Pinned Tweet
Here is my latest piece for the International Law Blog on India’s attempt to unilaterally put the Indus Waters Treaty (IWT) in “abeyance” after the Pahalgam attack. @IntlLawBlog
While the political anger following a major security crisis is entirely understandable, “abeyance” simply doesn't exist as a legal mechanism, neither within the text of the treaty itself nor under the customary rules of the Vienna Convention. In short, political grievances, no matter how severe, don't give #India the right to rewrite treaty law.
In the article, I walk through why Article XII of the IWT is so explicit. It states that #IWT stays in force until both countries agree to terminate it. There is zero provision for a unilateral freeze. Under the core rule of pacta sunt servanda, binding legal commitments must be honoured in good faith. By ignoring this, along with the Court of Arbitration’s ruling, New Delhi is setting a dangerous precedent for the entire international legal order.
What makes this so dangerous is not just immediate water access. India doesn't currently have the engineering setup to divert those rivers anyway. The real issue is the politicization of a framework that survived wars in 1965, 1971, and 1999 specifically because it kept water management technical rather than political.
By deliberately walking away from a foundational framework, India is hellbent on inviting another major conflict between two nuclear-armed neighbours.
internationallaw.blog/2026/0… via @InternationalLawBlog
Hassan Aslam Shad retweeted
In an open letter to the Chief Justice of Pakistan former Prime Minister Imran Khan alleges that his and his wife Bushra Bibi’s fundamental rights, medical needs and judicial protections are being disregarded while they remain incarcerated.The letter comes after a recent Supreme Court order directing Khan’s transfer to a hospital (Shiffa International) was not implemented. His lawyers subsequently filed a contempt of court petition, which remains pending.Khan has appealed to Pakistan’s highest judicial authorities to intervene urgently, ensure proper medical treatment,enforce court orders and deliver justice before his or his wife’s health deteriorates beyond recovery.
Hassan Aslam Shad retweeted
Open Letter of Mr Imran Khan for kind consideration of Hon Chief Justice's of Pakistan. Humanitarian Plea for Medical Treatment & Shift to Hospital - Voice From Behind the Prison Walls of Adyala.
This is very serious and alarming. In a letter purportedly written by @ImranKhanPTI and shared by his lawyers, Imran has raised serious concerns regarding his health. What particularly strikes me is that Imran Khan is not one to complain about trivial health concerns. If he has written that his blood pressure has shot through the roof, and mentioned the possibility of a cardiac arrest or a brain haemmorhage, then this is to be taken as nothing but a direct threat to his life and well-being. What breaks my heart is that this is happening right before our eyes to a sporting legend, the leading philanthropist of the country and its former prime minister. With a dysfunctional judicial system, all we can do is hope and pray that he will be given the basic medical care that a human being deserves, let alone a living legend of his stature.
dawn.com/news/2044922/i-may-…
Hassan Aslam Shad retweeted
Replying to @HassShad @VishnuNDTV
Contrary to the Indian claims, an independent French newspaper reported this
Hassan Aslam Shad retweeted
Finally, an Indian having the gall of speaking the truth. Indian Airforce got pummeled by the Pakistan Airforce on the morning of 6 May, and received the shock of its life. The Godi media tried to cleanse the narrative and spun stories to deceive the public and largely succeeded in doing so. But deep down, both the Indian government and the Indian military know the trial by fire they went through against Pakistan. @majorgauravarya @GeneralBakshi @IAF_MCC @Kanthaswam80359
I think we lost the Air Battle and lost a lot of aircraft against 🇵🇰 on 6-7 May 2025
I think 90% of Sindoor Narrative by India is doubtful now.
Modi did the same thing against General MM Narvane too after the Galwan conflict
He didn't nominate MMN for CDS which was assumed to be routine by then
Otherwise why should he humiliate someone who destroyed 11 Pakistani Air Bases and did so much damage to Pakistan?
The man should be a national hero and Modi should have attended his farewell himself right ?
Finally, an Indian having the gall of speaking the truth. Indian Airforce got pummeled by the Pakistan Airforce on the morning of 6 May, and received the shock of its life. The Godi media tried to cleanse the narrative and spun stories to deceive the public and largely succeeded in doing so. But deep down, both the Indian government and the Indian military know the trial by fire they went through against Pakistan. @majorgauravarya @GeneralBakshi @IAF_MCC @Kanthaswam80359
I think we lost the Air Battle and lost a lot of aircraft against 🇵🇰 on 6-7 May 2025
I think 90% of Sindoor Narrative by India is doubtful now.
Modi did the same thing against General MM Narvane too after the Galwan conflict
He didn't nominate MMN for CDS which was assumed to be routine by then
Otherwise why should he humiliate someone who destroyed 11 Pakistani Air Bases and did so much damage to Pakistan?
