Pinned Tweet
How Ukraine 🇺🇦 Can and Likely Will Significantly Outmatch Russia 🇷🇺 Within 1-4 Years
(10-15 minute read)
Putin was wrong - on February 24th 2022, he thought he’d take Kyiv in 3 days.
Putin is wrong still today - he thinks he has the advantage over Ukraine in a long war of attrition.
And now, Putin is slowly but steadily marching Russia directly into a comprehensive military catastrophe.
Though we are seeing rough parity between Ukrainian and Russian forces on the ground today; parity for a moment is no guarantee of parity indefinitely.
The frontline situation in Ukraine is as active as it has been at any point in the war. The decimation currently being inflicted on Russian forces will likely destroy their long term prospects in this conflict. Momentum can shift rapidly in warfare, and with more time, I anticipate it will shift slowly but steadily in Ukraine's favor.
If this war drags on beyond 2024 into 2025, Russia 🇷🇺 will more likely than not lose battlefield parity with Ukraine 🇺🇦, and will more likely than not begin to accumulate significant disadvantages on the frontlines.
Six reasons Ukraine will almost certainly gain decisive advantages over Russia within 1-4 years:
1) Russia’s reportedly “bottomless” stores of key Soviet kit have bottoms that are rapidly looming into view:
• @CovertCabal completed independent counts of stored Russian artillery systems, infantry fighting vehicles, and tanks, finished 14 July, 21 Oct, and 27 Oct respectively.
• W/out these three systems, Russia will lose practically all offensive ground capability, and will also struggle to defend occupied ground.
• At whole-war average loss rates, Russia will be out of stores of artillery systems in 3 years, IFVs in 3-3.5 years, and tanks in 2.75 years.
• They pull the best condition units first, so the longer they draw down stores, the worse the condition of what is pulled, and the harder it will be to field. So, they may run out of usable units sooner than the above estimates.
• In their assault on Avdiivka, Russia’s armor and artillery losses have surged: tank losses have jumped from ~4 per day to 10+ per day.
• If we consider the drawdown of remaining stores may happen at either the new faster rate or the slower whole-war average rate, Russia will be struggling to field all three systems within 1-3 years.
• Once they run out of stored systems, there will be a slight lag for their fielded equipment to attrit to a point they are struggling at the frontlines. Therefore, their struggles for tanks, IFVs, and artillery systems will almost certainly begin within 1-4 years from Oct 2023.
• Currently, Russian domestic production of these systems doesn’t come close to battlefield losses, hence the rapid drawdown of stored systems. It is highly unlikely for both cost and logistical reasons Russia could ramp their domestic production to match battlefield losses which are in the multi-thousands of each system per year.
2) Putin’s option of full mobilization and switching to a total war economy has practically evaporated entirely:
• @TheStudyofWar in their 30 Nov Russia/Ukraine update summarized October opposition polling in Russia, and support for the war is plummeting.
• Only 12% of Russian respondents want the war to continue and military spending increased to support it - down from 22% in February.
• Only 33% in total want the war to continue; 21% therefore apparently want it to continue, but without increased military spending - 33% is down from 47% in February.
• 40% support a withdrawal regardless of whether military objectives are achieved.
• 55% want Russia to begin peace negotiations.
• The partial mobilization last year drove ~1M working/fighting age Russians to flee the country.
• A full mobilization would cause another exodus and cripple the already fragile economy.
• Inflation in Russia is high and edging higher: it rose from 6% in September to 6.7% in October, and is expected to have exceeded 7.5% in November.
• The ruble continues to trade near the 100 ruble per USD mark, hampering Russia's purchasing power with neighbors.
• Labor shortages in Russia have been driving up wages, thus putting further upward pressure on inflation.
• @Telegraph reported Dec 8th in their "Ukraine The Latest" podcast that labor shortages are hitting the factories producing military equipment, thus Russia can only produce large quantities of simpler systems and cannot produce much of the more sophisticated equipment they need such as cruise missiles.
• So Russia is in a bind: keep men at home to produce equipment and struggle to man the front, or man the front and struggle to produce the equipment that is needed to arm the front. This problem will steadily get worse as the war drags on.
