records. The government’s own 2021 strategy was to heavily promote our universities to students in Nigeria, India and Pakistan. The expect replacement of student origins did take place. Students from the EU shrank to 28k or -57% and soared from non-EU countries to 399k or +54%. The result was an asylum surge. In 2024, the amount of students from non-EU claiming asylum. In 2024, a full 4% of all non-EU migrants on student visas issued that year claimed asylum. Thats 15,910 people or 15.2% of all that year’s UK asylum claims. A cool £230m cost to the tax payer over the life of those claims. As much as 15.4% of all study visas issued to Pakistanis in 2024 claimed asylum. EU nationals essentially can’t claim asylum only in the most extreme circumstances and even there are unlikely to get it. In 2024 only one — yes, 1 — EU national on a study visa from Spain claimed asylum. Moving our universities back to relying primarily on EU students if they are to rely on foreign nationals at all, is therefore important if you want to reduce the asylum explosion from study visas. Just one reason why 53% of eligible voters polled think Brexit has failed on migration.
10
36
1
136
5,115
Some transparent data from @hmtreasury & @educationgovuk would be welcome. Maybe @CommonsEd would welcome some too after the vast increase in SEND units & >130 self-funding school closures? Dozens of schools close between each @CommonsEd meeting. Infrastructure crumbles and crumbles and crumbles whilst hugely expensive unworkable Inclusion/Exclusion Zones are not not an obvious answer.
1
3
40
Replying to @Harpreet911
Here are the stats
4
10
2
23
4,777
A Plan 2 Graduate pays up to 6% interest on their student debt. Trapped in debt, they need to earn £66k a year just to keep ahead of the interest payments. But rather than help, government plans to spend £450m subsidising EU student fees. Priorities??? edrith.co.uk/p/rage-rage-aga…
8
86
6
285
15,657
Many people will evaluate the reputational consequences of holding a belief before evaluating the evidence for it.
63
412
35
2,640
71,013
Okay so I am confused. Should I be preparing for a 90 day blackout, WW3, or Christmas , cause I do not have money for all three.
240
1,339
81
12,198
406,079
Sort it out @sainsburys. Neglecting the elderly is not good for business.
812
2,960
172
15,016
811,743
Should I be preparing for WW3, a 90-day blackout, or the holidays? Because I don’t have the money for all 3.
919
7,655
447
57,460
1,509,477
Replying to @ChildrensComm @DCMS
Just checking — will ALL schoolchildren benefit equally from this initiative, regardless of the type of school they attend? Or will some theatres continue to operate discriminatory two-tier pricing, charging independent school pupils more for exactly the same experience? And if they do, will you @lisanandy and @ChildrensComm be writing to them to challenge these policies and demand equal treatment for ALL children? Removing barriers to arts and culture must mean removing them for every child. #EducationNotTax educationnottaxation.org/ind…
1
13
1
66
1,356
Earlier this year, the poor earnings of graduates with low prior attainment began to get traction - including in articles by the FT's @Smyth_Chris and in my own Tarnished Towers. DfE responded by...removing the data from the latest release. Thanks to FOI, here it is:
8
32
4
232
52,677
Deb retweeted
Michigan's Democratic candidate for Senate Abdul El-Sayed confronted @jamesmatthewsky, telling him he wouldn't answer his questions as he wants "zero" votes in the UK. Watch the heated exchange between the two. Watch our live coverage of the US midterms➡️ trib.al/BikRSb2
4,418
2,230
2,267
25,384
13,432,623
Everyone wants to argue about reparations for slavery that ended 200 years ago. ⚖️ Almost nobody talks about the 50 million people living in slavery right now. ⛓️ In North Korea, it's one person in every ten. 2.7 million. 🇰🇵 In Eritrea, some are trapped for decades in "national service". 320,000 people. 🇪🇷 Mauritania only made owning a slave a crime in 2007. 😶 In Saudi Arabia, Kuwait and the UAE, workers have their passports locked in a drawer. Over 900,000 people. 🛂 Turkey's basement sweatshops. Tajikistan's cotton fields. Russia's building sites. Afghanistan's brick kilns. Millions more. 🧱 In 1772, it was argued in an English court that England's air was too pure for a slave to breathe. 🌬️ Last year, over 23,000 possible victims were found in Britain. One in five were British. 🇬🇧 Two hundred years ago, ordinary Britons refused to look away. They ended it once. ⚓ So before we argue about the past, how about we finish ending slavery? ☝️ Every number is in the film. 🎬 Nullius in verba. Take nobody's word for it. Not even ours. 📊 Sources: UN International Labour Organization, Walk Free and the International Organization for Migration, Global Estimates of Modern Slavery 2022. Walk Free, Global Slavery Index 2023. Home Office, National Referral Mechanism statistics. Be part of us. Be Proud Of Us.
20
535
22
1,258
34,260
The numbers don’t lie. Labour’s VAT tax on education has driven 43,126 kids out of independent schools, 3 times their forecast and forced 251+ schools to close or merge. Calling this “modest” is a joke. It’s an attack on aspiration. Scrap this spiteful tax now
The @Telegraph reports that civil servants told ex EdSec @bphillipsonMP that the impact of @UKLabour's spiteful tax on children was "not transformative" and that the exodus of children was "modest" according to an FOI request. The data doesn't back this, and it's time to end this tax. @SabriSun_Miller, thank you for your helpful reporting. We would love to see the FOI documents as well. telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/10…
7
31
2
122
1,903
What if there is another way to look at this and that is the 'Boris wave' were purposefully brought over by vulture employment agencies & Private Care home businesses to purposefully keep wages & conditions low so everyone could make a profit. And this course of action has been the worst choice for everyone except those who are making a lot of of money out of it.
It's shocking to see 'low-wage care workers' portrayed as a drain on the welfare state. They're doing essential jobs and the only reason they claim benefits is that the fat cat private equity bosses that own care homes don't pay them enough to live on.
26
48
2
286
5,926
So the government taxes me for paying for my own education… …and wants to subsidise European student to the tune of 1/2 a billion. Europeans don’t pay taxes in the uk but get an education subsidy. Whereas I pay taxes in the uk and pay an education tax. Disgraceful
Andy Burnham is planning to spend up to £450m a year subsidising tuition fees for European students. In a major giveaway to Brussels, the Prime Minister is reportedly considering cutting fees for EU students from £38,000 to as low as £9,535, in line with domestic UK undergraduates 🔗 telegraph.co.uk/politics/202…
7
28
1
76
1,067