The man should be a national hero and Modi should have attended his farewell himself right ?
Hassan Aslam Shad retweeted
As I type this, I can hear the sound of Saudi air defences above me, intercepting Houthi drones and missiles aimed at the Kingdom. It is a chilling reminder that behind the slogans and propaganda lies a reckless militia that has repeatedly chosen to endanger innocent civilians, including people living, working and worshipping in Saudi Arabia.
@FaisalJAbbas's excellent piece captures the moral bankruptcy of the Houthi narrative: a militia that attacks civilian airports and threatens holy sites, yet attempts to shift blame onto its victims. The Houthis are not champions of a cause, but a malign instrument of destabilization, exploiting religion and suffering while serving the strategic interests of their patrons in Tehran.
The Kingdom of Saudi Arabia has shown extraordinary restraint, dignity and responsibility in the face of these attacks. The international community must see the Houthis for what they are: a dangerous extremist militia whose reckless aggression cannot be normalized. The security and peace of the region require that this cancerous threat be decisively confronted and removed. Allowing this cancer to grow will lead to further chaos in the region.
#SaudiArabia
arab.news/vsscg
As I type this, I can hear the sound of Saudi air defences above me, intercepting Houthi drones and missiles aimed at the Kingdom. It is a chilling reminder that behind the slogans and propaganda lies a reckless militia that has repeatedly chosen to endanger innocent civilians, including people living, working and worshipping in Saudi Arabia.
@FaisalJAbbas's excellent piece captures the moral bankruptcy of the Houthi narrative: a militia that attacks civilian airports and threatens holy sites, yet attempts to shift blame onto its victims. The Houthis are not champions of a cause, but a malign instrument of destabilization, exploiting religion and suffering while serving the strategic interests of their patrons in Tehran.
The Kingdom of Saudi Arabia has shown extraordinary restraint, dignity and responsibility in the face of these attacks. The international community must see the Houthis for what they are: a dangerous extremist militia whose reckless aggression cannot be normalized. The security and peace of the region require that this cancerous threat be decisively confronted and removed. Allowing this cancer to grow will lead to further chaos in the region.
#SaudiArabia
arab.news/vsscg
Hassan Aslam Shad retweeted
بالأمس يستهدفون مكة المكرمة، واليوم يقتلون ضيوف الرحمن، ويروعون المعتمرين، ويصدونهم عن المسجد الحرام! فأي حرمة بقيت لم ينتهكوها؟!
#مع_السعودية_إلى_الأبد 🇸🇦🇰🇼
Hassan Aslam Shad retweeted
The Iranian-backed Houthi terrorist militia and all its enablers will pay a heavier price than they ever imagined.
The reckoning shall begin.
Hassan Aslam Shad retweeted
Replying to @RShivshankar
@RShivshankar writing it in uppercase as a "DIPLOMATIC COUP" doesn't make it one. This is standard diplomatic language used in joint press releases issued during global summits. These and similar theatrics from Godi media can't detract from the fact that not one country has blamed Pakistan for Pahalgam attacks. Not one. Also, #Pakistan itself called for an investigation in #Pahalgam but hubristic wannabe "superpower" #India didn't want one because there is not a shred of evidence of Pakistan's involvement. Your tweets only have buyers among brainwashed bhagts and the illiterate Hindutva brigade.
Hassan Aslam Shad retweeted
Are Chinese friends worried about Pakistan's commitment and capacity?
tribune.com.pk/story/2628812…
Hassan Aslam Shad retweeted
The gloves are off. Saudi Arabia will finish the job against the Iranian-backed Houthi militia.
Saudi Ministry of Defense: "73 civilians, including women and children, were injured in attacks by the Houthi militia on civilian and economic facilities in southern Saudi Arabia."
Hassan Aslam Shad retweeted
Replying to @ShivAroor
@ShivAroor elevating a random AI generated clip from some silly keyboard warrior is a rather desperate attempt to manufacture noise where facts are required. A stupid internet video does not erase uncomfortable questions that remain unanswered.
The IAF, whose mythology you and @VishnuNDTV have spent years cheerleading and celebrating, faced a brutal ambush conducted by the PAF on the morning of 6 May. No amount of memes, propaganda clips or social media cheerleading can rewrite what happened. IAF simply got bludgeoned on that days. Air wars, my friend, are not won on television panels or Twitter timelines. They are settled by evidence and operational facts.
So, I repeat my simple request:
Can you or Vishu please produce one single frame showing all 36 IAF Rafales intact?