3) Russia's air defense capabilities are strained and with more time will certainly degrade to ineffectiveness:
• The open sourced site Oryx, which has counted Russian equipment losses since the start of the full invasion, has confirmed a minimum of 188 surface to air missile systems and 45 anti-aircraft guns have been lost. These are visually confirmed losses, and so they represent the MINIMUM that Russia has lost so far. oryxspioenkop.com/
• Over the summer, @Telegraph reported through "Ukraine The Latest" that roughly 300 of Russia's 700+ air defense systems had been taken offline.
• Ukraine claims to have inflicted damage to 605 systems, which can be assumed to be the maximum number of Russia's systems that have been damaged, destroyed, and/or captured. Some of these systems will have been repaired and brought back online
• It is clear Russia's air defense issue is growing considering they appear to have recently pulled systems from their satellite enclave, Kaliningrad, which is surrounded on all sides by NATO members.
*** It should be noted that if Putin was truly worried about a NATO invasion, he would not have done this. He has yet again exposed that his concerns about NATO expansion were a fabricated excuse to try to exercise a land-grab. ***
• As more air defense systems are damaged and destroyed, the network as a whole that must protect both the entire 600 mile frontline in Ukraine as well as the similarly long shared boarder between the warring countries will be increasingly at risk of being destroyed entirely.
• Increased gaps in the network will allow Ukraine to selectively target key nodes, and thus they will expand existing gaps by more easily destroying additional systems. This will slowly but surely happen throughout the 1-4 years it will take for armor and artillery to also attrit to critical levels.
• As Russia's air defense network in Ukraine continues to degrade, ongoing Ukrainian deep strikes on Russian targets will have higher and higher success rates, thus exacerbating manpower and supply issues for Russia at the frontlines.
4) The forced withdrawal of Russia's Black Sea Fleet weakens Russia's ability to threaten southern Ukraine:
• While frontline shifts on the ground have been minimal for both Ukraine and Russia over the past year, Ukraine secured an enormous victory by forcing Russia to withdraw nearly its entire Black Sea Fleet from Sevastopol in Western Crimea.
• By achieving so many successful strikes on Sevastopol, Ukraine has reduced Russia's navy presence in the Black Sea to be little more than very expensive cruise missiles silos that can only fire from the far side of Crimea.
• With Russia's navy in the Black Sea incapable of operating west of Crimea due to the risk of losing more ships costing hundreds of millions in US dollars, Ukraine has successfully secured safe passage for commercial ships transporting Ukrainian grown grain, thus insulating a key element of Ukraine's economy from Russia's efforts to destroy critical civilian infrastructure.
• By further insulating their domestic economy from the threats posed by the war, Ukraine is ensuring they can continue to bring the fight to Russia long-term if the war indeed lasts multiple additional years.
5) While Russia's military capabilities continue to draw down and degrade, Ukrainian armament continues to improve:
• Ukraine independently developed the world's most effective kamikaze sea drones which proved critical to forcing the Black Sea Fleet from Sevastopol and far from the Ukrainian mainland.
• In their defense of Avdiivka, Ukraine successfully held up an advance of Russian infantry south of the city and inflicted heavy casualties in large part using a single remote controlled machine gun turret.
• For the entire war, Ukraine has successfully innovated in the yet increasingly sophisticated use of FPV aerial drones, including with the newly fielded "Baba Yaga" which is now precision-dropping 33lb rocket warheads at night using infrared sights.
• Ukraine also continues to find ways to fire NATO weaponry from their older Soviet weapons systems.
• By engineering a way to fit Storm Shadow / Scalp missiles donated by the UK and France to their Soviet era Su-24 aircraft, the Ukrainians have inflicted devastating punishment on deep Russian targets for most of 2023.
• In recent weeks Ukraine has successfully adapted their Soviet era Buk air defense systems with modern US Sea Sparrow air defense missiles. This pairing is capable of shooting down Russian cruise missiles that are once again illegally targeting Ukrainian civilian energy infrastructure.
*** Russia is targeting Ukraine's energy infrastructure again this winter in an effort to break Ukrainian will by freezing them to death. Both Ukraine's military and civilian population have been preparing for months to combat this anticipated Russian war crime. ***
• For conventional weapons, it was just announced Ukraine has achieved a production rate of 6 self-propelled 155mm howitzers per month. Comparable systems donated from allies cost nearly $10M per unit, and Ukraine will now produce at least 72 such systems on their own in 2024. They also explained they already see ways they can expand production beyond the newly reached 6/mo rate.
• German defense giant Rheinmetall is expected to soon sign a contract with Ukraine to produce Fuch armored personnel carriers and Lynx infantry fighting vehicles in Ukraine with with initial production timelines of 6-7 and 12-13 months respectively. These brand new APCs and IFVs produced in Ukraine would then be heading to the frontlines just as Russia's shortage of APCs and IFVs might be starting to develop.
• Throughout 2024 and into 2025, Ukraine will be receiving American made F-16 fighters from NATO allies. The arrival of these airframes will significantly increase the array of NATO standard air launched missiles that can be donated to Ukraine from the US and other allies. Thus, Ukraine's long-range strike capabilities against both air and ground targets will improve well beyond their current capabilities.
• As the PrSM missile program continues to reach production targets in the US, it will open the door for more ATACMS ground launched precision ballistic missiles to be delivered to Ukraine, thus giving Ukraine easy reach of all targets in the occupied south of the country, plus large portions of Crimea.
• In addition to potentially receiving more ATACMS, GLSDB rockets are already set to be delivered. Despite having a shorter range than ATACMS, GLSDBs still significantly enhance Ukrainian HIMARS launcher capabilities by nearly doubling the range of the GMLRS rockets Ukraine has been using since the first HIMARS launching vehicles were delivered.
• Since GLSDBs can hit moving targets, Ukraine's ability to threaten Russian logistics in southern Ukraine will reach new heights, further stressing an already worn down frontline. They are also cheaper than ATACMS, and will therefore likely be donated in larger quantities.
• In the past month, key Ukrainian allies have been announcing larger and longer-term commitments that show significant steps beyond prior donations.
• Germany pledged in early Nov they will double their military aid to Ukraine in 2024 to reach a total of 8.5 billion euros.
• The Netherlands announce it is allocating 2 billion euros for Ukraine in 2024 .
• Denmark recently allocated 500 million euros worth of military equipment to Ukraine.
• Finland also announced their most recent aid package worth 100 million euros.
• Though delayed, the largest aid package yet from the US is surely imminent. @SpeakerJohnson has explicitly expressed that additional aid to Ukraine is a "top priority".
• The delays to passing additional aid through the US congress are not due to the merit of the funding itself, but due to the unrelated issue of US boarder security. Once Democrats and Republicans successfully negotiate an agreement on a boarder security bill, additional aid to Ukraine will surely follow. It will be the largest single aid package to date from the US to Ukraine.
• Professor of History at Yale, @TimothyDSnyder, speaking on 2 Dec on "Ukraine The Latest" by @Telegraph, succinctly explained that just a few of Europe's largest economies together can support Ukraine sufficiently to keep them in the fight with Russia. If support from the US dwindles, key European allies have made clear their support will not waiver. And the longer the fight drags on, the more advantages Ukraine will accumulate on the battlefield.
• Even if Donald Trump wins a second term as US president in 2024, he won’t take office until 2025, when even more US aid will almost surely have already been signed into law and orders will have already been placed. Once in motion, it would be hard for Trump to reverse these orders since they will be law, so aid would continued to flow even after he potentially took office in 2025.
• In a second term, Trump may even surprise everyone by choosing to support Ukraine - he's changed his mind on a dime before, and usually acts as his advisors encourage him to. If he chooses to support Ukraine, you can be sure his die-hard base will follow suit.
6) While Russia's stealth mobilization efforts may struggle in the months ahead to find men to push into the war in Ukraine, Ukraine itself has refrained from fully mobilizing their population and still have more than a million capable individuals to recruit into their armed forces:
• As stated under reason #2, Putin now likely can't fully mobilize the Russian military due to domestic opposition.
• Since the very unpopular partial mobilization in Fall 2022, Russia is increasingly relying on mobilizing the prisoner population within Russia.