I asked Vishnu the same question. Silence followed. Perhaps because when the noise fades away, even the loudest cheerleaders know that the battlefield did not follow the script they had prepared. If you're unable to answer this question because of the embarassment you feel, you may just drop me a DM to admit this fact. I will not ask this question again.
And to all the Hindutiva lunatics, pajeets and brainwashed Islamophobes who will vomit and post filth:
You guys should ask this question from your government. Tell them to set the facts straight once and for all and show ALL 36 Ralafes in one single frame. It isn't that hard. Do it.
Hassan Aslam Shad retweeted
A splendid night marking 75 years of China‑Pakistan diplomatic ties🎵 Co‑hosted by Pakistan Embassy in China and China International Culture Communication Center. Qawwali, the soul‑stirring Sufi devotional music from Pakistan, blends beautifully with Chinese pipa and erhu. East‑west melodies weave together to sing the timeless friendship between the two nations🪕
This clip from @ShivAroor's talk is a perfect window into the parallel universe India’s media ecosystem has created for itself. A reality where a pilot who was shot down by the PAF in broad daylight is magically transformed into a mythical hero who allegedly shot down a Pakistani F-16 that, according to the US assessment, never happened, and whose fleet remained intact.
The sheer confidence with which this fantasy is repeatedly churned out is truly phenomenal. It takes a special kind of gutter media ecosystem to manufacture a victory out of a resounding defeat, package it as history, and then have hysterical cheerleaders like Aroor scream it from the rooftops to make volume substitute for facts. Pure fiction and fantasy is the official narrative in today's India.
This is simultaneously hilarious and deeply tragic. Indian society fed constant doses of propaganda now treats manufactured legends for reality. The Abhinandan saga is a case study in how far an echo chamber can drift from facts when mythmaking replaces truth.
Hassan Aslam Shad retweeted
Hassan Aslam Shad @HassShad has succinctly and convincingly explained how the Indus Water Treaty works and how the Permanent Court of Arbitration is legally permitted to investigate #India’s decision to place the IWT “in abeyance”. Moreover, he makes clear that India cannot selectively choose à la carte—and incorrectly so at that— the bits it likes in the Treaty to suit its needs.
I am genuinely SHOCKED by the level of treaty illiteracy now passing for serious commentary in parts of #India’s policy circles.
Have you even read Article IX(5) of the #IWT before declaring the Court “illegal”? It expressly provides that a Court of Arbitration may be established “at the request of either Party” in circumstances specified there. Annexure G, paragraph 2(b), repeats the same rule. This is not Pakistan’s interpretation: These are the words of the Treaty itself, conveniently available on #India’s own Ministry of External Affairs website!
#India’s refusal to nominate its two arbitrators does not somehow hand India a veto over a process to which it had already consented by treaty. Annexure G contains machinery specifically capable of operating despite non-participation at critical stages of constituting the Court. Paragraph 9 expressly addresses a party failing to participate in the drawing of lots for the umpires. Paragraph 11 then provides that the three umpires, together with “such arbitrators as have been appointed”, shall form the Court, and permits it to transact business when all three umpires and at least two arbitrators are present. Paragraph 16 expressly empowers the Court to decide all questions relating to its own competence.
And this is not some Pakistani gloss on the Treaty. The Court considered India’s objections and unanimously held that India’s non-appearance did not deprive it of competence, that the arbitration had been initiated in accordance with Article IX(3), (4) and (5), and that the Court was properly constituted under paragraphs 4 to 11 of Annexure G. India is perfectly entitled to dislike that conclusion. What it cannot do is erase the actual words of the Treaty and replace them with “we did not participate, therefore the Court is illegal”. That may work as a slogan for the galleries but as treaty law, it is remarkably thin and only exposes your sheer ignorance!
I am genuinely SHOCKED by the level of treaty illiteracy now passing for serious commentary in parts of #India’s policy circles.
Have you even read Article IX(5) of the #IWT before declaring the Court “illegal”? It expressly provides that a Court of Arbitration may be established “at the request of either Party” in circumstances specified there. Annexure G, paragraph 2(b), repeats the same rule. This is not Pakistan’s interpretation: These are the words of the Treaty itself, conveniently available on #India’s own Ministry of External Affairs website!
#India’s refusal to nominate its two arbitrators does not somehow hand India a veto over a process to which it had already consented by treaty. Annexure G contains machinery specifically capable of operating despite non-participation at critical stages of constituting the Court. Paragraph 9 expressly addresses a party failing to participate in the drawing of lots for the umpires. Paragraph 11 then provides that the three umpires, together with “such arbitrators as have been appointed”, shall form the Court, and permits it to transact business when all three umpires and at least two arbitrators are present. Paragraph 16 expressly empowers the Court to decide all questions relating to its own competence.