• Incarcerated individuals in Russia fell from 433,000 earlier this year in January to just 266,000 in October.
•These prisoners are given just one month, or even reportedly just 2-3 weeks of training, and they are then effectively pushed forward at gunpoint in human-wave tactics that Russia has used for over a year to try to overwhelm Ukrainian defenses. The Ukrainians, however, have effectively held these human-wave attacks back.
• Some of these prisoners who have been recruited have been bribing their officers with the entirety of their wages to avoid being sent into actual combat.
• After 6 months of military service, the former prisoners are pardoned, and return to Russia free. Murderers, rapists, and even reportedly a cannibal are now walking free in Russia following their pardons.
• Considering Russian casualties are currently hovering around 1000+ per day, they will likely run out of prisoners capable of being mobilized sometime in 2024.
• @TheStudyofWar wrote in their 7 Dec report, “Russian forces may be suffering losses along the entire front in Ukraine at a rate close to the rate at which Russia is currently generating new forces.”
• In just one section of the front, in the Kupyask, Lyman, and Bakhmut directions, Russia reported lost 11,000 soldiers in November alone, presumably counting both those killed in action as well as those wounded too severely to fight again.
• In the Avdiivka and Marinka section between 10-26 Oct, Russia reported lost 5,000 men. The operational tempo since then has significantly increased, and Russian losses may be even higher now.
• Russia’s current losses of both men and equipment are unsustainable every sense of the word.
• Dissent among Russian mothers and wives of regular mobilized men killed in combat is growing rapidly. Families have not been compensated, and this news is permeating the Kremlin's grip on the information space.
• News of terrible treatment on the frontlines and failures by the Russian government to compensate families of killed soldiers will further reduce motivation in the Russian population to enlist.
• Barring the inconceivable idea of fully mobilizing the country for war, Russia will likely struggle to continue to 'stealth mobilize' for their war effort in the same manner they have been able to since their unpopular partial mobilization in 2022.
• While they hopefully won't have to, Ukraine on the other hand could still fully mobilize their country for the war effort.
• Though tired, the Ukrainians are committed to victory over Russia. It's their fight, and they have expressed their will to push the Russians from every inch of their sovereign territory.
• Torsten Heinrich, who was formerly an armored recon serviceman in the German army, explained succinctly on his Youtube channel, "Military and History", that Urkaine is nowhere near a severe manpower shortage: youtu.be/RDQeT-75On4?si=CzYh…
• In the above linked video, Heinrich explains that even if Ukraine relied only on 20% of its male fighting age population, there is still a pool of roughly 1.3 million men to draw from. This assessment already subtracts those currently serving as well as those who have been killed and wounded too severely to fight again.
• The reason Ukraine's average age of fighting men is so old, at 43, is because they are doing all they can to avoid sending their youngest men into the war.
• Young Ukrainian men have been held back from the front while recruitment has so far been fulfilled by volunteers who mostly had already served in some capacity. These veterans are the easiest to rapidly recruit because they have already received some amount of training in the past.
• Most younger Ukrainian men have remained in universities and/or have continued to work in civilian and non-combat military roles.
• Once the Russian armed forces show clear signs of weakening to the point of ineffectiveness in 1-4 years, you can be sure the Ukrainians will smell the prospect of victory and will rally their efforts into a decisive push for total victory.
I want this costly and pointless war to end as much as anyone, but I only want this to happen on Ukraine's terms.
The Ukrainians are fighting not just for their sovereignty but for their very existence as a people.
This is their War of 1812, but with the significance of 1776.
Yes, the Ukrainians are tired, but they've expressed its there wish to liberate every last inch of land Russia illegally occupies.
If they are given what they need to achieve victory, Ukraine will be reborn as the most freedom loving democracy in Europe.
Every person on this planet who believes in the righteousness of freedom should be voicing their support for the Ukrainian cause against Russia's aggression.
It’s been 653 days of war, and Ukraine has liberated more than 50% of the land Russia took since the beginning of the full scale invasion.
Putin's only hope for holding on to the land his forces still occupy is the possibility that support for Kyiv disappears.
Numerous European nations have pledged to support Kyiv no matter how long it takes, and they are reaffirming those commitments now.
The remainder of the West must now steel their resolve and double down in their supportive efforts. We must help Ukraine end this war on their terms sooner rather than later.
As the war drags on, Russia's combat capabilities will only worsen while Ukraine's continue to strengthen. by rushing the Ukrainians what they need now, we can accelerate this process and shorten the war.
The Ukrainians are holding the line in the fight of Freedom v. Tyranny.
The end of Putin's ability to continue his invasion is so much closer than anyone realizes.
Give the Ukrainians what they need, and you can be assured they will use it well and they will win.
Slava Ukraini 🇺🇦
#Ukraine️ #UkraineWillWin #UkraineRussiaWar #UkraineRussianWar #SlavaUkraini #SlavaUkraïni #RussiaUkraineWar #RussianUkrainianWar #RussiaIsATerroristState #RussiaIsLosing #RussianArmy
@ZelenskyyUa @CinC_AFU @DefenceU @Ukraine @ReportingFromUA @TDF_UA @KpsZSU @MriyaReport @MriyaAid @ukraine_map @U24_gov_ua @United24media @rynkrynk @maksymeristavi @AlGGDirect @irgarner @djknowles22 @DomNicholls @FrancisDearnley @Telegraph @TelegraphWorld @timkmak @jaketapper @TimothyDSnyder @McFaul @AdamKinzinger @JamieMetzl @general_ben @RyanMcbeth @prestonstew_ @POTUS @WhiteHouse @JoeBiden @VP @KamalaHarris @DeptofDefense @SenSchumer @SpeakerJohnson @SenatorRomney @MittRomney @SecBlinken
Hans Nothstein retweeted
While losing Syria, about to lose Georgia, $200 million in failed election efforts in Moldova, Romania likely to imprison his candidate for treason, Putin's failures are adding up spectacularly.
So, he commits a massacre in Ukraine.
7 dead. including kids, in Zaporizhia.
Hans Nothstein retweeted
After the pro-Kremlin Georgian Dream party won the elections in Georgia, the Kremlin began to implement a plan to integrate the unrecognized republics of Abkhazia and North Ossetia into Russia. However, it did not work out. After the local authorities in Abkhazia announced
1/7
Hans Nothstein retweeted
Seems like it’s time for me to explain again, why Ukraine cannot simply freeze the war and call it peace:
- Without a defense clause and troops on the ground from other countries, Ukraine will need a massive standing army to guard a frontline spanning over a thousand kilometers.
- No deterrence against a new invasion will drive more people to leave as borders reopen, fearing a repeat attack.
- Post-war elections in a democratic Ukraine will spark a political crisis if Zelensky is forced into a bad peace deal.
- A nation in political turmoil, under constant Russian threat, won’t attract investments or recover its economy with high-interest loans.
- It will embolden those who argue that yielding to Russian demands is the only way to avoid Ukraine’s fate, referring to a cheap oil and gas as justification.
- An impoverished, crisis-ridden Ukraine will be no match for a partially recovering Russia, which can leverage eased sanctions and resource exports.
- Aid at current levels won’t continue indefinitely, while Russia has more potential to recover than an aid-deprived Ukraine.
In short, any deal that doesn’t deter Russia from a second invasion is a death sentence for Ukraine
Hans Nothstein retweeted
NEW: Russian forces reportedly lost almost 200 tanks, over 650 armored vehicles, and suffered an estimated 80,000 casualties in taking roughly 1,500 square kilometers during a period of intensified Russian offensive operations in September and October 2024.🧵(1/8)
Hans Nothstein retweeted
Amazing idea to break up an alliance that has kept the West safe for 80 years after two World Wars, and fulfill Putin’s lifelong dream, because the EU is being mean to Elon.
Hans Nothstein retweeted
APPALLING — 67 fake bomb threats.
Most of them targeting heavily Democratic cities — all of which had lower turnout than in 2020.
Many of the threats were traced to Russia.
And somehow this is NOT a headline news story — and there is ZERO federal investigation.