And this is not some Pakistani gloss on the Treaty. The Court considered India’s objections and unanimously held that India’s non-appearance did not deprive it of competence, that the arbitration had been initiated in accordance with Article IX(3), (4) and (5), and that the Court was properly constituted under paragraphs 4 to 11 of Annexure G. India is perfectly entitled to dislike that conclusion. What it cannot do is erase the actual words of the Treaty and replace them with “we did not participate, therefore the Court is illegal”. That may work as a slogan for the galleries but as treaty law, it is remarkably thin and only exposes your sheer ignorance!
The Indus Waters Treaty permits the setting up of an Arbitration Court only with the consent of both parties.
Each party nominates its own experts.
There is no provision in the Treaty to set up such a Court at the instance of one party.
India did not name any arbitrators or participated in its proceedings.
There is no provision in the IWT for ex-party judgments by such a Court.
India is right to categorically dismiss the Court’s findings as illegal.
What is absolutely mind-boggling is the intellectual contortion now underway across #India’s policy establishment and its hyper-nationalist echo chamber to explain away what is, by any sensible legal reading, a devastating gut punch and massive reputational hit.
New Delhi invented “abeyance”, a status found nowhere in the Indus Water Treaty and has now been told unanimously at The Hague that none of the grounds it advanced justify suspension or termination. #India’s response is breathtaking in its simplicity: "we reject the Court". Of course you do when the law goes against you, when apparently the easiest solution is to declare the referee illegitimate!
And this is where Indian swagger begins to look embarrassingly hollow. For years, New Delhi has lectured the world about “rules based international order”. But the moment those rules constrain #India, jurisdiction disappears, tribunals become unlawful and adverse decisions are dismissed as scraps of paper.
Judging from some of the replies under my posts from the brainwashed Indians who have a below freezing point IQ, this selective understanding of international law has travelled remarkably well from government talking points into the nationalist commentariat. Repeating “India does not recognise the Court” fifty times does not become a legal argument on the fifty first try. It remains political chest thumping masquerading as jurisprudence and only exposes deep rooted ignorance, illiteracy and plain stupidity.
#India also needs to disabuse itself of one particularly dangerous illusion. The Indus is not Shri Narendra Modi’s private reservoir and #Pakistan’s water rights are not a favour dispensed by New Delhi when relations are cordial. India signed a binding treaty and if it wants that bargain changed, there is a negotiating table and a treaty mechanism.
What an "aspiring hegemon" like Indian cannot credibly do is invent “abeyance”, flirt with weaponizing the lifeline of 250 million people, wrap the exercise in Hindutva bravado and then imagine that saffron nationalism can repeal international law.
The louder the #Indian swagger becomes, the more obvious become the legal weakness underneath it. #India has been literally caught with its pants down for the world to see, but Indians insist on the "Emperor's New Clothes".
dawn.com/news/2026730
It is truly astonishing that even after the Court stripped #India's stunt naked, Chellaney still presents it as some mystery of bureaucratic drafting. There is no mystery here! New Delhi reached for the legally meaningless word “abeyance” since recognized doctrines of suspension and termination demand lawful grounds and evidence and legal consequences. India had none that could withstand scrutiny. “Abeyance” was therefore the last resort and chest-thumping political theatre disguised as international law.
The intellectual bankruptcy of India’s policy class is laid bare by its effort to reduce this humiliation to semantics. The Court did not quibble over vocabulary. Guess what: it simply demolished India's entire legal fiction, held the IWT fully in force and affirmed that India remains bound by its obligations. This was a judicial slap so resounding that New Delhi has been left utterly speechless and humiliated.
The beginnig was a spectacle to watch: #India swaggered into this dispute threatening to weaponize water. It has emerged before the world with its legal trousers around its ankles, shouting “sovereignty” at a tribunal constituted under the very Treaty it signed. This is what happens when WhatsApp nationalism is confused with statecraft and bureaucratic bravado is sold as international law.
India's decision not to suspend or withdraw from the Indus Waters Treaty (IWT), but instead to keep it "in abeyance" (a term neither defined by New Delhi nor recognized in international law) has returned to the spotlight following an arbitral tribunal's ruling. The tribunal held that "India's decision on 'abeyance' of the Treaty was not permissible under the Treaty or other applicable rules of international law."
The question is why New Delhi chose not to invoke the recognized doctrines of international law governing treaty suspension or withdrawal, but instead adopted the legally undefined formulation of placing the IWT "in abeyance," creating ambiguity about its practical effect and its permanence.
The novel formulation may ultimately reflect India's deeply ingrained bureaucratic culture, where administratively crafted ambiguity can come at the expense of legal clarity.






