Hans Nothstein retweeted
Everyone who endorses the false claim that the US economy of 2024 is an inflation-wracked hellscape of misery for working people ...
is doing advance comms work for the Trump administration when in 90 days time they start taking credit for the best economy since the 1960s.
Hans Nothstein retweeted
After last night, I have taken a long look and made a decision:
I’m doubling down. We will protect our democracy, and never give up.
NEVER
Hans Nothstein retweeted
My heart is full today—full of gratitude for the trust you have placed in me, full of love for our country, and full of resolve.
Hans Nothstein retweeted
Trump's nephew: There are no guardrails anymore stopping Donald Trump. There is no General Kelly. There is no General Mattis. It is now only Stephen Miller, Tom Homan, and Rudy Giuliani. That should scare everybody in America
Hans Nothstein retweeted
Taylor Swift wrote a song about my son, Ronan, after he died of cancer. She put me on as a co-writer, and donated the proceeds directly to pediatric cancer -no strings, no hidden motives, just pure compassion and integrity.
In stark contrast, the Trump family engaged in significant fundraising efforts for children with cancer through the Eric Trump Foundation. However, reports later revealed that funds were used to pay Trump-owned properties for hosting fundraising events, raising concerns about conflicts of interest and self-dealing. What could have been a mission solely dedicated to supporting children in need became tainted by financial practices that appeared to benefit the Trump Organization, casting a shadow over the charitable intentions initially claimed.
This election is a no-brainer. It’s a choice between compassion and corruption, between someone like Kamala Harris, who has spent her career fighting for justice, and Trump, who has exploited the vulnerable at every turn. Kamala has consistently shown a commitment to supporting communities and ensuring people’s rights are protected, while Trump and his family have even stooped to taking funds meant for children with cancer.
If integrity, empathy, and basic decency matter, then this choice couldn’t be clearer. Supporting Kamala and her values means standing up for the kind of future where compassion isn’t just talk—it’s action. We owe it to ourselves and to the next generation to reject self-interest and stand on the right side of history.
Hans Nothstein retweeted
If Harris wins, will Congress certify the results?
There are now 172 election deniers in Congress.
But the new Congress gets sworn in before the presidential election is certified.
Your down ballot votes could decide whether your presidential vote is respected or discarded.
Hans Nothstein retweeted
I'm finding it hilarious that, right now, Elon Musk's lawyers are arguing in court that they scammed every Trump supporter who signed that petition.
Hans Nothstein retweeted
Trump: They have already pulled out of a couple of states. Word is they pulled out of North Carolina and they cut all of their ads and they are using their money someplace else.I even heard they ran out of money. They don’t have any money
Hans Nothstein retweeted
Let me tell something hopeful. In 2020 , a total of 778 ballots were cast in my county. 78% of them voted for Trump.
In early voting today, my oldest daughter, my wife, and I voted. My wife fed her ballot into the machine last. She was ballot #790.
The lady behind me said, “I haven’t voted in years.” I said, “I won’t ask.” She replied,”Don’t worry. It’s not him.”
The county clerk also said they have already had many young voters. I feel safe in saying those young voters didn’t come out to vote the first time for Donald Trump.
Keep in mind, Missouri has long been a red state. Change is coming.
Donald Trump, old boy…you are screwed, son.
Hans Nothstein retweeted
Univision poll: Latino voters
Harris 64%
Trump 30%
69% said the Puerto Rico garbage remark was "more racist than humorous."
Oct. 29-Nov. 3, MOE +/-5%
Hans Nothstein retweeted
3 Election Day 2024 WARNINGS:
1) Stay Alert for Turnout Trends: As turnout data comes in, remember that early turnout numbers may not paint a full picture. Republicans tend to vote more in the morning, while Democrats often vote later in the afternoon and evening.
2) Verify Voting Information: Be cautious about polling information on social media. For accurate details on voting times, locations, and guidelines, rely on reputable news sources or official state election websites.
3) Avoid Conspiracy Narratives: Let’s steer clear of unproven claims about election rigging or massive fraud. In over 240 years, the U.S. has maintained a strong election process, so let’s uphold trust in that foundation.



























